Abstract
Purpose
The effect of regional factors on life cycle assessment (LCA) of camelina seed production and camelina methyl ester production was assessed in this study. While general conclusions from LCA studies point to lower environmental impacts of biofuels, it has been shown in many studies that the environmental impacts are dependent on location, production practices, and even local weather variations.
Methods
A cradle-to-farm gate and well-to-pump approaches were used to conduct the LCA. To demonstrate the impact of agro-climatic and management factors (weather condition, soil characteristics, and management practices) on the overall emissions for four different regions including Corvallis, OR, Pendleton, OR, Pullman, WA, and Sheridan, WY, field emissions were simulated using the DeNitrification-DeComposition (DNDC) model. openLCA v.1.4.2 software was used to quantify the environmental impacts of camelina seed and camelina methyl ester production.
Results and discussion
The results showed that greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions during camelina production in different regions vary between 49.39 and 472.51 kg CO2-eq./ha due to differences in agro-climatic and weather variations. The GHG emissions for 1 kg of camelina produced in Corvallis, Pendleton, Pullman, and Sheridan were 0.76 ± 11, 0.55 ± 10, 0.47 ± 18, and 1.26 ± 6 % kg CO2-eq., respectively. The GHG emissions for 1000 MJ of camelina biodiesel using camelina produced in Corvallis, Pendleton, Pullman, and Sheridan were 53.60 ± 5, 48.87 ± 5, 44.33 ± 7, and 78.88 ± 4 % kg CO2-eq., respectively. Other impact categories such as acidification and ecotoxicity for 1000 MJ of camelina biodiesel varied across the regions by 43 and 103 %, respectively.
Conclusions
It can be concluded that process-based crop models such as DNDC in conjunction with Monte Carlo analysis are helpful tools to quantitatively estimate the influence of regional factors on field emissions which consequently can provide information about the expected variability in LCA results.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aalde H et al. (2006) IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories, vol 4: agriculture, forestry, and other land use, Chap. 2: generic methodologies applicable to multiple land-use. http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2006gl/pdf/4_Volume4/V4_02_Ch2_ Generic.pdf. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Bare JC (2002) Developing a consistent decision-making framework by using the US EPA’s TRACI. American Institute of Chemical Engineers Symposium. https://clu-in.org/conf/tio/lcia/AICHE2002paper.pdf. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Bessou C, Lehuger S, Gabrielle B, Mary B (2013) Using a crop model to account for the effects of local factors on the LCA of sugar beet ethanol in Picardy region, France. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18:24–36
Brandess A (2012) Modeling the profitability of Camelina sativa as a biofuel feedstock in Eastern Colorado. Master’s thesis in Agricultural and Resource Economics, Colorado State University, Fort Collins
Broch A, Hoekman SK, Unnasch S (2013) A review of variability in indirect land use change assessment and modeling in biofuel policy. Environ Sci Pol 29:147–157
Brown L, Syed B, Jarvis SC, Sneath RW, Phillips VR, Goulding KWT, Li C (2002) Development and application of a mechanistic model to estimate emission of nitrous oxide from UK agriculture. Atmos Environ 36:917–928
Butterbach-Bahl K, Baggs EM, Dannenmann M, Kiese R, Zechmeister-Boltenstern S (2013) Nitrous oxide emissions from soils: how well do we understand the processes and their controls? Philos Trans R Soc Lond Ser B Biol Sci 368:20130122
Chatskikh D, Olesen JE (2007) Soil tillage enhanced CO2 and N2O emissions from loamy sand soil under spring barley. Soil Till Res 97:5–18
Dangol N, Shrestha DS, Duffield JA (2015) Life cycle analysis and production potential of camelina biodiesel in the Pacific Northwest. Trans ASABE 58:465–475
