Preoperative bronchoscopic cancer confirmation does not increase risk of recurrence in stage1A non-small cell lung cancer
- 125 Downloads
This study was conducted to evaluate the risk of recurrence possibly caused by preoperative bronchoscopic cancer confirmation in stage1A non-small cell lung cancer.
One hundred and seventy-nine cases of peripheral non-small cell lung cancer (including 151 adenocarcinoma) with no more than 3 cm in their tumor longer diameter were selected. All patients underwent preoperative diagnostic bronchoscopy followed by lobectomy, and were demonstrated to have pathologically free of lymph node involvement and pleural involvement. Radiological and pathological low-grade adenocarcinomas were excluded. Of 179 cases, 95 were confirmed lung cancer by bronchoscope (Group 1) and rest 84 had failed cancer confirmation by bronchoscope before surgery (Group 2). Forty-eight pairs for non-small cell lung cancer and 41 pairs for adenocarcinoma were identified from each group by propensity caliper matching. Kaplan–Meier method and log-rank test were performed on matched groups, and Cox proportional hazard model analysis was performed on whole matched cases.
Log-rank test revealed no significant inferiority of recurrence-free survival of Group 1 in both all-NSCLC and adenocarcinoma subset. Cox proportional hazard model analysis also revealed that the ‘presence of preoperative bronchoscopic cancer confirmation’ dose not increase risk of recurrence in both NSCLC and adenocarcinoma subset.
It is unlikely that preoperative bronchoscopic cancer confirmation would increase recurrence risk in stage1A non-small cell lung cancer; however, a future prospective study with larger cohorts would be warranted to validate the results.
KeywordsBronchoscope Diagnosis Lung adenocarcinoma Prognostic factor
Endobronchial ultrasonography-guide sheath
High-resolution computed tomography
Left lower lobe
Left upper lobe
Non-small cell lung cancer
Right lower lobe
Right middle lobe
Right upper lobe
For this publication, each author had engaged in the work as follows; Jiro Abe designed the study structure, collected patients’ data, analyzed data, and wrote the article; Toshimasa Okazaki collected patients’ data; Naohiko Kikuchi collected patients’ data; Satomi Takahashi collected patients’ data; Akira Sakurada advised regarding statistical issue; Yoshinori Okada supervised the whole work.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors have declared that no conflict of interest exists.