Cooperation towards public goods relies on credible threats of punishment to deter cheats. However, punishing is costly, so it remains unclear who incurred the costs of enforcement in our evolutionary past. Theoretical work suggests that human cooperation may be promoted if people believe in supernatural punishment for moral transgressions. This theory is supported by new work in cognitive psychology and by anecdotal ethnographic evidence, but formal quantitative tests remain to be done. Using data from 186 societies around the globe, I test whether the likelihood of supernatural punishment—indexed by the importance of moralizing “high gods”—is associated with cooperation.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Alexander, R. D. 1987 The Biology of Moral Systems. Hawthorne, New York: Aldine.
Bering, J. M. 2002 The Existential Theory of Mind. Review of General Psychology 6:3–24.
2004 The Evolutionary History of an Illusion: Religious Causal Beliefs in Children and Adults. In Origins of the Social Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and Child Development, B. Ellis and D. Bjorklund, eds. Pp. 411–437. New York: Guilford Press.
in press The Folk Psychology of Souls.
Bering, J. M., and D. F. Bjorklund 2004 The Natural Emergence of Reasoning about the Afterlife as a Developmental Regularity. Developmental Psychology 40:217–233.
Bering, J. M., and D. D. P. Johnson 2005 “Oh Lord, You Hear My Thoughts from Afar”: Recursiveness in the Cognitive Evolution of Supernatural Agency. Journal of Cognition and Culture 5:118–143.
Bering, J. M., and T. Shackelford 2004 The Causal Role of Consciousness: A Conceptual Addendum to Human Evolutionary Psychology. Review of General Psychology 8:227–248.
Bering, Jesse M., Katrina McLeod, and Todd K. Shackelford 2005 Reasoning about Dead Agents Reveals Possible Adaptive Trends. Human Nature 16:360–381.
Boyd, R., H. Gintis, S. Bowles, and P. J. Richerson 2003 The Evolution of Altruistic Punishment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 100:3531–3535.
Burnham, T. 2001 Mean Genes: From Sex to Money to Food, Taming Our Primal Instincts. New York: Penguin.
Burnham, T., and D. D. P. Johnson 2005 The Biological and Evolutionary Logic of Human Cooperation. Analyse & Kritik 27, in press.
Clutton-Brock, T. H., and G. A. Parker 1995 Punishment in Animal Societies. Nature 373:209–216.
Coward, H. 2003 Sin and Salvation in the World Religions: A Short Introduction. Oxford: Oneworld.
Cronk, L. 1994 Evolutionary Theories of Morality and the Manipulative Use of Signals. Zygon 4:117–135.
Davidson, R. J., K. M. Putnam, and C. L. Larson 2000 Dysfunction in the Neural Circuitry of Emotion Regulation: A Possible Prelude to Violence. Science 289:591–594.
Dawkins, R. 1986 The Selfish Gene. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
de Quervain, D. J.-F., U. Fischbacher, V. Treyer, M. Schellhammer, U. Schnyder, A. Buck, and E. Fehr 2004 The Neural Basis of Altruistic Punishment. Science 305:1254–1258.
de Waal, F. B. 1996 Good Natured: The Origins of Right and Wrong in Humans and Other Animals. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Divale, W. 2000 Pre-Coded Variables for the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample, Vols. 1 and 2. New York: York College, CUNY.
Ember, C. R., and M. Ember 1992 Codebook for “Warfare, Aggression, and Resource Problems: Cross-Cultural Codes.” Behavior Science Research 26:169–186.
1998 Cross-Cultural Research. In Handbook of Methods in Cultural Anthropology, H. R. Bernard, ed. Pp. 647–687. Walnut Creek, California: AltaMira.
Fehr, E., and U. Fischbacher 2003 The Nature of Human Altruism. Nature 425:785–791.
Fehr, E., and S. Gächter 2000 Cooperation and Punishment in Public Goods Experiments. American Economic Review 90:980–994.
2002 Altruistic Punishment in Humans. Nature 415:137–140.
2003 Reply to Johnson et al. Nature 421:912.
Frank, R. H. 1988 Passions within Reason: The Strategic Role of the Emotions. New York: Norton.
Frayser, S. G. 1985 Varieties of Sexual Experience. Pittsburgh: HRAF Press.
Goldstein, M. A. 2002 The Biological Roots of Heat-of-Passion Crimes and Honor Killings. Politics and the Life Sciences 21:28–37.
