Skip to main content

Advertisement

Log in

Re-thinking oil: compensation for non-production in Yasuní National Park challenging sumak kawsay and degrowth

  • Original Article
  • Published:
Sustainability Science Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

The Yasuní-ITT Initiative was an innovative development proposal based on the non-production of oil in Yasuní National Park in Ecuador, in exchange for international compensation, eitherin the form of direct payment or payment for environmental services. My aim is to investigate how the different actors understand this compensation for non-production of oil in Ecuador, an oil dependent country. Using a chronological review of the Initiative and forty in-depth interviews with key players, I critically engage the ‘environmental narrative’ around the Initiative inspired by sumak kawsay -a philosophy of life based on non-mercantilist values, known as “well living” in English or “buen vivir” in Spanish- and degrowth. In this article I argue that understanding the Initiative as an environmental matter and not as a problem of oil rent dependency exemplifies the limits of sumak kawsay and degrowth as proposals for an alternative to development. Results from Yasuní show that the Initiative ended up reproducing the fictions of nature valuation instead of de-linking nature from the valuation process. By drawing on a critical political economic framework, this paper shows that categories such as “dependency” and “rent” are fundamental in understanding the challenges of moving away from extraction-based development in developing countries. In summary, failing to differentiate between payment for the non-production of oil and compensation from the environmental services, Yasuní was a ´lost ‘opportunity for a bottom-up debate on what to produce and what not.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Subscribe and save

Springer+ Basic
EUR 32.99 /Month
  • Get 10 units per month
  • Download Article/Chapter or Ebook
  • 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
  • Cancel anytime
Subscribe now

Buy Now

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Similar content being viewed by others

Notes

  1. Ishpingo-Tambococha-Tiputini are located in Yasuní National Park.

  2. The Tagaeri and Taromenane are two indigenous communities who live in voluntary and highly vulnerable isolation due to the expansion of the oil frontier and the illegal felling of trees, amongst other historical and cultural factors that influence patterns of violence.

  3. Workshops of the Degrowth Conference held in Barcelona in 2010, Istanbul 2011 and Lille 2013.

  4. Workshop of the 9th International Conference of European Society for Ecological Economies 2011.

  5. Meeting with President Rafael Correa, María Isabel Salvador -Minister of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in December 2007.

  6. “Emphasizes that various approaches, including opportunities for using markets, to enhance the cost-effectiveness of, and to promote, mitigation actions, bearing in mind different circumstances of developed and developing countries, must meet standards that deliver real, permanent, additional and verified mitigation outcomes, avoid double counting of effort, and achieve a net decrease and/or avoidance of GHG emissions”.

  7. At least three different schools of thought are influencing the development of the sumak kawsay concept in the political sphere. It is therefore difficult to conclude which of them best represents collective aspirations. However, the National Development Plan for Good Living 2009–2013 is ambiguous in itself. While nature is recognized as a subject of rights, public policy is driving the energy and the production transition with more extractivism and not without it. This strategy of development erodes the possibility of implementing sumak kawsay as a transformative concept that confronts capitalist organization.

References

  • Acosta A (2007) Agenda Energética 2007–2011. Hacia un sistema energético sustentable, Ministerio de Energía y Minas

  • Acosta A (2008) El buen vivir, una oportunidad por construir (Tema Central)

  • Acosta A (2009) La maldición de la abundancia. Comité Ecuménico de Proyectos

  • Acosta A (2013) Extractivism and neoextractivism: two sides of the same curse. In: Beyond Development, pp 62–86

  • AGENCIA AFP (2010) Ecuador anuncia gestión ante Alemania para conseguir apoyo al ITT (Ecuador announces negotiations with Germany for support for ITT), Monday 20th September, 2010. Diario El Universo

  • AGENCIA AFP (2013) Alemania formalizó aporte de 34,5 millones de euros para el Yasuní (Germany formalized contribution of 34.5 million euros for Yasuní) Monday 21th February, 2013. Diario El Universo

  • Albó X (2008) To live well = to coexist well. CIPCA Notas 217

  • Amin S (1997) Los desafíos de la mundialización. Siglo XXI

  • Amin S (1998) El capitalismo en la era de la globalización

  • Amin S (2011) La ley del valor mundializado. El Viejo Topo

  • Anguelovski I (2014) Environmental justice. In: Degrowth: a vocabulary for a new era, pp 33–36