Del Grosso SJ, Parton WJ (2011) Quantifying nitrous oxide emissions from agricultural soils and management impacts. Understanding greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural management. American Chemical Society, Washington, pp. 3–13
Del Grosso SJ, Halvorson AD, Parton WJ (2008) Testing DAYCENT model simulations of corn yields and nitrous oxide emissions in irrigated tillage systems in Colorado. J Environ Qual 37:1383–1389
Dietiker D, Buchmann N, Eugster W (2010) Testing the ability of the DNDC model to predict CO2 and water vapour fluxes of a Swiss cropland site. Agric Ecosyst Environ 139:396–401
Eve M, Pape D, Flugge M, Steele R, Man D, Riley-Gilbert M, Biggar S, Eds (2014) Quantifying greenhouse gas fluxes in agriculture and forestry: methods for entity-scale inventory. Technical bulletin number 1939. Office of the chief economist, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington
Fang HJ, Yu GR, Cheng SL, Zhu TH, Wang YS, Yan JH, Wang M, Cao M, Zhou M (2010) Effects of multiple environmental factors on CO2 emission and CH4 uptake from old-growth forest soils. Biogeosciences 7:395–407
Fumoto T, Kobayashi K, Li C, Yagi K, Hasegawa T (2008) Revising a process-based biogeochemistry model (DNDC) to simulate methane emission from rice paddy fields under various residue management and fertilizer regimes. Glob Change Biol 14:382–402
Gilhespy SL, Anthony A, Cardenas L, Chadwick D, Prado AD, Li C, Misselbrook T, Rees RM, Salas W, Sanz-Cobena A, Smith P, Tilston EM, Topp CFE, Vetter S, Yeluripati JB (2014) First 20 years of DNDC (DeNitrification DeComposition): model evolution. Ecol Model 292:51–62
Gnansounou E, Dauriat A, Panichelli L, Villegas JD (2008) Energy and greenhouse gas balances of biofuels: biases induced by LCA modeling choices. J Sci Ind Res (JSIR) 67:885–897
Gnansounou E, Dauriat A, Villegas J, Panichelli L (2009) Life cycle assessment of biofuels: energy and greenhouse gas balances. Bioresource Technol 100:4919–4930
Goglio P, Smith WN, Grant BB, Desjardins RL, McConkey BG, Campbell CA, Nemecek T (2015) Accounting for soil carbon changes in agricultural life cycle assessment (LCA): a review. J Clean Prod 104:23–39
González-García S, García-Rey D, Hospido A (2013) Environmental life cycle assessment for rapeseed-derived biodiesel. Int J Life Cycle Assess 18:61–76
Hanna M (2005) Fuel required for field operations. Iowa State University, University Extension, Ag Decision Maker. https://www.extension.iastate.edu/agdm/crops/pdf/a3-27.pdf. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Hastings AF, Wattenbach M, Eugster W, Li C, Buchmann N, Smith P (2010) Uncertainty propagation in soil greenhouse gas emission models: an experiment using the DNDC model and at the Oensingen cropland site. Agric Ecosyst Environ 136:97–110
Horak J, Siska B (2006) Evaluation of N2O emissions by DNDC model for sandy loam soils of danubian lowland. J Environ Eng Landscape Manage 14:165–171
IPCC (2006) IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories. Prepared by the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme. In: Eggleston HS, Buendia L, Miwa K, Ngara T, Tanabe K (eds), Published: IGES, Japan
Jungbluth N, Chudacoff M, Dauriat A, Dinkel F, Doka G, Faist Emmenegger M, Gnansounou E, Kljun N, Schleiss K, Spielmann M, Stettler C, Sutter J (2007) Life cycle inventories of bioenergy. ecoinvent report No. 17, Swiss Center for Life Cycle Inventories, Dubendorf, CH. http://www.ecoinvent.ch. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Kelischek N (2011) Energy budget of nitrogen use in the United States. JSRESA 1:32–35
Keske CM, Hoag DL, Brandess A, Johnson JJ (2013) Is it economically feasible for farmers to grow their own fuel? A study of Camelina sativa produced in the western United States as an on-farm biofuel. Biomass Bioenergy 54:89–99
Kim S, Dale BE (2008) Life cycle assessment of fuel ethanol derived from corn grain via dry milling. Bioresource Technol 99:5250–5260
Kim S, Dale BE (2009) Regional variations in greenhouse gas emissions of biobased products in the United States—corn-based ethanol and soybean oil. Int J Life Cycle Assess 14:540–546
