Philosophia

, Volume 41, Issue 3, pp 589–602 | Cite as

Aquinas on Intellectual Cognition: The Case of Intelligible Species

Article

Abstract

The paper argues in favour of a direct realist reading of Aquinas’s theory of intelligible species, in opposition to the recent representationalist challenges. In order to secure the direct realist reading, the paper follows three steps: a short description of Aquinas’s process of cognition, a survey of the direct realist arguments and the analysis of the representationalist interpretation. The final step consists of investigating the representationalist reading as it is suggested by two scholars, Claude Panaccio in Aquinas on Intellectual Representation and Robert Pasnau in Theories of Cognition in the Latter Middle Ages. Thus, the paper can be construed as a reply to these two authors, due to the thorough attention paid to their argumentative trails. With regard to Panaccio’s reading the paper focuses on the identity between the intelligible species and the essence of the extra-mental object and argues that Panaccio understands identity in a very narrow sense. Concerning Pasnau’s line of reasoning the focus is on the primum cognitum status of the intelligible species, and the main argument is that intelligible species is understood by Aquinas as the quo and not the quod of cognition. As the paper shows, neither one, nor the other interpretation poses a threat to the direct realist reading of Aquinas’s intelligible species.

Keywords

Cognitive and causal role Direct realism Formal identity Intelligible species Primum cognitum Representationalism Thomas Aquinas 

References

  1. Aquinas, T. (1979). Compendium theologiae ad fratrem Reginaldum. In R. A. Verardo (Ed.), Opuscula theologica (Vol. 1). Torino: Marietti.Google Scholar
  2. Aquinas, T. (1929). In P. Mandonnet (Ed.), Scriptum super libros Sententiarum magistri Petri Lombardi episcopi Parisiensis. Paris: P. Lethielleux.Google Scholar
  3. Aquinas, T. (1952). In P. Caramello (Ed.), Summa theologiae. Torino: Marietti.Google Scholar
  4. Aquinas, T. (1961). In C. Pera (Ed.), Summa contra Gentiles. Torino: Marietti.Google Scholar
  5. Aquinas, T. (1965). In P. M. Pession (Ed.), Quaestiones disputatae de Potentia. Torino: Marietti.Google Scholar
  6. Aquinas, Th. (1970–1976). Quaestiones disputatae de Veritate, in Opera Omnia, ed. Dondaine, H. F. XXII. Roma & Paris: Commissio Leonina & Cerf.Google Scholar
  7. Aquinas, Th. (1996). Quaestiones quodlibetales, in Opera Omnia, ed. Gauthier, R. –A. XXV. Roma & Paris: Commisio Leonina & Les Éditions du Cerf.Google Scholar
  8. Aquinas, Th. (2000). Quaestio disputata De spiritualibus creaturis, in Opera Omnia, ed. Cos, J. XXIV-2. Roma & Paris: Commissio Leonina - Les Éditions du Cerf.Google Scholar
  9. Klima, G. (1996). “Nulla virtus cognoscitiva circa proprium obiectum decipitur”, Critical comments on Robert Pasnau, “The Identity of Knower and Known”, http://faculty.fordham.edu/klima/APA.htm. Accessed 19 July 2012.
  10. Panaccio, C. (2000). “Aquinas on Intellectual Representation”, in Cahiers d’epistémologie. Groupe de recherche en épistémologie comparée, no. 2002.Google Scholar
  11. Panaccio, C. (2010). Mental representation. In R. Pasnau & C. van Dyke (Eds.), The Cambridge History of Medieval Philosophy (Vol. 1). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Pasnau, R. (1997). Theories of Cognition in the Latter Middle Ages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  13. Perler, D. (2000). Essentialism and direct realism: some late medieval perspectives. Topoi, 19(2), 111–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Perler, D. (2002). Theorien der Intentionalität im Mittelalter. Frankfurt am Main: Vittorio Klosterman.Google Scholar
  15. Spruit, L. (1994). Species intelligibilis: From Perception to Knowledge (Vol. 1). Leiden: Brill.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.“Alexandru Dragomir” Institute for Philosophy, Romanian Society for PhenomenologyBucharestRomania

Personalised recommendations