Nutcracker Syndrome and Sickle Cell Trait: A Perfect Storm for Hematuria
- 243 Downloads
We describe the case of a 27-year-old woman with a history of sickle cell trait (SCT) who presented with several months of hematuria and was found to have nutcracker syndrome (NCS). While SCT is a common cause of hematuria resulting from renal papillary necrosis, our patient had concomitant abdominal pain and anemia, prompting further evaluation and the subsequent diagnosis of NCS. Interestingly, the anoxia in the left renal vein from NCS predisposes patients with SCT to sickling. Our case highlights key clinical features of both NCS and SCT and the relationship between the two disease processes.
KEY WORDSnutcracker syndrome sickle cell trait hematuria
Nutcracker syndrome (NCS) is characterized by complex and nonspecific symptoms secondary to the impingement of the left renal vein (LRV) against the aorta by the superior mesenteric artery (SMA). There is a paucity of data regarding the syndrome, and currently no validated diagnostic or therapeutic guidelines exist to identify the syndrome, resulting in an unknown prevalence and incidence.1 However, a higher rate of symptomatic NCS has been proposed in patients with sickle cell trait (SCT).2 , 3 Hematuria is a common complaint in patients with SCT, and many times does not result in further investigation; however, hematuria is often the only presenting sign of NCS and is thought to be more significant in patients with SCT secondary to increased sickling from venous compression.1 , 2 Here, we present a case of a young woman with SCT who presented with symptomatic anemia and hematuria and was subsequently diagnosed with NCS.
A previously healthy 27-year-old African-American woman with SCT presented to the emergency department with a 6-month history of persistent, grossly bloody urine, diffuse abdominal pain following urination which worsened with movement, fatigue, and dyspnea on exertion. She noted a dark urine stream at the initiation of urination, which did not clear. She had also developed shortness of breath with daily activities. She had been seen multiple times at urgent care clinics and repeatedly diagnosed and empirically treated for urinary tract infections without improvement. She denied any cough, chest pain, fever, joint pains, changes in weight, swelling, recent illnesses, or history of easy bleeding/bruising.
Her family history was significant only for sickle cell disease in her father. She denied taking any prescribed or over-the-counter medications. On physical examination, her pulse was 115 beats/min with a blood pressure of 97/50 mmHg and body mass index of 18.8 kg/m2. She had conjunctival pallor but no abdominal or flank tenderness.
She was referred to a vascular surgeon, who performed a left venogram which revealed left renal vein compression, further supporting the diagnosis of NCS. The patient initially declined any surgical intervention; however, after her abdominal pain persisted and she required further blood transfusions for symptomatic anemia, she elected to have a left renal vein bypass to decompress her renal vein. Following the procedure, her hematuria and abdominal pain resolved.
Outpatient follow-up at 1 and 2 years showed sustained resolution of hematuria and anemia. She reported no further episodes of abdominal pain.
Hematuria may be either grossly visible (macroscopic) or seen only with examination of the urine (microscopic). Microscopic hematuria is defined as three or more red blood cells per high-power field, although there is no acceptable lower limit where significant disease is excluded.4 Microscopic and gross hematuria not explained by an obvious cause occurs in up to 40% of young adults and is typically transient without any long-term significance.5 , 6 However, when hematuria is persistent, further evaluation is warranted. A more detailed history focusing on the temporal description of hematuria may aid in the localization of the lesion. Initial hematuria, with bleeding at the onset of urination, suggests a lesion in the urethra or prostate. Terminal hematuria, with bleeding at the end of urination, is typically due to a lesion in the bladder or prostate. Total hematuria, with bleeding throughout urination, is concerning for a lesion in the bladder, ureter, or kidneys.7 While the etiology of hematuria is not identified in many cases; the most common causes of hematuria are urinary tract infection, benign prostatic hyperplasia, and urinary calculi.8 Less frequently, the cause is urologic malignancy or renal disease.
SCT is a carrier state of sickle cell disease, as patients have one normal beta globulin gene and one sickle variant gene, producing hemoglobin AS. The prevalence in the United States is 8–10% in the African-American population.9 Microscopic and macroscopic hematuria is the most frequent complication associated with SCT, with half of these cases thought to be due to renal papillary necrosis resulting from micro-infarctions in the renal medulla. SCT renal papillary necrosis produces a painless hematuria which is not associated with anemia.10 Despite its prevalence, clinicians should not assume that hematuria in a SCT patient is due to renal papillary necrosis. Clinicians should perform an appropriate evaluation for the cause of the hematuria, especially if signs and symptoms of alternate etiologies are present. In our patient (who had abdominal pain and anemia in addition to the hematuria), further investigation revealed clinically significant NCS, which was surgically corrected.
