Abstract
This article places an episode in the history of sociological theory into intellectual history in the twentieth century. The perspective is chronological as well as contextual. The themes are two theoretical approaches, both embedded in both American and German history, Parsonian Systems Theory and “Frankfurt School” Critical Theory. The chronology shown spanned mainly from the 1940s to the 1960s. The context of the two theories is a period that is crucial in twentieth century history. The protagonists of the two approaches were, in the 1940s, Americans and Germans exiled in the United States. In the 1950s, both approaches were affected by McCarthyism in different ways. The 1960s, however, were the culmination. The dynamics of the two approaches led into a schism which came into the open on the occasion of the 1964 German Sociology Conference in Heidelberg celebrating Max Weber. The article shows the stages in the evolution of the schism, emulating three acts in a drama. The final split was over whether Weber or Marx should be the classic whose oeuvre was to influence sociological thinking today. My aim is to exemplify how these two authoritative approaches in sociological theory, far from escaping the vagaries and vicissitudes of their times, were embedded in twentieth-century history.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackerman, Nathan W., and Marie Jahoda. 1950. Anti-Semitism and Emotional Disorder: A Psycho-analytic Interpretation. New York: Harper and Brothers.
Adorno, Theodor W. 1946. “Anti-Semitism and Fascist Propaganda.” In: Ernst Simmel (ed.), Anti-Semitism—a Social Disease. New York: International Universities Press, 125–137.
— 1951. Minima Moralia: Reflexionen aus dem beschädigten Leben. Berlin and Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
— 1952a. “Zur gegenwärtigen Situation der empirischen Sozialforschung in Deutschland.” In: Empirische Sozialforschung: Meinungsund Marktforschung Methoden und Probleme. Frankfurt am Main: Institut zur Förderung öffentlicher Angelegenheiten e.V., 27–39.
-. 1952b. “Die revidierte Psychoanalyse,” reprinted: Adorno, Gesammelte Schriften (editor, Rolf Tiedemann), vol. 8, Soziologische Schriften I, Frankfurt: Suhrkamp 1972, 20-41.
—1955a. Prismen: Kulturkritik und Gesellschaft. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
— 1955b. “Zum Verhältnis von Soziologie und Psychologie.” In: Sociologica: Aufsätze Max Horkheimer zum Sechzigsten Geburtstag gewidmet. Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanstalt 1955, 11–45; translated: “Sociology and Psychology,” New Left Review, vol. 46, 1967, 63-80, and vol. 47, 1968, 79-97.
—1957. “Soziologie und empirische Sozialforschung.” In: Klaus Ziegler, Wesen und Wirklichkeit des Menschen: Festschrift für Helmuth Plessner. Göttingen: Vandenhoek und Ruprecht, 245–267.
—1962. “Zur Logik der Sozialwissenschaften,” Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, vol. 14, 233–248.
— 1965. “Rede beim offiziellen Empfang im Heidelberger Schloss,” in: Otto Stammer (ed.), Max Weber und die Soziologie heute. Tübingen: Mohr, 99–102.
— 1967. “Vorrede,” in: Joachim Bergmann, Die Theorie des sozialen Systems von Talcott Parsons, Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanstalt, 3–5.
— 1969. “Einleitung,” in: Adorno et al., Der Positivismusstreit in der deutschen Soziologie. Neuwied: Luchterhand, 7–80.
—Else Frenkel-Brunswik, Daniel Levinson, and R. Nevitt Sanford (in collaboration with Betty Aron, Maria Hertz Levinson, and William Morrow). 1950. The Authoritarian Personality. New York: Harper and Brothers.
—Ralf Dahrendorf, Harald Pilot, Hans Albert, Jürgen Habermas, and Karl Popper. 1969. Der Positivismusstreit in der deutschen Soziologie. Neuwied: Luchterhand.
Albrecht, Clemens, Günter C. Behrmann, Michael Bock, Harald Homann, and Friedrich Tenbruck. Die intellektuelle Gründung der Bundesrepublik: Eine Wirkungsgeschichte der Frankfurter Schule. Frankfurt/New York: Campus.
Alexander, Jeffrey. 1983. The Modern Reconstruction of Classical Thought: Talcott Parsons. Theoretical Logic in Sociology, vol. 4, Berkeley: University of California Press.
Bendix, Reinhard. 1960. Max Weber—An Intellectual Portrait. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Bendix, Reinhard 1965. “Diskussionsbeitrag,” in: Otto Stammer (ed.), Max Weber und die Soziologie heute, 184-191.
