Anything but peripheral to the institutional and political struggles of African American Studies in the post-Black Power era, the University of Virginia (UVA) occupies an important place in the field’s history. Combined with its role as a major funding source for graduate students and advanced scholars with research interests in the history, culture, and politics of the African diaspora, the University has been the site of passionate debates over the field’s transformative potential in both the academy and the larger world. It has also been an institution with a rather complicated relationship to the Black Studies project, due in no small part to internal divisions over the best way to advance the field’s pedagogical goals, research agenda, and political objectives. Consequently, UVA’s African American and African Studies program, particularly its “institute model” of scholarly advancement, provides an excellent case study for examining the regional breadth of the Black Studies movement and its broad impact on knowledge production within and beyond the academy.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Here, my deployment of the term “field” in reference to UVA’s African American Studies program reflects a conscious attempt on my part to use terminology representative of the dominant perspective—and by extension institutional arrangements—at the University of Virginia. This is not to say, however, that the University did not have scholars and students who viewed African American/Black Studies as a discipline. As was the case at many colleges and universities throughout the country, students, faculty, and administrators at UVA did not arrive at a general consensus on the question of whether African American Studies constituted a discipline or a field. On the one hand, scholars such as Armstead L. Robinson, along with key University administrators, viewed African American Studies as an interdisciplinary field of knowledge production that drew on the paradigms, methodological approaches, and theoretical frameworks of traditional disciplines (i.e., History, Sociology, Anthropology, and English). On the other hand, Vivian V. Gordon, a sociologist who served as the director of UVA’s Afro-American Studies program during the second half of the 1970s, embraced the position that Black Studies was indeed a discipline with its own methods of research and theoretical analyses. Hers was a perspective that increasingly drew the support of many black students during the late 1970s and the early 1980s.
For example, critical questions must be raised about the Carter G. Woodson Institute’s pre-doctoral and post-doctoral fellowship program, the intellectual profile of its recipients, and the extent to which the scholarship of the Institute’s fellows represent the diverse modes of inquiry within the field of African American Studies.
For a firsthand account of these developments see Gaston 2009.
Taylor and Harris submitted the proposal on behalf of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Black Students for Freedom and Members of the Black Academic Community.
Conspicuously absent from the UVA proposal is any discussion of how the future AAS program would serve the larger Charlottesville community, particularly African Americans. Such an omission is telling given the fact that most proposals demanding a Black Studies program devoted considerable attention to the field’s “practical dimension.” For example, in his important 1969 essay, “Black Studies: A Concept and A Plan,” James Turner, director of the Afro-American Studies Center at Cornell University, let it be known that his center would be deeply committed to responding to the needs and concerns of the African American community. “Contemporary black students,” he noted, “feel a keen sense of themselves as an extension of the Black community-a distinct few who seek to gain educational and scientific experiences in order to work within the Black community… Increasing, Black students are seeking to promulgate a conceptual and theoretical framework within which constructive change may be channeled into the black community. They seek to build; thus, a relevant education becomes a necessity.” A parallel perspective appears in Darwin Turner’s proposal for the Center for Afro-American Studies at North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University.” In that text, Turner wrote: “What is essential to the proponents of such a Black Studies program is that each item of the program be planned in reference to a goal of liberation and development of black people. In short, the student is not to be trained to be a ‘credit to his race’—to echo the old platitude of praise—but to be an asset to his people.” Though the University of Virginia’s “Proposal for an Afro-American Studies” recommended courses that would address issues of concern for African American communities, one never gets a sense that the program would have an intimate connection to local people (Turner; Turner 1969).
For more detail on the student protests at Duke University consult the following sources: New York Times, “Protesters Disrupt Duke and C.C.N.Y,” February 14, 1969; Fergus 2009. Significantly, the campuses of UNC-Chapel Hill, UNC-Charlotte, UNC-Greensboro, and North Carolina A&T also witnessed a great deal of political unrest as youth activists organized around issues ranging from workers wages to the formation of Black Studies programs. See Fink 1995.
Jet Magazine, “Virginia to Offer Black Studies Major,” August 13, 1970.
According to James Cone and Gayraud Wilmore, Washington’s negative reply to the query of whether African American churches were Christian “made him the most talked about and controversial Black scholar of religion” during the late sixties. See Cone and Wilmore 1993. For a small sampling of Washington’s immense contributions to black religious thought, as well as the scholarly critiques of his work see Wilmore 1983; Coleman 2000; Evans 1992; Baldwin 1992.
Cavalier Daily, October 13, 1975.
Consult Cavalier Daily, November 11, 1980.
It is important to note that the National Council for Black Studies regularly engaged in these debates. Vivian Gordon, the only UVA faculty member with strong ties to the NCBS, was often a participant in these debates.
