Multi-axial correction system in the treatment of radial club hand
- 1k Downloads
Radial club hand is a well-recognized congenital malformation characterized by hypoplasia of bone and soft tissue on the radial aspect of the forearm and hand. The modalities of treatment have traditionally varied from stretching casts with soft-tissue procedures to the use of multiple corrective osteotomies. These osteotomies can be stabilized by a variety of methods, including external fixators that allow the possibility of gradual distraction with neohistiogenesis. This current study outlines the usage of one such device (multi-axial correction system [MAC]) in the management of deformity associated with severe radial club hand.
Three consecutive cases of unilateral or bilateral severe (Bayne type IV) congenital radial club hand were corrected using MAC fixation in the last 5 years. This is a retrospective review of all three cases. Data parameters included: patient demographics, presentation findings, degree of deformity, amount of correction/lengthening, length of procedure, length of treatment, and associated complications. The surgical technique is described in detail for the benefit of the readership.
The three patients with severe congenital radial club hand had a total of four limb involvements that underwent correction using osteotomies and usage of the MAC device for external fixation. All three patients underwent successful correction of deformity with the restoration of alignment, lengthening of forearm for improvement of function, and stabilization of the wrist (mean duration, mean lengthening, mean time to consolidation). The MAC system was well tolerated in all patients and associated complications were limited.
The MAC fixator seems to be a good alternative modality of stabilization and correction for severe congenital radial club hand deformities. Its usage is fairly simple and it provides the ease of application of a mono-lateral fixator with far superior three-dimensional control, like the circular external fixator. We recommend that clinicians should add this modality to their armamentarium for the deformity correction of severe radial club hand and others in general.
KeywordsMAC fixator Radial club hand Multi-axial correction system
Longitudinal radial deficiency, or radial club hand, encompasses a collection of congenital deformities characterized by hypoplasia of bones, joints, muscles, tendons, ligaments, nerves, and vasculature on the radial aspect of the forearm [1, 2]. Radial club hand is a rare condition, occurring in approximately 1 in every 30,000 live births, with a slightly increased incidence in males. The anomaly occurs bilaterally 50% of the time, and is frequently asymmetrical . Most cases of radial deficiency are sporadic, and they are commonly associated with a number of congenital syndromes: thrombocytopenia absent radius (TAR) syndrome; vertebral defects, anal atresia, cardiac malformation, tracheoesophageal fistula, esophageal atresia, renal anomalies, and limb anomalies (VACTERL); Fanconi’s anemia; Holt-Oram syndrome; and trisomies 13 and 18 [1, 4].
Clinically, the radial club hand spectrum is classifiable by severity into one of four types based on the degree of radius present (as described by Bayne and Klug ) or by a modified scheme that grades thumb, carpal, and radius deficiencies in summation [2, 5]. The treatment of radial club hand varies considerably with the extent of the deformity and the age of the patient. Mild cases of Bayne type I may be sufficiently treated by stretching and splinting. More severe cases may require preliminary soft tissue distraction and tendon transfer to rebalance the wrist [6, 7, 8, 9, 10], followed by surgical centralization of the wrist on the ulna and tendon transfer to rebalance the wrist [11, 12, 13]. Subsequent ulnar lengthening and angular correction may be performed, particularly in the case of failed soft tissue surgery, progressive angular deformity, or inadequate functional length; these procedures are preferable at early adolescence, where an external fixator can be tolerated and treatment does not interfere with psychosocial development [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20].
Forearm lengthening and subsequent deformity corrections have, for the most part, been approached with gradual distraction using the Ilizarov technique involving a circular external fixator. Although successful in producing multi-planar deformity correction and an approximately 50% increase in ulnar length, the Ilizarov technique brings with it a steep clinician learning curve. Device application, cumbersome hardware, lengthy total treatment time, and relatively high risk of complications may prove problematic and have effectively limited the use of the device to adolescents and older [14, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20].