  • Annual Report (2011) Report of the Ecuador Yasuní ITT Trust Fund. Period 1 January–31 December 2011, 31 May 2012

  • Annual Report (2012) Report of the Ecuador Yasuní ITT Trust Fund, 31 May 2013

  • Arsel M (2012) Between ‘Marx and markets’? The state, the ‘left turn’and nature in Ecuador. Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie 103(2): 150–163

  • Castre N (2005) The epistemology of particulars: human geography, case studies and ‘context’. Geoforum 36(5):541–544

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Chancosa B (2010) Sumak Kawsay desde la visión de la mujer. En Hidalgo Capitán AL, Arias A, Ávila J, Tibán L, Tutillo S, Pacari N (2014) Antología del pensamiento indigenista ecuatoriano sobre Sumak Kawsay. Sumak Kawsay Yuyay, pp 221–228

  • Cholango H (2010) Sumak Kawsay y mundo indígena. En Hidalgo Capitán AL, Arias A, Ávila J, Tibán L, Tutillo S, Pacari N (2014) Antología del pensamiento indigenista ecuatoriano sobre Sumak Kawsay. Sumak Kawsay Yuyay, pp 237–244

  • Christian M, Finer M, Ross C (2008) Last chance to save one of world’s most species—rich regions. Nature 455(7215):861

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  • Chuji M (2009) Sumak Kawsay vs Desarrollo. En Hidalgo Capitán AL, Arias A, Ávila J, Tibán L, Tutillo S, Pacari N (2014) Antología del pensamiento indigenista ecuatoriano sobre Sumak Kawsay. Sumak Kawsay Yuyay, pp 229–236

  • Correa R (2007a) Speech of President Rafael Correa, ‘United Nations high level dialogue about climate change’, New York, September 24

  • Correa R (2007b) Speech of President Rafael Correa, ‘III OPEP Summit’, Riad del Novembre 18

  • Correa R (2007c) Speech of President Rafael Correa, Official Presentation of the Yasuni-ITT Initiative, June 5

  • Correa R (2012a) Speech of President Rafael Correa, ‘III ASPA Summit’, October 2

  • Correa R (2012b) Speech of President Rafael Correa, ‘Rio +20 Summit’, México

  • Correa R (2013) Press conference ‘The announcement of the cancelation of the Yasuní-ITT Initiative’ given by President Correa on the 14th August 2013

  • Correa R (2014a) Lecture given by President Correa in Yale, New Haven, April 10

  • Correa R (2014b) Lecture given by President Correa “Development as Political Process: the Ecuadorian Dream” on the Institute of Politics on Harvard University, United States, April

  • Correa R (2014c) Speech of President Correa, Universidad de Barcelona on April 23

  • D’Alisa G, Demaria F, Kallis G (2014) Degrowth: a vocabulary for a new era. Routledge, London

    Google Scholar 

  • Dávalos P (2008) El ‘Sumak Kawsay’(‘Buen vivir’) y las cesuras del desarrollo. Revista América Latina en Movimiento

  • Demaria F, Schneider F, Sekulova F, Martinez-Alier J (2013) What is degrowth? From an activist slogan to a social movement. Environ Values 22(2):191–215

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Deutscher Bundestag Declaration (2008) Drucksache 16/9758 16. Wahlperide, 25 Jun 2008

  • Dussel E (1985) La producción teórica de Marx. Siglo Veintiuno editores, 2da edición

  • Echeverría B (1994) Circulación capitalista y reproducción de la riqueza social. Apunte crítico sobre los esque

  • Echeverría B (1998) Valor de uso y utopía. Siglo XXI

  • Echeverría B (2010) Modernidad y blanquitud. Ediciones Era

  • Echeverría B (2012) Interview of Bolívar Echeverría by Fernando Rojas. (Videoteca Contracorriente del ICAIC), 28 Dec 2012. Publicado en: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lTnGZSz5Qrs

  • Ecuadorian Government (2007) Leaving Ecuador’s oil in the ground: avoiding carbon emissions and saving the Yasuní rainforest (Yasuní-ITT proposal), September

