Forest fire policy: change conventional thinking of smoke management to prioritize long-term air quality and public health
Wildland fire smoke is inevitable. Size and intensity of wildland fires are increasing in the western USA. Smoke-free skies and public exposure to wildland fire smoke have effectively been postponed through suppression. The historic policy of suppression has systematically both instilled a public expectation of a smoke-free environment and deferred emissions through increased forest fuel loads that will lead to an eventual large spontaneous release. High intensity fire smoke is impacting a larger area including high density urban areas. Policy change has largely attempted to provide the avenue for increased use of ecologically beneficial fire but allows for continued reliance on suppression as a primary tool for a smoke averse population. While understanding the essential role of suppression in protection of life and property, we dispute the efficacy of attempting to eliminate smoke exposure through suppression in a fire prone area to protect human health at the population level. Sufficient consideration to future negative health outcomes needs to be considered in fire management decisions. It is likely that long term air quality is inextricably linked to ecosystem health in the Sierra Nevada. We contend that landscape use of ecological fire is essential to forest and human health. Radical change is needed where beneficial wildland fire smoke is treated as natural background and exempted from much of the regulation applied to anthropogenic sources. Tolerance of the measured release of routine smoke emissions from beneficial fire is needed. Using present air quality standards in the more remote areas will provide an opportunity to increase burning in many forests while protecting public health.
KeywordsWidland fire Air quality Policy Public health Smoke management
- Exceptional Events Rule (2007) Part II Environmental Protection Agency 40 CFR parts 50 and 51 treatment of data influenced by exceptional events; Final Rule.Google Scholar
- Kilgore B (1981) Fire in ecosystem distribution and structure: western forests and scrublands. HA Mooney, TM Bonnicksen, NL Christ. Proc. Conf. Fire Regimes Ecosyst. Prop. pp. 58–89. USDA For. Serv. Gen. Tech. Rep. WO-GTR-26 58–89.Google Scholar