Cliometrica

, Volume 11, Issue 3, pp 349–374 | Cite as

Latin American earnings inequality in the long run

Original Paper

Abstract

This paper traces between-group earnings inequality for six Latin American countries over two centuries based on wage and income series compiled from a large array of primary and secondary sources. We find that inequality varied substantially by country and by period, questioning the notion that colonial legacies largely dominated the evolution of inequality. There is a broader inequality trajectory over the long run in the form of an “m” pattern with peaks around 1880 and the 1990s and a trough around 1920/1930s. Export-led growth does not necessarily imply a rise in inequality, while the import-substitution industrialisation efforts did not translate into a more egalitarian distribution of income. More notably, Latin America’s experience does not exhibit the great inequality levelling as seen in the North Atlantic economies from the 1930s to the 1970s.

Keywords

Economic history Economic development Income inequality Latin America 

JEL Classification

N36 O15 O54 J31 

References

  1. Acemoglu D, Johnson S, Robinson J (2001) The colonial origins of comparative development: an empirical investigation. Am Econ Rev 91(5):1369–1401CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Alvaredo F (2010) The rich in Argentina over the twentieth century 1932–2004. Chapter 6. In: Atkinson A, Piketty T (eds) Top incomes vol. II: a global perspective. University Press Oxford, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  3. Archivo Arzobispal (1830–1900) Convento, CaracasGoogle Scholar
  4. Archivo General de la Nación de Argentina (1820–1900) Sala IX: Documentos de Gobierno (Administrativos y militares), Periodo Nacional, Hospital de Hombres, Hospital de Mujeres, Ejército, Contaduría, Oficina de la Sociedad Filantrópica, Buenos Aires, ArgentinaGoogle Scholar
  5. Archivo General de la Nación de Venezuela, Recopilación de Leyes y Decretos de Venezuela, (1830–1903), Caracas, VenezuelaGoogle Scholar
  6. Archivo Histórico del Distrito Federal, Empleados (1856–1877), Beneficencia Pública del Distrito Federal (1862–1900)Google Scholar
  7. Archivo Histórico del Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Hospitales (1820–1860)Google Scholar
  8. Arrillaga BJ (1830–1900) Recopilación De Leyes, Decretos, Bandos, Reglamentos, Circulares y Providencias de los Supremos Poderes y otras autoridades de la República Mexicana. Imprenta de J. M. Fernandez de Lara, MéxicoGoogle Scholar
  9. Arroyo Abad L (2013a) Persistent inequality? Trade, factor endowments and inequality in Republican Latin America. J Econ Hist 73:38–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Arroyo Abad L (2013b) Inestabilidad, costo de vida y salarios reales en Venezuela en el Siglo XIX. Am Lat Hist Econ 20:114–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Arroyo Abad L, Sánchez-Alonso B (2015) A city of trades: Spanish and Italian immigrants in late nineteenth century Buenos Aires, Argentina. EHES working papers in Economic History 88Google Scholar
  12. Astorga P (2012) Mean reversion in long-horizon real exchange rates: evidence from Latin America. J of Inter Money and Finance 31(6):1529–1550CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Astorga P (2015a) Functional inequality in Latin America: news from the twentieth century. Discussion Papers in Economic and Social History, Universidad of Oxford, 135Google Scholar
  14. Astorga P (2015b) Inequality and economic development in Latin America, 1900–2011. Paper presented at the EHES conference at Pisa, Italy, September 4–5Google Scholar
  15. Astorga P (2016) Functional inequality in Latin America: news from the twentieth century. In: Bértola L, Williamson JG (eds) Has Latin American inequality changed direction? Looking over the long run. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  16. Astorga P, Bergés AR, Fitzgerald EVK (2005) The standard of living in Latin America during the twentieth century. Econ Hist Rev 59(1):765–796CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Atkinson A (2008) The changing distribution in OECD countries. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Baptista A (1997) Bases cuantitativas de la economía venezolana, 1830–1995. Ediciones Fundación Polar, CaracasGoogle Scholar
  19. Barba FE (1999) Aproximación al estudio de precios y salarios en Buenos Aires desde fines del siglo XVII hasta 1860. Editorial de la Universidad Nacional de La Plata, La PlataGoogle Scholar
  20. Bazant J (1975) Cinco haciendas mexicanas: tres siglos de vida rural en San Luis Potosí. El Colegio de México, MexicoGoogle Scholar
  21. Berg EJ (1968) Wage structure in less developed countries. Center for Research on Economic Development. Discussion Paper 1. University of MichiganGoogle Scholar