  • ECUADORINMEDIATO (2011) Germany will not finance the Yasuní plan because it feels it would be considered to be a “precedent”. Thursday 9th June 2011

  • Escobar A (1996) Construction nature: elements for a post-structuralist political ecology. Futures 28(4):325–343

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Escobar A (1998) Whose knowledge, whose nature? Biodiversity, conservation, and the political ecology of social movements. J Political Ecol 5(1):53–82

    Google Scholar 

  • Escobar A (2011) Encountering development: The making and unmaking of the Third World. Princeton University Press

  • Escobar A (2012) Post-extractivismo y pluriverso. América Latina en Movimiento, 473.Fatheuer: Buen Vivir a brief introduction to Latin America’s new concepts for the good life and the rights of nature. Heinrich Böll Foundation, Berlin

  • Farley J (2014) Steady-state economics. Degrowth: a vocabulary for a New Era. 49

  • Frank AG (1978) Dependent accumulation and underdevelopment. Macmillan, Londres

    Book  Google Scholar 

  • Frank AG (1981) Crisis in the third world. Holmes & Meier, Nueva York

    Google Scholar 

  • García-Linera Á (2007) Indianismo and Marxism: the mismatch of two revolutionary rationales, International Journal of Socialist Review, Translated and introduced by Richard Fidler, La Paz 2005 & Mexico

  • García-Linera Á (2010) El socialismo comunitario. Revista de Análisis 3(5)

  • García-Linera Á (2011) Las tensiones creativas de la revolución: La quinta fase del proceso de cambio. Vicepresidencia del Estado Plurinacional, Presidencia de la Asamblea Legislativa Plurinacional

  • Gudynas E (2011a) Alcances y contenidos de las transiciones al post-extractivismo. Ecuador Debate 82(4):60–79

    Google Scholar 

  • Gudynas E (2011b) Buen Vivir: today’s tomorrow. Development 54(4):441–447

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Gudynas E, Acosta A (2011) El Buen Vivir más allá del desarrollo. Revista Qué Hacer 181:70–81

    Google Scholar 

  • Henrichmann J (2013) Protección del Parque Nacional Yasuní: ¿bendición o maldición? (Protection of Yasuni National Park: blessing or curse?), 22 Jan 2013. Publicado en: http://www.dw.de/protección-del-parque-nacional-yasun%C3%AD-bendición-o-maldición/a-16541216

  • Hidalgo Capitán AL, Arias A, Ávila J, Tibán L, Tutillo S, Pacari N (2014) Antología del pensamiento indigenista ecuatoriano sobre Sumak Kawsay. Sumak Kawsay Yuyay, pp 159–168

  • Hornborg A (1998) Towards an ecological theory of unequal exchange: articulating world system theory and ecological economics. Ecol Econ 25(1):127–136

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Kallis G (2011) In defence of degrowth. Ecol Econom 70(5):873–880

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Kowii A (2009) El Sumak Kawsay. En Hidalgo Capitán AL, Arias A, Ávila J, Tibán L, Tutillo S, Pacari N (eds)(2014). Antología del pensamiento indigenista ecuatoriano sobre Sumak Kawsay. Sumak Kawsay Yuyay pp 159–168

  • Lander E (2010) Estamos viviendo una profunda crisis civilizatoria. AMERICA LATINA en movimiento 452:1–3

  • Lander E (2011) The discourse of civil society and current decolonisation struggles in South America. In: Heine J, Thakur RC (eds) The dark side of globalization. United Nations University Press, New York

    Google Scholar 

  • Larrea C (2010) Yasuní-ITT: Una Iniciativa para cambiar la historia. ISO 690. http://www.campusvirtual.uasb.edu.ec/uisa/images/yasuni/documentos/2011%20itt%20folleto%20esp.pdf. Accessed 08 Feb 2016

  • Larrea C, Greene N, Rival L, Sevilla E, Warnars L (2009) Yasuni–ITT Initiative: a big idea from a small country. Quito, Ecuador: Ministerio del Ambiente de Ecuador, UNDP Ecuador, MdGs

  • Latouche S (2012) La sociedad de la abundancia frugal. Barcelona, Icaria

  • Le Quang M (2013) La iniciativa Yasuní-ITT en los debates europeos. Letras Verdes. Revista Latinoamericana de Estudios Socioambientales (9):89–96

