Advertisement

Trends in Organized Crime

, Volume 20, Issue 3–4, pp 273–295 | Cite as

‘No banquet can do without liquor’: alcohol counterfeiting in the People’s Republic of China

  • Anqi Shen
  • Georgios A. Antonopoulos
Article

Abstract

The illegal trade in alcohol has been an empirical manifestation of organised crime with a very long history; yet, the nature of the illegal trade in alcohol has received relatively limited academic attention in recent years despite the fact that it has been linked with significant tax evasion as well as serious health problems and even deaths. The current article focuses on a specific type associated with the illegal trade in alcohol, the counterfeiting of alcohol in China. The article pays particular attention to the counterfeiting of baijiu - Chinese liquor - in mainland China. The aim of the article is to offer an account of the social organisation of the alcohol counterfeiting business in China by illustrating the counterfeiting process, the actors in the business as well as its possible embeddedness in legal practices, trades and industries. The alcohol counterfeiting business is highly reflective to the market demand and consumer needs. Alcohol counterfeiting in China is characterised primarily by independent actors many of whom are subcontracted to provide commodities and services about the counterfeiting process. The business relies on personal networks – family and extended family members, friends and acquaintances. Relationships between actors in the business are very often based on a customer-supplier relationship or a ‘business-to-business market’. The alcohol counterfeiting business in China highlights the symbiotic relationship between illegal and legal businesses.

Keywords

Counterfeiting Alcohol China 

Notes

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments on an early draft of this article.

Compliance with ethical standards

Authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

This article does not contain any studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.