Heckathorn, D. D. 1989 Collective Action and the Second-Order Free Rider Problem. Rational Society 1:78–100.
Hamilton, W. D. 1964 The Genetical Evolution of Social Behavior, I and II. Journal of Theoretical Biology 7:1–52.
Henrich, J., and R. Boyd 2001 Why People Punish Defectors: Weak Conformist Transmission Can Stabilize Costly Enforcement of Norms in Cooperative Dilemmas. Journal of Theoretical Biology 208:79–89.
Henrich, J., R. Boyd, S. Bowles, C. Camerer, E. Fehr, and H. Gintis, eds. 2004 Foundations of Human Sociality: Economic Experiments and Ethnographic Evidence from Fifteen Small-Scale Societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hultkrantz, A. 1967 The Religions of the American Indians. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Irons, W. 2001 Religion as a Hard-to-Fake Sign of Commitment. In Evolution and the Capacity for Commitment, R. Nesse, ed. Pp. 292–309. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
Johnson, D. D. P., and J. M. Bering in prep. Hand of God, Mind of Man: Punishment and Cognition in the Evolution of Cooperation.
Johnson, D. D. P., and O. Kruger 2004 The Good of Wrath: Supernatural Punishment and the Evolution of Cooperation. Political Theology 5(2):159–176.
Johnson, D., P. Stopka, and S. Knights 2003 The Puzzle of Human Cooperation. Nature 421:911–912.
Kagel, J. H., and A. E. Roth, eds. 1995 The Handbook of Experimental Economics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Krebs, J. R., and N. B. Davies 1993 An Introduction to Behavioral Ecology. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific.
Lagace, R. O. 1979 The HRAF Probability Sample. Behavior Science Research 14:211–229.
Lang, H. 1998 CONAN: An Electronic Code-Text Data-Base for Cross-Cultural Studies. World Cultures 9:13–56.
Malinowski, B. 1935 The Foundations of Faith and Morals: An Anthropological Analysis of Primitive Beliefs and Conduct with Special Reference to the Fundamental Problem of Religion and Ethics. London: Oxford University Press.
McClure, S. M., D. I. Laibson, G. Loewenstein, and J. D. Cohen 2004 Separate Neural Systems Value Immediate and Delayed Monetary Rewards. Science 306:503–507.
Murdock, G. P. 1962–1971 (Various articles in various issues.) Ethnology.
1967 Ethnographic Atlas. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
1980 Theories of Illness: A World Survey. Pittsburgh: HRAF, University of Pittsburgh Press.
1981 Atlas of World Cultures. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Murdock, G. P., and D. O. Morrow 1970 Subsistence Economy and Supportive Practices: Cross-Cultural Codes 1. Ethnology 9:302–330.
Murdock, G. P., and C. Provost 1973 Measurement of Cultural Complexity. Ethnology 12:379–392.
Murdock, G. P., and D. R. White 1969 Standard Cross-Cultural Sample. Ethnology 8:329–369.
Murdock, G. P., and S. F. Wilson 1972 Settlement Patterns and Community Organization: Cross-Cultural Codes 3. Ethnology 11:254–295.
Nettle, D. 2004 Adaptive Illusions: Optimism, Control and Human Rationality. In Emotion, Evolution and Rationality, D. Evans and P. Cruse, eds. Pp. 191–206. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Olson, M. 1965 The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Ostrom, E. 1990 Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ostrom, E., J. Walker, and R. Gardner 1992 Covenants with and without a Sword: Self Governance Is Possible. American Political Science Review 86:404–417.
Peregrine, P. N. 1995a The Birth of the Gods and Replications: Background to the Data and Codes. World Cultures 9:57–64.
1995b The Birth of the Gods Revisited: A Partial Replication of Guy Swanson’s (1960) Cross-Cultural Study of Religion. Cross-Cultural Research 30:84–112.
Povinelli, D. J., and J. M. Bering 2002 The Mentality of Apes Revisited. Current Directions in Psychological Science 11:115–119.
Rice, W. R. 1989 Analyzing Tables of Statistical Tests. Evolution 43:223–225.
Robinson, P. H., and J. M. Darley 2004 Does Criminal Law Deter? A Behavioural Science Investigation. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 24:173–205.
Roes, F. L., and M. Raymond 2003 Belief in Moralizing Gods. Evolution and Human Behaviour 24:126–135.
