Abstract
Organizational quality improvement practices have gained wide acceptance in manufacturing industries over the last several decades. A substantial number of books have been written on Lean and Six Sigma alone, which today are the leading improvement initiatives. The healthcare industry however has been slower to adopt these methods, although anecdotal evidence suggests they are now being gradually diffused throughout hospitals on an increasing basis. Yet, these new practices have been developed substantially without a theoretical foundation (Linderman et al. J Oper Manag 21:193–203, 2003) and the question of industry “fit” is the topic of debate for many physicians and administrators (Kassirer N Engl J Med 339:1543–1545, 1998). This article provides the descriptive results from our mixed methods research, combining survey questionnaire with semi-structured interviews, that examines implementation of two quality improvement initiatives (Lean and Six Sigma) in a cross-sectional sample of hospitals. We used correlations and non-parametric tests to examine relationships between goal attainment and quality management, and present descriptive findings about reported usage and adoption of quality initiatives. Importantly, we find that the efficacy of quality improvement initiatives in healthcare may be impeded by the lack of goal clarity and measurement. We build on these initial results by offering recommendations to improve results in practice, as well as an agenda for further research of quality initiatives in healthcare. The objectives of our research are to better understand how Lean and Six Sigma fit in the healthcare industry and to explore goal and value attainment from these projects.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams R, Warner P, Hubbard B, Goulding T (2004) Decreasing turnaround time between general surgery cases. J Nurs Adm 34:140–148
Ahire P, Golhar D, Waller M (1996) Development and validation of TQM implementation constructs. Decis Sci 27:23–56
Al-Assaf AF, Assaf R (1997) Managed care quality: a practical guide. CRC, New York
Alexander J, Weiner B, Griffith J (2006) Quality improvement and hospital financial performance. J Organ Behav 27:1003–1029
Barsness ZI, Shortell SM, Gillies RR, et al (1993) The quality march: national survey profiles quality improvement activities. Hosp Health Network December 67(23):52–55
Ben-Tovim DI, Bassham JE, Bennett DM et al (2008) Redesigning care at the Flinders Medical Centre: clinical process redesign using “lean thinking”. Med J Aust 188:S27–S31
Black K, Revere L (2006) Six Sigma arises from the ashes of TQM with a twist. Int J Health Care Qual Assur 19:259–266
Brewer GA, Selden SC (2000) Why elephants gallop: assessing and predicting organizational performance in federal agencies. J Public Adm Res Theory 10:685–712
Buck C (2001) Application of Six Sigma to reduce medical errors. Annu Qual Congr P 55:739–742
Bush SH, Lao MR, Simmons KL et al (2007) Patient access and clinical efficiency improvement in a resident hospital-based women’s medicine center clinic. Am J Manag Care 13:686–690
Carrigan MD, Kujawa D (2006) Six Sigma in health care management and strategy. Health Care Manag 25:133–141
Chan ALF, Pharm BS (2004) Use of Six Sigma to improve pharmacist dispensing errors at an outpatient clinic. Am J Med Qual 19:128–131
Chan WP, Chiu W, Chen W et al (2005) Applying Six Sigma methodology to maximize magnetic resonance imaging capacity in a hospital. Int J Healthc Technol Manag 6:321–330
Chassin MR (1998) Is health care ready for Six Sigma quality? Milbank Q 76:565–591
Chassin R (2008) The Six Sigma initiative at Mount Sinai Medical Center. Mount Sinai J Med 75:45–52
Chen Y, Lin J, Chang C (2005) Taiwan: improving radiography through application of Six Sigma techniques. J Health Qual 27:44–52
Christianson JB, Warrick LH, Howard R, Vollum J (2005) Deploying Six Sigma in a health care system as a work in progress. J Qual Patient Saf 31:603–613
Daniels SE (2007) Six Sigma at Cigna. Qual Prog 40:43–48
Dickson EW, Singh S, Cheung DS et al (2008) Application of Lean manufacturing techniques in the emergency department. J Emerg Med 11:1–6
Does RJ, Vermaat TM, Verver JP et al (2009) Reducing start time delays in operating rooms. J Qual Technol 41:95–109
Dow D, Samson D, Ford S (1999) Exploding the myth: do all quality management practices contribute to superior quality performance? Prod Oper Manag 8:1–27
Drenckpohl D, Bowers L, Cooper H (2007) Use of the Six Sigma methodology to reduce incidence of breast milk administration errors in the NICU. Neonatal Netw 26:161–166
Elberfeld A, Goodman K, Van Kooy M (2004) Using the Six Sigma approach to meet quality standards for cardiac medication administration. J Clin Outcomes Manag 11:510–516
Eldridge NE, Woods SS, Bonello RS et al (2006) Using the Six Sigma process to implement the centers for disease control and prevention guideline for hand hygiene in 4 intensive care units. J Gen Intern Med 21:S35–S42
Esimai G (2005) Lean Six Sigma reduces medication errors. Qual Prog 38:51–57
Fairbanks C (2007) Using Six Sigma and Lean methodologies to improve OR throughput. AORN J 86:73–82
Gibson JW, Tesone D (2001) Management fads: emergence, evolution, and implications for managers. Acad Manag Exec 15:122–133
Godin E, Raven D, Sweetapple C, Del Giudice FR (2004) Faster test results. Qual Prog 37:33–39
Gorman A, Donnell L, Hepp H, Mack T (2007) Improving communication and documentation concerning preliminary and final radiology reports. J Healthc Qual. Available via: http://www.nahq.org/journal/ce/article.html?article_id=276. Accessed August 15, 2009
Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS) (2009) Available via: http://www.himss.org/ASP/membershipHome.asp. Accessed on August 16, 2009
Hendricks K, Singhal V (2001) Firm characteristics, total quality management, and financial performance. J Oper Manag 19:269–285
Johnson T, Currie G, Keill P et al (2005) New York-Presbyterian Hospital: translating innovation into practice. J Qual Patient Saf 31:554–560
Johnston R, Michel S (2008) Three outcomes of service recovery; customer recovery, process recovery, and employee recovery. Int J Oper Prod Manage 28:79–99
Joint Commission (2009) National Patient Safety Goals. Available via: http://www.jointcommission.org/patientsafety/nationalpatientsafetygoals/. Accessed August 16, 2009
Kang JO, Kim MH, Hong SE et al (2005) The application of the Six Sigma program for the quality management of the PACS. Am J Roentgenol 185:1361–1365
Kassirer JP (1998) Doctor discontent. N Engl J Med 339:1543–1545
Kelly A, Bryant M, Cox L, Jolley D (2007) Improving emergency department efficiency by patient streaming to outcomes-based teams. Aust Health Rev 31:16–21
Lam MY, Poon GKK, Chin KS (2008) An organizational learning model for vocational education in the context of TQM culture. Int J Qual Reliab Manage 25:238–255
Landy FJ (1989) The psychology of work behavior. Brooks-Cole, Pacific Grove
Latham GP, Yukl GA (1975) A review of research on the application of goal setting in organizations. Acad Manage J 18:824–845
LeBlanc F, McLaughlin S, Freedman J et al (2004) A Six Sigma approach to maximizing productivity in the cardiac cath lab. J Cardiovasc Manag 15:19–24
Leslie M, Hagood C, Royer A et al (2006) Using lean methods to improve OR turnover times. AORN 84:849–855
Linderman K, Schroeder R, Zaheer S, Choo A (2003) Six Sigma: a goal-theoretic perspective. J Oper Manag 21:193–203
Linderman K, Schroeder R, Choo A (2005) Six Sigma: the role of goals in improvement teams. J Oper Manag 21:779–790
Locke EA (1970) Job satisfaction and job performance: a theoretical analysis. Organ Behav Hum Perform 3:157–190
Locke EA, Latham GP (1990) A theory of goal setting and task performance. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Locke EA, Shaw K, Saari L, Latham G (1981) Goal setting and task performance. Psychol Bull 90:125–152
Martin WF (2007) Quality models: selecting the best model to deliver results. Physician Exec 33:24–29
Neri RA, Mason CE, Demko LA (2008) Application of Six Sigma/CAP methodology: controlling blood-product utilization and costs. J Healthc Manag 53:183–196
Perry JL, Porter LW (1982) Factors affecting the context for motivation in public organizations. Acad Manag Rev 7:89–98
Printezis A, Gopalakrishnan M (2007) Current pulse: can a production system reduce medical errors in health care? Qual Manag Health Care 16:226–238
Raab SS, Grzybicki DM, Stewart WR et al (2008) Effect of Lean method implementation in the histopathology section of an anatomical pathology laboratory. J Clin Pathol 61:1193–1199
Rodgers R, Hunter JE (1992) A foundation of good management practice in government: management by objectives. Public Admin Rev 52:27–39
Saraph J, Benson P, Schroeder R (1989) An instrument for measuring the critical factors of quality. Decis Sci 20:810–829
Schroeder RG, Linderman K, Zhang D (2005) Evolution of quality: first fifty issues of production and operations management. Prod Oper Manag 14:468–481
Schroeder RG, Linderman K, Liedtke C, Choo AS (2008) Six Sigma: definition and underlying theory. J Oper Manag 26:236–554
Shipton H, Armstrong C, West M, Dawson J (2008) The impact of leadership and quality climate on hospital performance. Int J Qual Health Care 20:439–446
Shortell S, O’Brien J, Hughes E et al (1994) Assessing the progress of TQM in US hospitals: findings from two studies. Qual Lett Healthc Lead 6:14–17
Shortell SM, Bennett CL, Byck GR (1998) Assessing the impact of continuous quality improvement on clinical practice: what it will take to accelerate progress. Milbank Q 76:593–624
Stamatis DH (2000) Who needs Six Sigma, anyway? Qual Digest. Available via: http://www.qualitydigest.com/may00/html/sixsigmacon.html. Accessed August 15, 2009
Tsasis P, Bruce-Barrett C (2008) Organizational change through Lean thinking. Health Serv Manag Res 21:192–198
Van den Heuvel J, Does RJ, Bogers AJ, Berg M (2006) Implementing Six Sigma in the Netherlands. J Qual Patient Saf 32:393–399
Wilk LA, Redmon WK (1990) A daily-adjusted goal-setting and feedback procedure for improving productivity in a university admissions office. J Organ Behav Manage 11:55–75
Wright BE (2004) The role of work context in work motivation: a public sector application of goal and social cognitive theories. J Public Admin Res Theor 14:59–78
Wright PM, Kacmar KM (1994) Goal specificity as determinant of goal commitment and goal change. Org Behav Hum Decis Process 59:242–261
Yukl GA, Latham GP (1978) Interrelationships among employee participation, individual differences, goal difficulty, goal acceptance, goal instrumentality, and performance. Pers Psychol 31:305–323
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Appendix I: Survey questions
Appendix I: Survey questions
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Langabeer, J.R., DelliFraine, J.L., Heineke, J. et al. Implementation of Lean and Six Sigma quality initiatives in hospitals: A goal theoretic perspective. Oper Manag Res 2, 13–27 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12063-009-0021-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12063-009-0021-7