Abstract
There is growing interest in using multi-species plantation systems when undertaking reforestation for timber production. Such plantations can have ecological and socio-economic advantages over those of traditional monocultures. Despite increasing evidence about the functional advantages of increasing species richness in reforestation, there are few silvicultural guidelines to assist in the design and management of multi-species plantings. This paper presents the results of a systematic assessment of previous studies of mixed-species plantings with a particular focus on their advantages and disadvantages for meeting the needs of rural smallholders and communities in tropical regions. Research on mixed-species plantations has increased in recent years. Many earlier studies were concerned with the capacity of mixed-species plantings to improve productivity or the nutritional impacts of mixtures. Many of these studies emphasised young plantations and mixtures of a few relatively fast-growing Acacia, Eucalyptus and Pinus species. More recent studies have explored a wider range of outcomes arising from using mixtures including on the supply of ecosystem services. Issues deserving further study concern the economic advantages or disadvantages of mixed-species plantations, how these plantations might be designed to suit various environmental and socio-economic situations, and how to manage older mixed-species plantations where the interactions between species may be different to those in younger plantations. There is also a need to explore how increased species richness may affect the capacity of new plantations to withstand damage from insect pests or disturbances such as storms or wildfire.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Binkley D, Dunkin KA, Debell D, Ryan MG (1992) Production and nutrient cycling in mixed plantations of Eucalyptus and albizia in Hawaii. Forest Sci 38(2):393–408
Bosu PP, Cobbinah JR, Nichols JD, Nkrumah EE, Wagner MR (2006) Survival and growth of mixed plantations of Milicia excelsa and Terminalia superba 9 years after planting in Ghana. Forest Ecol Manag 233(2–3):352–357
Boyden S, Binkley D, Senock R (2005) Competition and facilitation between Eucalyptus and nitrogen-fixing Falcataria in relation to soil fertility. Ecology 86(4):992–1001
Bristow M, Vanclay JK, Brooks L, Hunt M (2006) Growth and species interactions of Eucalyptus pellita in a mixed and monoculture plantation in the humid tropics of north Queensland. Forest Ecol Manag 233(2–3):285–294
Carnus J-M, Parrotta J, Brockerhoff E, Arbez M et al (2006) Planted forests and biodiversity. J Forest 104(2):65–77
Chirwa TS, Mafongoya PL, Chintu R (2003) Mixed planted-fallows using coppicing and non-coppicing tree species for degraded Acrisols in eastern Zambia. Agroforest Syst 59(3):243–251
DeBell DS, Keyes CR, Gartner BL (2001) Wood denity of Eucalytpus saligna grown in Hawaiian plantations: effects of silvicultural practices and relation to growth rate. Austral For 64(2):106–110
Doust SJ, Erskine PD, Lamb D (2008) Restoring rainforest species by direct seeding: tree seedling establishment and growth performance on degraded land in the wet tropics of Australia. Forest Ecol Manag 256(5):1178–1188
Engel VL, Parrotta JA (2001) An evaluation of direct seeding for reforestation of degraded lands in central São Paulo state, Brazil. Forest Ecol Manag 152(1–3):169–181
Ewel JJ (1986) Designing agricultural ecosystems for the humid tropics. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 17:245–271
Farwig N, Sajita N, Bohning-Gaese K (2009) High seedling recruitment of indigenous tree species in forest plantations in Kakamega Forest, western Kenya. Forest Ecol Manag 257(1):143–150
Forrester DI (2004) Mixed-species plantations of nitrogen-fixing and non–nitrogen-fixing trees. Dissertation, The Australian National University, School of Resources, Environment and Society
Forrester DI, Bauhus J et al (2004) Growth dynamics in a mixed-species plantation of Eucalyptus globulus and Acacia mearnsii. Forest Ecol Manag 193(1–2):81–95
Forrester DI, Bauhus J, Cowie AL, Vanclay JK (2006) Mixed-species plantations of Eucalyptus with nitrogen-fixing trees: a review. Forest Ecol Manag 233(2–3):211–230
Gregorio N, Herbohn J, Harrison S, Smith C (2015) A systems approach to improving the quality of tree seedlings for agroforestry, tree farming and reforestation in the Philippines. Land Use Policy 47:29–41
IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature) (2016) The Bonn Challenge. IUCN and the Global Partnership on Forest Landscape Restoration, Washington DC. http://www.bonnchallenge.org. Accessed 10 Dec 2016
Keenan R, Lamb D, Sexton G (1995) Experience with mixed species rainforest plantations in North Queensland. Commonw Forest Rev 74(4):315–321
