Conflicts Between Parents and Health Professionals About a Child’s Medical Treatment: Using Clinical Ethics Records to Find Gaps in the Bioethics Literature
- 1.1k Downloads
Clinical ethics records offer bioethics researchers a rich source of cases that clinicians have identified as ethically complex. In this paper, we suggest that clinical ethics records can be used to point to types of cases that lack attention in the current bioethics literature, identifying new areas in need of more detailed bioethical work. We conducted an analysis of the clinical ethics records of one paediatric hospital in Australia, focusing specifically on conflicts between parents and health professionals about a child’s medical treatment. We identified, analysed, and compared cases of this type from the clinical ethics records with cases of this type discussed in bioethics journals. While the cases from journals tended to describe situations involving imminent risk to the child’s life, a significant proportion of the clinical ethics records cases involved different stakes for the child involved. These included distress, poorer functional outcome, poorer psychosocial outcome, or increased risk of surgical complications. Our analysis suggests that one type of case that warrants more detailed ethics research is parental refusal of recommended treatment, where the refusal does not endanger the child’s life but rather some other aspect of the child’s well-being.
KeywordsPaediatrics Clinical ethics Parents Conflict
The authors thank Alison Brookes for her research assistance. This project was funded by an Australian Research Council Discovery Early Career Researcher Award (grant number DE120100488).
- Guillemin, M., and L. Gillam. 2006. Telling moments: Everyday ethics in health care. Melbourne: IP Communications.Google Scholar
- Komesaroff, P.A. 1995. From bioethics to microethics: Ethical debate and clinical medicine. In Troubled bodies: Critical perspectives on postmodernism, medical ethics, and the body, edited by P.A. Komesaroff, 62–86. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.Google Scholar
- McDougall, R., and L. Notini. Unpublished. What kinds of cases do paediatricians refer to clinical ethics? Insights from 184 case referrals at an Australian paediatric hospital.Google Scholar
- McDougall, R.J., and L. Notini. 2014. Overriding parents’ medical decisions for their children: A systematic review of normative literature. Journal of Medical Ethics 40(7): 448–452.Google Scholar
- McDougall, R., C. Delany, M. Spriggs, and L. Gillam. 2014. Collaboration in clinical ethics consultation: a method for achieving “balanced accountability.” The American Journal of Bioethics 14(6): 47–48.Google Scholar
- Rossiter, K., and S. Diehl. 1997. Gender reassignment in children: Ethical conflicts in surrogate decision making. Pediatric Nursing 24(1): 59–62.Google Scholar
- Worthley, J.A. 1997. The ethics of the ordinary in healthcare: Concepts and cases. Chicago: Health Administration Press.Google Scholar