Optimizing marketer costs and consumer benefits across “clicks” and “bricks”
The Internet has revolutionized the retailing landscape and how goods and services are sold and distributed to consumers. One avenue of significant growth in online selling comes from multichannel retailers who offer products in stores as well as over the Web. These hybrids may leverage their “brick” locations by allowing customers to pick up or return orders purchased online at retail stores. This option lets Web-based buyers avoid added shipping costs and long package carrier lead times, albeit at a cost to retailers. To examine the viability of this strategy, we develop a mathematical model that examines the cost and value of providing in-store pickup and return. The model is used to determine the best subset of brick-and-mortar stores to handle in-store pickup and return demand. One of the principal takeaways is that not all retail stores should be offering in-store pickups and/or returns. Our computational results show optimizing the set of pickup and return locations may reduce system cost over baseline marketing policies where these services are set up at all or none of a retailer’s stores. In addition, we show that retailers can significantly improve some consumer benefits at little extra cost.
KeywordsE-tailing Internet marketing Clicks and bricks Optimization models
- Eppen, G., & Schrage, L. (1981). Centralized ordering policies in a multi-warehouse system with lead times and random demand. In L. B. Schwarz (Ed.), Multi-level production/inventory systems: Theory and practice. North-Holland: TIMS Studies in Management Sciences.Google Scholar
- Forrester Research. (2007). The state of retailing online 2006. www.forrester.com.
- Mahar, S. P., Wright, D., & Bretthauer, K. (2011). Dual channel supply chains: challenges and opportunities in e-fulfillment. Production and Inventory Management Journal, 47, 14–30.Google Scholar
- Miller, P. (2004). In-store pickup pitfalls and payoffs. Catalog Age, December, 27.Google Scholar
- Sharma, A., & Sheth, J. N. (2004). Web-based marketing: the coming revolution in marketing thought and strategy. Journal of Business Strategy, 57, 696–702.Google Scholar
- Spencer, J. (2003). “I ordered that?” Web retailers make it easier to return goods. Wall Street Journal—Eastern Edition, 242, D1–D2.Google Scholar