Journal of Experimental Criminology

, Volume 7, Issue 4, pp 347–374 | Cite as

Spatial displacement and diffusion of benefits among geographically focused policing initiatives: a meta-analytical review

  • Kate J. Bowers
  • Shane D. Johnson
  • Rob T. Guerette
  • Lucia Summers
  • Suzanne Poynton
Article

Abstract

Objectives

To undertake a systematic review of the extent to which geographically focused policing initiatives appear to displace crime (simply relocate it to other places) or diffuse benefits (lead to reductions elsewhere).

Methods

Evaluation research which assessed whether such schemes may have led to displacement or diffusion of benefit to nearby areas was identified, obtained and coded. Research reports were assessed in terms of their methodological rigor and the quantitative estimates of outcomes collected. A hierarchy for estimates of displacement was established. For 16 studies, meta-analysis was used to produce a collection of results that had two sets of outcome information in terms of effect sizes (the success of the intervention and the extent to which it may have caused displacement or diffusion).

Results

The main findings of the meta-analysis suggested that on average geographically focused policing initiatives for which data were available were (1) associated with significant reductions in crime and disorder, and (2) that, overall, changes in catchment areas were non-significant but there was a trend in favor of a diffusion of benefit.

Conclusion

The results demonstrate that in the case of geographically focused police efforts, displacement is far from inevitable, and in fact, on balance, that the opposite, a diffusion of crime control benefits, appears to be the more likely outcome. This in turn demonstrates that such endeavors on average have an overall reductive impact on crime.

Keywords

Diffusion of benefits Displacement Evaluation Focused policing initiatives Meta-analysis 

