Abstract
Understanding what motivates farmers to adopt “climate-smart” regenerative practices is critical for developing the right policies, incentives, outreach, and support mechanisms. This article explores factors that motivated farmers in NSW Australia to transition from conventional to regenerative agriculture (RA), focusing on the role that their perceptions of agrochemicals and the microbiome played. Drawing on integral theory, the article takes a holistic approach to analyzing how farmer interiorities in personal and collective realms interacted with external behavior and the larger social-ecological system in which food and fiber is produced. A key finding is that negative experiences with agrochemicals associated with increasing costs and declining results were an important driver of change. Conversely, positive experiences learning about the microbiome and practicing ecological approaches to fertilization and pest control engendered enthusiasm and commitment to a transition away from high-input agriculture and a transformation in mindset. Further, conviviality associated with communities of practice, e.g. microscope groups, played an important role in the transition process, as farmers solidified new identities and participated in ongoing social learning. Based on these results, I argue that farmers’ feelings of kinship with nature (animals, plants, microbes) resulting from learning about and working with soil are underappreciated drivers of behavioral change and powerful leverage points for larger-scale social-ecological transformation. The integral model facilitates recognition of the connections between soil condition, farmers’ perceptions of and feelings about its condition, ensuing behavior including participation in new networks, and the creation of new norms, all of which create space for the emergence of institutional and systemic change.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abson DJ, Sherren K, Fischer J (2019) The resilience of Australian agricultural landscapes characterized by land sparing versus land sharing. In: Gardner S, Ramsden S, Hails R (eds) Agricultural resilience: perspectives from ecology and economics. Ecological reviews (British Ecological Society) (Chapter 11). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 232–252
Adevi AA, Martensson F (2013) Stress rehabilitation through garden therapy: The garden as a place in the recovery from stress. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 12(2):230–237
Adger WN, Barnett J, Chapin FS, Ellemor H (2011) This must be the place: underrepresentation of identity and meaning in climate change decision-making. Global Environmental Politics 11(2):1–25
Adger WN, Barnett J, Brown K, Marshall N, O’Brien K (2013) Cultural dimensions of climate change impacts and adaptation. Nat Clim Chang 3(2):112–117
Babaian C, Twigg P (2011) The power of plants: Introducing ethnobotany and biophilia into your biology class. American Biology Teacher 73(4):217–221
Barnes ML, Wang P, Cinner JE, Graham NAJ, Guerrero AM, Jasny L, Lau J, Sutcliffe SR, Zamborain-Mason J (2020) Social determinants of adaptive and transformative responses to climate change. Nat Clim Chang. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41558-020-0871-4
Barrera-Bassols N, Zinck JA (2003) Ethnopedology: A worldwide view on the soil knowledge of local people. Geoderma 111(3–4):171–195
Bernard HR (2006) Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches. AltaMira Press, Lanham, MD
Best D, Beckwith M, Haslam C, Haslam SA, Jetten J, Mawson E, Lubman DI (2015) Overcoming alcohol and other drug addiction as a process of social identity transition: the social identity model of recovery (SIMOR). Addict Res Theory 24(2):111–123
Beus C, Dunlap R (1990) Conventional vs. alternative agriculture: the paradigmatic roots of the debate. Rural Sociol 55(4):590–616
Brown AM (2017) Emergent Strategy: Shaping Change, Changing Worlds. AK Press, Chico, CA
Brown K, Adger WN, Devine-Wright P, Anderies JM, Barr S, Bousquet F, Butler C, Evans L, Marshall N, Quinn T (2019) Empathy, place and identity interactions for sustainability. Global Environmental Change Part A 56:11–17
Burton RJF (2004) Seeing through the ‘good farmer’s’ eyes: Towards developing an understanding of the social symbolic value of ‘productivist’ behaviour. Sociol Rural 44(2):195–215
Caillon S, Cullman G, Verschuuren B, Sterling EJ (2017) Moving beyond the human–nature dichotomy through biocultural approaches: Including ecological well-being in resilience indicators. Ecol Soc 22(4):27. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-09746-220427
