Abstract
In this paper, form vulnerability theory was applied to the analysis of the failure mechanisms of single-layer latticed spherical shells subjected to seismic excitations. Three 1/10 scale testing models were designed with characteristics as follows: Model 1 possesses overall uniform stiffness and is expected to collapse in the strength failure mode as some members become plastic; Model 2 possesses six man-made weak parts located on six radial main rib zones and is expected to collapse in the dynamic instability mode with all members still in the elastic stage; Model 3 strengthens the six weak zones of Model 2, and therefore, its stiffness is uniform. Model 3 is proposed to collapse in the strength failure mode when the members are still in the elastic stage. By increasing the peak ground accelerations of seismic waves gradually, the shaking table tests were carried out until all three models collapsed (or locally collapsed). On the basis of form vulnerability theory, topological hierarchy models of the test models were established through a clustering process, and various failure scenarios, including overall collapse scenarios and partial collapse scenarios, were identified by unzipping corresponding hierarchical models. By comparison of the failure scenarios based on theoretical analysis and experiments, it was found that vulnerability theory could effectively reflect the weakness zones in topological relations of the structures from the perspective of internal causes. The internal mechanisms of the distinct failure characteristics of reticulated shells subjected to seismic excitations were also revealed in this process. The well-formedness of structural clusters, Q, is closely related to the collapse modes, i.e., uniform changes of Q indicate a uniform distribution of overall structural stiffness, which indicates that strength failure is likely to happen; conversely, non-uniform changes of Q indicate that weak zones exist in the structure, and dynamic instability is likely to occur.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ye J H. Dynamic stability analysis of single layer reticulated shell structures. Dissertation of Doctoral Degree. Shanghai: Tongji University, 1995
Ishikawa K, Kato S. Elastic-plastic dynamic buckling analysis of reticular domes subjected to earthquake motion. Int J Space Struct, 1997, (3&4): 205–215
Fan F, Shen S Z. Study on the dynamic strength failure of reticulated domes under severe earthquakes. In: Proc IASS Int Symp. Montpellier, France: International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures, 2004. 140–141
Guo H S, Shen S Z. Analysis method of dynamic stability of single-layer reticulated domes (in Chinese). J Building Struct, 2003, 24: 1–9
Shen S Z, Zhi X D. Failure mechanism of reticular shells subjected to dynamic actions (in Chinese). China Civil Eng J, 2005, 38: 11–20
Yuan H Y, Ye J H, Shen S Z, et al. Failure mechanism analysis of single-layer spherical shells subjected to simple dynamic loads (in Chinese). Earthquake Resistant Eng Retrofitting, 2006, 28: 10–17
Zhi X D, Fan F, Shen S Z. Seismic failure of single-layer reticulated domes (in Chinese). Eng Mech, 2008, 25: 7–11
Du W F, Gao B Q, Dong S L. Double-control criterion of dynamical strength failure for single layer latticed shells (in Chinese). J Zhejiang Univ (Eng Sci), 2007, 41: 1916–1920
Wei Z, Ye J H, Shen S Z. Failure type prediction of single-layer spherical shells under earthquake based on maximum entropy (in Chinese). J Vib Shock, 2008, 27: 64–69
Wu X, Blockley D I, Woodman N J. Vulnerability of structural systems part1: rings and clusters. Civ Eng Environ Syst, 1993, 10: 301–317
Wu X, Blockley D I, Woodman N J. Vulnerability of structural systems part 2: Rings and clusters. Civ Eng Environ Syst, 1993, 10: 319–333
Lu Z, Yu Y, Woodman N J, et al. A theory of structural vulnerability. Structl Eng, 1999, 77: 17–24
Agarwal J, Blockley D I, Woodman N J. Vulnerability of 3-dimensional trusses. Struct Saf, 2001, 23: 203–220
Agarwal J, Blockley D I, Woodman N J. Vulnerability of structural systems. Struct Saf, 2003, 25: 263–286
Wang X C. Finite Element Method (in Chinese). Beijing: Tsinghai University Press, 2003
Yuan Z F, Song S D. Multivariate Statistical Analysis (in Chinese). Beijing: Science Press, 2009
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ye, J., Liu, W. & Pan, R. Research on failure scenarios of domes based on form vulnerability. Sci. China Technol. Sci. 54, 2834–2853 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11431-011-4590-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11431-011-4590-y