Bendix, Reinhard 1971. “Two Sociological Traditions,” in: Bendix and Guenther Roth, Scholarship and Partisanship: Essays on Max Weber. Berkeley: University of California Press, 282–298.
Bergmann, Joachim. 1967. Die Theorie des sozialen Systems von Talcott Parsons. Frankfurter Beiträge zur Soziologie, vol. 20. Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanstalt.
Bettelheim, Bruno, and Morris Janowitz. 1950. Dynamics of Prejudice: A Psychoanalytic and Sociological Study of Veterans. New York: Harper and Brothers (reissued: New York: The Free Press of Glencoe, 1964).
Bierstedt, Robert. 1981. American Sociological Theory. New York: Academic Press.
Bloom, Allan. 1987. The Closing of the American Mind. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Camic, Charles (ed.). 1991. Talcott Parsons. The Early Essays. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Cerny, Carl. 1964. “The Storm Over Weber,” Encounter, vol. 23, No. 8, 57–59 (Aug., 1964).
Christie, Richard, and Marie Jahoda (eds.). 1954. Studies in the Scope and Method of “The Authoritarian Personality. “ Glencoe, IL: The Free Press of Glencoe.
Converse, Jean M. 1987. Survey Research in the United States: Roots and Emergence, 1890–1960. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Dahrendorf, Ralf. 1958. “Out of Utopia,” American Journal of Sociology, vol. 64, 115–127.
Durkheim, Émile. 1893. De la division du travail social. Étude sur l’organisation des sociétés supérieures. Translated by George Simpson: The Division of Labor in Society. New York: Macmillan 1933.
Frenkel-Brunswik, Else, and R. Nevitt Sanford. 1946. “The Anti-Semitic Personality. A Research Report.” In: Ernst Simmel (ed), Anti-Semitism—a Social Disease. New York: International Universities Press, 96–124.
Gerhardt, Uta. 1993a (ed.), Talcott Parsons on National Socialism. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
-1993b. “Talcott Parsons’s Sociology of National Socialism.” In: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, 1-77.
— 1996. “Scholarship, Not Scandal.” Sociological Forum, vol. 11, 623–630.
—1999. “National Socialism and the Politics of The Structure of Social Action.” In: Bernard Barber and Gerhardt (eds.), Agenda for Sociology. Classic Sources and Current Uses of Talcott Parsons’s Work. Baden-Baden: Nomos, 87–164.
-. 2001. Idealtypus: Zur methodologischen Begründung der modernen Soziologie. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp
—. 2002. Talcott Parsons—An Intellectual Biography. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Habermas, Jürgen, 1965. “Diskussionsbeitrag,” in Otto Stammer (ed.), Max Weber und die Soziologie heute. Tübingen: Mohr, 74–81.
— Ludwig von Friedeburg, Egon Becker, and Christoph Oehler. 1961. Student und Politik. Neuwied: Luchterhand.
Hartmann, Heinz. 1939. Ego Psychology and the Problem of Adaptation. New York: International Universities Press.
— 1950a. “Technical Implications of Ego Psychology.” The Psychoanalytic Quarterly, vol. 20, 31–43.
— 1950b. “The Application of Psychoanalytic Concepts to Social Science,” The Psychoanalytic Quarterly, vol. 19, 385–392.
—and Ernst Kris. 1946. “Comments on the Formation of the Psychic Structure,” Psychoanalytic Study of the Child, vol. 2, 11–38.
Hinkle, Roscoe C. 1994. Developments on American Sociological Theory, 1915–1950. Albany: State University of New York Press.
— and Gisela J. Hinkle. 1954. The Development of Modern Sociology. New York: Random House.
Horkheimer, Max. 1937. “Traditionelle und kritische Theorie.” Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung, vol. 6, 245–294.
— 1939. “Die Juden und Europa.” Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung, vol. 8, 115–137.
— 1946. “Sociological Background of the Psychoanalytic Approach.” In: Ernst Simmel (ed.), Anti-Semitism—a Social Disease. New York: International Universities Press, 1–10.
— 1947. Eclipse of Reason. New York: Oxford University Press.
—1959. “Philosophie und Soziologie,” in: Verhandlungen des Vierzehnten Deutschen Soziologentages in Berlin, Tübingen: Mohr (Siebeck), 27–38.
