Abstract
Following the age of directing group, anchoring catalysis starts coming to the center of the stage. Different from the directing-group strategy that needs a preinstalled directing group in substrates, anchoring catalysis relies on a reversible interaction between a substrate and a catalyst, which then directs metal to activate inert chemical bonds. Such reversible directing effect not only generates good site- and stereo-selectivity as traditional directing groups do but also eliminates the requirement of stoichiometric amounts of directing groups. Among variously reported anchoring catalysis, coordinative bimetallic anchoring catalysis in general displays superior reactivity than others because coordinative bonding not only affords strong interaction of catalysts with substrates but also displays good compatibility with substrates and reaction conditions. In recent years, big progress has been achieved for coordinative bimetallic anchoring catalysis. This review gave a detailed summary of this field, including catalyst development, catalyst types, reaction types and reaction mechanisms.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Kakiuchi F, Chatani N. Adv Synthesis Catal, 2003, 345: 1077–1101
Godula K, Sames D. Science, 2006, 312: 67–72
Yamaguchi J, Yamaguchi AD, Itami K. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2012, 51: 8960–9009
For selected reviews on C-H activation: Dyker G. Angew Chem Int Ed, 1999, 38: 1698–1712
Ritleng V, Sirlin C, Pfeffer M. Chem Rev, 2002, 102: 1731–1770
Kakiuchi F, Murai S. Acc Chem Res, 2002, 35: 826–834
Seregin IV, Gevorgyan V. Chem Soc Rev, 2007, 36: 1173–1193
Lewis JC, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. Acc Chem Res, 2008, 41: 1013–1025
Giri R, Shi BF, Engle KM, Maugel N, Yu JQ. Chem Soc Rev, 2009, 38: 3242–3272
Colby DA, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. Chem Rev, 2010, 110: 624–655
Wencel-Delord J, Dröge T, Liu F, Glorius F. Chem Soc Rev, 2011, 40: 4740–4761
Yang L, Huang H. Chem Rev, 2015, 115: 3468–3517
Tao P, Jia Y. Sci China Chem, 2016, 59: 1109–1125
Newton CG, Wang SG, Oliveira CC, Cramer N. Chem Rev, 2017, 117: 8908–8976
Diesel J, Cramer N. ACS Catal, 2019, 9: 9164–9177
For selected reviews on C-C activation: Jun CH. Chem Soc Rev, 2004, 33: 610–618
Murakami M, Matsuda T. Chem Commun, 2011, 47: 1100–1105
Chen F, Wang T, Jiao N. Chem Rev, 2014, 114: 8613–8661
Dermenci A, Coe JW, Dong G. Org Chem Front, 2014, 1: 567–581
Marek I, Masarwa A, Delaye PO, Leibeling M. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2015, 54: 414–429
Souillart L, Cramer N. Chem Rev, 2015, 115: 9410–9464
Chen PH, Billett BA, Tsukamoto T, Dong G. ACS Catal, 2017, 7: 1340–1360
Murakami M, Ishida N. Chem Rev, 2021, 121: 264–299
For selected examples on intramolecular C-H activation, see: Ames DE, Opalko A. Tetrahedron, 1984, 40: 1919–1925
For selected examples on intramolecular C-H activation, see: Echavarren AM. J Am Chem Soc. 2006, 128: 1066–1067
For selected examples on intramolecular C-H activation, see: Basolo L, Beccalli EM, Borsini E, Broggini G. Tetrahedron, 2009, 65: 3486–3491
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Jun CH, Moon CW, Lee DY. Chem EurJ, 2002, 8: 2422–2428
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Wang J, Chen W, Zuo S, Liu L, Zhang X, Wang J. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2012, 51: 12334–12338
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Corbet M, De Campo F. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2013, 52: 9896–9898
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Rouquet G, Chatani N. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2013, 52: 11726–11743
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Zhang M, Zhang Y, Jie X, Zhao H, Li G, Su W. Org Chem Front, 2014, 1: 843–895
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Chen Z, Wang B, Zhang J, Yu W, Liu Z, Zhang Y. Org Chem Front, 2015, 2: 1107–1295
