Conclusion
As we have seen, history is not only a tale of great men and their wills and their imagination, but it is partly also that story. Following Professor Lipset’s injuction, we find that by including leaders in our understanding of the world and in our reckoning of what is possible and desirable in human societies, we can more fully appreciate the extent to which choices can stretch constraits. The depths of Italian and Japanese liberalism and their replacement by fascism point us toward reisserting choice between great social, economic, and political forces on the one hand, and outcomes on the other. The choices to bolster the state against the challenges of mass politics. Goilitti reached out to leftist parties in a failed effort to incorporate the masses. Neither Hara nor Giolitti ever reached out directly to the masses with a compelling idea about a shared national project. Thay did not inspire citizens—they bought voters. And, in the event, buying agve way to bullying in both countries. Hara Kei and Giovanni Giolitti, two consummate politicians, had failed to be sufficiently creative. Their successors were remarkably creative bricoleurs who would not make the same mistake. And, as Lipset has reminded us, so long as leaders are creative, history has no shortcut and no end.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adler, Hugh Franklin. 1995. Italian Industrialists from Liberalism to Fascism: The Political Development of the Industrial Bourgeoisie, 1906-1934. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Aquarone, Alberto. 1974. “The Rise of the Fascist State: 1926-1928.” Pp. 101–115 in The Ax Within: Italian Fascism in Action, edited by R. Sarti. New York: New Viewpoints.
Beasley, W. G. 1990. The Rise of Modern Japan. London: Weidenfeld & Nicholson.
Berger, Gordon. 1977. Parties Out of Power in Japan: 1931-1941. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bosworth, R. J. B. 1998. The Italian Dictatorship: Problems and Perspectives in the Interpretation of Mussolini and Fascism. London: Arnold.
Chabod, Federico. 1996. Italian Foreign Policy: The Statecrafi of the Founders. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Clark, Martin. 1996. Modern Italy: 1871-1995, second edition. London: Longmans.
Coppa, Frank J. 1970. “Economic and Ethical Liberalism in Conflict: The Extraordinary Liberalism of Giovanni Giolitti.” The Journal of'Mod0ern History 42 (2): 191–215.
—. 1971. Planning, Protection, and Politics in Liberal Italy: Economics and Politics in the Giolittian Age. Washington, DC: The Catholic University Press.
Croce, Benedetto. 1944. “Ilfascismo comeparentesi” (Fascism as a parenthesis). Speech before the first Congress of the parties to the Committee of National Liberation, Bari, 28 January. Reprinted in Casucci, Costanzo, ed. 1944. Ilfascismo: antologia di scritti critici (Fascism: An Anthology of Critical Writings) Bologna: II Mulino, X, p. 347.
De Grand, Alexander J. 2001. The Hunchback's Tailor: Giovanni Giolitti and Liberal Italy from the Challenge of Mass Politics to the Rise of Fascism, 1882-1922. Westport: Praeger.
Duus, Peter. 1968. Party Rivalry and Political Change in Taisho Japan. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Ferrata, Giansiro and Niccolo Gallo, eds. 1964. 2000 pagine di gramsci (volumeprimo) nel tempo della lotta (1914-1926) (2000 pages of Gramsci, first volume, In the Period of Struggle, 1914-1926) Milano: II Saggiatore.
Germino, Dante L. 1971. The Italian Fascist Party in Power: A Study in Totalitarian Rule. New York: Howard Fertig.
Giolitti, Giovanni. 1923. Memoirs of My Life. London and Sydney: Chapman and Dodd.
Gordon, Andrew. 1991 Labor and Imperial Democracy in Prewar Japan. Berkeley: University of California Press. Hori, Makiyo. 1990. “Kita Ikki and Japanese Fascism.” Pp. 70–79 in Rethinking Japan (Volume II: Social Sciences, Ideology, and Thought), edited by Adriana Boscaro, Franco Gatti, and Massimo Raveri. Sandgate: Japan Library.
Ikeda, Hajime. 1983. Nihon Shimin Shisō to Kokkaron (The Political Thought of the Japanese People and Nationalist Ideas). Tokyo: Ronsôsha.
