Abstract
Disputes between separated couples over whether frozen embryos can be used in an attempt to create a child create a moral dilemma for public policy. When a couple create embryos intending to parent any resulting children, New Zealand’s current policy requires the consent of both people at every stage of the ART process. New Zealand’s Advisory Committee on Assisted Reproductive Technology has proposed a policy change that would give ex-partners involved in an embryo dispute twelve months to come to an agreement before the embryos are destroyed. New Zealand’s current policy and the proposed policy both favour the person who wishes to avoid procreation. Two alternative policy approaches that do not favour procreative avoidance are considered. Using pre-fertilisation contracts to determine the decision reached in embryo disputes allows the couple’s wishes at the time the embryos are created to determine what happens to the embryos if they separate. However, pre-fertilisation contracts are agreements about healthcare and personal relationships, and changing circumstances can make enforcing such agreements unjust. Finally, it is argued that New Zealand’s Family Court system should be used to reach decisions that balance the interests of those involved in the dispute.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
See A.Z. v. B.Z., 725 N. E. 2d (Mass. 2000); Bohn v. Mobley, 97-26334-DC (Mich. 2001); Davis v. Davis, 842 S. W. 2d (Tenn. 1992); J.B. v. M.B., 783 A.2d (N.J. 2001); Kass v. Kass, 696 N.E.2d (N.Y. 1998); Litowitz v. Litowitz, 48 P.3d (Wash. 2002); Roman v. Roman, 193 S. W.3d (Tex. App. 2006).
References
ACART. 2016. Advice to the Minister of Health about informed consent and assisted reproductive technology. Advisory Committee on Assisted Reproductive Technology.
Ainge Roy, Eleanor. 2016. "New Zealand's serious sperm shortage: 'It has become a continuous drought' " The Guardian, 15 Sep 2016. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/15/new-zealands-serious-sperm-shortage-it-has-become-a-continuous-drought. Accessed 5 November 2019.
Alghrani, A. 2005. Deciding the fate of frozen embryos. Medical Law Review 13(2): 244–256.
Barilan, Yechiel Michael. 2012. "Ulysses contracts and the nocebo effect." The American Journal of Bioethics 12 (3):37-39. https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2011.652800.
BBC News. 2002. "IVF wrangle cases go to court." BBC News Online, 11 Sep 2002. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/2249442.stm. Accessed 5 November 2019.
Ben-Naftali, O., and I. Canor. 2008. Evans v. United Kingdom. American Journal of International Law 102(1): 128-134.
Blyth, Eric, Lucy Frith, Marilyn S. Paul, and Roni Berger. 2011. "Embryo relinquishment for family building: How should it be conceptualised?" International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 25 (2):260-285. https://doi.org/10.1093/lawfam/ebr003.
Cousineau, Tara M., and Alice D. Domar. 2007. "Psychological impact of infertility." Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology 21 (2):293-308.
Daar, Judith F. 2001. "Frozen embryo disputes revisited: A trilogy of procreation-avoidance approaches." The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 29 (1):197-202. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-720X.2001.tb00708.x.
Department of Internal Affairs. 16 Oct 2017. Notification of Birth for Registration of child born in New Zealand. edited by Internal Affairs. Wellington, New Zealand.
Epstein, Richard A. 1995. "Surrogacy: The case for full contractual enforcement." 81 Virginia Law Review: 2305-2342.
Erickson, Theresa M., and Megan T. Erickson. 2009. "What happens to embryos when a marriage dissolves? Embryo disposition and divorce." William Mitchell Law Review 35 (2):469-488.
Getz, Lindsey. 2012. "The impact of infertility." Social Work Today 12 (6).
Hasanpoor-Azghdy, Seyede Batool, Masoumeh Simbar, and Abouali Vedadhir. 2014. "The Emotional-Psychological Consequences of Infertility among Infertile Women Seeking Treatment: Results of a Qualitative Study " Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine 12 (2):131–138.
Heathcotte, Brock. 2013. A.Z. v. B.Z. [Brief] (2000). In Embryo Project Encyclopedia, edited by Jane Maienschein: Arizona State University. School of Life Sciences. Center for Biology and Society. Original edition, 2008.
IVF Australia. 2017. "Egg freezing." Virtus Health. https://www.ivf.com.au/fertility-treatment/fertility-preservation/egg-freezing. Accessed 5 November 2019.
Jaeger, Carinne. 2017. "Yours, mine, or ours: resolving frozen embryo disputes through genetics." Seattle University Law Review 40 (3):1141-1163.
Johnston, M. 2009. Separated couple row over frozen embryos. New Zealand Herald, March 15. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10561876. Accessed 20 Jul 2018.
Kushnir, Vitaly A., David H. Barad, David F. Albertini, Sarah K. Darmon, and Norbert Gleicher. 2015. "Outcomes of fresh and cryopreserved oocyte donation." Journal of the American Medical Association 314 (6):623-624. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2015.7556.
Live Kidney Donation Aotearoa. 2017. "What if I change my mind?". New Zealand Ministry of Health. http://kidneydonor.org.nz/donor/guides/becoming-live-kidney-donor/what-if-i-change-my-mind-0. Accessed 5 November 2019.
Lyerly, A., E. Brelsford, B. Bankowski, R. Faden, and E. Wallach. 2004. "A qualitative study of individuals' attitudes regarding their cryopreserved embryos." International Congress Series 1271:353-356. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ics.2004.05.058.
Newton, C. R., J. Fisher, V. Feyles, F. Tekpetey, L. Hughes, and D. Isacsson. 2007. "Changes in patient preferences in the disposal of cryopreserved embryos." Human Reproduction 22 (12):3124-3128. https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/dem287.
Petropanagos, Angel, Alana Cattapan, Françoise Baylis, and Arthur Leader. 2015. "Social egg freezing: risk, benefits and other considerations." CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association Journal 187 (9):666-669. https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.141605.
Sills, E., and S. Murphy. 2009. Determining the status of non-transferred embryos in Ireland: A conspectus of case law and implications for clinical IVF practice. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 4(1): 8.
Strasser, Mark P. 2009. "You take the embryos but I get the house (and the business): recent trends in awards involving embryos upon divorce." Buffalo Law Review 57 (4):1159-1225.
Strom, Roy. 2014. "Frozen embryos: Who do they belong to?" Chicago Lawyer 37 (9).
Warnock, Mary. 1985. "St Catherine's College Seminars: The Warnock report." British Medical Journal (Clinical research ed.) 291 (6489):187-189. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.291.6489.187.
Wiggins, Amy. 2017. "Sperm donor shortage leaves women waiting two years." New Zealand Herald, 22 Oct 2017. http://www.nzherald.co.nz/lifestyle/news/article.cfm?c_id=6&objectid=11934847. Accessed 5 November 2019.
Acknowledgements
The author thanks Nicola Forrest, Alison Parker, Douglas Campbell, Michael-John Turp and reviewers for the Journal of Bioethical Inquiry for their comments on earlier versions of this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mason, C. New Zealand Policy on Frozen Embryo Disputes. Bioethical Inquiry 17, 121–131 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-019-09950-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-019-09950-0