References

  1. Allat, P. (1984). Residential security: containment and displacement of burglary. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 23, 99–116.Google Scholar
  2. Barr, R., & Pease, K. (1990). Crime placement, displacement and deflection. In Michael Tonry & N. Morris (Eds.), Crime and justice: A review of research, vol. 12. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  3. Bowers, K., & Johnson, S. (2003). Measuring the geographical displacement and diffusion of benefit effects of crime prevention activity. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 193, 275–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Braga, A. A. (2007). Effects of hot spots policing on crime. A Campbell Collaboration systematic review, available at: http://www.aic.gov.au/campbellcj/reviews/titles.html.
  5. Braga, A. A., & Bond, B. J. (2008). Policing crime and disorder hot spots: A randomized controlled trial. Criminology, 46(3), 577–607.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Braga, A. A., Weisburd, D. L., Waring, E. J., Mazerolle, L. G., Spelman, W., & Gajewski, F. (1999). Problem-oriented policing in violent crime places: A randomized controlled experiment. Criminology, 37(3), 541–580.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brantingham, P. L., & Brantingham, P. J. (1981). Notes on the geometry of crime. In P. Brantingham & P. Brantingham (Eds.), Environmental criminology. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  8. Campbell, D. T. & Stanley, J. C. (1963). Experimental and quasi-experimental designsfor research. Dallas: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
  9. Chaiken, J. M., Lawless, M., & Stevenson, K. A. (1974). The impact of police activity on crime. Urban Analysis, 3, 173–205.Google Scholar
  10. Clarke, R. V., & Eck, J. (2005). Crime analysis for problem solvers in 60 small steps. Washington: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, United States Department of Justice.Google Scholar
  11. Clarke, R. V., & Weisburd, D. (1994). Diffusion of crime control benefits: Observations on the reverse of displacement. In R. V. Clarke (Ed.), Crime prevention studies, vol. 2. Monsey: Criminal Justice Press.Google Scholar
  12. Cornish, D. B., & Clarke, R. V. (Eds.). (1986). The reasoning criminal. New York: Springer-Verlag.Google Scholar
  13. Duval, S. J., & Tweedie, R. L. (2000). A non-parametric “trim and fill” method of accounting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 95, 89–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Eck, J. E. (1993). The threat of crime displacement. Criminal Justice Abstracts, 253, 527–546.Google Scholar
  15. Eck, J., Clarke, R. V., & Guerette, R. T. (2007). Risky facilities: Crime concentration in homogeneous sets of establishments and facilities. Crime Prevention Studies, 21, 225–264.Google Scholar
  16. Farrington, D., & Welsh, B. (2002). Effects of improved street lighting on crime: A systematic review. Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate, August, Research Study 251.Google Scholar
  17. Farrington, D. P., Gill, M., Waples, S. J., & Argomaniz, J. (2007). The effects of closed-circuit television on crime: Meta-analysis of an English national quasiexperimental multi-site evaluation. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 3(1), 21–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Green, L. (1995). Cleaning up drug hot spots in Oakland, California: The displacement and diffusion effects. Justice Quarterly, 124, 737–754.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Guerette, R. T., & Bowers, K. (2009). Assessing the Extent of Crime Displacement and Diffusion of Benefits: A Review of Situational Crime Prevention Evaluations. Criminology, 47(4).Google Scholar
  20. Hesseling, Rene. (1994). Displacement: A review of the empirical literature. In R. V. Clarke (Ed.), Crime prevention studies, vol. 3. Monsey: Criminal Justice Press.Google Scholar
  21. Johnson, S. D. (2009). Potential uses of computational methods in the evaluation of crime reduction activity. In J. Knuttson & N. Tilley (Eds.), Evaluating crime prevention. New York: Criminal Justice Press.Google Scholar
  22. Lipsey, M. W., & Wilson, D. B. (2001). Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks: Sage.Google Scholar
  23. Marchant, P. (2004). A demonstration that the claim that brighter lighting reduces crime is unfounded. British Journal of Criminology, 44, 441–447.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Marchant, P. (2005). What works? A critical note on the evaluation of crime reduction initiatives. Crime Prevention and Community Safety, 7(2), 7–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Lorraine, M., Rombouts, S., & Soole, D. W. (2007). Street-level drug law enforcement: A meta-analytic review. A Campbell Collaboration Systematic review, available at: http://www.campbellcollaboration.org/library.php.
  26. Miethe, T. D. (1991). Citizen-based crime control activity and victimization risks: An examination of displacement and free rider effects. Criminology, 29, 419–439.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Pease, K. (1998). Repeat victimization: Taking stock. Crime detection and prevention paper series paper #90. London: Home Office.Google Scholar
  28. Petticrew, M., & Roberts, H. (2006). Systematic reviews in the social sciences: A practical guide. Oxford: Blackwell.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Rengert, G., Wasilchick, J. (1985). Suburban burglary: A time and a place for everything. Springfield, IL: CharlesThomasGoogle Scholar
  30. Sherman, L., Gartin, P. R., & Buerger, M. E. (1989). Hotspots of predatory crime: Routine activities in the criminology of place. Criminology, 27(1), 27–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Weisburd, D., & Green, L. (1995a). Measuring immediate spatial displacement: Methodological issues and problems. In J. Eck & D. Weisburd (Eds.), Crime and place. Crime prevention studies, vol. 4. Monsey: Criminal Justice Press.Google Scholar
  32. Weisburd, D., & Green, L. (1995b). Policing drug hot spots: The Jersey City drug market analysis experiment. Justice Quarterly, 12(4), 711–735.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Weisburd, D., Wyckoff, L., Ready, J., Eck, J., Hinkle, J. C., & Gajewski, F. (2006). Does crime just move around the corner? A controlled study of spatial displacement and diffusion of crime control benefits. Criminology, 44(3), 549–591.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Weisburd, D., Telep, C. W., Hinkle, J. C., & Eck, J. E. (2008). The effects of problem-oriented policing on crime and disorder. A Campbell Collaboration Systematic Review available at: http://test.c2admin.org/index.php?go=browse&sort=title&view=all&search=weisburd&search_criteria=author.
  35. Weisburd, D., Telep, C. W., Hinkle, J. C., & Eck, J. E. (2010). Is problem-oriented policing effective in reducing crime and disorder? Criminology & Public Policy, 9(1), 139–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

