Mental health care providers increasingly confront challenges posed by the introduction of new neurotechnology into the clinic, but little is known about the impact of such capabilities on practice patterns and relationships with patients. To address this important gap, we sought providers’ perspectives on the potential clinical translation of functional neuroimaging for prediction and diagnosis of mental illness. We conducted 32 semi-structured telephone interviews with mental health care providers representing psychiatry, psychology, family medicine, and allied mental health. Our results suggest that mental health providers have begun to re-conceptualize mental illness with a neuroscience gaze. They report an epistemic commitment to the value of a brain scan to provide a meaningful explanation of mental illness for their clients. If functional neuroimaging continues along its projected trajectory to translation, providers will ultimately have to negotiate its role in mental health. Their perspectives, therefore, enrich bioethical discourse surrounding neurotechnology and inform the translational pathway.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Mental health providers often use the term “client” to refer to individuals who receive healthcare services, usually in lieu of the term “patient.” This paper will use the term client in the same way, however client may be used interchangeably with patient in the narratives of the mental health providers highlighted in our text.
The Journal of Psychiatric Practice lists Cheung’s paper as the “Winner of the Resident Paper Award 2008–2009.”
Blood oxygen level-dependent. In the MRI, the BOLD signal is correlated with changes in deoxyhemoglobin in the brain.
All names of participants are pseudonyms.
Abi-Rached, J.M., and N. Rose. 2010. The birth of the neuromolecular gaze. History of the Human Sciences 23(1): 11–36.
Angermeyer, M.C., and H. Matschinger. 2005. Labeling—stereotype—discrimination: an investigation of the stigma process. Social Psychiary and Epidemiology 40(5): 391–405.
Bennett, M.R., and P.M.S. Hacker. 2003. Philosophical foundations of neuroscience. Oxford: Blackwell.
Bloch, S., P. Chodoff, and S.A. Green. 1999. Psychiatric ethics, 3rd ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
Boeije, H. 2002. A purposeful approach to the constant comparative method in the analysis of qualitative interviews. Quality and Quantity 36(4): 391–409.
Buchman, D.Z., and J. Illes. 2010. Imaging genetics for our neurogenetic future. Minnesota Journal of Law, Science, & Technology 11(1): 79–97.
Campbell, P. 2010. A decade for psychiatric disorders. Nature 463(7277): 9.
Cheung, E.H. 2009. A new ethics of psychiatry: neuroethics, neuroscience, and technology. Journal of Psychiatric Practice 15(5): 391–401.
Corrigan, P.W., S.A. Kuwabara, and J. O’Shaughnessy. 2009. The public stigma of mental illness and drug addiction: findings from a stratified random sample. Journal of Social Work 9(2): 139–147.
Davis, L.J. 2010. The bioethics of diagnosis: a biocultural critique of certainty. Bioethical Inquiry 7(2): 227–235.
Dumit, J. 2000. When explanations rest: “Good Enough” brain science and the new socio-medical disorders. In: M. Lock, A. Young and A. Cambrosio (Eds.). In Living and working with the new medical technologies: Intersections of inquiry, 209–232. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Edwards, J., P. Harvey, and P. Wade. 2010. Technologized images, technologized bodies. In Technologized images, technologized bodies, ed. J. Edwards, P. Harvey, and P. Wade, 1–36. New York: Berghahn.
Farmer, R.L. 2008. Neuroscience and social work practice: the missing link. Newbury Park: Sage.
Finnell, D.S. 2000. The case for teaching patients about the neurobiological basis of addictions. Journal of Addictions Nursing 12(3/4): 149–158.
Foucault, M. 1963/2010. The birth of the clinic: an archeology of medical perception. London: Routledge.
Fry, C. 2009. A descriptive social neuroethics is needed to reveal lived identities. The American Journal of Bioethics-Neuroscience 9(9): 16–17.
Gillett, G. 2009. The subjective brain, identity, and neuroethics. The American Journal of Bioethics-Neuroscience 9(9): 5–13.
Gillett, G. 2010. The multiaxial, multi-layered reality that is mental disorder. Bulletin of the Association for the Advancement of Philosophy and Psychiatry 17(1): http://alien.dowling.edu/%7Ecperring/aapp/BulletinVol17No1.pdf.
Giovanni, F., and S. Anker. 2009. Neuroculture. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 10: 815–821.
Glannon, W. 2007. Bioethics and the brain. New York: Oxford University Press.
Glannon, W. 2009. Our brains are not us. Bioethics 23(6): 321–329.
Glaser, B.G. 1965. The constant comparative method of qualitative analysis. Social Problms 12(4): 436–445.
Guze, S.B. 1992. Why psychiatry is a branch of medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hacking, I. 2004. Historical ontology, 99–114. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Hoop, J.G., and R. Spellecy. 2009. Philosophical and ethical issues at the forefront of neuroscience and genetics: an overview for psychiatrists. Psychiatric Clinics of North America 32(2): 437–439.
Huber, L. 2009. Imaging the brain: visualising “pathological entities”? Searching for reliable protocols within psychiatry and their impact on the understanding of psychiatric disease. Poiesis praxis 6(1–2): 27–41.
Hyman, S.E. 2007. Can neuroscience be integrated into the DSM-V? Nature Reviews Neuroscience 8(9): 725–732.
Illes, J., S. Lombera, J. Rosenberg, and B. Arnow. 2008. In the mind’s eye: provider and patient attitudes on functional brain imaging. Journal of Psychiatric Research 43(2): 107–114.
Insel, T.R., and P.S. Wang. 2010. Rethinking mental illness. Journal of the American Medical Association 303(19): 1970–1971.
Jacobs, D.H. 2009. Is a correct psychiatric diagnosis possible? Major depressive disorder as a case in point. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 11(2): 83–96.
