Abstract
The mysteries of sunspot penumbrae have been under an intense scrutiny for the past 10 years. During this time, some models have been proposed and refuted, while the surviving ones had to be modified, adapted and evolved to explain the ever-increasing array of observational constraints. In this contribution I will review two of the present models, emphasizing their contributions to this field, but also pinpointing some of their inadequacies to explain a number of recent observations at very high spatial resolution (0.32″). To help explaining these new observations I propose some modifications to each of those models. These modifications bring those two seemingly opposite models closer together into a general picture that agrees well with recent 3D magneto-hydrodynamic simulations.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Lites B W, Elmore D F, Seagraves P, et al. Stokes profile analysis and vector magnetic fields. VI. Fine scale structure of a sunspot. Astrophys J, 1993, 418: 928–942
Danielson R E. The structure of sunspot penumbras. Astron J, 1960, 65: 343–343
Solanki S K, Montavon C A P. Uncombed fields as the source of the broad-band circular polarization of sunspots. Astron Astrophys, 1993, 275: 283
Choudhuri A R. The dynamics of magnetically trapped fluids. I — Implications for umbral dots and penumbral grains. Astrophys J, 1986, 302: 809–825
Spruit H C, Scharmer G B. Fine structure, magnetic field and heating of sunspot penumbrae. Astron Astrophys, 2006, 447: 343–354
Meyer F, Schmidt H U. Magnetisch ausgerichtete Strmungen zwischen Sonnenflecken. Z Angew Math Mech, 1968, 48: 218–221
Montesinos B, Thomas J H. The Evershed effect in sunspots as a siphon flow along a magnetic flux tube. Nature, 1997, 390: 485–487
Schlichenmaier R, Jahn K, Schmidt H U. Magnetic flux tubes evolving in sunspots. A model for the penumbral fine structure and the Evershed flow. Astron Astrophys, 1998, 337: 897–910
Schlichenmaier R. Penumbral fine structure: Theoretical understanding. Astron Nachr, 2002, 323: 303–308
del Toro Iniesta J C, Bellot Rubio L R, Collados M. Cold, supersonic Evershed downflows in a sunspot. Astrophys J, 2001, 549: L139–L142
Borrero J M, Lagg A, Solanki S K, et al. On the fine structure of sunspot penumbrae. II. The nature of the Evershed flow. Astron Astrophys, 2005, 436: 333–345
Sobotka M, Brandt P N, Simon G W. Fine structure in sunspots. III. Penumbral grains. Astron Astrophys, 1999, 348: 621–626
Sobotka M, Stterlin P. Fine structure in sunspots. IV. Penumbral grains in speckle reconstructed images. Astron Astrophys, 2001, 380: 714–718
Kubo M, Shimizu T, Tsuneta S. Vector magnetic fields of moving magnetic features and flux removal from a sunspot. Astrophys J, 2007, 659: 812–828
Zhang J, Solanki S K, Wang J. On the nature of moving magnetic feature pairs around sunspots. Astron Astrophys, 2003, 399: 755–761
Zhang J, Solanki S K, Woch J, et al. The velocity structure of moving magnetic feature pairs around sunspots: Support for the U-loop model. Astron Astrophys, 2007, 471: 1035–1041
Ryutova M, Hagenaar H. Magnetic solitons: Unified mechanism for moving magnetic features. Sol Phys, 2007, 246: 281–294
Sainz Dalda A, Martnez Pillet V. Moving magnetic features as prolongation of penumbral filaments. Astrophys J, 2005, 632: 1176–1183
Cabrera Solana D, Bellot Rubio L R, Beck C, et al. Temporal evolution of the Evershed flow in sunspots. I. Observational characterization of Evershed clouds. Astron Astrophys, 2007, 475: 1067–1079
Scharmer G B, Spruit H C. Magnetostatic penumbra models with field-free gaps. Astron Astrophys, 2006, 460: 605–615
Borrero J M, Solanki S K, Lagg A, et al. On the fine structure of sunspot penumbrae. III. The vertical extension of penumbral filaments. Astron Astrophys, 2006, 450: 383–393
Bellot Rubio L R, Collados M, Ruiz Cobo, et al. Photospheric structure of an extended penumbra. Il Nuovo Cimento C, 2002, 25: 543–549
Bellot Rubio L R, Balthasar H, Collados M. Two magnetic components in sunspot penumbrae. Astron Astrophys, 2004, 427: 319–334
Borrero J M, Solanki S K, Bellot Rubio L R, et al. On the fine structure of sunspot penumbrae. I. A quantitative comparison of two semiempirical models with implications for the Evershed effect. Astron Astrophys, 2004, 422: 1093–1104
Schlichenmaier R, Collados M. Spectropolarimetry in a sunspot penumbra. Spatial dependence of Stokes asymmetries in Fe I 1564.8 nm. Astron Astrophys, 2002, 381: 668–682
Rüedi I, Solanki S K, Keller C U, et al. Infrared lines as probes of solar magnetic features. XIV. TI i and the cool components of sunspots. Astron Astrophys, 1998, 338: 1089–1101
Cabrera Solana D, Bellot Rubio L R, Borrero J M, et al. Temporal evolution of the Evershed flow in sunspots. II. Physical properties and nature of Evershed clouds. Astron Astrophys, 2008, 477: 273–283