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Castro LCM, Chatani N. Chem Lett, 2015, 44: 410–421
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Wang K, Hu F, Zhang Y, Wang J. Sci China Chem, 2015, 58: 1252–1265
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Zhu RY, Farmer ME, Chen YQ, Yu JQ. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2016, 55: 10578–10599
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Zhang L, Fang DC. Org Chem Front, 2017, 4: 1250–1260
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Rej S, Ano Y, Chatani N. Chem Rev, 2020, 120: 1788–1887
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Ali W, Prakash G, Maiti D. Chem Sci, 2021, 12: 2735–2759
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Dutta U, Maiti S, Bhattacharya T, Maiti D. Science, 2021, 372: eabd5992
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Suseelan AS, Dutta A, Lahiri GK, Maiti D. Trends Chem, 2021, 3: 188–203
For selected reviews on directing group, see: Dey A, Sinha SK, Achar TK, Maiti D. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2019, 58: 10820–10843
For selected reviews see: Wu Y, Shi B. Chin J Org Chem, 2020, 40: 3517–3535
For selected reviews see: Liao G, Zhang T, Lin ZK, Shi BF. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2020, 59: 19773–19786
For selected reviews see: Becica J, Dobereiner GE. Org Biomol Chem, 2019, 17: 2055–2069
For selected reviews see: Omann L, Königs CDF, Klare HFT, Oestreich M. Acc Chem Res, 2017, 50: 1258–1269
For selected reviews see: Davis HJ, Phipps RJ. Chem Sci, 2017, 8: 864–877
For selected reviews see: Chen DF, Han ZY, Zhou XL, Gong LZ. Acc Chem Res, 2014, 47: 2365–2377
For selected reviews see: Dong XQ, Zhao Q, Li P, Chen C, Zhang X. Org Chem Front, 2015, 2: 1425–1431
For selected reviews see: Dydio P, Reek JNH. Chem Sci, 2014, 5: 2135–2145
For selected reviews see: Raynal M, Ballester P, Vidal-Ferran A, van Leeuwen PWNM. Chem Soc Rev, 2014, 43: 1660–1733
For selected reviews see: Tan KL. ACS Catal, 2011, 1: 877–886
For selected reviews see: Rousseau G, Breit B. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2011, 50: 2450–2494
For selected reviews see: Sawamura M, Ito Y. Chem Rev, 1992, 92: 857–871
For selected reviews on non-covalent interaction, see: Haldar C, Hoque M E, Bisht R, Chattopadhyay B. Tetrahedron Lett, 2018, 59: 1269–1277
For selected reviews on non-covalent interaction, see: Rasheed OK, Sun B. ChemistrySelect, 2018, 3: 5689–5708
For selected reviews on non-covalent interaction, see: Mahmudov KT, Gurbanov AV, Guseinov FI, Guedes da Silva MFC. Coord Chem Rev, 2019, 387: 32–46
For selected reviews on non-covalent interaction, see: Kuninobu Y, Torigoe T. Org Biomol Chem, 2020, 18: 4126–4134
Pandit S, Maiti S, Maiti D. Org Chem Front, 2021, https://doi.org/10.1039/d1qo00452b
For selected reviews on non-covalent interaction, see: Trouvé J, Gramage-Doria R. Chem Soc Rev, 2021, 50: 3565–3584
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Sun H, Guimond N, Huang Y. Org Biomol Chem, 2016, 14: 8389–8397
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Afewerki S, Córdova A. Chem Rev, 2016, 116: 13512–13570
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Zhao Q, Poisson T, Pannecoucke X, Besset T. Synthesis, 2017, 49: 4808–4826
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Kim DS, Park WJ, Jun CH. Chem Rev, 2017, 117: 8977–9015
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Gandeepan P, Ackermann L. Chem, 2018, 4: 199–222
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Bhattacharya T, Pimparkar S, Maiti D. RSC Adv, 2018, 8: 19456–19464
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: St John-Campbell S, Bull JA. Org Biomol Chem, 2018, 16: 4582–4595
For selected reviews on reversible covalent bonding, see: Niu B, Yang K, Lawrence B, Ge H. ChemSusChem, 2019, 12: 2955–2969