The multi-axial correction (MAC) system (Biomet, Parsippany, NJ) is an external fixator capable of gradual or acute correction, as well as tri-planar angulation, translational, rotational, and length deformity correction that overcomes many of the issues faced by the traditional Ilizarov technique; this approach is particularly suited for angularity and length correction in early adolescents with previous failed soft tissue procedures. In this report, we describe a series of three cases (previously presented at the 2007 Pediatric Orthopaedic Society of North America [POSNA] Conference) of severe radial club hand in which the MAC fixation system was used to achieve successful deformity resolution and ulnar lengthening.
After obtaining institutional review board (IRB) approval, the surgical database of a senior surgeon at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia was reviewed retrospectively from 2003 to 2008 to identify patients with congenital radial club hand that underwent treatment. Patients were included in the study if they had either unilateral or bilateral Bayne type IV congenital radial club hand, were less than 18 years old at the time of surgery, had adequate clinical and radiographic data, and underwent treatment using the MAC fixation system. Exclusion criteria included age and prior trauma to the affected extremity. Three cases that met the inclusion criteria were selected for further evaluation; all patients were consecutive cases of radial club hand and were all operated on by the same attending physician. Data collected included patient information, history of the condition, degree of deformity, amount of correction/lengthening, duration of procedure, duration of treatment, and complications. Complications were defined as neurovascular injury, infection requiring antibiotics, over-correction, under-correction, delayed union of osteotomy, non-union of osteotomy, device failure, and any intra-operative problems encountered.
For the correction of radial deviation in this series of cases, the primary hinge of the MAC fixator is centered on the center of rotation of angulation (CORA) along the ulna, and angulated to match the deformity [21, 22]. A rotational arc capable of at least 80° of rotational correction is attached proximally to the primary hinge, and a compression/distraction clamp is attached to the MAC fixator distally. Three bicortical hydroxyapatite-coated cortical screws are placed proximally, which do not have to be perpendicular to the ulna. Three screws are placed distally in the medial aspect of the ulna or across the carpals.
The ulnar osteotomy is performed distal to the CORA from the lateral aspect of the ulna in order to avoid damage to the vasculature and nervous tissue. No corrections are performed acutely to avoid ulnar nerve stretch injury. In the first post-operative week, patients are taught to perform range of motion exercises at the ipsilateral shoulder, elbow, and hand. Post-operatively, patients are taught to turn the compression/distraction mechanism for distraction of the osteotomized ulnar bone fragments. Lengthening is carried out at a rate of 1–2 cm per month, until satisfactory length is achieved. Monthly X-rays are obtained until consolidation, usually over 6 or 7 months, after which the device is removed. Sports are not permitted until at least 6 weeks after removal of the fixator, and contact sports are not permitted for 6 months.
Three cases of radial club hand were identified, all of which were associated with VATER (vertebrae, anus, trachea, esophagus, and renal) syndrome. Two of the patients had bilateral radial club hand, while one had unilateral deficiency. A total of four limbs underwent application of the MAC fixator; the results were followed through the removal of each device.
Patient 2 presented at age 17 years with severe bilateral radial club hand. He had previously failed non-slot centralization/stabilization attempts at both wrists at age 2 years without pollicization or tendon transfer. There was a 90° annular bend of the left ulna and moderate bowing of the right ulna. His right wrist was fairly centered on the ulna, while the left wrist was on the radial side of the ulna. Both wrists were radially deviated and had limited mobility. MAC fixator systems were applied to the left and right arms sequentially for 245 and 173 days, respectively, in order to achieve lengthening and correction of ulnar bowing. Deformity was corrected successfully in both arms, with the left forearm lengthened an additional 8 cm from 10 cm, and the right forearm lengthened an additional 7 cm from 10 cm. Following alignment and lengthening, the MAC fixation device on the left wrist was used to achieve centralization. After the correction of wrist alignment and stable fusion, the fixator was removed after 188 days.