Cavalier Daily, February 24, 1981.
Ad Hoc Committee of the Black Students for Freedom (1969). Proposal for Afro-American studies. March 14.
Aldridge, D. P. (2009). Imagine a world: pioneering black women sociologists (pp. 37–46). Maryland: University Press of America.
Asante, M., & Ravitch, D. (1991). Multiculturalism: an exchange. American Scholar, 60, 267–276.
Baldwin, L. V. (1992). To make the wounded whole: The cultural legacy of Martin Luther King, Jr (pp. 90–95). Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
Baker, H. A. (2007). I don’t hate the south: reflections on Faulkner, family, and the south. New York: Oxford University Press.
Berry, R. (1971). Julian Bond keynotes black culture program. Daily progress. February 15, p. 1.
Black Student Alliance Archives (1980a). University of Virginia, folder. (April 24, 1980). Letter from Michael Campbell to Joseph J. Russell.
Black Student Alliance Archives (1980b). University of Virginia, folder. (June 12, 1980). Letter from Talmadge Anderson to Mike Campbell.
Black Student Alliance Archives (1991). University of Virginia, folder. (no date). Tahnee Jackson Correspondence.
Buford, R. (1969). Shannon appoints 9 to Faculty Committee for Black Studies. Cavalier daily. September 5, p. 1.
Cavalier Daily. (1980). Gordon’s departure. March 4, p 3.
Center for the Study of Civil Rights Brochure. (1989).
Charlottesville-Albemarle Tribune. (1970). U.V.A. Black Studies major approved by the State Board. June 8, p 5.
Coleman, W. (2000). Tribal talk: black theology, hermeneutics, and African/American way of “telling the story” (pp. 173–174). University Park: Penn State University Press.
Cone, J. H., & Wilmore, G. S. (1993). Black theology: a documentary history, volume one: 1966–1979 (p. 89). Maryknoll: Orbis Books.
Cruse, H. (1979). The academic side of the movement and the movement side of the academic. In V. Gordon (Ed.), Lectures: black scholars on black issues (pp. 23–35). Washington: University Press of America.
Davies, C. B. (2003). Decolonizing the academy: African diaspora studies. Trenton: African World Press.
Du Bois, W.E.B. . (1989). The Souls of Black Folk. New York: Penguin Books.
Evans, J., Jr. (1992). We have been believers: African American systematic theology. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
Executive Board (1981). University chapter, NAACP. Institute would diminish incentive. Cavalier daily. December 5, p. 2.
Faulders, T. (1969). Students to present proposal for ending ‘Racist atmosphere’. Cavalier daily. February 19, p. 1.
Fergus, D. (2009). Liberalism, black power, and the making of American politics, 1965–1980 (p. 34). Athens: University of Georgia Press.
Fink, W. (1995). William Friday: power, purpose, and American higher education (pp. 128–158). Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Gaston, P. (2009). Coming of age in utopia: the odyssey of an idea (pp. 245–332). Montgomery: New South Books.
Gordon, V. V. (1974). The self concept of Black Americans. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA.
Gordon, V. V. (1977). The self-concept of Black Americans. Washington: University Press of America.
Gordon, V. V. (Ed.). (1979). Lectures: black scholars on black issues. Washington: University Press of America.
Gordon, V.V. (1980). The coming of age of Black Studies: beyond ‘Relevance’. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, pp 51–56, September.
Gordon, V. V. (1981). The coming of age of Black Studies: beyond ‘relevance’. New Directions for Teaching and Learning 6.
Gordon, V. V. (1987). Black women, feminism, and black liberation: which way? Chicago: Third World Press.
Hamilton, T. (1981a). Institute: Robinson predicts success for infant program. Cavalier daily. May 1, p 4.
Hamilton, T. (1981b). Administration fulfills two afro institute promises. Cavalier daily. August 31, p A4.
Hathaway, S. (1980). Campbell: Protests will continue. Cavalier daily, October 15, p 1.
Johnson, D. (1981a). Council rejects afro department. Cavalier daily. February 19, p 1.
Johnson, D. (1981b). Afro institute unveiled, praised. Cavalier daily. April 23, p 1.
Jordon, A. & Crawford, K. (1980). Poll shows department favored. Cavalier daily. December 3, p 2.
Joseph, P. E. (2006). Black Studies, student activism, and the black power movement. In P. Joseph (Ed.), The black power movement: rethinking the civil rights-black power era (pp. 251–277). New York: Routledge.
Judy, R. A. T. (1993). Disforming the American canon: African-Arabic slave narratives and the vernacular. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Katz, D. (1980). Afro-American proposals debated. Cavalier daily. December 3, p 8.
Katz, D. (1981). Afro institute given final approval. Cavalier daily. April 22, p 1.