Ross, M. 1983 Political Decision Making and Conflict: Additional Cross-Cultural Codes and Scales. Ethnology 22:169–192.
Sanday, P. 1981 Female Power and Male Dominance. Unpublished ms. (Data encoded in SCCS; cited in Divale 2001)
Sanfey, A. G., J. K. Rilling, J. A. Aronson, L. E. Nystrom, and J. D. Cohen 2003 The Neural Basis of Economic Decision-Making in the Ultimatum Game. Science 300:1755–1758.
Schneider, D. M. 1957 Political Organization, Supernatural Sanctions and the Punishment for Incest on Yap. American Anthropologist 59:791–800.
Sigmund, K., C. Hauert, and M. Nowak 2001 Reward and Punishment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 98:10757–10761.
Sokal, R., and F. J. Rohlf 1995 Biometry: The Principles and Practice of Statistics in Biological Research. New York: Freeman.
Sosis, R. 2000 Religion and Intragroup Cooperation: Preliminary Results of a Comparative Analysis of Utopian Communities. Cross-Cultural Research 34:71–88.
2003 Why Aren’t We All Hutterites? Costly Signaling Theory and Religious Behavior. Human Nature 14:91–127.
Sosis, R., and C. Alcorta 2003 Signaling, Solidarity, and the Sacred: The Evolution of Religious Behavior. Evolutionary Anthropology 12:264–274.
Sosis, R., and E. R. Bressler 2003 Cooperation and Commune Longevity: A Test of the Costly Signaling Theory of Religion. Cross-Cultural Research 37:211–239.
Sosis, R., and B. J. Ruffle 2003 Religious Ritual and Cooperation: Testing for a Relationship on Israeli Religious and Secular Kibbutzim. Current Anthropology 44:713–722.
Swanson, G. E. 1960 The Birth of the Gods. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan.
Thomas, W. I., and D. S. Thomas 1928 The Child in America: Behavior Problems and Programs. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
Tinbergen, N. 1968 On War and Peace in Animals and Man: An Ethologist’s Approach to the Biology of Aggression. Science 160:1411–1418.
Tomasello, M., J. Call, and B. Hare 2003 Chimpanzees Understand Psychological States—The Question Is Which Ones and To What Extent. Trends in Cognitive Science 7:153–156.
Trivers, R. L. 1971 The Evolution of Reciprocal Altruism. Quarterly Review of Biology 46:35–57.
Tuden, A., and C. Marshall 1972 Political Organization: Cross-Cultural Codes 4. Ethnology 11:436–464.
Tylor, E. B. 1948 Primitive Culture: Researches into the Development of Mythology, Philosophy, Religion, Language, Art and Custom. New York: Harper and Bros. (Originally published in 1871)
Underhill, R. 1975 Economic and Political Antecedents of Monotheism: A Cross-Cultural Study. American Journal of Sociology 80:841–861.
Weber, M. 1978 The Sociology of Religion. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Wheeler, V. 1974 Drums and Guns: A Cross-Cultural Study of the Nature of War. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Oregon, Eugene.
Whyte, M. K. 1978 The Status of Women in Preindustrial Societies. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Wilson, D. S. 2002 Darwin’s Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Wilson, E. O. 2000 Sociobiology: The New Synthesis, rev. ed. Harvard: Belknap Press. (Originally published in 1975)
Wrangham, R. W. 1999 The Evolution of Coalitionary Killing. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 42:1–30.
Yamagishi, T. 1986 The Provision of a Sanctioning System as a Public Good. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 51:110–116.
Zahavi, A. 1995 Altruism as Handicap: The Limitations of Kin Selection and Reciprocity. Journal of Avian Biology 26:1–3.
Dominic Johnson is a fellow in the Princeton University Society of Fellows. He holds a D.Phil. in biology from Oxford University and a Ph.D. in political science from Geneva University. His research revolves around the evolutionary biology of human behavior and how this impacts on conflict, cooperation, politics, and religion. His recent book, Overconfidence and War: The Havoc and Glory of Positive Illusions, was published in 2004 by Harvard University Press.
About this article
Cite this article
Johnson, D.D.P. God’s punishment and public goods. Hum Nat 16, 410–446 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12110-005-1017-0
- Evolution of cooperation
- High gods
- Intentionality system
- Standard Cross-Cultural Sample
- Supernatural punishment
- World cultures