For selected examples on H-bonding, see: Kuninobu Y, Ida H, Nishi M, Kanai M. Nat Chem, 2015, 7: 712–717
For selected examples on H-bonding, see: Lu X, Yoshigoe Y, Ida H, Nishi M, Kanai M, Kuninobu Y. ACS Catal, 2019, 9: 1705–1709
For selected examples on H-bonding, see: Bai ST, Bheeter CB, Reek JNH. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2019, 58: 13039–13043
For selected examples on H-bonding, see: Reyes RL, Sato M, Iwai T, Suzuki K, Maeda S, Sawamura M. Science, 2020, 369: 970–974
For selected examples on H-bonding, see: Genov GR, Douthwaite JL, Lahdenperä ASK, Gibson DC, Phipps RJ. Science, 2020, 367: 1246–1251
For selected examples on ion-pair bonding, see: Davis HJ, Mihai MT, Phipps RJ. J Am Chem Soc, 2016, 138: 12759–12762
For selected examples on ion-pair bonding, see: Davis HJ, Genov GR, Phipps RJ. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2017, 56: 13351–13355
For selected examples on ion-pair bonding, see: Mihai MT, Davis HJ, Genov GR, Phipps RJ. ACS Catal, 2018, 8: 3764–3769
For selected examples on ion-pair bonding, see: Lee B, Mihai MT, Stojalnikova V, Phipps RJ. J Org Chem, 2019, 84: 13124–13134
For selected examples on ion-pair bonding, see: Montero Bastidas JR, Oleskey TJ, Miller SL, Smith III MR, Maleczka Jr. RE. J Am Chem Soc, 2019, 141: 15483–15487
For selected examples on electrostatic interactions, see: Chattopadhyay B, Dannatt JE, Andujar-De Sanctis IL, Gore KA, Maleczka Jr. RE, Singleton DA, Smith III MR. J Am Chem Soc, 2017, 139: 7864–7871
For selected examples on electrostatic interactions, see: Chaturvedi J, Haldar C, Bisht R, Pandey G, Chattopadhyay B. J Am Chem Soc, 2021, 143: 7604–7611
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: van den Beuken EK, Feringa BL. Tetrahedron, 1998, 54: 12985–13011
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Rowlands GJ. Tetrahedron, 2001, 57: 1865–1882
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Matsunaga S, Shibasaki M. Bull Chem Soc Jpn, 2008, 81: 60–75
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Pérez-Temprano MH, Casares JA, Espinet P. Chem Eur J, 2012, 18: 1864–1884
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Park J, Hong S. Chem Soc Rev, 2012, 41: 6931–6943
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Hetterscheid DGH, Chikkali SH, de Bruin B, Reek JNH. ChemCatChem, 2013, 5: 2785–2793
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Mankad NP. Chem Eur J, 2016, 22: 5822–5829
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Fu J, Huo X, Li B, Zhang W. Org Biomol Chem, 2017, 15: 9747–9759
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis with both two metals as catalysts, see: Pye DR, Mankad NP. Chem Sci, 2017, 8: 1705–1718
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis without directing effect, see: Wang YX, Ye M. Sci China Chem, 2018, 61: 1004–1013
For selected reviews on bimetallic catalysis without directing effect, see: Hu Y, Wang C. Acta Physico-Chim Sin, 2019, 35: 913–922
Shapley JR, Samkoff DE, Bueno C, Churchill MR. Inorg Chem, 1982, 21: 634–639
Moore EJ, Pretzer WR, O’Connell TJ, Harris J, LaBounty L, Chou L, Grimmer SS. J Am Chem Soc, 1992, 114: 5888–5890
Chatani N, Fukuyama T, Kakiuchi F, Murai S. J Am Chem Soc, 1996, 118: 493–494
Fukuyama T, Chatani N, Tatsumi J, Kakiuchi F, Murai S. J Am Chem Soc, 1998, 120: 11522–11523
Kawashima T, Takao T, Suzuki H. J Am Chem Soc, 2007, 129: 11006–11007
Kwak J, Kim M, Chang S. J Am Chem Soc, 2011, 133: 3780–3783
Berman AM, Lewis JC, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. J Am Chem Soc, 2008, 130: 14926–14927
Berman AM, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. J Org Chem, 2010, 75: 7863–7868
Tamaki T, Ohashi M, Ogoshi S. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2011, 50: 12067–12070
Liu S, Sawicki J, Driver TG. Org Lett, 2012, 14: 3744–3747