Beck C. A 3D sunspot model derived from an inversion of spectropolarimetric observations and its implications for the penumbral heating. Astron Astrophys, 2008, 480: 825–838
Cabrera Solana D, Bellot Rubio L R, Beck C, et al. Evershed clouds as precursors of moving magnetic features around sunspots. Astrophys J, 2006, 649: L41–L44
Schlichenmaier R, Müller D A N, Steiner O, et al. Net circular polarization of sunspot penumbrae. Symmetry breaking through anomalous dispersion. Astron Astrophys, 2002, 381: L77–L80
Müller D A N, Schlichenmaier R, Steiner O, et al. Spectral signature of magnetic flux tubes in sunspot penumbrae. Astron Astrophys, 2002, 393: 305–319
Borrero J M, Bellot Rubio L R, Mller D A N. Flux tubes as the origin of net circular polarization in sunspot penumbrae. Astrophys J, 2007, 666: L133–L136
Tritschler A, Müller D A N, Schlichenmaier R, et al. Fine structure of the net circular polarization in a sunspot fenumbra. Astron Astrophys, 2007, 671: L85–L88
Martínez Pillet V. Spectral signature of uncombed penumbral magnetic fields. Astron Astrophys, 2000, 361: 734–742
Martínez Pillet V, Lites B W, Skumanich A. Active region magnetic fields. I. Plage fields. Astrophys J, 1997, 474: 810–842
Solanki S K. Sunspots: An overview. Astron Astrophys Rev, 2003, 11: 153–286
Schlichenmaier R, Bruls J H M J, Schüssler M. Radiative cooling of a hot flux tube in the solar photosphere. Astron Astrophys, 1999, 349: 961–973
Schlichenmaier R, Solanki S K. On the heat transport in a sunspot penumbra. Astron Astrophys, 2003, 411: 257–262
Langhans K, Scharmer G B, Kiselman D, et al. Inclination of magnetic fields and flows in sunspot penumbrae. Astron Astrophys, 2005, 436: 1087–1101
Langhans K, Scharmer G B, Kiselman D, et al. Observations of dark-cored filaments in sunspot penumbrae. Astron Astrophys, 2007, 464: 763–774
Ruiz Cobo B, Bellot Rubio L R. Heat transfer in sunspot penumbrae. Origin of dark-cored penumbral filaments. Astron Astrophys, 2008, 488: 749–756
Scharmer G B, Gudiksen, B V, Kiselman D, et al. Dark cores in sunspot penumbral filaments. Nature, 2002, 420: 151–154
Borrero J M, Rempel M, Solanki S K. The uncombed penumbra. Astron Soc Pac Conf, 2006, 358: 19–24
Borrero J M. The structure of sunspot penumbrae. IV. MHS equilibrium for penumbral flux tubes and the origin of dark core penumbral filaments and penumbral grains. Astron Astrophys, 2007, 471: 967–975
Bellot Rubio L R, Tsuneta S, Ichimoto K, et al. Vector spectropolarimetry of dark-cored penumbral filaments with hinode. Astrophys J, 2007, 668: L91–L94
Schlichenmaier R, Schmidt W. Flow geometry in a sunspot penumbra. Astron Astrophys, 2000, 358: 1122–1132
Heinemann T, Nordlund Å, Scharmer G B, et al. MHD simulations of penumbra fine structure. Astrophys J, 2007, 669: 1390–1394
Rempel M, Schuessler M, Knoelker M. Radiative MHD simulation of sunspot structure. Astrophys J, 2009, 691: 640–649
Borrero J M, Solanki S K. Are there field-free gaps near τ = 1 in sunspot penumbrae? Astrophys J, 2008, 687: 668–677
Scharmer G B, Nordlund Å, Heinemann T. Convection and the origin of evershed flows in sunspot penumbrae. Astrophys J, 2008, 677: L149–L152
Zakharov V, Hirzberger J, Riethmüller T L, et al. Evidence of convective rolls in a sunspot penumbra. Astron Astrophys, 2008, 488: L17–L20
Ichimoto K, Suematsu Y, Tsuneta S, et al. Twisting motions of sunspot penumbral filaments. Science, 2007, 318: 1597–1599
Rimmele T. On the relation between umbral dots, dark-cored filaments, and Light Bridges. Astrophys J, 2008, 672: 684–695
Bellot Rubio L R, Langhans K, Schlichenmaier R. Multi-line spectroscopy of dark-cored penumbral filaments. Astron Astrophys, 2005, 443: L7–L10
Schüssler M, Vögler A. Magnetoconvection in a sunspot umbra. Astrophys J, 2006, 641: L73–L76
Barthi L, Jain R, Jaaffrey S N A. Evidence for magnetoconvection in sunspot umbral dots. Astrophys J, 2007, 665: L79–L82
Riethmller T L, Solanki S K, Lagg A. Stratification of sunspot umbral dots from inversion of Stokes profiles recorded by Hinode. Astrophys J, 2008, 678: L157–L160
Bellot Rubio L R, Schlichenmaier R, Tritschler A. Twodimensional spectroscopy of a sunspot. III. Thermal and kinematic structure of the penumbra at 0.5 arcsec resolution. Astron Astrophys, 2006, 453: 1117–1127
Borrero J M, Lites B W, Solanki S K. Evidence of magnetic field wrapping around penumbral filaments. Astron Astrophys, 2008, 481: L13–L16
Thomas John H, Weiss Nigel O, Tobias Steven M, et al. Downward pumping of magnetic flux as the cause of filamentary structures in sunspot penumbrae. Nature, 2002, 420: 390–393
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0 ), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Borrero, J.M. Models and observations of sunspot penumbrae. Sci. China Ser. G-Phys. Mech. Astron. 52, 1670–1677 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11433-009-0247-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11433-009-0247-2