—1965. “Einleitung zur Diskussion,” zu “Diskussion zum Thema: Wertfreiheit und Objektivität,” in: Otto Stammer (ed.), Max Weber und die Soziologie heute. Verhandlungen des 15. Deutschen Soziologentages. Tübingen: Mohr, 65–67.
—, Erich Fromm, Herbert Marcuse et al., 1936. Studien über Autorität und Familie. Paris: Félix Alcan.
—and Theodor W. Adorno. 1947. Dialektik der Aufklärung. Amsterdam: Querido Publishers.
— 1956. Soziologische Exkurse. Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanstalt; translated: Aspects of Sociology, by The Frankfurt Institute for Social Reseach, London: Heinemann 1973.
Huxley, Aldous. 1932. Brave New World. A Novel. London: Chatto & Windus.
Jahoda, Marie. 1954. “Introduction,” in: Richard Christie and Jahoda (eds.), Studies in the Scope and Method of “The Authoritarian Personality, “ 11-23.
Jay, Martin. 1973. The Dialectical Imagination. A History of the Frankfurt School and the Institute of Social Research, 1923–1950. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kaesler, Dirk (ed.). 1999. Klassiker der soziologischen Theorie. Munich: Hanser (2 vols.).
Levinson, Daniel, and R. Nevitt Sanford. 1944. “A Scale for the Measurement of Anti-Semitism.” Journal of Psychology, vol. 7, 339–370.
Lowenthal, Leo, and Norbert Guterman. 1950. Prophets of Deceit: A Study of the Technique of the American Agitator. New York: Harper and Brothers.
Mannheim, Karl. 1950. Freedom, Power, and Democratic Planning. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Marcuse, Herbert. 1964. One-Dimensional Man. Boston: Beacon Press.
-. 1965a. “Industrialisierung und Kapitalismus,” in: Otto Stammer (ed.), Max Weber und die Soziologie heute, 161-180.
-. 1965b. “Schlusswort,” in Otto Stammer (ed.), 216-218.
Maslow, A.H. 1943. “The Authoritarian Character Structure,” Journal of Social Psychology, S.P.S.S.I. Bulletin, vol. 18, 404–411.
Massing, Paul W. 1950. Rehearsal for Destruction: A Study of Political Anti-Semitism in Imperial Germany. New York: Harper and Brothers.
Merton, Robert K. 1936. “The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action,” American Sociological Review, vol. 1, 894–904.
— 1949. “Manifest and Latent Function,” in: Social Theory and Social Structure. New York: The Free Press 1957 (2nd edition), 19–84.
Mills, C. Wright. 1956. The Power Elite. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mommsen, Wolfgang. 1959. Max Weber und die deutsche Politik 1890–1920. Tübingen: Mohr (Siebeck), 2nd revised edition, 1974.
Nelson, Benjamin 1965. “Diskussionsbeitrag,” in: Otto Stammer (ed.), Max Weber und die Soziologie heute, 192-201.
Parsons, Talcott. 1937. The Structure of Social Action: A Study in Social Theory With Special Reference to a Group of Four Recent European Writers. New York: McGraw Hill.
— 1942a. “Max Weber and the Contemporary Political Crisis.” Review of Politics, vol. 4. Reprinted in: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism. New York: Aldine de Gruyter 1993, 291–314.
— 1942b. “Some Sociological Aspects of the Fascist Movements,” Social Forces, vol. 17. Reprinted: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, 203–218.
— 1942c. “Propaganda and Social Control.” Psychiatry, vol. 5. Reprinted: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, 243–274.
—1942d. “The Sociology of Modern Anti-Semitism.” In Isaac Graeber and Stuart Britt Henderson (eds.), Jews in a Gentile World. New York: Macmillan. Reprinted: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, 131–152.
-. 1945a. “The Problem of Controlled Institutional Change. An Essay in Applied Social Science.” Reprinted: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, {pp291-324}.
—1945b. “Racial and Religious Differences as Factors in Group Tensions.” In: Lyman Bryson, Louis Finckelstein, and Robert McIver (eds), Approaches to Unity. New York: Harper and Brothers. Reprinted: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, 275-290.
— 1947. “Certain Primary Sources and Patterns of Aggression in the Social Structure of the Western World.” Psychiatry, vol. 10. Reprinted: Talcott Parsons on National Socialism, 325–347.
— 1950. “Psychoanalysis and Social Structure.” The Psychoanalytic Quarterly, vol. 19, 371–384.
— 1951. The Social System. Glencoe, IL: The Free Press.