References

  1. Antonopoulos GA, Hall S (2014) The death of the legitimate merchant? In: van Duyne PC, Harvey J, Antonopoulos GA, Maljevic A, Markovska A, von Lampe J (eds) Corruption, greed and crime money. Wolf Legal Publishers, NijmegenGoogle Scholar
  2. Block A (1983) East side-west side: organizing crime in New York, 1930–1950. Transaction, Newark, NJGoogle Scholar
  3. Cai P (1998) How was the ‘bitter’ liquor manufactured? China Tens of Thousand Miles towards Quality 5:18–25Google Scholar
  4. CCTV (2011) Weekly quality report: how is fake alcohol made? available at http://www.newssohucom/20111107/n324716346shtml on 11 August 2016
  5. Chan A, Wong S, Leung P (1998) Ethical beliefs of Chinese consumers in Hong Kong. J Bus Ethics 17(11):1163–1170CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Chen T (1985) The extracted proceedings of the roundtable discussions on the protection of consumer interests through legislation. Outlook 15:18–20Google Scholar
  7. Chen Z (2013) Launching and developing Co-ordinated battles against product counterfeiting. Journal of Hubei University of Police 12:14–16Google Scholar
  8. Cheung W, Prendergast G (2004) An exploratory study of the materialism and conformity motivations of consumers who knowingly buy pirated products: a Hong Kong and shanghai comparison. Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong KongGoogle Scholar
  9. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2012) Wan, Su and Zhe Three Provinces Cracked down a Counterfeiting Case involving Alcohol of Hundreds Millions Market Value, 11: 9–21Google Scholar
  10. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2013a) Information: Anti-counterfeiting, 9: 14–20Google Scholar
  11. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2013b) Economic Case Report, 10: 74–75Google Scholar
  12. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2013c) Liuan, Anhui detected an alcohol counterfeiting group; Large Quantity of Ingredients Seized, 11: 97Google Scholar
  13. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2013d) Cangnan detected a case involving the making and selling of fake liquor packing materials, 12: 94–95Google Scholar
  14. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2014) Review high profile fake alcohol cases, 3: 36–37Google Scholar
  15. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2015a) Little caps led to a 100-million worth alcohol counterfeiting case, 3: 79–80Google Scholar
  16. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2015b) Bottling cheap base liquor in a toilet and selling it at several tens of thousands Yuan, 4: 69–72Google Scholar
  17. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2016a) ‘Deceived by Promoters: spend over 10,000 yuan on 60 bottles of fake “Maotain”’, 1: 103Google Scholar
  18. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2016b) Liuan detected alcohol counterfeiting case of 51,740 yuan market value, 2: 91Google Scholar
  19. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2016c) Binzhou detected an alcohol counterfeiting case, 4: 89Google Scholar
  20. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2016d) The public security authorities coordinated crackdowns and detected over 200,000 counterfeiting cases, 5: 84–95Google Scholar
  21. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report (2016e) Xiamen detected a very large counterfeiting cases involving market value of one hundred million, 6: 93–95Google Scholar
  22. China Food & Drug Administration (2016) The chaoyang mass’ performed meritorious service again: report on crackdown against alcohol counterfeiters, 1: 30–31Google Scholar
  23. China News (2010) How can a bottle of fake liquor costed 80 yuan be sold at 300? Available at http://www.chinanews.com/life/2010/09-27/2557090.shtml on 11 August 2016
  24. China News (2012) Hunan chende dismantled an alcohol counterfeiting factory, available at http://www.chinanews.com/fz/2012/03-28/3780337.shtml on 13 August 2016
  25. Chow D (2000) Counterfeiting in the People’s republic of China. Washington University Law Quarterly 78(1):1–57Google Scholar
  26. Chow D (2004) Counterfeiting in China and its effect on US manufacturing. https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/download/testimony-chow-042004. Accessed 8 Nov 2016
  27. Cnwinenews (2007) Lu Ronghua: regulating the sale of alcohol from a broad perspective, available at http://www.cnwinenews.com/html/2007/pinglun_0307/53891.html on 13 August 2016
  28. Cochrane J, Chen H, Conigrave KM, Hao W (2003) Alcohol use in China. Alcohol & Alcoholism 38(6):537–542CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Critchley D (2009) The origin of organised crime in America: the New York City mafia, 1981–1931. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  30. Derrida J (1992) Given time: I. Counterfeiting money. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  31. Dimitrov MK (2009) Piracy and the state: the politics of intellectual property rights in China. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Edwards C, Jeffray C (2014) On tap: organised crime and the illegal trade in tobacco, alcohol and pharmaceuticals in the UK. RUSI, LondonGoogle Scholar
  33. Europol (2016) Counterfeit products: why buying fakes can be bad for your health (and More), available at http://www.europol.europa.eu, accessed on 1 September 2016
