Privileged protection? Effects of suspect race and mental illness status on public perceptions of police use of force
This study experimentally examined the joint influence of suspect race and mental illness status on the public’s support for police use of force, and whether participants’ race and social attitudes moderated these findings.
A diverse sample of community members (n = 259) from Portland, OR completed a survey with an imbedded experiment. Participants read a case file describing a police officer using force against a suspect who varied in race (Black vs. White) and mental illness status (history of mental illness vs. not), and indicated their level of support for the officer’s use of force.
While overall support for use of force was low, an analysis of variance (ANOVA) confirmed a significant interaction between suspect mental illness status and race on the public’s support for police force. Mental illness was a mitigating factor against support for police use of force, but only for White suspects. For Black suspects, mental illness instead increased support for police force, although support remained relatively low. These results were not influenced by participants’ race. Instead, effects were moderated by participants’ pre-existing affect about Blacks, such that positive affect decreased support for force against mentally ill Black suspects.
Mental illness status provides different protections based on suspect race, leading to racial bias in public support for police force. The results suggest that it may be relatively harder for the public to enact change against police force when it is directed against mentally ill racial minorities, as it is perceived less negatively by the public compared to White mentally ill individuals.
KeywordsRace Mental illness Police Use of force Stereotypes Racial bias
- Barillas, M. E. (2012). Police officers as first line responders: Improving mental health training to effectively serve the mentally Ill population. Order no. 3499136, dissertation, Alliant International University.Google Scholar
- Beale, F. (1979). Double jeopardy: to be black and female. In T. Cade (Ed.), The black woman (pp. 90–100). New York: New American Library.Google Scholar
- Bernstein, M. (2012). Federal government files civil lawsuit against City of Portland stemming from police inquiry. The Oregonian, December 17, 2012.Google Scholar
- Black Lives Matter. (2015). We affirm that All Black Lives matter. Black Lives Matter. Downloaded from http://blacklivesmatter.com/guiding-principles/.
- Bonilla-Silva, E. (2013). Racism without racists: Color-blind racism and the persistence of racial inequality in America (4th ed.). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.Google Scholar
- Brown, B., & Benedict, W. (2002). Perceptions of the police: past findings, methodological issues, conceptual issues and policy implications. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management, 25, 543–580. doi:10.1108/13639510210437032.
- Carpenter, Z. (2015). Why can’t one of America’s most ‘progressive’ cities reform its police force? The Nation. http://www.thenation.com/article/why-cant-one-americas-most-progressive-cities-reform-its-police-force/. Accessed 7 September 2015.
- de Crane, R. S., & Spielberger, C. D. (1981). Attitudes of Hispanic, Black, and Caucasian university students toward mental illness. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 3, 241–253.Google Scholar
- Dovidio, J. F., & Gaertner, S. L. (2004). Aversive racism. In M. P. Zanna (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 36, pp. 1–52). San Diego, CA: Academic Press. doi:10.1016/s0065-2601(04)36001-6.
- Fazio, R. H. (1986). How do attitudes guide behavior? The handbook of motivation and cognition: Foundations of social behavior, 1, 204–243.Google Scholar
- Flanagan, T. J., & Vaughn, M. S. (1996). Public opinion about police abuse of force. In W. A. Geller & H. Toch (Eds.), Police violence: Understanding and controlling police abuse of force (pp. 113–128). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- Gaertner, S. L., & Dovidio, J. F. (1986). The aversive form of racism. In J. F. Dovidio & S. L. Gaertner (Eds.), Prejudice, discrimination, and racism (pp. 61–89). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.Google Scholar
- Gaertner, S. L., Dovidio, J. F., Nier, J., Hodson, G., & Houlette, M. A. (2005). Aversive racism: Bias without intention. In L. B. Nielsen & R. L. Nelson (Eds.), Handbook of employment discrimination research (pp. 377–393). Netherlands: Springer.Google Scholar
- Johnston, E. L. (2013). Vulnerability and just desert: a theory of sentencing and mental illness. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 103, 147–230.Google Scholar
- Livingston, J. D., Desmarais, S. L., Verdun-Jones, S., Parent, R., Michalak, E., & Brink, J. (2014). Perceptions and experiences of people with mental illness regarding their interactions with police. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 37, 334–340. doi:10.1016/j.ijlp.2014.02.003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Police Executive Research Forum. (2012). An integrated approach to de-escalation and minimizing use of force. Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
- Santos, F. & Goode, E. (2014). Police confront rising number of mentally ill suspects. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/02/us/police-shootings-of-mentally-ill-suspects-are-on-the-upswing.html.
- Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (1986). The social identity theory of intergroup behavior. In S. Worchel & W. G. Austin (Eds.), Psychology of intergroup relations (2nd ed., pp. 409–426). Chicago: Nelson-Hall.Google Scholar
- Thomas, W. J., Stubbe, D. E., & Pearson, G. (1999). Race, juvenile justice, and mental health: new dimensions in measuring pervasive bias. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 89, 615–670. doi:10.2307/1144139.
- Thompson, M. (2010). Mad or bad? Race, class, gender, and mental disorder in the criminal justice system. New York: LFB Scholarly Publishing.Google Scholar
- Thompson, M., & Kahn, K. B. (2016a). Mental health, race, and police contact: intersections of risk and trust in the police. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management, 39, 807–819. doi:10.1108/PIJPSM-02-2016-0015.
- Thompson, M., & Kahn, K. B. (2016b). The effects of mental health, race, and arrest on preferences for police training on mental health crises. Manuscript submitted for publication.Google Scholar
- Tyler, T. R., & Huo, Y. J. (2002). Trust in the law: encouraging public cooperation with the police and courts through. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
- United States Census Bureau. (2010). Quick facts: Portland, OR. Retrieved from http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/41/4159000.html on 1April 2014.
- United States of America v. City of Portland. (2012). Case 3:12-cv-02265-SI, filed 12/17/12.Google Scholar
- Watson, A. C., Angell, B., Morabito, M. S., & Robinson, N. (2008). Defying negative expectations: dimensions of fair and respectful treatment by police officers as perceived by people with mental illness. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 35, 449–457. doi:10.1007/s10488-008-0188-5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Williams, J. S., Thomas, C. W., & Singh, B. K. (1983). Situational use of police force: public reactions. American Journal of Police, 3, 37–50.Google Scholar
- Wilson, T. D., Aronson, E., & Carlsmith, K. (2010). The art of laboratory experimentation. In S. T. Fiske, D. T. Gilbert, & G. Lindzey (Eds.), Handbook of social psychology (Vol. 1, pp. 51–81). Hoboken: Wiley.Google Scholar