  • Le Quang M, Vercoutère T (2013) Ecosocialismo y buen vivir. Diálogo entre dos alternativas al capitalismo. pp 28–30

  • Leff E (2014) Ecología y capital: racionalidad ambiental, democracia participativa y desarrollo sustentable. Siglo XXI

  • Luxemburgo A (1968) The Accumulation of Capital, Nueva York y Londres

  • Macas L (2010) El Sumak Kawsay/Buen Vivir/Vivir Bien. En Hidalgo Capitán AL, Arias A, Ávila J, Tibán L, Tutillo S, Pacari N (eds) (2014). Antología del pensamiento indigenista ecuatoriano sobre Sumak Kawsay. Sumak Kawsay Yuyay, pp 177–192

  • Martin PL (2011a) Global governance from the Amazon: leaving oil underground in Yasuní National Park Ecuador. Glob Environ Politics 11(4):22–42

  • Martin PL (2011b) Oil in the ground: the politics of paying to preserve the Amazon. Rowman & Littlefield, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • Martínez E (2009) Yasuní El tortuoso camino de Kioto a Quito. Ediciones Abya-Yala

  • Martínez E, Acosta A (2010) (copiladores) ITT-Yasuní Entre el petróleo y la vida. Ediciones Abya-Yala

  • Martínez-Alier J (2011) Hacia una Economía Sostenible: Dilemas del ecologismo actual. Revista de Economía Crítica 11:186–204

    Google Scholar 

  • Martínez-Alier J (2012) Environmental justice and economic degrowth: an alliance between two movements. Capital Nat Soc 23(1):2012

    Google Scholar 

  • Martínez-Alier J, Pascual U, Vivien FD, Zaccai E (2010) Sustainable de-growth: mapping the context, criticisms and future prospects of an emergent paradigm. Ecol Econ 69(9):1741–1747

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Marx K (1975) El capital. Crítica de la economía política. Libro primero. El proceso de producción del capital (vols. 1–3). (P. Scaron, Trad.) Siglo XXI, Mexico

  • McAfee K (1999) Selling nature to save it? Biodiversity and green developmentalism. Environ Plan D Soc Space 17(2):133–154

  • McAfee K (2012) Nature in the Market-World: Ecosystem services and inequality. Development 55(1):25–33

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Migñolo W (2010) The communal and the decolonial. Rethink Intellect Latin Am, 245–261

  • Migñolo W (2014) Las ciencias sociales en América Latina: un análisis desde el enfoque de. Sociológica 29(81):283–292

    Google Scholar 

  • Ministry of External Affairs (2007) Change of model for climate change. Conceptual document. Written by Lucía Gallardo

  • Ministry of External Affairs (2008) Daly Correa Tax. Written by Lucía Gallardo, Kevin Koenig, Max Christian, Joan Martínez Alier

  • Niebel (2010) The pronuncement of Niebel (The pronuncement of Niebel), Publicado en: http://www.direktzu.de/niebel/messages/oekoprojekt-im-yasuni-nationalpark-in-ecuador-27663. Accessed 08 Feb 2016

  • Pellegrini L, Arsel M, Falconí F, Muradian R (2014) The demise of a new conservation and development policy. Exploring the tensions of the Yasuní ITT initiative. Extr Ind Soc 1(2):284–291

    Google Scholar 

  • Plan de Gobierno de Alianza País (2007–2011). Propuesta en construcción colectiva 12/05/2006. Publicado en: http://www.latinreporters.com/equateurRafaelCorreaPlandeGobiernoAlianzaPAIS.pdf. Accessed 10 Aug 2016

  • Polanyi k (2007) La Gran Transformación: los orígenes políticos y económicos de nuestro tiempo. con prólogo de Joseph E. Stiglitz. Ed. 1ª ed. Buenos Aires, Fondo de Cultura Económica. Traducido por Eduardo Suárez. Páginas 118–127

  • Quijano A (2011) Bien Vivir: entre el desarrollo y la des/colonialidad del poder. Ecuad Debate. 84

  • Ramírez R (2010) Socialismo del sumak kawsay o biosocialismo republicano. SENPLADES