Callicott JB (1990) The metaphysical transition in farming: From the Newtonian-mechanical to the Eltonian ecological. Journal of Agricultural Ethics 3:36–49. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02014479
Campbell H (2020) Farming Inside Invisible Worlds: Modernist Agriculture and its Consequences. Bloomsbury Academic, London
Campbell BM, Beare DJ, Bennett EM, Hall-Spencer JM, Ingram JSI, Jaramillo F, Ortiz R, Ramankutty N, Sayer JA, Shindell D (2017) Agriculture production as a major driver of the Earth system exceeding planetary boundaries. Ecol Soc 22(4):8
Chapin FS III, Chapin FS, Pickett STA, Power ME et al (2011) Earth stewardship: a strategy for social–ecological transformation to reverse planetary degradation. Journal of Environmental Studies and Science 1:44–53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13412-011-0010-7
Cox TEB (2014) Integral agriculture: Taking seriously the mindset of the farmer, the interiority of the beings on the farm, and a metaphysics that connects them. Unpublished PhD dissertation, Iowa State University
Creswell JW (2009) Research Design: Qualitative. Sage Publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, US, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches
Cross R, Ampt P (2016) Exploring agroecological sustainability: Unearthing innovators and documenting a community of practice in Southeast Australia. Soc Nat Resour 30(5):585–600
Davis JV (2011) Ecopsychology, transpersonal psychology and nonduality. International Journal of Transpersonal Studies 30(1–2):137–147
de Bruyn LL, Abbey JA (2003) Characterisation of farmers’ soil sense and the implications for on-farm monitoring of soil health. Aust J Exp Agric 43(3):285–305
de Bruyn LL, Andrews S (2016) Are Australian and United States farmers using soil information for soil health management? Sustainability 8(4):304
de Bruyn LL, Jenkins A, Samson-Liebig S (2017) Lessons learnt: Sharing soil knowledge to improve land management and sustainable soil use. Soil Sci Soc Am J 81(3):427–438
Doherty D, Jeeves A (2016) Regrarians handbook. Regrarian, Ltd., Victoria, Australia
Esbjorn-Hargens S, Zimmerman M (2009) Integral Ecology: Uniting Multiple Perspectives on the Natural World. Shambhala, Boston, MA
Evich HB (2019) How a closed-door meeting shows farmers are waking up on climate change. Politico, December 9, 2019. https://www.politico.com/news/2019/12/09/farmers-climate-change-074024
Fazey IRA (2010) Resilience and higher order thinking. Ecol Soc 15(3):9
Folke C, Jansson A, Rockstrom J, Olsson P, Carpenter SR, Chapin FS, Crepin A-S, Daily G, Danell K, Ebbesson J, Elmqvist T, Galasz V, Moberg F, Nilsson M, Osterblom H, Ostrom E, Persson A, Peterson G, Polasky S, Steffen W, Walker B, Westley F (2011) Reconnecting to the biosphere. Ambio 40(7):719–738
Folke C, Österblom H, Jouffray JB, Lambin EF, Adger WN, Scheffer M, Crona BI, Nyström M, Levin SA, Carpenter SR, Anderies JM, Chapin S III, Crépin AS, Dauriach A, Galaz V, Gordon LJ, Kautsky N, Walker BH, Watson JR, Wilen J, de Zeeuw A (2019) Transnational corporations and the challenge of biosphere stewardship. Nature Ecology & Evolution 3:1396–1403
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) (2013) Climate-Smart Agriculture: Sourcebook. United Nations, Rome
Fortuna G (2020) Europe revives carbon farming but without access to carbon markets. Euractiv.com, September 30, 2020. https://www.euractiv.com/section/agriculture-food/news/europe-revives-carbon-farming-but-without-access-to-carbon-markets/
Fountain H (2021) A different kind of land management: Let the cows stomp. New York Times, February 17, 2021. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/17/climate/regenerative-grazing-cattle-climate.html
Francis CA, Harwood RR (1985) Enough food: achieving food security through regenerative agriculture. Rodale Institute, Kutztown, PA
Fullerton J (2015) Regenerative capitalism: how universal principles and patterns will shape our new economy. Capital Institute, Greenwich, CT
Fynn R (2012) Functional resource heterogeneity increases livestock and rangeland productivity. Rangeland Ecology Management 65(4):319–329
Giles J (2019) Could this new way of grazing help avoid a culture clash over burgers? GreenBiz July 22, 2019. https://www.greenbiz.com/article/could-new-way-grazing-help-avoid-culture-clash-over-burgers
Giller KE, Hijbeek R, Andersson JA, Sumberg J (2021) Regenerative Agriculture: An agronomic perspective. Outlook Agric. https://doi.org/10.1177/0030727021998063