— 1952. “The Superego and the Theory of Social Systems,” Psychiatry, vol. 15, 15–25.
— 1953. “Psychoanalysis and Social Science with Special Reference to the Oedipus Problem,” in: Franz Alexander and Helen Ross (eds.), Twenty Years of Psychoanalysis. New York: Norton, 186–215.
— 1954. “The Father Symbol: An Appraisal in the Light of Psychoanalytic and Sociological Theory.” In: Lyman Bryson, Louis Finkelstein, and Robert McIver (eds.), Symbols and Values. Thirteenth Symposium of the Conference on Science, Philosophy and Religion. New York: Harper and Row, 523–544.
— 1957. “The Distribution of Power in American Social Structure,” World Politics, vol. 10, 123–143.
— 1959. “Some Problems Confronting Sociology as a Profession.” American Sociological Review, vol. 24, 547–559.
Parsons, Talcott 1963 “On the Concept of Political Power.” Reprinted: Parsons, Politics and Social Structure. New York: Free Press 1969, 352-404.
- Parsons, Talcott 1965a. “Wertfreiheit und Objektivität.” In: Otto Stammer ed., Max Weber und die Soziologie heute, 39-64.
— 1965b. “Evaluation and Objectivity,” in: Parsons, Sociological Theory and Modern Society, New York: Free Press 1967, 79–101.
— 1965c. “Max Weber, 1864-1964,” American Sociological Review, vol. 30, 171–175.
— 1965d. “Unity and Diversity in the Modern Intellectual Disciplines: The Role of the Social Sciences,” Daedalus, vol. 94, 39–65.
-. 1967. “Some Comments on the Sociology of Karl Marx,” in: Sociological Theory and Modem Society, 102-135.
— 1980. “The Circumstances of My Encounter with Max Weber.” In Robert K. Merton and Matilda White Riley (eds.), Sociological Traditions from Generation to Generation, Glimpses of the American Experience. Norwood, N.J.: Ablex, 39–43.
— and Edward Shils (eds.). 1951. Toward a General Theory of Action. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
—and Renée Fox. 1952. “Illness, Therapy, and the Modern Urban Family,” Journal of Social Issues, vol. 8, 31–44.
—, Edward A. Shils, and Robert F. Bales. 1953. Working Papers in the Theory of Action ncoe IL Free Press.
—and Robert F. Bales. 1955. Family Socialization and Interaction Process London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Ringer, Fritz. 1969. The Decline of the German Mandarins. The German Academic Community, 1890–1933. Reprinted: Hanover and London: University Press of New England 1990.
Sanford, R. Nevitt and Else Frenkel-Brunswik. 1945. “Some Personality Factors in Anti-Semitism,” Journal of Psychology, vol. 20, 271–291.
Shils, Edward A. 1954. “Authoritarianism—‘Right’ or ‘Left’?” In Richard Christie and Marie Jahoda (eds.), Studies in the Scope and Method of “The Authoritarian Personality,” 24-49.
Simmel, Ernst (ed.). 1946. Anti-Semitism—a Social Disease. New York: International Universities Press.
Sorokin, Piritim. 1928. Contemporary Sociological Theories. New York: Harper and Brothers.
Stammer, Otto (ed). 1965. Max Weber und die Soziologie heute. Verhandlungen des Fünfzehnten Deutschen Soziologentages 1964 in Heidelberg. Tübingen: Mohr.
Weber, Max. 1904. “Die ‘Objektivität’ sozialwissenschaftlicher und sozialpolitischer Erkenntnis.” In: Gesammelte Aufsätze zur Wissenschaftslehre. 3rd edition. Tübingen: Mohr 1968, 146–214; translated as: “‘Objectivity’ in Social Science and Social Policy,” in The Methodology of the Social Sciences: Max Weber, translated and edited by Edward A. Shils and Henry A. Finch, New York: The Free Press 1949, 50-112.
Weber, Max. 1922. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft. Grundriss der Sozialökonomik. Tübingen: Mohr; translated by Guenter Roth and Claus Wittich: Economy and Society. New York: Bedminster Press 1968.
Wiggershaus, Rolf. 1986. Die Frankfurter Schule. Geschichte, Theoretische Entwicklung, Politische Bedeutung. München: Hanser.
Willkie, Wendell. 1943. One World. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gerhardt, U. Worlds come apart: Systems theory versus critical theory. Drama in the history of sociology in the twentieth century. Am Soc 33, 5–39 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12108-002-1001-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12108-002-1001-7