Abstract
Whether bacterial drug-resistance is drug-induced or results from rapid propagation of random spontaneous mutations in the flora prior to exposure, remains a long-term key issue concerned and debated in both genetics and medicinal fields. In a pioneering study, Luria and Delbrück exposed E. coli to T1 phage, to investigate whether the number of resistant colonies followed the Poisson distribution. They deduced that the development of resistant colonies is independent of phage presence. Similar results have since been obtained on solid medium containing antibacterial agents. Luria and Delbrück’s conclusions were long considered a gold standard for analyzing drug resistance mutations. More recently, the concept of adaptive mutation has triggered controversy over this approach. Microbiological observation shows that, following exposure to drugs of various concentrations, drug-resistant cells emerge and multiply depending on the time course, and show a process function, inconsistent with the definition of Poisson distribution (which assumes not only that resistance is independent of drug quantity but follows no specific time course). At the same time, since cells tend to aggregate after division rather than separating, colonies growing on drug plates arise from the multiplication of resistant bacteria cells of various initial population sizes. Thus, statistical analysis based on equivalence of initial populations will yield erroneous results. In this paper, 310 data from the Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiment were reanalyzed from this perspective. In most cases, a high-end abnormal value, resulting from the non-synchronous variation of the two above-mentioned time variables, was observed. Therefore, the mean value cannot be regarded as an unbiased expectation estimate. The ratio between mean value and variance was similarly incomparable, because two different sampling methods were used. In fact, the Luria-Delbrück data appear to follow an aggregated, rather than Poisson distribution. In summary, the statistical analysis of Luria and Delbrück is insufficient to describe rules of resistant mutant development and multiplication. Correction of this historical misunderstanding will enable new insight into bacterial resistance mechanisms.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Xue J L. Epigenetics. Shanghai: Shanghai Science and Technology Press, 2006
Luria S E, Delbrück M. Mutations of bacteria from virus sensitivity to virus resistance. Genetics, 1943, 28: 91–511
Newcombe H B. Origin of bacterial variants. Nature, 1949, 164: 150–151
Lederberg J, Lenderberg E M. Replica plating and indirect selection of bacteria mutants. J Bacteriol, 1952, 63: 399–405
Demerce M. Origin of bacterial resistance to antibiotics. J Bacteriology, 1948, 56: 63–74
Cairns J, Overbaugh J, Miller S. The origin of mutants. Nature, 1988, 335: 142–145
Foster P L. Are adaptive mutations due to a decline in mismatch repair? The evidence is lacking. Mutat Res, 1999, 436: 179–184
Crump K S, Hoel D G. Mathematical models for estimating mutation rates in cell populations. Biometrika, 1974, 61: 237–237
Liu C Y. Estimates of microbial mutation rate (in Chinese). Sci China Ser B-Chem Sci, 1983, 7: 625–633
Tlsty T D, Margolin B H, Lum K. Differences in the rates of gene amplification in nontumorigenic and tumorigenic cell lines as measured by Luria-Delbrück fluctuation analysis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 1989, 86: 9441–9445
Sahotra S. Haldane’s solution of the Luria-Delbriick distribution. Genetics, 1991, 1217: 257–261
Jones M E, Thomas S M, and Rogers A. Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiments: design and analysis. Genetics, 1994, 136: 1209–1216
Stewart F M. Fluctuation tests: how reliable are the estimates of mutation rates? Genetics, 1994, 137: 1139–1146
Rosche W A, Foster P L. Determining mutation rates in bacterial population. Methods, 2000, 20: 4–17
Kepler T B. Improved inference of mutation rates: I. An integral representation for the Luria-Delbrück distribution. Theor Popul Biol, 2001, 59: 41–48
Angerer W P. An explicit representation of the Luria-Delbrück distribution. Math Biol, 2001, 42: 145–174
Zheng Q. Statistical and algorithmic methods for fluctuation analysis with SALVADOR as an implementation. Math Biol, 2002, 176: 237-
Zheng Q. New algorithms for Luria-Delbrück fluctuation analysis. Math Biol, 2005, 196: 198–214
Zheng Q. On Haldane’s formulation of Luria and Delbrück’s mutational model. Math Biosci, 2007, 209: 237–252
Dewanji A, Luebeck E G, Moolgavkar S H. A generalized Luria-Delbrück model. Math Biosci, 2005, 197: 140–152
Zheng Q. On Haldane’s formulation of Luria and Delbrück’s mutation model. Math Biosci, 2007, 209: 500–513
Hall B M, Ma C X, Liang P, et al. Fluctuation analysis calculator: a web tool for the determination of mutation rate using Luria-Delbrück fluctuation analysis. Bioinformatics, 2009, 25: 1564–1565
Wax R G, Lewis K, Salyers A A, et al. Bacterial Resistance to Antimicrobials. 2nd ed. New York: CRC Press, 2007
Mortelmans K, Zeiger E. The Ames Salmonella/microsome mutagenicity assay. Mutat Res, 2000, 455: 29–60
Liu S. Tracking bacterial growth in liquid media and a new bacterial life model (in Chinese). Sci China Ser C-Life Sci, 1999, 29: 571–579
Ferenci T. Growth of bacterial cultures’ 50 years on: towards an uncertainty principle instead of constants in bacterial growth kinetics. Res Microbiol, 1999, 150: 431–443