Gosnell H, Gill N, Voyer M (2019) Transformational adaptation on the farm: Processes of change and persistence in transitions to “climate-smart” regenerative agriculture. Glob Environ Chang 59:101965. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2019.101965
Gosnell H, Grimm K, Goldstein B (2020a) A half century of Holistic Management: What does the evidence reveal? Agric Hum Values 37(3):849–867. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-020-10016-w
Gosnell H, Charnley S, Stanley P (2020b) Climate change mitigation as a co-benefit of regenerative ranching: Insights from Australia and the United States. Interface Focus 10:20200027. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsfs.2020.0027
Grenni S, Soini K, Horlings LG (2019) The inner dimension of sustainability transformation: How sense of place and values can support sustainable place-shaping. Sustain Sci 15:411–422
Griscom BW, Adams J, Ellis PW, Houghton RA, Lomax G, Miteva DA, Schlesinger WH, Shoch D, Siikamäki JV, Smith P, Woodbury P, Zganjar C, Blackman A, Campari J, Conant RT, Delgado C, Elias P, Gopalakrishna T, Hamsik MR, Herrero M, Kiesecker J, Landis E, Laestadius L, Leavitt SM, Minnemeyer S, Polasky S, Potapov P, Putz FE, Sanderman J, Silvius M, Wollenberg E, Fargione J (2017) Natural climate solutions. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 114:11645–11650. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1710465114
Gunderson L, Holling CS (2001) Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems. Island Press, Washington, DC
Hochachka G (2011) Integrating interiority in sustainable community development: a case study with San Juan del Gozo Community, El Salvador. In: Esbjorn-Hargens S, Zimmerman M (eds) Integral ecology: uniting multiple perspectives on the natural world. Integral Books, Boston
Holscher K, Wittmayer JM, Loorbach D (2018) Transition versus transformation: What’s the difference? Environmental Innovations and Societal Transitions 27:1–3
Hustak C, Myers N (2012) Involutionary momentum: affective ecologies of plant/insect encounters. Differences 23(3):74–118
Kamatsis I, Francis AJP (2013) Spirituality mediates the relationship between engagement with nature and psychological well-being. J Environ Psychol 36:136–143
Kellert SR, Wilson EO (1995) The Biophilia Hypothesis. Island Press, Washington DC
LaCanne CE, Lundgren JG (2018) Regenerative agriculture: merging farming and natural resource conservation profitably. PeerJ 6:e4428. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.4428
Lal R (2020) Regenerative agriculture for food and climate. J Soil Water Conserv. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.2020.0620A
Watershed Landcare, Inc (2013) “Beyond the Rhetoric” - Mudgee Microscope Group, a case study: a cooperative approach by land managers to better understand and manage for soil biological health. http://www.csu.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/617590/Mudgee-Microscope-Group-Case-Study.pdf
Lloro-Bidart T (2018) Cultivating affects: a feminist posthumanist analysis of invertebrate and human performativity in an urban community garden. Emot Space Soc 27:23–30. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1755458617301767
Lorimer J (2020) The Probiotic Planet: Using Life to Manage Life. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN
Machmuller MB, Kramer MG, Cyle TK, Hill N, Hancock D, Thompson A (2015) Emerging land use practices rapidly increase soil organic matter. Nat Commun 6:6995. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms7995
Mann C, Parkins JR, Isaac ME, Sherren K (2019) Do practitioners of holistic management exhibit systems thinking? Ecol Soc 24(3):19. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-11092-240319
Marquis A (2007) What is integral theory? Couns Values 51(3):164–179
Massy C (2017) Call of the Reed Warbler: A New Agriculture, A New Earth. University of Queensland Press, St. Lucia, Queensland
Masters N (2019) For the love of soil: strategies to regenerate our food production systems. Printable Reality, New Zealand
Masterson VA, Stedman RC, Enqvist J, Tengö M, Giusti M, Wahl D, Svedin U (2017) The contribution of sense of place to social-ecological systems research: A review and research agenda. Ecol Soc 22(1):49. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-08872-220149
Maxwell JA (2005) Qualitative Research Design: An Interactive Approach. Sage Publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, US
