Identifying bounded rationality with panel data: evidence from the labor markets of Italy and Germany
In this paper we question the hypothesis of bounded rationality against full rationality in the context of job changing behavior, via simple econometric explorations on microdata drawn from Worker Histories Italian Panel (WHIP) and Sample of Integrated Labor Market Biographies (SIAB). The identification strategy builds on a quasi-counterfactual experiment in which the performance of each voluntary mover is compared to the average performance of a peer-group of stayers of the same skill group, co-workers in the firm from which the movers’ job switch originated. Voluntary movers are identifiable in the WHIP and SIAB datasets, while it is not possible to do the same among the stayers. Full rationality suggests that the performance of voluntary movers should be superior to the stayers’ (both voluntary and involuntary) as the involuntary stayers have a smaller decision set from which to choose. In this exploration we find a clear opposite result, which we take as evidence of bounded rationality of the movers.
KeywordsBehavioral economics Decision making Counterfactual identification
Bruno Contini is grateful to C. Flinn for a casual observation at lunch table that led me to readdress from scratch the identification strategy of this study. I also thank an unknown referee for useful comments.
- Akerlof GA (1991) Procrastination and obedience. Am Econ Rev 81(2):1–19Google Scholar
- Akerlof GA, Dickens WT (1982) The economic consequences of cognitive dissonance. Am Econ Rev 72(3):307–319Google Scholar
- Ashenfelter O, Genesove D (1992) Testing for price anomalies in real-estate auctions. Am Econ Rev 82(2):501–505Google Scholar
- Conlisk J (1996) Why bounded rationality? J Econ Lit 34(2):669–700Google Scholar
- Contini B, Morini M (2007) Testing bounded rationality against full rationality in job changing behavior. IZA WP p 3148Google Scholar
- Goldberger AS (1989) Economic and mechanical models of intergenerational transmission. Am Econ Rev 79(3):504–513Google Scholar
- Kunreuther H et al (1978) Disaster insurance protection. Public policy lessons. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Shui H, Ausubel LM (2004) Consumer time inconsistency: evidence from a market experiment in the credit card market. Econometric Society North American Summer Meetings series (176)Google Scholar