References of Eligible Studies

  1. Bellamy, L. C. (1997). The toller lane crime management tool: Tackling crime more effectively. Security Journal, 9(1–3), 15–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Braga, A. A., & Bond, B. J. (2008b). Policing crime and disorder hot spots: A randomized controlled trial. Criminology: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 46(3), 577–607.Google Scholar
  3. Braga, A. A., Weisburd, D. L., Waring, E. J., Mazerolle, L. G., Spelman, W., & Gajewski, F. (1999b). Problem-oriented policing in violent crime places: A randomized controlled experiment. Criminology, 37(3), 541–580.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Caeti, T. (1999). Houston’s targeted beat program:? A quasi-experimental test of police patrol strategies. PhD. Diss., Sam Houston State University. Ann Arbor MI: University Microfilms International.Google Scholar
  5. Cator, M. (2006). Operation mullion: Reducing anti-social behaviour and crime in and around Mayfield School. Hampshire Constabulary. Tilley Award Finalist.Google Scholar
  6. Chenery, S., Holt, J., & Pease, K. (1997). Biting back II: Reducing repeat victimisation in Huddersfield. Crime Detection and Prevention Series, Paper 82, Home Office.Google Scholar
  7. Clarke, R. V., & Goldstein, H. (2002). Reducing theft at construction sites: Lessons from a problem oriented project. Crime Prevention Studies, 13, 89–130.Google Scholar
  8. Clarke, R. V., & Goldstein, H. (2003). Thefts from cars in city-center parking facitlities: A case study in implementing problem oriented policing. Crime Prevention Studies, 15, 257–298.Google Scholar
  9. Cohen, J., & Ludwig, J. (2003). Policing crime guns. In J. Ludwig & P. J. Cook (Eds.), Evaluating gun policy; effects on crime and violence (pp. 217–250). Washington: Brookings Institute Press.Google Scholar
  10. Cummings, R. (2006). ‘What if’: The counterfactual in program evaluation. Evaluation Journal of Australasia, 6(2), 6–15 (new series).Google Scholar
  11. Curran, K., Dale, M., Edmunds, M., Hough, M., Millie, A., & Wagstaff, M. (2005). Street crime in London: Deterrence, disruption and displacement. London: Government Office for London.Google Scholar
  12. Eck, J., & Spelman, W. (1987). Problem-solving: Problem oriented policing in Newport News. Police Executive Research Forum.Google Scholar
  13. Esbensen, F. A. (1987). Foot patrols: Of what value. American Journal of Police, 6, 45. Retrieved from www.heonline.org.Google Scholar
  14. Farrell, G., Chenery, S., & Pease, K. (1998). Consolidating police crackdowns: Findings from an anti-burglary project. Police Research Series Paper 113, London, UK.Google Scholar
  15. Forrester, D. H., Chatterton, M. R., & Pease, K. (1988). The Kirkholt burglary prevention demonstration project, Home Office Crime Prevention Unit Paper no. 13. London: HM Stationary Office.Google Scholar
  16. Green, L. (1995b). Cleaning up drug hot spots in Oakland. California: The Displacement and Diffusion Effects, Justice Quarterly, 12, 737.Google Scholar
  17. Grogger, J. (2002). The effects of civil gang injunctions on reported violent crime: Evidence from Los Angeles County. Journal of Law and Economics, 45(1), 69–90.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Higgins, D. F., & Coldren, J. R. (2000). Evaluating gang and drug house abatement in Chicago. Chicago: Criminal Justice Authority.Google Scholar
  19. Hope, T. J. (1994). Problem oriented policing and drug market locations: Three case studies. Crime Prevention Studies, 2, 5–31.Google Scholar
  20. Hopkins, M. (2004). Targeting hotspots of alcohol-related town centre violence: A Nottinghamshire case study. Security Journal, 17(4), 53–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Kane, R. J. (2006). On the limits of social control: Structural deterrence and the policing of "Suppressible" crimes. Justice Quarterly, 23(2), 186–213.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Katz, C. M., Webb, V. J., & Schaefer, D. R. (2001). Assessment of the impact of quality-of-life policing on crime and disorder. Justice Quarterly, 18(4), 825–876.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Knutsson, J. (1996). Restoring public order in a city park. Crime Prevention Journal, 6, 133–151.Google Scholar
  24. Lateef, A. B. (1974). Helicopter patrol in law enforcement - An evaluation. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 2(1), 62–65.Google Scholar
  25. Lawton, B. A., Taylor, R. B., & Luongo, A. J. (2005). Police officers on drug corners in Philadelphia, drug crime, and violent crime: Intended, diffusion, and displacement impacts. Justice Quarterly, 22(4), 427–451.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Matthews, R. (1993). Kerb-crawling, prostitution and multi-agency policing. Crime Prevention Unit Paper 43.Google Scholar
