Can the world itself be vague, so that rather than vagueness be a deficiency in our mode of describing the world, it is a necessary feature of any true description of it? Gareth Evans famously poses this question in his paper ‘Can There Be Vague Objects’ (Analysis 38(4):208, 1978). In his recent paper ‘Indeterminacy and Vagueness: Logic and Metaphysics’, Peter van Inwagen (2009) elaborates the account of vagueness and, in particular, in the case of sentences, consequent indeterminacy in truth value, to which this conception of ‘worldly’ vagueness is opposed, calling it the ‘sensible’ theory of indeterminacy and rejecting it. In what follows, I defend the sensible theory van Inwagen rejects. I first explain more fully what it involves and, as importantly, what it does not.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Barnes E, Williams R (2009) Vague parts and vague identity. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 90 (2):176–187.
Dummett M (1991) The logical basis of metaphysics. Harvard University Press, Harvard.
Edgington D (2000) Indeterminacy de re. Philosophical Topics 28 (1): 27–44.
Evans G (1978) Can there be vague objects? Analysis 38 (4): 208.
Hawley K (2002) Vagueness and existence. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 102 (1):125–140.
Lewis D (1984) Putnam’s paradox. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 62: 221–236.
Lewis D (1993) Many, but almost one. In: Cambell K,Bacon J, Reinhardt L (eds.) Ontology, causality, and mind: Essays on the philosophy of D. M. Armstrong. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Lowe E J (1994) Vague identity and quantum indeterminacy. Analysis 54 (2):110–114.
Quine WVO (1981) What price bivalence? Journal of Philosophy 78 (2): 90–95.
Shoemaker S, Swinburne S (1984) Personal identity: Great debates in philosophy. Blackwell, Oxford.
Tye M (2000) Vagueness and reality. Philosophical Topics 28 (1):195–210.
Weatherson B (2003) Many many problems. Philosophical Quarterly 53: 481–501.
van Inwagen P (1990) Material beings. Cornell University Press, Ithaca (NY).
van Inwagen P (2009) Indeterminacy and vagueness: Logic and metaphysics. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 1 (2): 1–19.
Williams R (2008) Multiple actualities and ontically vague identity. Philosophical Quarterly 58: 134–154.
About this article
Cite this article
Noonan, H.W. In Defence of the Sensible Theory of Indeterminacy. Int Ontology Metaphysics 14, 239–252 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12133-013-0124-3