Mayer FS, Frantz CM, Bruehlman-Senecal E, Dolliver K (2009) Why is nature beneficial? The role of connectedness to nature. Environ Behav 41(5):607–643
McGuire A (2018) Regenerative agriculture: solid principles, extraordinary claims. Washington State University, Center for Sustaining Agriculture and Natural Resources. https://csanr.wsu.edu/regen-ag-solid-principles-extraordinary-claims/
Meadows D (2008) Thinking in systems: a primer. Earthscan, Sterling, VA
Mercola J (2017) Will McDonald’s transition to regenerative agriculture? Organic Consumers Association. Dec. 19, 2017. https://www.organicconsumers.org/news/will-mcdonalds-transition-regenerative-agriculture
Miles MB, Huberman AM (1994) Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd edn. Sage Publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, US
Montgomery DR (2017) Growing a Revolution: Bringing Our Soil Back to Life. W. W. Norton & Co., New York
Moore M-L, Tjornbo O, Enfors E, Knapp C, Hodbod J, Baggio JA, Norström A, Olsson P, Biggs D (2014) Studying the complexity of change: toward an analytical framework for understanding deliberate social-ecological transformations. Ecol Soc 19(4):54. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-06966-190454
Moore M-L, Riddell D, Vocisano D (2015) Scaling out, scaling up, scaling deep: Strategies of non-profits in advancing systemic social innovation. J Corp Citizsh 58:67–84
Moser SC, Hart JF (2015) The long arm of climate change: Exploring climate change impacts via teleconnections. Clim Change. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-015-1328-z
Nerbonne JF, Lentz R (2003) Rooted in grass: Challenging patterns of knowledge exchange as a means of fostering social change in a southeast Minnesota farm community. Agric Hum Values 20:65–78
Neufeldt H, Jahn M, Campbell BM, Beddington JR, DeClerck F, De Pinto A, Gulledge J (2013) Beyond climate-smart agriculture: Toward safe operating spaces for global food systems. Agriculture & Food Security 2(1):1–6
Newton P, Civita N, Frankel-Goldwater L, Bartel K, Johns C (2020) What is regenerative agriculture? A review of scholar and practitioner definitions based on processes and outcomes. Front Sustain Food Syst 4:577723. https://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2020.577723
O’Brien AT (2013) Supporting soil fungi to rebuild soils in agriculture. PAN: Philosophy Activism Nature 10
O’Brien K (2013) The courage to change: adaptation from the inside-out. In: Moser S, Boykoff M (eds) Successful adaptation: linking science and practice in managing climate change impacts. Routledge, London
O’Brien K (2018) Is the 1.5C target possible? Exploring the three spheres of transformation. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 31:153–160
O’Brien K, Hochachka G (2010) Integral adaptation to climate change. Journal of Integral Theory and Practice 5(1):89–102
Ogden LA, Hall B, Tanita K (2013) Animals, plants, people, and things: A review of multispecies ethnography. Environment and Society: Advances in Research 4:5–24
Patton MQ (2002) Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods. Sage Publications Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA, US
Pauli N, Abbot LK, Negrete-Yankelevich S, Andres P (2016) Farmers’ knowledge and use of soil fauna in agriculture: A worldwide review. Ecol Soc 21(3):19
Paustian K, Lehmann J, Ogle S, Reay D, Robertson GP, Smith P (2016) Climate-smart soils. Nature 532:49–57. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature17174
Pelling M (2010) Adaptation to Climate Change: From Resilience to Transformation, 1st edn. Routledge
Perroni E (2019) A regenerative era in Australian agriculture is emerging. Food movement, food systems news and reviews. Sustainable Food Trust. https://sustainablefoodtrust.org/articles/a-regenerative-era-in-australian-agriculture-is-emerging/
Pincus L, Ballard H, Harris E, Scow K (2018) Seeing below the surface: Making soil processes visible to Ugandan smallholder farmers through a constructivist and experiential extension approach. Agric Hum Values 35(2):425–440
Pouliot A (2013) Intimate strangers of the subterrain: a mycelial metaphor for connectivity. PAN: Philosophy, Activism, Nature, no 10
Provenza F (2018) Nourishment: What Animals Can Teach Us About Rediscovering Our Nutritional Wisdom. Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction, VT
Puig de la Bellacasa M (2014) Making time for soil: Technoscientific futurity and the pace of care. Soc Stud Sci 45(5):691–716