Thattai M, Oudenaarden A. Stochastic gene expression in fluctuation experiments. Genetics, 2004, 167: 523–530
Waldor M K, Friedman D L, Adhya S L. Phages: their role in bacterial phathogenesis and biotechnology. Washington: ASM press, 2005
Mantzaris N V. Stochastic and deterministic simulations of heterogeneous cell population dynamics. J Theor Biol, 2006, 241: 690–706
Wax R G, Levis K, Salyers A A, et al. Bacterial resistance to antibiotics. 2nd ed. New York: CRC Press, 2008
Kohanski M A, Owyer D J, Hayeto B, et al. A common mechanism of cellular death induced by bactericidal antibiotics. Cell, 2007, 130: 797–810
Trindade S, Perfiito L, Gordo I. Rate and effects of spontaneous mutations that affect fitness in mutator E. coli. Phil Trans R Soc B, 2010, 305: 1177–1186
Chen L L, Peng Z G, Zhang W L, et al. The significance of mutations in genomic evolution (in Chinese). Hereditas, 2006, 28: 631–638
Liu Y Q, Zhang Y Z, Sun C Y, et al. A novel approach to estimate in vitro antibacterial potency of Chinese medicine using a concentration-killing curve method. Am J Chin Med, 2005, 33: 671–682
Zhang H Q, Liu Y Q, Liu B, et al. A novel approach for estimating growth phases and parameters of bacterial population in batch culture (in Chinese). Sci China Ser C-Life Sci, 2005, 35: 1–11
Liu Y Q, Zhang H Q, Shen J Z, et al. Effect of the physiological heterogeneity of E. coli populations on susceptibility test (in Chinese). Sci China Ser C-Life Sci, 2007, 37: 524–529
Zhang H Q, Lu L L, Yan X L, et al. Effect of the population heterogeneity on growth behavior and its estimation (in Chinese). Sci China Ser C-Life Sci, 2007, 37: 246–256
Liu B, Jin J L, Zhang H, et al. Uncertainty of Ames test (in Chinese). Chin J Appl Environ Biol, 2007, 13: 726–730
Jin J L, Yang W Q, Zhang H, et al. Modification the synchrony coefficient for mutation rate calculating in bacterial population (in Chinese). Microbiology, 2009, 36: 446–452
Zhang H Q, Zhao Y, He X L, et al. A novel approach for assessing the susceptibility of Escherichia coli to antibiotics. Sci China Ser C-Life Sci, 2010, 40: 75–85
Liu Y Q, Zhang H Q, Hu M, et al. Methodological limitation of antimicrobial susceptibility tests and its improvement (in Chinese). J Shandong Univ (Health Sci), 2011, 49: 124–132
Jin J L, Zhang W C, Li Y, et al. Bactericidal effect of soybean peroxidase-hydrogen peroxide-potassium iodide system (in Chinese). Acta Microbiol Sin, 2011, 51: 393–401
Zhang Z, Huang J, Wang Z F, et al. Impact of indels on the flanking regions in structural domains. Mol Biol Evol, 2011, 28: 291–301
Yang J K, Qiao X L, Chen L. Biological Mathematical Probability. Beijing: Science Press, 1982. 392-
Ma Y H. Experimental Statistics. Beijing: Agriculture Press, 1982. 446
Li T B. The Mathematical Processing of the Experiments. Beijing: Science Press, 1983
Fang K T, Xu J L. Statistical Distribution. Beijing: Science Press, 1987. 289
Tang Q Y, Wang L, Hu G Y. Misuse regression model analysis, chi-square test (χ2) (in Chinese). Entomology, 1997, 34: 353–354
Gerry P Q, Keough M J. Biological experimental design and data analysis. Beijing: Higher Education Press, 2003
Lei M. Application of the linear correlation analysis of normality test in the medical statistics (in Chinese). J Beihua Univ (Nat Sci), 2001, 11: 61–62
Grubbs F E. Sample criteria for testing out typing observations. Ann Math Stat, 1950, 21: 27–58
Dixon W J. Analysis of extreme values. Ann Math Stat, 1950, 21: 488–506
Liu Y L, Ding D M. Judgment of several discrete distributions (in Chinese). Chin J Health Stat, 1989, 6: 14–17
Bliss C I, Fisher R A. Fitting the negative distribution to biological data. Biometrics, 1953, 9: 176–200
Fan J C, Mei C L. Data Analysis. Beijing: Sciences Press, 2002. 12–17
Lv Z, Wang A Q. A new experimental system for study the adaptive mutation (in Chinese). Sci China Ser C-Life Sci, 2000, 30: 547–553
Miller J H. Spontaneous mutation in bacteria: insights into pathways and repair. Annu Rev Microbiol, 1996, 50: 625–643
Lewis R W, Taber A S. Bacterial resistance to antimicrobials. 2nd ed. New York: CRC Press, 2008
Jin J L, Gao P J. Bacterial mutation under selective condition (in Chinese). Nat Mag, 2002, 27: 320–323
Gregory J M, Reuben S H, Petter L L, et al. The SOS response regulates adaptive mutation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2000, 97: 6646–6651
Chiang C L, Poisson process. In: Robert E. An Introduction to Stochastic Processes and Their Applications. 1st ed. Krieger Publishing Co., 1980. 184–186
Chen X R. Mathematics of Probability. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press, 2000
Jin J L, Gao P J, Mao Y M. Occurrence of leu+ revertants under starvation cultures in Escherichia coli is growth-dependent. BMC Genetics, 2002, 3: 6
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This article is published with open access at Springerlink.com
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Jin, J., Wei, G., Yang, W. et al. Discussion on research methods of bacterial resistant mutation mechanisms under selective culture—uncertainty analysis of data from the Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiment. Sci. China Life Sci. 55, 1007–1021 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11427-012-4395-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11427-012-4395-7