  22. Berg EJ (1970) Wages and employment in less developed countries. Center for Research on Economic Development. Discussion Paper 13. University of MichiganGoogle Scholar
  23. Bértola L (2005) A 50 años de la curva de Kuznets: crecimiento y distribución del ingreso en Uruguay y otras economías de nuevo asentamiento desde 1870. Investigaciones en Historia Económica 3:135–176Google Scholar
  24. Bértola L, Ocampo JA (2012) The economic development of Latin America since independence. Oxford University Press, OxfordCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Bértola L, Williamson J (2006) Globalization in Latin America before 1940. In: Bulmer-Thomas V, Coatsworth JH, Cortes Conde R (eds) The Cambridge economic history of Latin America. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  26. Bértola L, Castelnovo C, Willebald H (2009) Income distribution in Brazil 1870–1920. Paper presented at the conference “A comparative approach to inequality and development: Latin America and Europe”, Instituto Figuerola, Universidad Carlos III, Madrid, May 8–9Google Scholar
  27. Bértola L, Castelnovo C, Rodríguez Weber J, Willebald H (2010) Between the colonial heritage and the first globalization boom: on income inequality in the southern cone. Revista de Historia Económica 20(2):307–341CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Bortz J (2005) Earning a living. A history of real wage studies in twentieth-century Mexico. Lat Am Res Rev 41(2):112–138CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Brito Figueroa F (1973) El problema tierra y esclavos en la historia de Venezuela. Ediciones Teoría y Praxis, CaracasGoogle Scholar
  30. Brito Figueroa F (2002) Historia económica y social de Venezuela. Universidad Central de Venezuela, CaracasGoogle Scholar
  31. Bucciferro JR (2016) Race and Brazilian inequality in the long run. In: Bértola L, Williamson JG (eds) Has Latin American inequality changed direction? Looking over the long run. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  32. Buchanan W (1898) La moneda y la vida en la República Argentina. Revista de Derecho, Historia y Letras I (II)Google Scholar
  33. Bulmer-Thomas V (2013) The economic history of Latin America since independence. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  34. Cámara de Diputados (1820–1900) Diario de los Debates de la Cámara de Diputados del Congreso de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos. Imprenta de la Cámara de Diputados, MéxicoGoogle Scholar
  35. Camou M, Maubrigades S (2016) The lingering face of gender inequality in Latin America. In: Bértola L, Williamson JG (eds) Has Latin American inequality changed direction? Looking over the long run. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  36. Carrasco G (1886) Descripción Geográfica y Estadística de la Provincia de Santa Fe. Imp. Lit. y Encuad. De Stiller & Laas, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  37. Cartay R (1988) Historia económica de Venezuela. Vadell Hermanos Editores, CaracasGoogle Scholar
  38. Catão LAV (1992) A new wholesale price index for Brazil during the period 1870–1913. Revista Brasileira de Economia 46:519–533Google Scholar
  39. Centro de Estudios para el Desarrollo Argentino (CENDA) (2005–2011) IPC en siete ProvinciasGoogle Scholar
  40. Challú AE, Gomez-Galvarriato A (2015) Mexico’s real wages in the age of Great Divergence. Rev Hist Econ 33:83–122Google Scholar
  41. Comisión Directiva del Censo (1898) Segundo Censo de la República Argentina, 10 de mayo de 1895 Taller Tip. de la Penitenciaria nacional, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  42. Congreso de la Nación (1860–1900) Diario de Sesiones, 1860–1900. Compañía Sud-American de Billetes de Banco, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  43. Cortés Conde R (1979) El progreso Argentino, 1880–1914. Editorial Sudamericana, 1979, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  44. Cuesta EM (2012) Precios y salarios en Buenos Aires durante la gran expansión. Revista de Instituciones, Ideas y Mercados 56:159–179Google Scholar
  45. De Corso G (2013) El crecimiento económico de Venezuela desde la oligarquía conservadora hasta la revolución bolivariana: 1830–2012. Una visión cuantitativa. Revista de Historia Económica 31(3):321–358CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Departamento General de Inmigración, 1895, 1914 (1895) Memoria del año 1894, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  47. Departamento General de Inmigración, 1895 (1914). Memoria del año 1913, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  48. Díaz J, Lüders R, Wagner G (2005) Chile 1820–2000: La República en cifras. SantiagoGoogle Scholar