Hoque ME, Bisht R, Haldar C, Chattopadhyay B. J Am Chem Soc, 2017, 139: 7745–7748
Bisht R, Hoque ME, Chattopadhyay B. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2018, 57: 15762–15766
Zhang Z, Tanaka K, Yu JQ. Nature, 2017, 543: 538–542
Ramakrishna K, Biswas JP, Jana S, Achar TK, Porey S, Maiti D. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2019, 58: 13808–13812
Achar TK, Ramakrishna K, Pal T, Porey S, Dolui P, Biswas JP, Maiti D. Chem Eur J, 2018, 24: 17906–17910
Achar TK, Biswas JP, Porey S, Pal T, Ramakrishna K, Maiti S, Maiti D. JOrg Chem, 2019, 84: 8315–8321
Shi H, Lu Y, Weng J, Bay KL, Chen X, Tanaka K, Verma P, Houk KN, Yu JQ. Nat Chem, 2020, 12: 399–404
Trouvé J, Zardi P, Al-Shehimy S, Roisnel T, Gramage-Doria R. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2021, 60: 18006–18013
Li HL, Kuninobu Y, Kanai M. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2017, 56: 1495–1499 2021, 11: 858–864
Hara N, Saito T, Semba K, Kuriakose N, Zheng H, Sakaki S, Nakao Y. J Am Chem Soc, 2018, 140: 7070–7073
Hara N, Uemura N, Nakao Y. Chem Commun, 2021, 57: 5957–5960
Yang L, Uemura N, Nakao Y. J Am Chem Soc, 2019, 141: 7972–7979
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Su B, Cao ZC, Shi ZJ. Acc Chem Res, 2015, 48: 886–896
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Zweig JE, Kim DE, Newhouse TR. Chem Rev, 2017, 117: 11680–11752
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Chen J, Guo J, Lu Z. Chin J Chem, 2018, 36: 1075–1109
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Obligacion JV, Chirik PJ. Nat Rev Chem, 2018, 2: 15–34
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Peng JB, Wu FP, Wu XF. Chem Rev, 2019, 119: 2090–2127
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Alig L, Fritz M, Schneider S. Chem Rev, 2019, 119: 2681–2751
For selected reviews on first-row transition metal-catalysis, see: Wang R, Luan Y, Ye M. Chin J Chem, 2019, 37: 720–743
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Khake SM, Chatani N. Chem, 2020, 6: 1056–1081
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Yamaguchi J, Muto K, Itami K. Top Curr Chem (Z), 2016, 374: 55
Cai XH, Xie B. ARKIVOC, 2015, 184–211
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Gandeepan P, Müller T, Zell D, Cera G, Warratz S, Ackermann L. Chem Rev, 2019, 119: 2192–2452
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Loup J, Dhawa U, Pesciaioli F, Wencel-Delord J, Ackermann L. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2019, 58: 12803–12818
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Wožniak Ł, Cramer N. Trends Chem, 2019, 1: 471–484
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Liu Y, Xia Y, Shi B. Chin J Chem, 2020, 38: 635–662
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Khake SM, Chatani N. Trends Chem, 2019, 1: 524–539
For recent reviews on 3d-metals catalyzed C-H functionalization, see: Chu JCK, Rovis T. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2018, 57: 62–101
Feng YN, Shi BF. Chin J Org Chem, 2021, https://doi.org/10.6023/cjoc202104004
Nakao Y, Idei H, Kanyiva KS, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2009, 131: 5070–5071
Miyazaki Y, Yamada Y, Nakao Y, Hiyama T. Chem Lett, 2012, 41: 298–300
Donets PA, Cramer N. J Am Chem Soc, 2013, 135: 11772–11775
Liu QS, Wang DY, Yang ZJ, Luan YX, Yang JF, Li JF, Pu YG, Ye M. J Am Chem Soc, 2017, 139: 18150–18153
Wang YX, Qi SL, Luan YX, Han XW, Wang S, Chen H, Ye M. J Am Chem Soc, 2018, 140: 5360–5364
Nakao Y, Morita E, Idei H, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2011, 133: 3264–3267
Wang YX, Zhang FP, Luan YX, Ye M. Org Lett, 2020, 22: 2230–2234
Chen H, Wang YX, Luan YX, Ye MC. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2020, 132: 9528–9532
Qi SL, Li Y, Li JF, Zhang T, Luan YX, Ye M. Org Lett, 2021, 23: 4034–4039
Gigant N, Chausset-Boissarie L, Gillaizeau I. Chem Eur J, 2014, 20: 7548–7564
