Nutrition in the life cycle assessment of foods—function or impact?
- 84 Downloads
This work provides an unambiguous conceptual framework for inclusion of nutrition in Life Cycle Assessments (LCAs) of food that enables the distinction between two different roles of nutrition, namely serving as the basis of food comparisons via the functional unit and as an impact pathway that links food ingestion with human health effects.
We compare how nutritional aspects have been considered in the functional unit of published LCAs of food with the procedural requirements for ensuring comparability of the functional units. We consider the relevance of nutrient profiling models for assessing food- and diet-related health damages and benefits in the context of LCAs of food. We finally recommend a method that will enable a systematic, comparative, and holistic assessment of the marginal health effect of food products on human health.
Results and discussion
Satiety is proposed as a central attribute for comparisons of food products, while weighted measures of nutrient content are suggested to be largely misplaced as part of the functional unit. In contrast, nutritional measures have a large role to play in assessing the human health impacts of the marginal ingestion of specific food products. Such measures should enable a direct quantification of human health effect and benefits and should take advantage of robust epidemiological evidence.
Nutritional measures enter into both the functional unit in the form of satiety measures and into the calculation of impacts in the form of the marginal influence of the specific food item on the human health impact of the overall diet. To enhance the differentiation of health impacts at the level of individual food items, it is recommended to combine the nutrient balance indicator with the DALY Nutritional Index (DANI) in each specific dietary context.
KeywordsDietary risk Functional unit Health impact Life cycle assessment Nutritional quality Satiety
The authors would like to gratefully acknowledge Olivier Jollliet and Victor L Fulgoni III for providing access to data from the DALY Nutritional Index.
- Beales II JH, Pahl TB, Rozell L, Froeb L, Ippolito PM, Murphy DR, Zywicki T, Ohlhausen MK (2004) Comments of the Staff of the US Federal Trade Commission on Nutrient Content Claims General Principles; Health Claims, General Requirements and Other Specific Requirements for Individual Health Claims, Docket Nos. 1994P-0390 and 1995P-0241. https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/advocacy_documents/ftc-staff-comment-food-and-drug-administration-concerning-nutrient-claims/v040020.pdf [Accessed 2019-05-13]
- Bruun Werner L, Flysjö A, Tholstrup T (2014) Greenhouse gas emissions of realistic dietary choices in Denmark: the carbon footprint and nutritional value of dairy products. Food Nutr Res 58:1–16Google Scholar
- van Dooren C (2016) Proposing the nutrient density unit as the functional unit in LCAs of foods. International Conference on Life Cycle Assessment of Food, DublinGoogle Scholar
- Forouzanfar MH et al (2016) Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 79 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks, 1990–2015: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. Lancet 388:1659–1724CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hopkins M, Blundell J, Halford J, King N, Finlayson G (2016) The regulation of food intake in humans. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK278931/. Accessed 2018-02-27
- IES (2010) Specific guide for Life Cycle Inventory data sets. International Reference Life Cycle Data System (ILCD) Handbook. Institute for Environment and Sustainability (IES), Joint Research Centre of the European Commission. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. EUR 24709 ENGoogle Scholar
- Stylianou KS (2018) Nutritional and environmental impacts of foods on human health. Dissertations & Theses @ University of Michigan. https://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/handle/2027.42/147641. Accessed 2019-05-13
- Stylianou S, Fulgoni III VL, Jolliet O (2019) HENI: a health burden-based nutritional index for food items. (Submitted for publication)Google Scholar
- Weidema BP (2017) Short procedural guideline to identify the functional unit for a product environmental footprint and to delimit the scope of product categories. 2.-0 LCA consultants, report to the Nordic Council of Ministers. http://lca-net.com/p/2527 [Accessed 2018-02-27]