Modern analysis of an ancient integrated farming arrangement: life cycle assessment of a mulberry dyke and pond system
- 670 Downloads
Integrated agriculture and aquaculture (IAA), as typified by the mulberry dike-pond system (DPS) of the Pearl River delta of southern China, is often cited as an example of sustainable intensified production due to its characteristic closed loop recycling of nutrients. In this study, we tackle two issues that have been hardly addressed in previous analyses of aquaculture production, greenhouse gas emissions (GHGe) from the pond and the role of labour.
Previous assessments led us to revisit the sustainability of the DPS system as a model for a well-studied IAA system using a life cycle assessment (LCA) methodology. Our study quantifies on-farm CH4 and N2O emissions and indirect emissions embedded in inputs, using the global warming potential (GWP) metric. To model the indirect impact of the high labour requirements of the system, a simple methodology based on metabolizable energy requirements is proposed.
Results and discussion
Our GHGe assessment suggests that using fish ponds to treat organic waste results in higher net emissions than alternative waste processing options (e.g. composting), even when the co-production of fish is accounted for. The majority of total system GWP100 (97 %) can be attributed to methane from the fertilised ponds. Food required to meet labour requirements plays an important role, from 11 to 22 % of total environmental impact.
Methane from semi-intensive ponds fertilised with organic waste appears to be a significant source of GWP, calling into question the environmental sustainability of IAA systems such as the mulberry DPS. Improving sustainability in such systems will require better understanding of GHGe from waste-fed aquaculture ponds, notably with respect to on-farm N2O and CH4.
KeywordsAquaculture GHGe IAA LCA Methane Silk
We thank the European Research Council (SP2-GA-2008-233409 and PoC 324607) for funding and the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments.
- Blackburn TH (1987) Role and impact of anaerobic microbial processes in aquatic systems. In: Moriarty DJW, Pullin RSV (eds) Detritus Microb. Ecol. Aquac. ICLARM, Manila, pp 32–53Google Scholar
- Chen M, Jin P, Huang L, Lu X (2006b) Emergy analysis of mulberry silkworm ecosystem in China. Chin J Appl Ecol 17:233–236Google Scholar
- Coche AG, Muir JF, Laughlin T (1996) Simple methods for aquaculture: management for freshwater fish culture ponds and water practices. FAO, RomeGoogle Scholar
- CSRTI (2013) Annual report 2012-2013. MysoreGoogle Scholar
- De Klein C, Novoa RS, Ogle S et al (2006) N2O emissions from managed soils, and CO2 emissions from lime and urea application. 2006 IPCC Guidel. Natl. Greenh. gas Invent, pp 1–54Google Scholar
- Edwards P (1993) Environmental issues in integrated agriculture-aquaculture and wastewater-fed culture systems. In: Pullin RSV, Rosenthal H, Maclean JL (eds) Environ. Aquac. Dev. Ctries. ICLARM, Manila, pp 139–170Google Scholar
- European Commission (2010) International reference life cycle data system (ILCD) handbook - general guide on LCA - general guide for life cycle assessment. doi: 10.2788/38479
- FAO (1972) Food composition table for East Asia. Rome, ItalyGoogle Scholar
- FAO (2004) Human energy requirements. FAO, RomeGoogle Scholar
- FAO Faostat. In: 2014. faostat.fao.org. Accessed 20 Sep 2014
- Henriksson PJG, Zhang W, Nahid SA et al (2014) Final LCA case study report - annexGoogle Scholar
- Hinshaw SE, Dahlgren RA (2013) Dissolved nitrous oxide concentrations and fluxes from the eutrophic San Joaquin River, California. Environ Sci Technol 47:1313–1322Google Scholar
- Ruddle K (1985) Rural reforms and household economies in the dike-pond area of the Zhujiang Delta, China. Bull Natl Museum Ethnol 10:1145–1174Google Scholar
- Ruddle K, Christensen V (1993) An energy flow model of the mulberry dike-carp pond farming system of the Zhujiang Delta, Guandong Province, China. In: Christensen V, Pauly D (eds) Trophic Model. Aquat. Ecosyst. ICLARM, Manila, pp 48–55Google Scholar
- Ruddle K, Zhong G (1988) Integrated agriculture-aquaculture in South China: the dike-pond system in the Zhujiang Delta. Cambridge University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Ruddle K, Hanzeng D, Guozhao L (1986) Energy exchanges and the energy efficiency of household ponds in the dike-pond system of the Zhujiang Delta, China. Bull Natl Museum Ethnol 11:323–343Google Scholar
- Schroeder GL (1987b) carbon pathways in aquatic detrital systems. In: Moriarty DJW, Pullin RSV (eds) Detritus Microb. Ecol. Aquac. ICLARM, Manila, pp 217–236Google Scholar
- Selvam BP, Natchimuthu S, Bastviken D (2014) Methane and carbon dioxide emissions from inland waters in India - implications for large scale greenhouse gas balances Department of Thematic Studies – Water and Environmental Studies, Linköping University, Current address: Department of Physical GeographyGoogle Scholar
- Weidema BP, Bauer C, Hischier R et al (2013) Overview and methodology. Data quality guideline for the ecoinvent database version 3. Ecoinvent Rep1(v3):StGoogle Scholar
- Wong Chor Yee A (1999) New developments in integrated dike-pond agriculture-aquaculture in the Zhujiang delta, China: Ecological implications. Ambio 28:529–533Google Scholar
- Yang N (2005a) Cultured aquatic species information programme. Hypophthalmichthys molitrix. In: FAO Fish Aquac Dep. http://www.fao.org/fishery/culturedspecies/Hypophthalmichthys_nobilis/en#tcNA00EA. Accessed 15 Jul 2015
- Yang N (2005b) Cultured aquatic species information programme. Hypophthalmichthys nobilis. In: FAO Fish Aquac Dep. http://www.fao.org/fishery/culturedspecies/Hypophthalmichthys_nobilis/en#tcNA00EA. Accessed 15 Jul 2015