Kernan, C. (1989). Evaluation report. In: R. Armstead (Ed.), AEP: Impact report for the Carter G. Woodson Institute. Charlottesville, VA, June 2.
Kimball, P. (1971). Joe Washington: Activist religion professor. Cavalier daily. February 26, p 1.
Lewis, A. N. (1981). Black Studies at the university? (p. 14). Ujamaa: Newsletter of the Office of Afro-American affairs.
Minton, B. (1978). Program lacks faculty support. Cavalier daily. December 1, p 6.
Nicholson, J. (1983). College professor, poet, activist pours energies into social issues. Daily progress. December 11: E1, E4.
Pearson, R. (1970). Faculty adopts major in Afro-American studies. Cavalier daily. March 26, p 1.
Pritchard, R. (1970). BSF presents black culture week. Cavalier daily. February 5, p 2.
Ravitch, D. (1990). Multiculturalism: E Pluribus Plures. American Scholar, 59(3), 337–354.
Robinson, A., Papers (1980a). Small special collections, University of Virginia, folder: correspondence. (May 13). Letter from Armstead Robinson to Jesse Ruth Gaston.
Robinson, A., Papers (1980b). Small special collections, folder: correspondence. (November 25). Letter from Armstead Robinson to Jesse Ruth Gaston.
Robinson, A. L. (1981). Beyond the realm of social consensus: new meanings of reconstruction for American history. Journal of American History, 68(2), 276–297.
Robinson, A. L. (1989). Report for SCHEV review of research and public service centers. Carter G. Woodson Institute for Afro-American and African Studies at the University of Virginia.
Robinson, A., Papers (1992). Small special collections, folder: correspondence. (October 22). Letter from Armstead Robinson to Ms. Shirley Meaker.
Rojas, F. (2007). From black power to Black Studies: how a radical movement became an discipline. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press.
Rooks, N. M. (2006). White money/black power: the surprising history of African American studies and the crisis of race in higher education. Boston: Beacon.
Ruford, B. (1969). Shannon appoints 9 to faculty committee for Black Studies. Cavalier daily, 1, September 25.
Schlesinger, A. M., Jr. (1992). The disuniting of America: reflections on a multicultural society. New York: WW Norton.
Small, M. L. (1999). Departmental conditions and the emergence of new disciplines: two cases in the legitimation of African-American studies. Theory and Society, 28, 659–707.
Stewart, J. B. (2003). The field and function of Black Studies: toward an accurate assessment of the state of Black Studies in the 1970s and 1980s. In D. P. Aldridge & C. Young (Eds.), Out of the revolution: the development of Africana studies (pp. 15–24). Lanham: Lexington Books.
Strolberg, S. (1980). Afro-Affairs institute possible. Cavalier daily. October 16, p 1.
Sudranski, E. (1975a). Living her educational ideal. Cavalier daily. October 13, p 3.
Sudranski, E. (1975b). Afro-American studies dispels myths. Cavalier daily. October 13, p 3.
Taylor, B. (1980a). Harris joins call for department. Cavalier daily, November 20, p 1.
Taylor, B. (1980b). Gordon quits chairmanship. Cavalier daily. March 4, p 1.
Turner, D. The center for Afro-American studies at North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University. Journal of Negro Education, 39(221), 229
Turner, J. (1969). Black Studies: a concept and a plan. Cornell Chronicle, 1(2), 1–8.
Turner, J. (2010). Sitting in and speaking out: student movements in the American South, 1960–1970. Athens: University of Georgia Press.
Washington, J. R. (1964). Black religion. Boston: Beacon.
White, D. (2004). New concepts for the new man: The Institute for the Black World (IBW) and the incomplete victory of the second reconstruction. Ph.D. dissertation, Ohio State University.
Wilkins, R. (1969). The case against separtism: ‘Black Jim Crow’ in Martin Kilson’s Black Studies: Myths and realities, 9-15 (pp. 38–40). A. Philip Randolph Educational Fund: New York.
Wilmore, G. S. (1983). Black religion and black radicalism: an interpretation of the religious history of afro-American people (pp. 210–211). Maryknoll: New York.
Wood, P. H. (1989). Evaluation report. In: R. Armstead (Ed.), AEP: Impact report for the Carter G. Woodson Institute. Charlottesville, VA, May 19.
Woodson, C. G. (1918). A century of Negro migration. Washington: Associated Publishers.
Woodson, C. G. (1933). Mis-education of the Negro. Washington: Associated Publishers.
Woodson, C. G. (1936). African background outlined. Washington: Associated Publishers.
About this article
Cite this article
Harold, C.N. “Of the Wings of Atalanta”: The Struggle for African American Studies at the University of Virginia, 1969–1995. J Afr Am St 16, 41–69 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12111-011-9172-3