Cliometrica

pp 1–34 | Cite as

A city of trades: Spanish and Italian immigrants in late-nineteenth-century Buenos Aires, Argentina

Original Paper

Abstract

The city of Buenos Aires in the 1890s is an extreme case in immigration history since the native workers accounted for less than one-third of the labour force. In this paper, we look at the labour market performance of Argentineans vis-à-vis the largest two immigrant groups, Italians and the Spaniards. We find that, on average, Argentineans enjoyed higher wages, but workers specialised in particular occupations by nationality. Immigrants clustered in occupations with lower salaries. Despite higher literacy levels and the language advantage, Spaniards did not outperform Italians in earnings. Ethnic networks facilitated the integration of immigrants into the host society and played a role in the occupation selection of immigrants. Our results suggest that Italian prosperity in Buenos Aires was not based on superior earnings or skills but on older and powerful networks.

Keywords

Migration Wages Networks Labour force Buenos Aires 

JEL Classification

N36 F22 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We thank Timothy J. Hatton, Javier Silvestre, anonymous reviewers and the editor of this Journal for very useful comments and suggestions. This article also benefited greatly from discussions in the Economic History Seminar of the Universitat de Barcelona and the XI Conference of the European Historical Economics Society (Pisa). The usual disclaimer applies.

References

  1. Abramitzky R, Boustan LP, Eriksson K (2014) A nation of immigrants: assimilation and economic outcomes in the age of mass migration. J Polit Econ 122(3):467–506CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Adelman J (1992) The harvest hand: wage-labouring on the Pampas, 1880–1914. In: Adelman J (ed) Essays in Argentine labour history, 1870–1930, St. Antony’s Series, Palgrave McMillan, Basingstoke, pp 91–111Google Scholar
  3. Adelman J (1994) Frontier development, land, labour and capital on the wheatlands of Argentina and Canada, 1890–1914. Clarendon Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Baily SL (1999) Immigrants in the land of promise: Italians in Buenos Aires and in New York City, 1870 to 1914. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NYGoogle Scholar
  5. Beaman LA (2012) Social networks and the dynamics of labour market outcomes: evidence from refugees resettled in the U.S. Rev Econ Stud 79(1):128–161CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bertola G, Sestito P (2011) A comparative perspective on Italy’s human capital accumulation. Quaderni di Storia Economica, num. 6, Banca d’ItaliaGoogle Scholar
  7. Bourdé G (1977) Buenos Aires. Urbanización e inmigración. Huemul, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  8. Buchanan W (1898) La moneda y la vida en la República Argentina. In: Revista de Derecho. Historia y Letras. I, vol II. Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  9. Chiswick BR (1991) Jewish immigrant skill and occupational attainment at the turn of the century. Explor Econ Hist 28:64–86CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Chiswick BR, Miller PW (2007) The economics of language: international analyses. Routledge, LondonGoogle Scholar
  11. Cinel D (1982) From Italy to San Francisco. The immigrant experience. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  12. Cortés Conde R (1979) El progreso argentino, 1880–1914. Ed. Sudamericana, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  13. Departamento General de Inmigración (1890) Memoria del año 1889, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  14. Devoto FJ (2003) Historia de la inmigración en Argentina. Ed. Sudamericana, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  15. Devoto FJ (2006) Historia de los italianos en la Argentina. Editorial Biblos, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  16. Dirección General de Estadística (1894) Censo de los empleados administrativos, funcionarios judiciales personal docente: De la República Argentina correspondiente al 31 de diciembre de 1893. Compañía sud-americana de billetes de banco, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  17. Dirección General de Inmigración (1925) Resumen estadístico del movimiento migratorio en la República argentina, 1857–1924. Ministerio de Agricultura, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  18. Duncan OD (1961) A socioeconomic index of all occupations. In: Reiss AJ (ed) Occupations and social status. Free Press of Glencoe, New York, pp 109–138Google Scholar
  19. Dustmann C (2001) Return migration, wage differentials, and the optimal migration duration. IZA Discussion paper series, No. 264Google Scholar
  20. Fernández A (1989) El mutualismo español en un barrio de Buenos Aires: San José de Flores, (1890–1900). Estudios Migratorios Latinoamericanos 4(13):609–642Google Scholar
  21. Foerster RF (1919) The Italian emigration of our times, vol 20. Harvard University Press, HarvardGoogle Scholar
  22. Galor O, Stark O (1990) Migrants’ savings, the probability of return migration and migrants’ performance. Int Econ Rev 31(2):463–467CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gandolfo R (1992) Las sociedades italianas de socorros mutuos de Buenos Aires: cuestiones de etnicidad y clase dentro de una comunidad de inmigrantes (1880–1920). In: Devoto FJ, Miguez EJ (eds) Asociacionismo, trabajo e identidad étnica. Los italianos en América Latina en una perspectiva comparada. CEMLA, Buenos Aires, pp 311–332Google Scholar
  24. Germani G (1966) Mass immigration and modernization in Argentina. Stud Comp Int Dev 2(11):165–182CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Gomellini M, Ó Gráda C (2011) Outward and inward migration in Italy: a historical perspective. Quaderni di Storia Economica, num. 8, Banca d’ItaliaGoogle Scholar
  26. Gutiérrez L (1981) Condiciones de la vida material de los sectores populares en Buenos Aires. 1880–1914. Rev Indias 41:167–202Google Scholar
  27. Hatton TJ, Leigh A (2011) Immigrants assimilate as communities not just as individuals. J Popul Econ 24:389CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hauser R (1982) Occupational status in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Hist Methods 15:111–126CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Juif D (2015) Skill selectivity in transatlantic migration: the case of Canary Islanders in Cuba. Rev Hist Econ J Iber Lat Am Econ Hist 33(2):189–222Google Scholar