  34. Fan Y (2016) Analysing why counterfeit and substandard food and drinks love to go to countryside and countermeasures. New Agriculture 11:50–52Google Scholar
  35. Feng M (2003) Be careful: fake liquor may make a scene again during the holiday seasons. China Anti-Counterfeiting Report 6:24–26Google Scholar
  36. Foshan Government (2012) A long way to go to eradicate alcohol counterfeiting, available at http://www.foshangovcn/zwgk/yjgl/dxal/201209/t20120901_3894573html on 12 August 2016
  37. Guangxi Quality Supervision Guide Periodical (2016) Counterfeiting workshop dismantled: fake Maotai worth 30 but sold at 1,000 yuan. Guangxi Quality Supervision Guide Periodical 1:55–56Google Scholar
  38. Haixi Morning Press (2016) Xiamen police detected an alcohol counterfeiting case involving market value of A hundred thousand yuan, available at http://www.hxnews.com/news/fj/mn/xm/201605/19/870814.shtml on 12 August 2016
  39. Hall A, Antonopoulos GA (2016) Fake meds online: the internet and the transnational market in illicit pharmaceuticals. Palgrave Macmillan, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Hobbs D, Antonopoulos GA (2013) Endemic to the species: ordering the ‘other’ via organised crime. Global Crime 14(1):27–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Huoqiu News (2014) ‘Alcohol counterfeiter brothers caught by the net: a report on how the Huoqiu police detected a trademark counterfeit case’, available at http://www.hqnews.cn/print.asp?WZ_ID=46658 on 2 August 2016
  42. Jiang L (2014) Call for copy – the culture of counterfeit in China. Journal of Chinese Economics 2(2):73–78Google Scholar
  43. Jin Y (1985) Talking of journalists “watching others dining”. The Journalist Profession 10:42–43Google Scholar
  44. Johansen PO (2005) Organised crime, Norwegian style. In: van Duyne PC, von Lampe K, van Dijck M, Newell JL (eds) The organised crime economy: Managing crime markets in Europe (pp.189–208). Wolf Legal Publishers, NijmegenGoogle Scholar
  45. Johansen PO (2007) The come-back boys of the illegal markets. In: van Duyne PC, Maljevic A, van Dijck M, von Lampe K, Harvey J (eds) Crime business and crime money in Europe: the dirty linen of illicit Enterprise. Wolf Legal Publishers, NijmegenGoogle Scholar
  46. Kang H, Wang H (2015) The current state of food safety inspection system in China, problems and countermeasures. Economic Vision 1:80–84Google Scholar
  47. Kleemans ER, van de Bunt H (1999) The social embeddedness of organised crime. Transnational Organized Crime 5(1):19–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Kotelnikova Z (2014) Consumption of Counterfeit Alcohol in Contemporary Russia. Working Paper 47/SOC/2014. National Research University Higher School of Economics, MoscowGoogle Scholar
  49. Kramer U (2006) Counterfeiting in the People’s republic of China: analysis of impact, drivers and containment options concerning increased counterfeiting. Diploma Thesis, HamburgGoogle Scholar
  50. Kyvig D (2000) Repealing National Prohibition, 2nd edn. Kent State University Press, Kent, OHGoogle Scholar
  51. Landesco J (1968) Organised crime in Chicago, 2nd edn. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IlGoogle Scholar
  52. Layder D (2013) Doing excellent small-scale research. Sage, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Legal Daily (2011) Suzhou detected the largest alcohol counterfeiting case: 18 detained and 4 arrests, available at http://www.legaldaily.com.cn/index_article/content/2011-09/18/content_2965298.htm?node=5955 on 11 August 2016
  54. Legal Daily (2013) Fake Maotai uses anti-counterfeiting marks that cannot be identified by human eye, available at http://epaper.legaldaily.com.cn/fzrb/content/20130514/Articel05010GN.htm on 11 August 2016
  55. Li Y (2014) Combining morality and legality to crackdown counterfeiting and making substandard goods. China Tens of Thousand Miles towards Quality 12:76–78Google Scholar
  56. Li X, Li X (2015) Strict criminal liability in the application in crimes of manufacturing and selling of counterfeiting and substandard products. Journal of Guangxi Police Academy 28(6):81–85Google Scholar
  57. Li, Xiaolong, Li, Jianhui & Yuan, Chunhui (2015) Security methods and security devices of alcoholic products, International Conference on Education Technology, Management and Humanities Science, available at http://www.cnki.net/KCMS/detail/detail.aspx?dbcode=IPFD&filename=JKDZ201503002184&dbname=IPFDLAST2015 on 8 August 2016
  58. Lin JY-C (2011) Fake stuff: China and the rise of counterfeit goods. Routledge, AbingdonGoogle Scholar
  59. Liu Y (1998) Genuine liquor, faked liquor, and others. China Tens of Thousand Miles towards Quality 6:28–31Google Scholar
  60. Liu L (2015) Determining “criminal proceeds” in crimes of violating others’ intellectual property rights. Journal of Chinese Criminal Law 2:136–140Google Scholar
  61. Liu C (2016) Difficult to distinguish fake and genuine liquor; the boss said He had someone in the county government. China Tens of Thousand Miles towards Quality 1:34–35Google Scholar
  62. Luo H, Li D, Wang L (1998) The tragedy should not be allowed to repeat. China Tens of Thousand Miles towards Quality 5:16–17Google Scholar
  63. Ma G, Zhe D, Hu X, Luan D, Kong L, Yang X (2005) The drinking practice of people in China. Acta Nutrimenta Sinica 5:8–13Google Scholar
  64. Mertha AC (2005) The politics of piracy: intellectual property in contemporary China. Cornell University Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
