Abstract
The author explores two aspects of the relationship between the “constitution” of the EU and member states’ constitutions – their potential for conflict, and possible elements of structural convergence. He considers the “constitutionalisation” of the EU as a starting point, as an on-going process, and as a desired result. The development of an autonomous institutional structure of the EU since the 1980s is presented, preliminarily culminating, after the failure of the Constitutional Treaty, in the explicitly non-statelike concept of the Lisbon Treaty. The author discusses the notion of “constitution” in a number of senses – formal vs. material, static vs. functional etc., and concludes that the potential conflict between the autonomy of EU law and the sovereignty of Member States is existential and cannot be resolved by legal means, which puts the national judge under a permanent challenge as he is obliged to serve two masters, EU law and national law. However, there is room for constructive coexistence of the two legal orders, and if considered as “non-momentary” constitutional systems “without an a priori claim of logical consistency” there is scope for mutual interaction – be it in a positive, “cross-fertilising”, or a negative, intruding way, and even convergence.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Baquero Cruz, J.: The legacy of the Maastrich-Urteil and the pluralist movement. Eur. Law J. 14(4), 389–422 (2008)
Barents, R.: The Precedence of EU Law from the perspective of constitutional pluralism. Eur. Const. Law Rev. 5(3), 421–446 (2009)
Bengoetxea, J., MacCormick, N., Moral Soriano, L.: Integration and integrity in the legal reasoning of the European Court of Justice. In: De Búrca, G., Weiler, J.H.H. (eds.) The European Court of Justice, pp. 43–85. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2001)
Frerichs, S.: Constitutional ideal types in the global age: a sociological review. In: Tuori, K., Sankari, S. (eds.) The Many Constitutions of Europe, pp. 69–88. Ashgate (2010)
Gerkrath, J.: L’émergence d’un droit constitutionnelle pour l’Europe. Modes de formation et sources d’inspiration de la constitution des communautés et de l’Union européenne. Éditions de l’Université de Bruxelles, Brussels (1997)
Griller, S.: Is this a constitution? Remarks on a contested concept. In: Griller, S., Ziller, J. (eds.) The Lisbon Treaty: EU Constitutionalism without a Constitutional Treaty? pp. 21–56. Springer, New York (2008)
Harris, J.W.: Law and Legal Science. An Inquiry into the Concepts “Legal Rule” and “Legal System”. Clarendon Press, Oxford (1979)
Hart, H.L.A.: The Concept of Law, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1997)
Jääskinen, N.: Euroopan unionin konstituutio – perussopimus vai perustuslaki? [The constitution of the European Union – a treaty or a constitutional enactment?] In: Oikeustiede-Jurisprudentia XXXIV, pp. 67–153 (2001)
Jääskinen, N.: Eurooppalaistuvan oikeuden oikeusteoreettisia ongelmia [The europeanisation of law – jurisprudential problems]. Helsinki 2008
Kelsen, H.: General Theory of Law and State. Harvard University Press, Cambridge (1946)
Kelsen, H.: Reine Rechstlehre. Verlag Österreich, Viena (1960). Nachdruck (2000)
Kiiver, P.: The European constitution and the role of national parliaments: hard law language, soft content. In: Albi, A., Ziller, J. (eds.) The European Constitution and National Constitutions. Ratification and Beyond, pp. 223–234. Kluwer Law International, Dordrecht (2007)
Lenaerts, K.: Federalism and the rule of law: perspectives from the European Court of Justice. Fordham Int. Law J. 33(5), 1338–1387 (2010)
Lenaerts, K.: The basic constitutional charter of a community based on the rule of law. In: Poiares Maduro, M., Azoulai, L. (eds.) The Past and Future of EU Law. The Classics of EU Law Revisited on the 50th Anniversary of the Rome Treaty, pp. 295–315. Hart Publishing, Oxford (2010)
Lenaerts, K., Gutiérrez-Fons, J.A.: The constitutional allocation of powers and general principles of EU law. Common Mark. Law Rev. 47(6), 1629–1669 (2010)
Louis, J.-V.: La primauté du droit de l’Union, un concept dépassé. In: Chemins d’Europe, Mélanges en l’honneur de Jean-Paul Jacqué, pp. 443–461. Dalloz (2010)
Mancini, G.F.: Democracy and Constitutionalism in the European Union: Collected Essays. Hart Publishing, Oxford (2000)
MacCormick, N.: Questioning Sovereignty. Law, State and Nation in European Commonwealth. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2001)
Rasmussen, M.: The origins of a legal revolution: the early history of the European Court of Justice. J. Eur. Integr. Hist. 14(2), 77–98 (2008)
Richmond, C.: Preserving the identity crisis. Autonomy, system and sovereignty in European Law. In: MacCormick, N. (ed.) Constructing Legal Systems: ‘European Union’ in Legal Theory, pp. 47–90. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht (1997)
Rosas, A., Armati, L.: EU Constitutional Law. An Introduction. Hart Publishing, Oxford (2010)
Salminen, J.: Manifestations of the European Union Membership in the Constitution of Finland – References to the European Union in the Constitution of Finland in the European Context. Eur. Tidskr. Nr. 3, pp. 509–527 (2010)
Smith, A.: The Theory of Moral Sentiments, 2nd edn. Millar, Kincaid and Bell, London/Edinburgh (1761). Amazon Kindle Version; Printed version
Stein, E.: Lawyers, judges and the making of a transnational constitution. Am. J. Int. Law 75(1), 1–27 (1981)
Tuori, K.: The many constitutions of Europe. In: Tuori, K., Sankari, S. (eds.) The Many Constitutions of Europe, pp. 3–30. Ashgate (2010)
Weiler, J.H.H.: IGC 2000: The Constitutional Agenda. In: Best, E., Gray, M., Stubb, A. (eds.) Rethinking the European Union: IGC 2000 and Beyond, pp. 219–236. EIPA, Maastricht (2000)
Weiler, J.H.H.: The Constitution of Europe: “Do The New Clothes Have an Emperor?” and Other Essays on European Integration. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1999)
Weyland, I.: The application of Kelsen’s theory of the legal system to European Community Law, the supremacy puzzle resolved. Law Phil. 1–37 (2002)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
I want to thank Dr Pekka Aalto, my chef du cabinet, and Ms Liisa Holopainen, for their comments and help. The usual disclaimer applies.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jääskinen, N. Constitutions in the European Union – Some Questions of Conflict and Convergence. ERA Forum 12 (Suppl 1), 205–218 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12027-011-0197-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12027-011-0197-9