  30. Kim J, Lauderdale DS, Shin HC, Lee Y (2014) Surname sampling: reevaluating Kim sampling in Korea and the United States. Field Methods 26(1):87–104CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Klein HS (1983) The integration of Italian immigrants into the United States and Argentina: a comparative analysis. Am Hist Rev 88(2):306–329CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Lafortune J, Tessada J (2014) Smooth(er) landing? The dynamic role of networks in the location and occupational choice of immigrants. WP ClioLab14 Eh Clio Lab Instituto de Economía. Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile. http://www.econ.puc-rio.br/pdf/seminario/2011/Draft-02-23-2011.pdf
  33. Lattes AE, Rechini de Lattes Z (1975) La población de Argentina. Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  34. Lubotsky D (2007) Chutes or ladders? A longitudinal analysis of immigrant earnings. J Polit Econ 115(5):820–867CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Mateo Avilés E de (1993) La emigración andaluza a América, 1850–1936. Ed. Arguval, MálagaGoogle Scholar
  36. McCaa R, Haines M, Mulhare E (2001) Argentina. The first national historical census microdata. In: Hall PK, McCaa R, Thorvaldsen G (eds) Handbook of international historical microdata for population research. The Minnesota Population Center, Minnesota, pp 13–22Google Scholar
  37. Minns C (2000) Income, cohort effects, and occupational mobility: a new look at immigration to the United States at the turn of the 20th century. Explor Econ Hist 37:326–350CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Moya JC (1998) Cousins and strangers. Spanish Immigrants in Buenos Aires, 1850–1930. University of California Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  39. Munshi K (2003) Networks in the modern economy: Mexican migrants in the US labor market. Q J Econ 118(2):549–599CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Munshi K (2014) Community networks and the process of development. J Econ Perspect 28(4):49–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Munshi K, Wilson N (2007) Identity and occupational choice in the American Midwest. Brown University Working PaperGoogle Scholar
  42. Patel K, Vella F (2013) Immigrant networks and their implications for occupational choice and wages. Rev Econ Stat 95(4):1249–1277CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Patroni A (1897) Los trabajadores en la Argentina. Imprenta Litografía y Ecuadernación, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  44. Peri G, Sparber C (2011) Highly educated immigrants and native occupational choice. Ind Relat J Econ Soc 50(3):385–411CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Quartulli D (2014) Historia y actualidad de dos muestras censales de población. Argentina 1869 y 1895. http://censos1869-1895.sociales.uba.ar/files/2014/05/Digitalizaci%C3%B3n-2.3.pdf
  46. Rocchi F (1999) La armonía de los opuestos: industria, importaciones y la construcción de Buenos Aires en el periodo 1880–1920. In: Amaral S, Valencia M (eds) Argentina: el país nuevo. Problemas de historia económica, 1880–1914. Editorial de la Universidad Nacional de la Plata, La Plata, pp 201–232Google Scholar
  47. Rocchi F (2006) Chimneys in the dessert. Industrialization in Argentina during the export boom years. 1870–1930. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  48. Sábato H (1989) Capitalismo y ganadería en Buenos Aires: la fiebre del lanar 1850–1890. Editorial Sudamericana, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  49. Sábato H, Romero LA (1992) Los trabajadores de Buenos Aires: la experiencia del mercado, 1850–1880. Editorial Sudamericana, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  50. Sánchez-Alonso B (2000) Those who left and those who stayed behind: explaining emigration from the regions of Spain. 1880–1914. J Econ Hist 60(3):730–755CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Sánchez-Alonso B (2007) The Other Europeans: immigration into Latin America and the International Labour Market, 1870–1930. Rev Hist Econ J Iber Lat Am Econ Hist 25(3):395–426Google Scholar
  52. Sargent Charles (1976) The spatial evolution of Greater Buenos Aires. Arizona State University, TempeGoogle Scholar
  53. Scobie J (1974) Buenos Aires: Plaza to Suburb. 1870–1910. Oxford University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  54. Segundo Censo Nacional (1895) Segundo censo Nacional de la República Argentina, Mayo 10 de 1895. Taller Tipográfico de la Penitenciaría Nacional, Buenos Aires, 1898Google Scholar
  55. Sobek M (1995) The comparability of occupations and the generation of income scores. Hist Methods 28(1):47–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Sobek M (1996) Work, status and income: men in the American occupational structure since the late nineteenth century. Soc Sci Hist 20(2):169–207Google Scholar
  57. Somoza J, Lattes A (1967) Muestras de los dos primeros censos nacionales de población. 1869 y 1895. Documento de Trabajo del Instituto Torcuato di Tella Nro. 46Google Scholar
  58. Sori E (1979) L’emigrazione italiana dall’Unità alla seconda guerra mondiale. Il Mulino, BolognaGoogle Scholar
  59. Suriano J (1994) Vivir y sobrevivir en la gran ciudad: formas de hábitat populares en la ciudad de Buenos Aires a comienzo de siglo. Estudios Sociales 7:49–68Google Scholar
  60. Szuchman M (1980) Mobility and integration in urban Argentina. Córdoba in the Liberal Era. Texas University Press, AustinGoogle Scholar
  61. Thernstrom S (1973) The other Bostonians: poverty and progress in the American Metropolis. 1880–1970. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MACrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Treiman DJ (1976) A standard occupational prestige scale for use with historical data. J Interdiscip Hist 7(2):283–304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Vence Conti A, Cuesta EM (2016) Prices and wages in the 1890 crisis in Buenos Aires. Rev Hist Econ J Lat Am Econ Hist 34(2):267–294Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Middlebury CollegeVermontUSA
  2. 2.Universidad CEU San PabloMadridSpain

Personalised recommendations