Rhodes CJ (2017) The imperative for regenerative agriculture. Sci Prog 100(1):80–129
Richelle L, Visser M, Bock L, Walpole P, Mialhe F, Colinet G, Dendoncker N (2018) Looking for a dialogue between farmers and scientific soil knowledge: learnings from an ethno-geomorphopedological study in a Philippine’s upland village. Agroecol Sustain Food Syst 42(1):2–27. https://doi.org/10.1080/21683565.2017.1322661
Riddell D (2011) Evolving approaches to conservation: integral ecology and Canada’s Great Bear Rainforest. In: Esbjorn-Hargens S, Zimmerman M (eds) Integral ecology: uniting multiple perspectives on the natural world. Integral Books, Boston
Riedy C (2007) The eye of the storm: an integral perspective on sustainable development and climate change response. VDM Verlag
Savory A, Butterfield J (2016) Holistic Management, Third Edition: A Commonsense Revolution to Restore Our Environment. Island Press, Washington, DC
Scannell L, Gifford R (2010) Defining place attachment: a tripartite organizing framework. J Environ Psychol 30:1–10
Scherr S, Shames S, Friedman R (2012) From climate-smart agriculture to climate-smart landscapes. Agric Food Secur 1(12)
Sherren K, Fischer J, Fazey I (2012) Managing the grazing landscape: Insights for agricultural adaptation from a mid-drought photo-elicitation study in the Australian sheep-wheat belt. Agric Syst 106:72e83
Shrivastava P, Smith MS, O’Brien K, Zsolnai L (2020) Transforming sustainability science to generate positive social and environmental change globally. One Earth 2(4):329–340
Singh N (2015) Payments for ecosystem services and the gift paradigm: Sharing the burden and joy of environmental care. Ecol Econ 117:53–61
Soloviev ER, Landua G (2016) Levels of regenerative agriculture. Terra Genesis International. http://www.terra-genesis.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/Levelsof-Regenerative-Agriculture-1.pdf
Stinner DH, Stinner BR, Martsolf E (1997) Biodiversity as an organizing principle in agroecosystem management: Case studies of holistic resource management practitioners in the USA. Agr Ecosyst Environ 62:199–213
Teague R, Barnes M (2017) Grazing management that regenerates ecosystem function and grazing land livelihoods. African Journal of Range & Forage Science 34(2):77–86. https://doi.org/10.2989/10220119.2017.1334706
Teague WR, Apfelbaum S, Lal R, Kreuter UP, Rowntree J, Davies CA (2016) The role of ruminants in reducing agriculture’s carbon footprint in North America. J Soil Water Conserv 71(2):156–164
Tissot B (2011) Integral marine ecology: community-based fishery management in Hawaii. In: Esbjorn-Hargens S, Zimmerman M (eds) Integral ecology: uniting multiple perspectives on the natural world. Integral Books, Boston
Toensmeier E (2016) The Carbon Farming Solution: A Global Toolkit of Perennial Crops and Regenerative Agriculture Practices for Climate Change Mitigation and Food Security. Chelsea Green Publishing, White River Junction, VT
Tourangeau W, Sherren K (2020) Leverage points for sustainable wool production in the Falkland Islands. J Rural Stud 74:22–33
Volcovici V (2019) In rare bipartisan bill, U.S. senators tackle climate change via agriculture. Reuters, June 4, 2020. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-climatechange-agriculture/in-rare-bipartisan-bill-u-s-senators-tackle-climate-change-via-agriculture-idUSKBN23B23J
Westley FR, Tjornbo O, Schultz L, Olsson P, Folke C, Crona B, Bodin Ö (2013) A theory of transformative agency in linked social-ecological systems. Ecol Soc 18(3)
Wilber K (1996) A Brief History of Everything, 2nd edn. Shambhala, Boston, MA
Yeomans PA (1954) The keyline plan. P.A. Yeomans, Sydney. https://soilandhealth.org/book/the-keyline-plan/
Acknowledgements
This research was made possible by a grant from the USDA Pacific Northwest Research Station and the generosity of colleagues at the University of Wollongong, especially Dr. Nicholas Gill. I am indebted to the many sheep and beef farmers, consultants, and educators who took the time to share their knowledge with me, and to the reviewers whose suggestions greatly improved this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Handled by Karen O'Brien, University of Oslo, Norway.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gosnell, H. Regenerating soil, regenerating soul: an integral approach to understanding agricultural transformation. Sustain Sci 17, 603–620 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-021-00993-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-021-00993-0