  49. Dirección General de Estadística (1894) Censo de los empleados administrativos, funcionarios judiciales personal docente: De la República Argentina correspondiente al 31 de diciembre de 1893. Compañía sud-americana de billetes de banco, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  50. Echeverri CA, Arango Echeverri R, Gaviria Rios M, Muñoz Valdez J (1989) Haciendas cafetaleras antioqueñas: relaciones técnicas y sociales. Lecturas de Economía 28:91–126Google Scholar
  51. ECLA (1978) Series históricas del crecimiento de América Latina, Cuadernos Estadísticos de la CEPAL 3, Santiago de ChileGoogle Scholar
  52. ECLAC (2015) CEPALSTAT|Bases de datos. http://interwp.cepal.org/sisgen/ConsultaIntegrada.asp?idIndicador=340&idioma=e. Accessed 10 Oct 2015
  53. EH ClioLab—Instituto Economía Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile (2015). http://economia.uc.cl/cliolab/. Accessed Oct 2015
  54. El Colegio de México (1965) Estadísticas económicas del Porfiriato. Fuerza de trabajo y actividad económica por sectores. El Colegio de México, MéxicoGoogle Scholar
  55. Engerman SL, Sokoloff KL (1997) Factor endowments, institutions, and differential paths of growth among New World economies: a view from economic historians of the United States. In: Haber S (ed) How Latin America fell behind. Stanford University Press, StanfordGoogle Scholar
  56. Ferreres OJ (2005) Dos siglos de economía argentina, 1810–2004: Historia argentina en cifras. Editorial El Ateneo, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  57. FitzGerald VFK (2008) Economic development and fluctuations in earnings inequality in the very long run: the evidence from Latin America 1900–2000. J Int Dev 20:1028–1048CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Frankema E (2010) Reconstructing labor income shares in Argentina, Brazil and Mexico 1870–2000. J Iber Lat Am Econ Hist 28(2):343–374CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Frankema E (2012) Industrial wage inequality in Latin America in global perspective, 1900–2000. Stud Comp Int Dev 47:47–74CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Galiani S Heymann D Magud N (2010) On the distributive effects of terms of trade shocks: the role of non-tradable goods. IMF working paper wp/10/241Google Scholar
  61. Gasparini L, Lustig N (2011) The rise and fall of income inequality in Latin America. ECINEQ Working Paper 2011-213Google Scholar
  62. Gasparini L, Cruces G, Tornarolli L (2011) Recent trends in income inequality in Latin America. Economía 10:147–201CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Gelman J, Santilli D (2014) Los salarios y la desigualdad en Buenos Aires, 1810–1870. Amér Lat en la Hist econ 21:83–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. González Pérez M (2012) Ceremoniales y nación: un escenario. Ediciones Antropos, BogotáGoogle Scholar
  65. Hofman A (2000) The economic development of Latin America in the twentieth century. CheltenhamGoogle Scholar
  66. Instituto Brasileiro de Geografía e Estadística, IBGE (2015). http://www.ibge.gov.br/
  67. Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos de la República Argentina, INDEC (2015). http://www.indec.mecon.ar/
  68. International Labour Organization (1936–1964) International Labour Review. ILO Publications: GenevaGoogle Scholar
  69. International Labour Organization (1964–1982) Yearbook of Labour Statistics. ILO Publications: GenevaGoogle Scholar
  70. Ketzelman F, Souza RF (1930) Colección Completa De Leyes Del Estado Y Provincia De Buenos Aires Desde 1854 a 1929. Editorial “Lex”, Buenos AiresGoogle Scholar
  71. Lana-Berasain JM (2014) Añil, cacao y reses. Los negocios del indiano Esteban González de Linares en tiempos de mudanza. Memorias 22Google Scholar
  72. Leyes de los Estados Unidos de Colombia (1830–1900). Imprenta de Gaitan, BogotáGoogle Scholar
  73. Lindert P, Williamson JG (1982) Revising England’s social tables 1688–1812. Explor Econ Hist 19:308–402CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Lobo EM (1978) História do Rio de Janeiro (do capital comercial ao industrial e financiero). IBMEC, Rio de JaneiroGoogle Scholar
  75. López Calva LF, Lustig N (2010) Declining inequality in Latin America: a decade of progress?. United Nations Development Programme, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  76. Lucas G (1991) Sueldos y salarios en Venezuela (1800–1936). Doctoral thesis, Universidad Católica Andrés BelloGoogle Scholar
  77. Márquez Padilla C (1981) Nivel del salario y dispersión de la estructura salarial (1939–1977). Econ Mex 3:53–54Google Scholar
  78. Matus M (2012) Crecimiento sin desarrollo: precios y salarios reales durante el ciclo salitrero en Chile (1880–1930). Editorial Universitaria, Santiago de ChileGoogle Scholar
  79. Meisel A, Ramirez MT (2007) Economía colombiana del siglo XIX. FCE, BogotaGoogle Scholar