Krohn BJ, Fripp M (2012) A life cycle assessment of biodiesel derived from the “niche filling” energy crop camelina in the USA. Appl Energy 92:92–98
Kumar D, Murthy GS (2012) Life cycle assessment of energy and GHG emissions during ethanol production from grass straws using various pretreatment processes. Int J Life Cycle Assess 17:388–401
Lee J, Hopmans JW, van Kessel C, King AP, Evatt KJ, Louie D, Rolston DE, Six J (2009) Tillage and seasonal emissions of CO2, N2O and NO across a seed bed and at the field scale in a Mediterranean climate. Agric Ecosyst Environ 129:378–390
Leip A, Marchi G, Koeble R, Kempen M, Britz W, Li C (2008) Linking an economic model for European agriculture with a mechanistic model to estimate nitrogen and carbon losses from arable soils in Europe. Biogeosciences 5:73–94
Li X, Mupondwa E (2014) Life cycle assessment of camelina oil derived biodiesel and jet fuel in the Canadian Prairies. Sci Total Environ 481:17–26
Li C, Frolking S, Frolking TA (1992) A model of nitrous oxide evolution from soil driven by rainfall events: 1. Model structure and sensitivity. J Geophys Res 97:9759–9776
Li C, Zhuang YH, Cao MQ, Crill PM, Dai ZH, Frolking S, Moore B, Salas W, Song WZ, Wang XK (2001) Comparing a national inventory of N2O emissions from arable lands in China developed with a process-based agro-ecosystem model to the IPCC methodology. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst 60:159–175
Li H, Qiu JJ, Wang LG, Xu MY, Liu ZQ, Wang W (2012) Estimates of N2O emissions and mitigation potential from a spring maize field based on DNDC model. J Integr Agr 11:2067–2078
Miller P, Kumar A (2013) Development of emission parameters and net energy ratio for renewable diesel from Canola and Camelina. Energy 58:426–437
Mosier AR, Parton WJ, Valentine DW, Ojima DS, Schimel DS, Delgado JA (1996) CH4 and N2O fluxes in the Colorado shortgrass steppe: 1. Impact of landscape and nitrogen addition. Glob Biogeochem Cycles 10:387–399
Mosier AR, Delgado JA, Cochran VL, Valentine DW, Parton WJ (1997) Impact of agriculture on soil consumption of atmospheric CH4 and a comparison of CH4 and N2O flux in subarctic, temperate and tropical grasslands. Nutr Cycle Agroecosys 49:71–83
NASS (2014) National Agricultural Statistics Service. http://www.nass.usda.gov. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
NCDC (2014) National Climatic Data Center. http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Nemecek T, Kagi T (2007) Life cycle inventories of Swiss and European agricultural production systems. Final report ecoinvent V2.0 No. 15a. Agroscope Reckenholz-Taenikon Research Station ART, Swiss Center for Life Cycle Inventories, Zurich and Dubendorf, CH. http://www.ecoinvent.ch. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
openLCA (2015) GreenDelta. http://www.openLCA.org. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Panichelli L, Dauriat A, Gnansounou E (2009) Life cycle assessment of soybean-based biodiesel in Argentina for export. Int J Life Cycle Assess 14:144–159
Paustian K, Six J, Elliott ET, Hunt HW (2000) Management options for reducing CO2 emissions from agricultural soils. Biogeochemistry 48:147–163
Pradhan A, Shrestha DS, McAloon A, Yee W, Haas M, Duffield JA, Shapouri H (2009) Energy life-cycle assessment of soybean biodiesel. Agricultural Economic Report Number 845 http://www.usda.gov/oce/reports/energy/ELCAofSoybeanBiodiesel91409.pdf. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Roy AK, Wagner-Riddle C, Deen B, Lauzon J, Bruulsema T (2014) Nitrogen application rate, timing and history effects on nitrous oxide emissions from corn (Zea mays L. Can J Soil Sci 94:563–573
Ryberg M, Vieira MDM, Zgola M, Bare J, Rosenbaum RK (2014) Updated US and Canadian normalization factors for TRACI 2.1. Clean Technol Environ 16:329–339
Sainju UM, Jabro JD, Stevens WB (2008) Soil carbon dioxide emission and carbon content as affected by irrigation, tillage, cropping system, and nitrogen fertilization. J Environ Qual 37:98–106