  65. Morcom A (2008) ‘getting heard in Tibet: music, media and markets’, Consumption. Markets and Culture 11(4):259–285CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Morselli C, Giguere C (2006) Legitimate strengths in criminal networks. Crime Law Soc Chang 46:185–200CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. MPS (2011) Jiangsu Suzhou police successfully cracked down three alcohol counterfeiting sites, available at http://www.mps.gov.cn/n2255079/n2256131/n2256134/c3620324/content.html on 11 August 2016
  68. Nanjing Public Security (2016) Nanjing detected a large alcohol counterfeiting case, available at http://www.njga.gov.cn/www/njga/2010/gaxw4-mb_a39160713323709750.htm on 28 July 2016
  69. Naylor RT (2003) Towards a general theory of profit-driven crimes. Br J Criminol 43(1):81–101CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Sina News (2012) The trustworthy alcohol model store selling fake liquor, available at http://finance.sina.com.cnconsume/puguangtai/20120314/075311584225.shtml on 12 August 2016
  71. OECD (2016) Trade in counterfeit and pirated goods mapping the economic impact, available at: http://www.oecd.org/gov/risk/trade-in-counterfeit-and-pirated-goods-9789264252653-en.htm on 9 August 2016
  72. Paglee CD (1996) Chinese trademark law revised: new regulations protect well-known trademarks. University of Baltimore Intellectual Property Law Journal 5:37–81Google Scholar
  73. Pang X, Liu X (2015) Legislative consideration on the strict criminal liability in crimes against food safety regulations. Economic Vision 3:96–101Google Scholar
  74. Potter GW (1994) Criminal organizations: vice racketeering and politics in an American city. Waveland Press, Prospect Heights, ILGoogle Scholar
  75. Przyswa E (2014) Counterfeiting in the wines and spirits market: key issues and presentation of anti-counterfeiting technologies. SELINKO, ParisGoogle Scholar
  76. PwC (2013) Counterfeit goods in the UK: who is buying what, and why? PwC, LondonGoogle Scholar
  77. Quality Inspection (2011) Ten serious alcohol counterfeiting cases in 2011, Z1: 22Google Scholar
  78. Quality Inspection (2016) Beijing Chaorang District black liquor workshop used bedsheets to refine Baijiu, 2: 34Google Scholar
  79. Ruggiero V (1996) Organised and corporate crime in Europe. Dartmouth, AldershotGoogle Scholar
  80. Saltburn Smugglers’ Heritage Centre (1993) A Guinea for the brandy. Saltburn Smugglers’ Heritage Centre, SaltburnGoogle Scholar
  81. Shānxi Daily (2011) Alcohol counterfeiting workshops operated in the workers’ residential estate were cracked down by the Joint Operation of the Authorities of Industry and Commerce and the Police, available at http://www.sxrb.com/wb/news_13/sx_0/3177358.shtml on 12 August 2016
  82. Shen A (2015) Offending women in contemporary China: gender and pathways into crime. Palgrave Macmillan, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Shen Y, Wang Z (1998) China. In: Grant M (ed) Alcohol and emerging markets. International Centre for Alcohol Policies, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  84. Shen A, Antonopoulos GA, von Lampe K (2010) The dragon breathes smoke: cigarette counterfeiting in the People’s republic of China. Br J Criminol 50:239–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Shen A, Antonopoulos GA, Papanicolaou G (2013) China’s stolen children: internal child trafficking in the People’s republic of China. Trends in Organised Crime 16(1):31–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Sichuan Provincial Department of Commerce (2007) Disordered competition led to crazy alcohol counterfeiting and the liquor market is heavily drunk, available at http://sccom.hwadee.com/hyzx/-/articles/v/652128.shtml on 11 August 2016
  87. Simons, C. (2009) ‘Generic Giants ’, Newsweek 27 July: 32–5Google Scholar
  88. Sina News (2004) 6 people died from methanol poison in the guangzhou poisonous rice liquor case, available at http://news.sina.com.cn/c/2004-05-16/10423243449.shtml on 23 August 2016
  89. Smith G (1989) Smuggling into the Bristol Channel, 1700–1850. Countryside Books, NewburyGoogle Scholar
  90. Southern China Daily (2011a) To identify counterfeit alcohol is more difficult than to Verify genuine one, available at http://epaper.southcn.com/nfdaily/html/2011-11/07/content_7022981.htm on 12 August 2016
  91. Southern China Daily (2011b) The largest online shop for alcohol selling ten thousand bottles daily; fake alcohol seriously affecting the development of alcohol trade, available at http://www.chinanews.com/cj/2011/12-27/3561614.shtml on 12 August 2016
  92. Southern China Daily (2014) To identify fake liquor is more difficult than to do genuine one, http://epaper.southcn.com/nfdaily/html/2011-11/07/content_7022981.htm on 13 August 2016
  93. Southern China Weekend (2004a) How to eliminate ‘poisonous’ food and drinks? available at http://www.southcn.com/weekend/commend/200405200019.htm on 22 August 2016
  94. Southern China Weekend (2004b) Underground alcohol workshop run opposite the villagers’ committee, available at available at http://www.southcn.com/weekend/tempdir/200405200022.htm on 22 August 2016Google Scholar
  95. Southern Metropolis (2012) Smuggled and Fake Foreign Liquor underneath Online Shopping, available at http://finance.sina.com.cn/money/lcbgt/20120821/093012906684.shtml on 13 August 2016