Kawada, Minoru. 1998. Hara Takashi to Yamagata Aritomo: Kokka Kōsō o Meguru Gaikō to Naisei (Hara Takashi and Yamagata Aritomo: Diplomacy and National Politics Related to Nationalism). Tokyo: Chûô Kôron.
Kikuchi, Taketoshi. 1992. Issan seitōjin Hara Takashi (Hara Takashi: Indefatigable Party Politician). Morioka: Iwate Nippôsha.
Lanzara, Giovan Francesco. 1998. “Self-Destructive Processes in Institution Building and Some Modest Countervailing Mechanisms,” European Journal of Political Research 33: 1–39.
Lévi-Strauss, Claude. 1966. The Savage Mind. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1998. “George Washington and the Founding of Democracy.” Journal of Democracy 9 (4): 24–38.
Losito, Marta and Sandro Segre. 1992. “Ambiguous Influences: Italian Sociology and the Fascist Regime.” Pp. 42–87 in Sociology Responds to Fascism, edited by Stephen P. Turner and Dirk Kasler. London: Routledge.
Machiavelli, Niccolô. 1986. The Discourses. London: Penguin.
Mack Smith, Denis. 1959 and 1969 (revised edition). Italy: A Modern History. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Maruyama, Masao. 1963. Thought and Behaviour in Modern Japanese Politics. London: Oxford University Press.
Mitani, Taichirô. 1995. Nihon Seitō Seiji no Keisei: Hara Takashi no Seiji Shidō no Tenkai (The State of Japanese Party Politics: The Evolution of Hara Takashi's Party Poitics). Tokyo: Tokyô Daigaku Shuppankai.
Moore Jr., Barrington. 1966. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy: Lord and Peasant in the Making of the Modern World. Boston: Beacon Press.
Mussolini, Benito. 1998. My Rise and Fall. New York: Da Capo Press.
Najita, Tetsuo. 1967. Hara Kei in the Politics of Compromise: 1905-1915. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Romano, Sergio. 1991. “La cultura della politica esterna italiana” (The Culture of Italian Foreign Policy). Pp. 17–34 in La politica esterna italiana: 1860-1985 (Italy's Foreign Policy: 1860-1985), edited by R. J. B. Bosworth and Sergio Romano. Bologna: II Mulino.
Salomone, A. William. Italian Democracy in the Making. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1945.
Sarti, Roland. 1974. “Introduction.” Pp. 1–12 in The Ax Within: Italian Fascism in Action, edited by Roland Sarti. New York: New Viewpoints.
Seton-Watson, Christopher. 1967. Italy from Liberalism to Fascism: 1870-1925. London: Methuen.
Silberman, Bernard S. 1996. “The Continuing Dilemma: Bureaucracy and Political Parties.” Social Science Japan 7, August.
Sprigge, Cecil J. S. 1969. The Development of Modern Italy. New York: Howard Fertig.
Sturzo, Luigi. 1926. Italy and Fascismo. New York: Harcourt Brace and Co.
Tarrow, Sidney. 1994. “The Odd Couple: Political-Institutional Change in Italy and Japan After the Cold War.” Unpublished paper presented to the Seminar on Institutional Change in Europe, Nuffield College, Oxford, 21 January.
Togliatti, Palmiro. 1973. Discorso su Giolitti (Discourse on Giolitti). Roma: Riuniti.
Tullio-Altan, Carlo. 1997. La coscienza civile degli italiani: valore e disvalore nella storia nazionale (Civil Consciousness of the Italians: Positive and Negative Values in National History). Udine: Paolo Gaspari.
Wilson, George Maklin. 1967-1968. “A New Look at the Problem of'Japanese Fascism',” Comparative Studies in Society and History. Volume X: 401–412.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
He is author of a new work called Leaders, published by Cornell Universiry Press. He is the recipient of grants from the Social Science Research Council and the Marshall Fund of Germany.
This paper is derived from my forthcoming book: Leaders. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2003. I am grateful to the Abe Fellowship Program of the Social Science Research Council and the German Marshall Fund for supporting my research.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Samuels, R.J. When leadership failed. Am Soc 34, 33–44 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12108-003-1004-z
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12108-003-1004-z