Kandel, E. 1998. A new intellectual framework for psychiatry. American Journal of Psychiatry 155: 457–469.
Kendell, R.E. 2000. The next 25 years. British Journal of Psychiatry 176: 6–9.
Klitzman, R. 2006. Clinicians, patients, and the brain. In Neuroethics: defining the issues in theory, practice, and policy, ed. J. Illes, 229–241. New York: Oxford University Press.
Lennox, B.R. 2009. The clinical experience and potential of brain imaging in patients with mental illness. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 3: 46.
Levy, N., and S. Clarke. 2008. Neuroethics and psychiatry. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 21(6): 568–571.
MacQueen, G.M. 2009. Magnetic resonance imaging and prediction of outcome in patients with major depressive disorder. Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience 34(5): 343–349.
Mashour, G.A., E.E. Walker, and R.L. Martuza. 2005. Psychosurgery: past, present, and future. Brain Research Reviews 48: 409–419.
Matto, H.C., and J. Strolin-Goltzman. 2010. Integrating social neuroscience and social work: innovations for advancing practice-based research. Social Work 55(2): 147–156.
Merton, R.K. 1976. Sociological ambivalence and other essays. New York: Free.
Murphy, E.R., and J. Illes. 2007. Neuroethics and psychiatry: new collaborations for emerging challenges. Psychiatric Annals 37(12): 398–804.
Novas, C., and N. Rose. 2000. Genetic risk and the birth of the somatic individual. Economy and Society 29(4): 485–513.
Pardo, M.S., and D. Patterson. 2010. Minds, brains, and norms. Neuroethics. doi:10.1007/s12152-010-9082-4.
Pescosolido, B.A., J.K. Martin, J.S. Long, T.R. Medina, J.C. Phelan, and B.G. Link. 2010. “A disease like any other”? A decade of change in public reactions to schizophrenia, depression, and alcohol dependence. American Journal of Psychiatry. doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.2010.09121743.
Phelan, J.C. 2005. Geneticization of deviant behaivour and consequences for stigma: the case of mental illness. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 46(4): 307–322.
Phelan, J.C., R. Cruz-Rojas, and M. Reiff. 2002. Genes and stigma: the connection between perceived genetic etiology and attitudes and beliefs about mental illness. American Journal of Psychiatric Rehabilitation 6(2): 159–185.
Racine, E., O. Bar-Ilan, and J. Illes. 2005. fMRI in the public eye. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 6(2): 159–164.
Read, J. 2007. Why promoting a biological ideology increases prejudice against people labelled “schizophrenic. Australian Psychologist 42(2): 118–128.
Reiner, P.B. 2011. The rise of neuroessentialsim. In The Oxford handbook of neuroethics, ed. J. Illes and B. Sahakian. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Reynolds, C.F., D.A. Lewis, T. Detre, A.F. Schatzberg, and D.J. Kupfer. 2009. The future of psychiatry as clinical neuroscience. Academic Medicine 84(4): 446–50.
Rose, N. 2003. The neurochemical self and its anomalies. In Risk and morality, ed. R. Ericson and A. Doyle, 407–437. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Rose, N. 2007. The politics of life itself: biomedicine, power and subjectivity in the twenty-first century. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Schleim, S., and J. P. Roiser. 2009. fMRI in translation: The challenges facing real-world applications. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 3: doi:10.3389/neuro.09.063.2009.
Schnittker, J. 2008. An uncertain revolution: why the rise of a genetic model of mental illness has not increased tolerance. Social Science & Medicine 67(9): 1370–1381.
Rosenberg, C.E. 2006. Contested boundaries: psychiatry, disease, and diagnosis. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 49(3): 407–424.
Singh, I., and N. Rose. 2009. Biomarkers in psychiatry. Nature 460(7252): 202–207.
The International Schizophrenia Consortium. 2009. Common polygenic variation contributes to risk of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Nature 460: 748–752.
Valenstein, E.S. 1986. Great and desperate cures: the rise and decline of pyschosurgery and other radical treatments for mental illness. New York: Basic Books.
Vidal, F. 2009. Brainhood: anthropological figure of modernity. History of the Human Sciences 22(1): 5–36.
Vos, R., and D.L. Willems. 2000. Technology in medicine: ontology, epistemology, ethics and social philosophy at the crossroads. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 21(1): 1–7.
Vul, E., C. Harris, P. Winkielman, and H. Pashler. 2009. Puzzingly high correlations in fMRI studies of emotion, personality, and social cognition. Perspectives on Psychological Science 4(3): 274–290.
Whooley, O. 2010. Diagnostic ambivalence: psychiatric workarounds and the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. Sociology of Health & Illness 32(3): 452–469.
Wittgenstein, L. 1953. Philosophical investigations. Oxford: Basil Blackwell. Trans. G. E. M. Anscombe.
Young, A. 1995. The harmony of illusions. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Supported by NIH/NIMH 9RO1MH84282, the Canadian Institutes for Health Research, Institutes for Neuroscience, Mental Health and Addiction (CIHR-INMHA) CNE #85117, the British Columbia Knowledge Development Fund (BCKDF), the Canadian Foundation for Innovation (CFI), and the Vancouver Coastal Health Research Institute. Special thanks to Dr. Allan H. Young and members of the Institute of Mental Health, Department of Psychiatry, University of British Columbia, and to the anonymous reviewer for thoughtful remarks.
An erratum to this article can be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11673-011-9284-4
About this article
Cite this article
Borgelt, E., Buchman, D.Z. & Illes, J. “This is Why you’ve Been Suffering”: Reflections of Providers on Neuroimaging in Mental Health Care. Bioethical Inquiry 8, 15–25 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-010-9271-1
- Mental health