Knoke T, Ammer C, Stimm B, Mosandl R (2008) Admixing broadleaved to coniferous tree species: a review on yield, ecological stability and economics. Eur J For Res 127(2):89–101
Lamb D (2011) Regreening the bare hills: tropical forest restoration in the Asia-Pacific region. Springer, Dordrecht
Lamb D, Nhan HD, Erskine PD (2005) Designing mixed-species plantations: Progress to date. In Erskine PD, Lamb D, Bristow M (eds) Reforestation in the tropics and subtropics of Australia using rainforest tree species Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Canberra, pp 129–141: An Australian Government Initiative
Lamb D, Stanturf J, Madsen P (2012) What is forest landscape restoration? In: Lamb D, Stanturf J, Madsen P (eds) Forest landscape restoration: integrating natural and social sciences. Springer, Netherlands, pp 3–23
Lang AC, von Oheimb G, Scherer-Lorenzen M, Yang B, Trogisch S, Bruelheide H, Ma KP, Hardtle W (2014) Mixed afforestation of young subtropical trees promotes nitrogen acquisition and retention. J Appl Ecol 51(1):224–233
Meng J, Lu Y, Zeng J (2014) Transformation of a degraded pinus massoniana plantation into a mixed-species irregular forest: impacts on stand structure and growth in Southern China. Forests 5(12):3199–3221
Montagnini F (2000) Accumulation in above-ground biomass and soil storage of mineral nutrients in pure and mixed plantations in a humid tropical lowland. Forest Ecol Manag 134(1–3):257–270
Montagnini F (2005) Selecting tree species for plantation. In: Mansourian S, Vallauri D (eds) Forest restoration in landscapes. Springer, New York, pp 262–268
Montagnini F, Jordan CF (2005) Tropical forest ecology: the basis for conservation and management. Springer, Dordrecht
Nguyen H, Lamb D, Herbohn J, Firn J (2014) Designing mixed species tree plantations for the tropics: balancing ecological attributes of species with landholder preferences in the Philippines. PLoS ONE 9(4):e95267
Nguyen H, Herbohn J, Clendenning J, Lamb D, Dressler W, Vanclay J, Firn J (2015) What is the available evidence concerning relative performance of different designs of mixed-species plantings for smallholder and community forestry in the tropics? A systematic map protocol. Environ Evid 4:15
Nguyen H, Vanclay J, Herbohn J, Firn J (2016) Drivers of tree growth, mortality and harvest preferences in species-rich plantations for smallholders and communities in the tropics. PLoS ONE 11(10):e0164957
Piotto D (2008) A meta-analysis comparing tree growth in monocultures and mixed plantations. Forest Ecol Manag 255(3–4):781–786
R Development Core Team (2014) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria https://www.R-project.org/. Accessed 2 Sept 2015
Sabogal C, Besacier C, McGuire D (2015) Forest and landscape restoration: concepts, approaches and challenges for implementation. Unasylva 66(245):3–10
Schneider T, Pohnan E (2012) Assessing Rainforestation: the social and ecological effects of smallholder-based native species reforestation in the Philippines. Trop Resour: Bull Yale Tropical Resour Inst 31:78–85
Simpson J, Osborne D (2006) Performance of seven hardwood species underplanted to Pinus elliottii in south-east Queensland. Forest Ecol Manag 233(2–3):303–308
Smith DM, Larson BC, Kelty MJ, Ashton PMS (1997) The practice of silviculture: applied forest ecology, 9th edn. Wiley, New York
Sovu MT, Savadogo P, Oden PC (2012) Facilitation of forest landscape restoration on abandoned swidden fallows in Laos using mixed-species planting and biochar application. Silva Fenn 46:39–51
Wormald T (1992) Mixed and pure forest plantations in the tropics and subtropics. FAO Forestry Paper 103. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome
Xing S, Chen C, Zhou B, Zhang H, Nang Z, Xu Z (2010) Soil soluble organic nitrogen and active microbial characteristics under adjacent coniferous and broadleaf plantation forests. J Soil Sediment 10(4):748–757
Acknowledgements
This study is a part of the Evidence-Based Forestry (EBF) initiative at the Centre for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), funded through the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development (DFID). We thank the DFID for funding the study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic Supplementary Material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nguyen, H., Herbohn, J., Lamb, D. et al. A Synthesis of the Available Evidence to Guide the Design of Mixed-Species Forest Plantings for Smallholder and Community Forestry. Small-scale Forestry 17, 105–123 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11842-017-9378-x
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11842-017-9378-x