  80. Méndez J (1950) Minimum wages in Latin America. Inter Labour Rev 62:116–140Google Scholar
  81. Milanovic B, Lindert P, Williamson JG (2010) Pre-industrial inequality. Econ J 121:255–272CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Ministerio de Hacienda y Crédito Público (1881–1892) Ley de ingresos y presupuesto de egresos del Tesoro Federal. Imprenta de I. Cumplido, MexicoGoogle Scholar
  83. Montevideo-Oxford Latin American Economic History Database, MOXLAD (2015) The Latin American Centre, Oxford University, and the Universidad de la República (Uruguay). http://www.lac.ox.ac.uk/moxlad-database
  84. Morley SA (2000) The effects of growth and economic reform on income distribution in Latin America. CEPAL Rev 71:23–40Google Scholar
  85. Newland C (1998) Exports and terms of trade in Argentina, 1811–1870. Bull Lat Am Res 17:409–416Google Scholar
  86. Patroni A (1897) Los trabajadores en la Argentina. Buenos Aires. Imprenta Litografía y EcuadernaciónGoogle Scholar
  87. Piketty T (2014) Capital in the twenty-first century. Harvard University Press, HarvardCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. Prados de la Escosura L (2007) Inequality and poverty in Latin America: a long-run exploration. The new comparative economic history: essays in honor of Jeffrey G. Williamson, 291–315Google Scholar
  89. PREALC (1982) Mercado de trabajo en cifras. 1950–1980. PREALC Publications, LimaGoogle Scholar
  90. PREALC (1990) Empleo y Equidad. PREALC Publications, LimaGoogle Scholar
  91. Roberts KM (2012) The politics of inequality and redistribution in Latin America’s post-adjustment era. UNU-WIDER Working Paper 2012/8Google Scholar
  92. Rodríguez F (2000) Factor shares and resource booms. Accounting for the evolution of Venezuelan inequality. UNU-WIDER Working Paper 205Google Scholar
  93. Rodríguez Weber J (2014) La economía política de la desigualdad de ingreso en Chile. Doctoral thesis in economic history, Universidad de la República de UruguayGoogle Scholar
  94. Rodríguez Weber J (2015). The political economy of the top 1% in an age of turbulence: Chile 1913–1973. Documentos de trabajo 41, facultad de ciencias sociales de la Universidad de la RepúblicaGoogle Scholar
  95. Roxborough I (1984) The urban working class and the labour movements in Latin America. In: Bethell L (ed) The Cambridge history of Latin America, vol 4. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  96. Sábato H (1990) Agrarian capitalism and the world market: Buenos Aires in the pastoral age, 1840–1890. University of New Mexico Press, AlbuquerqueGoogle Scholar
  97. Semo E (1988) Historia de la cuestión agraria mexicana. Siglo XXI, MexicoGoogle Scholar
  98. Sevilla Soler R (1992) Capital y mercado interno en Colombia, 1880–1930. Anu Estud Am 49:585–599Google Scholar
  99. Stallings B, Peres W (2000) Growth, employment, and equity: the impact of the economic reforms in Latin America and the Caribbean. ECLAC and Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  100. Székely M, Sámano C (2012) Did trade openness affect income distribution in Latin America? Evidence for the years 1980–2010. UNU-WIDER Working Paper 2012-3Google Scholar
  101. Thorp R (1998) Progress, poverty and exclusion: an economic history of Latin America in the 20th Century. Inter-American Development Bank Publications, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  102. Urrutia M, Arrubla M (1970) Compendio de estadísticas históricas de Colombia. BogotáGoogle Scholar
  103. Willebald H (2011) Natural resources, settler economies and economic development during the first globalization: land frontier expansion and institutional arrangements. Ph.D. dissertation. Universidad Carlos III, MadridGoogle Scholar
  104. Willebald H (2015) Patrones distributivos en las economías templadas de reciente asentamiento: desigualdad en el ingreso agrario durante la Primera Globalización (1870–1913). Hist Agrar 66:75–104Google Scholar
  105. Williamson JG (1999) Real wage inequality and globalization in Latin America before 1940. Revista de Historia Económica XVII(special issue):101–142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  106. Williamson JG (2002) Land, labor, and globalization in the Third World, 1870–1940. J Econ Hist 62(1):55–85Google Scholar
  107. Williamson JG (2010) Five centuries of Latin American inequality. Rev Hist Econ 28:227–252Google Scholar
  108. World Bank (2012) The labor market story behind Latin America’s transformation. Washington, D.CGoogle Scholar
  109. Yarrington D (1997) A coffee frontier: land, society and politics in Duaca, Venezuela, 1830–1936. University of Pittsburgh Press, PittsburghGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Middlebury CollegeMiddleburyUSA
  2. 2.Institut Barcelona d’Estudis Internacionals, IBEIBarcelonaSpain

Personalised recommendations