Zhu T, Xie S, Rojsitthisak P, Wu J. Org Biomol Chem, 2020, 18: 1504–1521
Rakshit S, Patureau FW, Glorius F. JAm Chem Soc, 2010, 132: 9585–9587
Wang RH, Li JF, Li Y, Qi SL, Zhang T, Luan YX, Ye M. ACS Catal, 2021, 11: 858–864
For selected examples on C5-H functionalization via electrophilic activation pathway, see: Itahara T, Ouseto F. Synthesis, 1984, 1984: 488–489
For selected examples on C5-H functionalization via electrophilic activation pathway, see: Li Y, Xie F, Li X. J Org Chem, 2016, 81: 715–722
For selected examples on C5-H functionalization via electrophilic activation pathway, see: Maity S, Das D, Sarkar S, Samanta R. Org Lett, 2018, 20: 5167–5171
For selected examples on selective C6-H functionalization via oxidative addition pathway, see: Tamura R, Yamada Y, Nakao Y, Hiyama T. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2012, 51: 5679–5682
For selected examples on selective C6-H functionalization via oxidative addition pathway, see: Nakao Y, Idei H, Kanyiva KS, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2009, 131: 15996–15997
For selected examples on selective C6-H functionalization via oxidative addition pathway, see: Chen Y, Wang F, Jia A, Li X. Chem Sci, 2012, 3: 3231–3236
Yin G, Li Y, Wang RH, Li JF, Xu XT, Luan YX, Ye M. ACS Catal, 2021, 11: 4606–4612
Ye M, Gao GL, Yu JQ. J Am Chem Soc, 2011, 133: 6964–6967
Nakao Y, Kanyiva KS, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2008, 130: 2448–2449
For relevant examples, see: Tsai CC, Shih WC, Fang CH, Li CY, Ong TG, Yap GPA. J Am Chem Soc, 2010, 132: 11887–11889
For relevant examples, see: Nakao Y, Yamada Y, Kashihara N, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2010, 132: 13666–13668
For relevant examples, see: Lee WC, Chen CH, Liu CY, Yu MS, Lin YH, Ong TG. Chem Commun, 2015, 51: 17104–17107
Zhang T, Luan YX, Lam N, Li JF, Li Y, Ye MC, Yu JQ. https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv.13250420.vl
Nakao Y, Yada A, Ebata S, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2007, 129: 2428–2429
Nakao Y, Ebata S, Yada A, Hiyama T, Ikawa M, Ogoshi S. J Am Chem Soc, 2008, 130: 12874–12875
Hirata Y, Yukawa T, Kashihara N, Nakao Y, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2009, 131: 10964–10973
Yada A, Yukawa T, Nakao Y, Hiyama T. Chem Commun, 2009, 107: 3931–3933
Nakao Y, Yada A, Hiyama T. J Am Chem Soc, 2010, 132: 10024–10026
Yada A, Ebata S, Idei H, Zhang D, Nakao Y, Hiyama T. BCSJ, 2010, 83: 1170–1184
Yamada Y, Ebata S, Hiyama T, Nakao Y. Tetrahedron, 2015, 71: 4413–4417
Nakai K, Kurahashi T, Matsubara S. J Am Chem Soc, 2011, 133: 11066–11068
Nakai K, Kurahashi T, Matsubara S. Org Lett, 2013, 15: 856–859
Nakai K, Kurahashi T, Matsubara S. Tetrahedron, 2015, 71: 4512–4517
Yasui Y, Kamisaki H, Takemoto Y. Org Lett, 2008, 10: 3303–3306
Yasui Y, Kinugawa T, Takemoto Y. Chem Commun, 2009, 1: 4275–4277
Yasui Y, Kamisaki H, Ishida T, Takemoto Y. Tetrahedron, 2010, 66: 1980–1989
Frost GB, Serratore NA, Ogilvie JM, Douglas CJ. J Org Chem, 2017, 82: 3721–3726
Dreis AM, Otte SC, Eastwood MS, Alonzi ER, Brethorst JT, Douglas CJ. Eur J Org Chem, 2017, 2017(1): 45–48
Hsieh JC, Ebata S, Nakao Y, Hiyama T. Synlett, 2010, 1709
Watson MP, Jacobsen EN. J Am Chem Soc, 2008, 130: 12594–12595
Zhang T, Luan YX, Zheng SJ, Peng Q, Ye M. Angew Chem Int Ed, 2020, 59: 7439–7443
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (91856104, 21871145), the Tianjin Applied Basic Research Project and Cutting-Edge Technology Research Plan (19JCZDJC37900) and “Frontiers Science Center for New Organic Matter”, Nankai University (63181206).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Li, JF., Luan, YX. & Ye, M. Bimetallic anchoring catalysis for C-H and C-C activation. Sci. China Chem. 64, 1923–1937 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11426-021-1068-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11426-021-1068-2