Learning the physics of electricity: A qualitative analysis of collaborative processes involved in productive failure
Earlier quantitative studies in computer-supported collaborative learning identified ‘Productive Failure’ (Kapur, Cognition and Instruction 26(3):379–424, 2008) as a phenomenon in which students experiencing relative failures in their initial problem-solving efforts subsequently performed better than others who were in a condition not involving an initial failure. In this qualitative study, we examine the problem-solving dynamics of two dyads: a Productive Failure (PF) dyad who initially received a low-structured activity and a Non-Productive Failure (N-PF) dyad who initially received a high-structured activity. Both dyads then received an identical high-structured problem-solving activity. This process was repeated using multiple sets of problems, and this paper will discuss two sets. Interactions of the two dyads were logged. Data for this study included video conversations of the dyads, screen captures of their use of a computer model, and their submitted answers. Results indicated that initial struggle and failed attempts provided an opportunity to the PF dyad to expand their observation space and thus engage deeply with the computer model. Over-scripting proved to be detrimental in creation of a mutual meaning-making space for the N-PF dyad. This paper suggests that the relative success of the PF dyad might be viewed in terms of induction of reflective reasoning practices.
KeywordsCollaboration Electricity Physics education Problem solving Productive failure Scientific inquiry
- American Association for the Advancement of Science. (1993). Benchmarks for science literacy. NewYork: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Ashcoft, N. W., & Mermin, N. D. (1976). Solid state physics. Philadelphia: Saunders college.Google Scholar
- Bittinger, M. L., & Davic, E. (2001). Intermediate algebra: Concepts and applications (6th ed.). MA: Addison-Wesley.Google Scholar
- Chinn, C. A., & Brewer, W. F. (1993). The role of anomalous data in knowledge acquisition: A theoretical framework and implications for science instruction. Review of Educational Research, 63, 1–49.Google Scholar
- Denzin, N. K. (1978). The research act: A theoretical introduction to sociological methods. New York: McGraw Hill.Google Scholar
- Jacobson, M. J., Kim, B., Pathak, S. A., & Zhang, B. (2009). Learning the physics of electricity with agent-based models: Fail first and structure later? Paper presented at the 2009 Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Diego, CA.Google Scholar
- Kapur, M. (2010b). Productive failure in learning the concept of variance. In S. Ohlsson & R. Catrambone (Eds.), Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society (pp. 2727–2732). Austin, TX: Cognitive Science Society.Google Scholar
- Klahr, D. (2000). Exploring science: The cognition and development of discovery process. Cambridge: MIT.Google Scholar
- Pathak, S. A., Jacobson, M. J., Kim, B., Zhang, B. H., & Feng D. (2008). Learning the physics of electricity with agent based models: paradox of productive failure. In T.-W. Chan, G. Biswas, F.-C. Chen, S. Chen, C. Chou, M. Jacobson, Kinshuk, F. Klett, C.-K. Looi, T. Mitrovic, R. Mizoguchi, K. Nakabayashi, P. Reimann, D. Suthers, S. Yang & J.-C. Yang. International Conference on Computers in Education (pp. 221–228).Google Scholar
- Purcell, E. M. (1985). Electricity and magnetism. London: Mc-Grall Hill.Google Scholar
- Sengupta, P., & Wilensky, U. (2007a). NetLogo Ohm’s Law model. Evanston, IL: Center for Connected Learning and Computer-Based Modeling, Northwestern University. Retrieved October, 23, 2007 from http://ccl.northwestern.edu/netlogo/models/Ohm'sLaw.
- Sengupta, P., & Wilensky, U. (2007b). NetLogo Parallel Circuit model. Evanston, IL: Center for Connected Learning and Computer-Based Modeling, Northwestern University. Retrieved October, 23, 2007 from http://ccl.northwestern.edu/netlogo/models/ParallelCircuit.
- Sengupta, P., & Wilensky, U. (2007c). NetLogo Series Circuit model. Evanston, IL: Center for Connected Learning and Computer-Based Modeling, Northwestern University. Retrieved October, 23, 2007 from http://ccl.northwestern.edu/netlogo/models/SeriesCircuit.
- Sengupta, P., & Wilensky, U. (2007d). NetLogo Electrostatics model. Evanston, IL: Center for Connected Learning and Computer-Based Modeling, Northwestern University. Retrieved October, 23, 2007 from http://ccl.northwestern.edu/netlogo/models/Electrostatics.