Nutcracker phenomenon was first described in 1937 as an anatomical variation seen in cadavers, at which time the compression of the LRV against the aorta by the SMA was likened to a nut within the jaws of a nutcracker.11 This type of anatomical variation resulting in compression has been seen in other clinical entities, including May–Thurner syndrome (compression of the left common iliac vein between the right common iliac artery and underlying vertebral body), SMA syndrome (compression of the third portion of the duodenum between the SMA and aorta), and median arcuate ligament syndrome (compression of the celiac artery by the median arcuate ligament). The first documented case of clinically significant NCS was described in 1950.12 The prevalence of the condition remains unknown. Most cases are seen in patients in their second and third decade of life, and a second peak in occurrence is seen in the sixth decade of life in women.13 Women, especially those with low body mass index in which there is little retroperitoneal adipose tissue causing reduction of the mesoaortic angle, are at increased risk of NCS.14
The clinical features of NCS are variable, ranging from asymptomatic hematuria to severe pelvic congestion with significant pain. Hematuria, the most common presenting symptom in NCS, results from rupturing of thin-walled peri- and pararenal varicosities and collaterals that form from increased pressure in the LRV.14 The hematuria can be macroscopic or microscopic depending on the severity of the renal venous hypertension.1 Abdominal pain in NCS can be caused by left ureteral colic from blood clots passing down the left ureter, while mesoaortic compression of the LRV results in left gonadal vein obstruction and reflux resulting in symptoms of pelvic congestion (pelvic pain, dyspareunia, dysuria, and dysmenorrhea in women and varicocele in men).1 , 15 Both hematuria and abdominal pain can be aggravated by physical activity.1 Orthostatic proteinuria is also commonly seen and is thought to be secondary to elevated levels of norepinephrine and angiotensin II.16
No validated diagnostic criteria exist to diagnose NCS. CT scans are able to determine the LRV diameter, collaterals, and mesoaortic angle, but cannot measure velocity changes. Venography is often considered the “gold standard” for diagnosis, as it measures the reno-caval pressure gradient; however, Doppler ultrasound can measure the LRV/inferior vena cava gradient and is often preferred due to its non-invasive nature.1 , 17
Conservative treatment is recommended for mild hematuria, especially in patients younger than 18 years of age, where 75% have complete resolution without specific interventions, while surgical decompression of the LRV is reserved for patients with refractory symptoms.1 , 14 Angiotensin inhibitors have been shown to decrease the proteinuria in patients with NCS.18 Overall, most surgical interventions attempt to reduce LRV hypertension, with poorer outcomes associated with patients who had lower pressure gradients preoperatively.19
In our case, the diagnosis of NCS was further supported by a concurrent diagnosis of SCT, as each clinical entity likely exacerbated the other. Patients with SCT are four times as likely to have left kidney renal medulla involvement resulting in hematuria. This occurs since the longer left renal vein is normally slightly compressed between the aorta and superior mesenteric artery, causing increased blood pressure in the vein, increasing relative anoxia in the renal medulla, and promoting sickling.2 This phenomenon is worsened and perpetuated by clinically significant NCS.
• Transient hematuria is often benign in young patients, but persistent hematuria deserves an evaluation for underlying pathology. The most common causes of hematuria are urinary tract infection, benign prostatic hyperplasia, and urinary calculi.
• Hematuria is a common complication of sickle cell trait (SCT), with half the cases due to renal papillary necrosis. Patients with SCT who develop hematuria should be evaluated for less common etiologies, such as nutcracker syndrome (NCS), based on their presentation and physical exam.
• NCS is a cause of hematuria secondary to the impingement of the left renal vein against the aorta by the superior mesenteric artery. In SCT patients, NCS can lead to anemia from red blood cell sickling due to anoxia from the compressed left renal vein
• No validated diagnostic criteria exist to diagnose NCS, although venography is often considered the “gold standard” for diagnosis. Conservative treatment is recommended for mild hematuria, while surgical decompression of the left renal vein is reserved for patients with refractory symptoms.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
To the best of our knowledge, no conflict of interest, financial or other, exists.
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors alone and do not reflect the views of the Department of Veterans Affairs.
- 2.Van Eps LS, de Jong PE. Diseases of the kidney and urinary tract. 2nd ed. Boston, Ma: Little, Brown & Co.; 1997:220.Google Scholar
- 7.Collier VU. Chapter 41. Hematuria. In: Henderson MC, Tierney Jr LM, Smetana GW, eds. The patient history: an evidence-based approach to differential diagnosis. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill; 2012.Google Scholar
- 11.Grant JC. Method of anatomy. 1st ed. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins; 1937:158.Google Scholar