  96. Sugar and Alcohol Quick News (2006) Wuhan detected a large scale alcohol counterfeiting Workshop, available at http://info.tjkx.com/news/00001139F1/2006-09-07/55959A6088.html on 11 August 2016
  97. The Guardian (2015) Bathtub booze and knock-off whisky: inside China's fake alcohol industry, available at https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2015/sep/16/china-fake-alcohol-industry-counterfeit-bathtub-booze-whisky on 20 August 2016
  98. The Telegraph (2015) Chinese people now drink more than British boozers, available at http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/11491900/Chinese-people-now-drink-more-than-British-boozers.html on 26 October 2016
  99. The World Bank (2016) Overview: China, available at http://www.worldbank.org/en/country/china/overview on 24 August 2016
  100. Tianjin Daily (1987) ‘Chasing up the counterfeit alcohol: a series’, Tianjin Daily 31 August – 4 SeptemberGoogle Scholar
  101. Tobacco China (2012) Alcohol counterfeiting persistent: Dongguan are having alcohol administration associates available at: http://www.tobaccochina.com/sales/news/show/20075/2007522161036_254592.shtml on 13 August 2012
  102. UNODC (2010) Counterfeit products. UNODC, ViennaGoogle Scholar
  103. van Duyne PC (2007) The Upperworld side of illicit trafficking. Crime & Justice International, November/December, pp. 46–47Google Scholar
  104. von Lampe K (2006) The cigarette black market in Germany and in the United Kingdom. Journal of Financial Crime 13:235–254CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. von Lampe K (2016) Organised crime: analysing illegal activities, criminal structures and extra-legal governance. Sage, Los Angeles, CaGoogle Scholar
  106. von Lampe K, Kurti M, Shen A, Antonopoulos GA (2012) The changing role of China in the global illegal cigarette trade. International Criminal Justice Review 22(1):43–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Wang Y (1988) Journalist investigation into the alcohol counterfeiting industry. Journalist Knowledge 12:11–15Google Scholar
  108. Wang K (1997) Celebrations Turn into Sorrow: Where is China’s consumer protection law? Canberra Law Review 4:151–199Google Scholar
  109. Wang H (2013) An analysis of current issues of food safety in Henan and their causes. Tianzhong Academic Journal 28(6):76–78Google Scholar
  110. Wang P (2014) Extra-legal protection in China: how guanxi distorts China’s legal system and facilitates the rise of unlawful protectors. Br J Criminol 54(5):809–830CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  111. Wang H (2015) A study on the problems in tackling crimes in relation to food and pharmaceutical products in Liuzhou and their countermeasures. Journal of Guangxi Police Academy 28(3):16–20Google Scholar
  112. Wang P, Antonopoulos GA (2015) Organized crime and illegal gambling: how do illegal gambling enterprises respond to the challenges posed by their illegality in China? Aust N Z J Criminol. doi: 10.1177/0004865815573874 Google Scholar
  113. Wang F, Lü H (2013) An analysis of the current characteristics of economic crimes and their preventive measures. Journal of Hubei University of Police 12:178–180Google Scholar
  114. Wu S (2015) The current situations of alcohol distribution inspection in Beijing and policy recommendations. China Marketing 5:20–21Google Scholar
  115. Xinhua News (2011a) Chongqing detected extremely large alcohol counterfeiting case and found over 30,000 sets of fake trademark signs, available at http://news.xinhuanet.com/food/2011-05/05/c_121379760.htm on 2 August 2016
  116. Xinhua News (2011b) Xinxua vision: investigation into counterfeit Maotai blended in a mortuary, available at http://news.xinhuanet.com/food/2011-05/16/c_121420718_3.htm on 2 August 2016
  117. Xinhua News (2011c) Chasing up the largest alcohol counterfeiting case in Hainan: how was the counterfeit alcohol made?, available at http://news.xinhuanet.com/food/2011-05/18/c_121430346.htm on 2 August 2016
  118. Xinhua News (2015) Counterfeit alcohol is sold in jin, hu and other places: alcohol bottled in a toilet was sold at over 10,000 yuan, available at http://www.hn.xinhuanet.com/2015-03/17/c_1114667243.htm on 2 August 2016
  119. Xue J (1991) Investigation into the alcohol markets and the legislative consideration. The Legal Journal 1:29–33Google Scholar
  120. Xuexidao (2015) Hu Ronghua: We must strengthen defence works to respond to alcohol counterfeiting, available at http://www.xxdao.com/180000/173924.shtml on 19 August 2016
  121. Yan X, Chen B (1985) Considering the wave of money worship. Academic Journal of Shānxi Provincial Committee Party School of the Chinese Communist Party S1:20–39Google Scholar
  122. Yang F (2016) Faked in China: nation branding, counterfeit culture and globalisation. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IndianaGoogle Scholar
  123. Zhan JV (2012) Filling the gap of formal institutions: the effects of guanxi network on corruption in reform-era China. Crime Law Soc Chang 58:93–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  124. Zhang Z (2012) Every link of the counterfeiting production chain has the 100 % profit margin. Qual Exploration Z1:19–22Google Scholar
  125. Zhong G, Zou H (2011) The facts about poisonous and faked liquor. China Brewing 9:198–199Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of Social Sciences, Business & LawTeesside UniversityMiddlesbroughUK

Personalised recommendations