  • Ramírez R (2012) La vida (buena) como riqueza de los pueblos. Hacia una socioecología política del tiempo, Línea de investigación en Economía y Sociedad, No.1 Quito

  • Ramírez R (2014) Restablecer el sentido de lo público en la Educación Superior. Entrevista a René Ramírez, en Contretemps, 08 de Enero de 2014

  • Ranger TO, Hobsbawm EJ (eds) (1983) The invention of tradition. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, p 211

  • Recasens Andreu Viola (2014) Discursos “pachamamistas” versus políticas desarrollistas: el debate sobre el sumak kawsay en los Andes. Íconos-Revista de Ciencias Sociales 48:55–72

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Rival L (2011) Anthropological encounters with economic development and biodiversity conservation (No. qehwps186). Queen Elizabeth House, University of Oxford

  • Sánchez-Parga J (2012) Discursos retrovolucionarios: Sumak Kausay, derechos de la naturaleza y otros pachamamismos (Tema Central)

  • Schneider F, Kallis G, Martínez-Alier J (2010) Crisis u oportunidad? El decrecimiento económico para la equidad social y la sostenibilidad ecológica. Introducción a esta edición especial. Diario de Producción más Limpia 18(6):511–518

  • SENPLADES S (2009) Plan Nacional para el Buen Vivir 2009–2013

  • SENPLADES S (2013) Plan Nacional de Desarrollo/Plan Nacional para el Buen Vivir 2013–2017

  • Sevilla R (2010) en ITT-Yasuní Entre el petróleo y la vida. Editorial Abya-Yala, Martínez E, Acosta A (compiladores)

  • Silvestrum (2009) Análisis de la Iniciativa ITT–Yasuní frente a los Mercados de Carbono. Cliente: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ), Con aportes de Profafor SA, Ecuador; y Climate Focus, Países Bajos, junio

  • Temper L, Fonseca S, Coelho R (2012) A new EJOLT report: towards a post-oil civilization. Yasunization and other initiatives to leave fossil fuels in the ground. With comments by Susana Fonseca and Ricardo Coelho. e-cadernos ces (17)

  • Thomson B (2011) Pachakuti: indigenous perspectives, buen vivir, sumaq kawsay and degrowth. Development 54(4):448–454

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Toledo V (2008) Metabolismos rurales: hacia una teoría económico-ecológica de la apropiación de la naturaleza. Revista Iberoamericana de Economía Ecológica 7:1–26

    Google Scholar 

  • Vallejo MC, Larrea C, Burbano R, Falconí F (2011) Análisis de la Iniciativa multicriterio Yasuní- ITT. De Consultoría, Informe Final, diciembre 2011, ISBN: 978-9978-9939-9-6

  • Vogel JH (2010) The economics of the Yasuní Initiative: climate change as if thermodynamics mattered. Anthem Press, UK

    Google Scholar 

  • Warnars L (2010) The Yasuni-ITT initiative: a new model to implement human rights and biological diversity conventions and frameworks? Policy Matters 17:2010

    Google Scholar 

  • Yin (2003) Case study, research design and methods, 3rd edn. Applied social research methods series, 5

Download references

Acknowledgments

I want to mention deep thanks to Louis Lemkow for his supervision and constructive comments. I wish to acknowledge Giorgos Kallis, Bob Thompson, Diego Andrucci, Fikret Adaman, Melissa García Lamarca, Panagiota Kotsila, Beatriz Rodríguez-Labajos, Dídac Jordà Capdevila. My gratitude to David Chávez for his theoretical support in spite of his doubts about sumak kawsay and degrowth as emancipatory narratives. I appreciate the time and the ideas of people who were interviewed. Research for this paper was supported by the Secretaría de Educación Superior, Ciencia, Tecnología e Innovación (SENECYT).

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Lucía Gallardo Fierro.

Additional information

Handled by Viviana Asara, Institut de Ciència i Tecnologia Ambientals, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain and Research & Degrowth, Spain.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Fierro, L.G. Re-thinking oil: compensation for non-production in Yasuní National Park challenging sumak kawsay and degrowth. Sustain Sci 12, 263–274 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-016-0389-x

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-016-0389-x

Keywords

Navigation