Shen W, Han W, Chock D, Chai Q, Zhang A (2012) Well-to-wheels life-cycle analysis of alternative fuels and vehicle technologies in China. Energy Policy 49:296–307
Shonnard DR, Williams L, Kalnes TN (2010) Camelina-derived jet fuel and diesel: sustainable advanced biofuels. Environ Prog Sustain Energy 3:382–392
Sintim HY, Zheljazkov VD, Obour AK, Garcia y Garcia A, Foulke TK (2015) Influence of nitrogen and sulfur application on camelina performance under dryland conditions. Ind Crop Prod 70:253–259
Six J, Ogle SM, Breidt FJ, Conant RT, Mosier AR, Paustian K (2004) The potential to mitigate global warming with no-tillage management is only realized when practiced in the long term. Glob Change Biol 10:155–160
Soil Survey Staff (2014) Natural Resources Conservation Service, United States Department of Agriculture. Web Soil Survey. http://websoilsurvey.nrcs.usda.gov. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Tabatabaie SMH, Murthy GS (2016) Cradle to farm gate life cycle assessment of strawberry production in the United States. J Clean Prod 127:548–554
Tenuta M, Sparling B (2011) A laboratory study of soil conditions affecting emissions of nitrous oxide from packed cores subjected to freezing and thawing. Can J Soil Sci 91:223–233
Ukaew S, Beck E, Archer DW, Shonnard DR (2015) Estimation of soil carbon change from rotation cropping of rapeseed with wheat in the hydrotreated renewable jet life cycle. Int J Life Cycle Assess 20:608–622
Ukaew S, Beck E, Meki MN, Shonnard DR (2014) Application of the roundtable on sustainable biofuels method to regional differences in nitrous oxide emissions for the rapeseed hydrotreated renewable jet life cycle. J Clean Prod 83:220–227
US EPA (2015) Climate impacts in the Northwest United States. http://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/impacts/northwest.html. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Uzoma KC, Smith W, Grant B, Desjardins RL, Gao X, Hanis K, Tenuta M, Goglio P, Li C (2015) Assessing the effects of agricultural management on nitrous oxide emissions using flux measurements and the DNDC model. Agric Ecosyst Environ 206:71–83
Velthof GL, Kuikman PJ, Oenema O (2002) Nitrous oxide emission from soils amended with crop residues. Nutr Cycle Agroecosys 62:249–261
Wang L, Qiu J, Tang H, Li H, Li C, Van Ranst E (2008) Modelling soil organic carbon dynamics in the major agricultural regions of China. Geoderma 147:47–55
Wang M, Huo M, Arora S (2011) Methods of dealing with co-products of biofuels in life-cycle analysis and consequent results within the U.S. context. Energy Policy 39:5726–5736
World Bank (2012) Economic and sector work. Carbon sequestration in agricultural soils (no. 67395-GLB). The World Bank, Washington
World Bank (2015) Commodity price. http://data.worldbank.org/data-catalog/commodity-price-data. Accessed 3 Dec 2015
Wysocki DJ, Chastain TG, Schillinger WF, Guyd SO, Karow RS (2013) Camelina: seed yield response to applied nitrogen and sulfur. Field Crop Res 145:60–66
Zaher U, Stöckle C, Painter K, Higgins S (2013) Life cycle assessment of the potential carbon credit from no-and reduced tillage winter wheat-based cropping systems in Eastern Washington State. Agric Syst 122:73–78
Acknowledgments
This project was supported by the Formula Grant No. 2012-67009-19917 from the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture and USDA Hatch Multistate research project at Oregon State University.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Responsible editor: Seungdo Kim
Electronic supplementary material
Online Resource 1
(XLSX 35 kb)
Online Resource 2
(XLSX 36 kb)
Online Resource 3
(XLSX 35 kb)
Online Resource 4
(XLSX 32 kb)
Online Resource 5
(PDF 68 kb)
Online Resource 6
(7z 309 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Tabatabaie, S.M.H., Murthy, G.S. Effect of geographical location and stochastic weather variation on life cycle assessment of biodiesel production from camelina in the northwestern USA. Int J Life Cycle Assess 22, 867–882 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-016-1191-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-016-1191-9