  27. Mazerolle, L. G., Price, J. F., & Roehl, J. (2000). Civil remedies and drug control: A randomized field trial in Oakland, California. Evaluation Review, 24(2), 212–241.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. McCabe, J. E. (2009). The narcotics initiative: An examination of the NYPD approach to drug enforcement, 1995–2001. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 20, 170–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. McGarrell, E. F., Chermak, S., Weiss, A., & Wilson, J. (2001). Reducing firearms violence through directed police patrol. Criminology & Public Policy, 1, 119–148.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Morris, S. (1996). Policing problem housing estates. Crime prevention and detection series, paper 74, Home Office.Google Scholar
  31. Novak, K. J., Hartman, J. L., Holsinger, A. M., & Turner, M. G. (1999). The effects of aggressive policing of disorder on serious crime. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 22(2), 171–190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Press, S. J. (1971). Some effects of an increase in police manpower in the 20th precinct of New York City. R-704-NYC. New York: New York City Rand Institute.Google Scholar
  33. Priest, T. B., & Brown Carter, D. (2002). Community-oriented policing: Assessing a police saturation operation (from policing and community partnerships, P 111–124, 2000, dennis J. stevens, ed., -- see NCJ-194083). Retrieved from http://www.policetrainings).
  34. Ratcliffe, J., & Makkai, T. (2004). Diffusion of benefits: Evaluating a policing operation. Trends & issues in crime and criminal justice, 278. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.Google Scholar
  35. Ratcliffe, J. H., Taniguchi, T., Groff, E. R., Wood, J. D. (2010). The Philadelphia foot patrol experiment: A randomized controlled trial of police patrol effectiveness in violent crime hotspots. Submitted to Criminology.Google Scholar
  36. Roman, C., Cahill, M., Coggeshall, M., Lagerson, E., Courtney, S. (2005). Weed and seed initiative and crime displacement in south florida: An examination of spatial displacement associated with crime control initiatives and the redevelopment of public health.Google Scholar
  37. Segrave, M., & Collins, L. (2005). Evaluation of a suburban crime prevention team, Technical and background paper series, 14. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.Google Scholar
  38. Sherman, L. W., & Rogan, D. P. (1995). Effects of gun seizures on gun violence: Hot spots patrol in Kansas City. Justice Quarterly, 12, 673.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Skogan, W. G., & Hartnett, S. M. (1997). Community policing: Chicago style. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  40. Smith, M. R. (2001). Police-led crackdowns and cleanups: An evaluation of a crime control initiative in Richmond, Virginia. Crime and Delinquency, 47(1), 60–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Tilley, N., & Hopkins, M. (1998). Business as usual: An evaluation of the small business and crime initiative. Police Research Series Paper 95. London: Home Office.Google Scholar
  42. Tita, G., Riley, K. J., Ridgeway, G., Grammich, C., Abrahamse, A., & Greenwood, P. W. (2003). Reducing gun violence: Results from an intervention in East Los Angeles. Santa Monica: Rand Public Safety and Justice, Rand Corporation.Google Scholar
  43. Wagers, M. (2007). Broken windows policing: The LAPD experience, Ph.D. diss., Rutgers The State University of New Jersey - Newark.Google Scholar
  44. Weidner, R. R. (1999). “I won’t do Manhattan”: A study of the causes and consequences of a decline in street prostitution. Ph.D. diss., Rutgers The State University of New Jersey - Newark.Google Scholar
  45. Weisburd, D., & Green, L. (1995c). Policing drug hot spots: The Jersey City Drug Market Analysis experiment. Justice Quarterly, 12(4), 711–742.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Weisburd, D., Wyckoff, L. A., Ready, J., Eck, J. E., Hinkle, J. C., & Gajewski, F. (2006b). Does crime just move around the corner? A controlled study of spatial displacement and diffusion of crime control benefits. Criminology: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 4.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kate J. Bowers
    • 1
  • Shane D. Johnson
    • 1
  • Rob T. Guerette
    • 2
  • Lucia Summers
    • 1
  • Suzanne Poynton
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Security and Crime ScienceUniversity College LondonLondonUK
  2. 2.School of International and Public AffairsFlorida International UniversityMiamiUSA

Personalised recommendations