The MAC fixation system has been available and clinically used for some time now. The purpose of this study was to answer the following question: is it possible to successfully correct the deformity in severe congenital radial club hand, with lengthening of the forearm and wrist stabilization, using the MAC device? The other point of the study was to establish if the device, technique, and treatment process was considered to be cumbersome by the patients/parents.
We present a retrospective review of three cases of severe congenital radial club hand that proved to be resistant to initial soft tissue surgeries and demonstrated progressive deformity. Corrective treatment was essential not only for deformity correction, but also to gain forearm length for functional improvement (increasing oral/aboral reach and overhead range of motion) and to stabilize the wrist. Traditionally at our institution, the circular external fixation system of Ilizarov has been used for ulnar lengthening and deformity correction in these cases [1, 23]. However, there can be some challenges with the Ilizarov device, especially in the pediatric patient population, being heavy, technically challenging to apply, and bulky in terms of occupying space. The MAC fixation system is presented in this study as an alternative to the complex circular external fixation system.
In this current study, we have shown the utility of the MAC fixation system for multi-axial deformity correction and gradual lengthening in severe radial club hand. The device is surgeon-friendly, and its technical application and adjustment could be learned very quickly. The placement and adjustment of the device requires no special instrumentation and can be easily conducted via follow-up radiographs that are available in all practice locations. Patients may readily adjust the fixator from home as per the surgeon’s directions for progressive correction. The complications associated with the placement and maintenance of the device are equal to or less than that associated with the use of other fixators; an occasional over-correction may be addressed by outpatient device adjustment, without removal/replacement of the fixator or complicated analysis. Lastly, the device itself is significantly less cumbersome than other circular external fixators, and it is tolerated better by pediatric patients.
The MAC external fixation system is a versatile approach to upper limb deformities, and it is capable of correction of carpal translation for wrist stabilization while improving hand and limb function, in addition to gradual lengthening. This series of three cases represents the unique utilization of the MAC fixator in treating four different aspects of treatment of the radial club hand deformity: the fixator system may be used for ulnar lengthening and straightening after previous wrist centralization (Patient 1), for ulnar lengthening and straightening in the case of an unstable wrist (Patient 2), for wrist distraction and centralization preceding fusion (Patient 2), and simultaneous ulnar lengthening and straightening with wrist stabilization (Patient 3).
There are limitations to this study. As it is a retrospective case series, no control group is available to compare the utilization of the MAC fixation system to another acceptable method. Furthermore, as the application of the fixator is case-dependent, and individual cases of radial longitudinal deficiency are often heterogeneous, the consistency of quantitative comparative measures between cases is limited. Finally, a clinical assessment of each of these patients was not performed due, in part, to the difficulty of quantifying the gain of function and patient satisfaction, and the difficulties in requiring corrected patients to return for follow-up several years after discharge from care.
In conclusion, this case series suggests that the MAC fixation system is a successful alternative modality of using external fixation in the correction of deformity associated with radial club hand and results in effective ulnar lengthening. The desired clinical outcomes are achieved with minimal complications. The MAC system offers many advantages over circular external fixation techniques and implements, including ease of application by the clinician and toleration by the patient. The MAC external fixator is a viable option for the surgical correction of radial longitudinal deficiencies and should be a part of the surgical armamentarium in deformity correction.
There were no grants or external sources of funding utilized for this study.
Conflict of interest statement
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
- 1.James MA, Bednar M (2005) Deformities of the wrist and forearm. In: Wolfe SW, Hotchkiss RN, Green DP, Pederson WC (eds) Green’s operative hand surgery. Elsevier, Philadelphia, pp 1469–1506Google Scholar
- 22.Paley D, Herzenberg JE, Tetsworth K et al (1994) Deformity planning for frontal and sagittal plane corrective osteotomies. Orthop Clin North Am 25:425–465Google Scholar
- 23.Lourie GM, Lins RE (1998) Radial longitudinal deficiency. A review and update. Hand Clin 14:85–99Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.