Six Years after the Commercial Introduction of Bt Maize
in Spain: Field Evaluation, Impact and Future Prospects
Review Received: 03 October 2005 Accepted: 07 October 2005 Abstract
We carried out a 6-year-field evaluation to assess potential hazards of growing Compa®, a transgenic Bt maize variety based on the transformation event CG 00256-176. Two categories of hazards were investigated: the potential of the target corn borer
Sesamia nonagrioides to evolve resistance to Bt maize and effects on non-target organisms. In order to address the first hazard, dispersal capacity of the corn borer was measured and our results indicated that larvae move to plants other than those onto which the female oviposited – even to plants in adjacent rows – in remarkable numbers and they do so mostly at a mature age, suggesting that mixing Bt and non-Bt seeds in the same field would not be a very useful deployment strategy to delay/prevent resistance. In addition, adults move among fields to mate and males may do so for up to 400 m. Three different aspects of potential non-target effects were investigated: sub-lethal effects on the target S. nonagrioides, effects on non-target maize pests, and effects on maize-dwelling predators. Larvae collected in Bt fields at later growth stages, in which event 176 Bt maize expresses Bt toxin at sub-lethal concentrations, had longer diapause and post-diapause development than larvae collected in non-Bt fields, a feature that might lead to a certain isolation between populations in both type of fields and accelerate Bt resistance evolution. Transgenic maize did not have a negative impact on non-target pests in the field; more aphids and leafhoppers but similar numbers of cutworms and wireworms were counted in Bt versus non-Bt fields; in any case differences in damage or yield were recorded. We observed no difference in the numbers of the most relevant predators in fields containing transgenic or no transgenic maize. Keywords Bt maize GMO non-target Sesamia transgenic References Albajes, R, Eras, J, López, C, Ferran, X, Vigatà, J, Eizaguirre, M 2004 Testing rubidium marking for measuring adult dispersal of the corn borer Sesamia nonagrioides: first results IOBC/WPRS Bull 27 15 22 Google Scholar Anglade, P 1972 Les Sésamia Balachowsky, AS eds. Entomologie appliquée à l’agriculture, Tome II Lepidoptères Masson et Cie Press Paris 1389 1401 Google Scholar
Anonymous (2005) Resistant Pest Management: Arthropod Database.
. Consulted on June 23, 2005
Asín, L, Pons, X 2001 Effect of high temperature on the growth and reproduction of corn aphids (Homoptera: Aphididae) and implications for their population dynamics on the northeastern Iberian Peninsula Environ Entomol 30 1127 1134 Google Scholar Cannon, RJC 2000 Bt transgenic crops: risks and benefits Int Pest Manage Rev 5 151 173 Google Scholar Chaufaux, J, Seguin, M, Swanson, JJ, Bourget, D, Siegfried, BD 2001 Chronic exposure of the European corn borer (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) to CryIAb Bacillus thuringiensis toxin J Econ Entomol 94 1564 1570 PubMed Google Scholar Crawley, MJ 1999 Bollworms, genes, and ecologists Nature 400 501 502 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Dale, T, Buntin, GD 2005 Effects of Bacillus thuringiensis corn for Lepidopteran control on nontarget arthropods Environ Entomol 34 1292 1301 Google Scholar Dively, GP 2005 Impact of transgenic VIP3A×Cry 1Ab Lepidopteran-resistant field corn on nontarget arthropod community Environ Entomol 34 1267 1291 Google Scholar Dutton, A, Obrist, L, D’Alessandro, M, Diener, L, Müller, M, Romeis, J, Bigler, F 2004 Tracking Bt-toxin in transgenic maize to assess the risks on non-target arthropods IOBC/WPRS Bull 27 57 64 Google Scholar Eizaguirre, M, López, C, Sans, A 2002 Maize phenology influences field diapause induction of Sesamia nonagrioides (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Bull Entomol Res 92 439 443 PubMed Google Scholar Eizaguirre, M, López, C, Albajes, R 2004 Dispersal capacity in the Mediterranean corn borer, Sesamia nonagrioides (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Entomol Exp Appl 113 25 34 CrossRef Google Scholar Eizaguirre, M, López, C, Albajes, R 2005 Sublethal effects of Bacillusthuringiensis on larval development in Sesamia nonagrioides J Econ Entomol 98 237 247 Google Scholar Eizaguirre, R, Albajes, R 1989 Present situation of arthropod pests in maize in Northeast Spain Acta Phytopathol Entomol Hung 24 77 80 Google Scholar Farinós, GP, Poza, M, Hernández-Crespo, P, Ortego, F, Castañera, P 2004 Resistance monitoring of field populations of the corn borers Sesamia nonagrioides and Ostrinia nubilalis after 5 years of Bt maize cultivation in Spain Entomol Exp Appl 110 23 30 Google Scholar Fearing, PL, Brown, D, Vlachos, D, Meghji, M, Privalle, L 1997 Quantitative analysis of CryIA(b) expression in Bt maize plants, tissues, and silage and stability of expression over successive generations Mol Breeding 3 169 176 CrossRef Google Scholar Gould, F 1998 Sustainability of transgenic insecticidal cultivars: integrating pest genetics and ecology Annu Rev Entomol 43 701 726 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Gressel, J 2005 Problems in qualifying and quantifying assumptions in plant protection models: resultant simulations can be mistaken by a factor of million Crop Prot 24 1007 1015 Google Scholar Groot, AT, Dicke, M 2002 Insect-resistant transgenic plants in a multi-trophic context Plant J 31 387 406 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Hanway, JJ 1966How a Corn Plant Develops Iowa State University of Science and Technology Cooperative Extension Services Ames, Iowa Google Scholar Head, G, Brown, CR, Groth, M, Duan, JJ 2001 Cry1Ab protein levels in phytophagous insects feeding on transgenic corn: implications for secondary exposure risk assessment Entomol Exp Appl 99 37 45 CrossRef Google Scholar Hilbeck, A, Baumgartner, M, Fried, MF, Bigler, F 1998 Effects of transgenic Bacillus thuringiensis corn-fed prey on mortality and development time of immature Chrysoperla carnea (Nueroptera: Chrysopidae) Environ Entomol 27 480 487 Google Scholar James, C 2004Global Status of Commercialized Biotech/GM Crops: 2003 ISAAA Briefs No. 32 International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications Ithaca, NY Google Scholar López, C, Eizaguirre, M, Albajes, R 1995 Diapause detection and monitoring in the Mediterranean corn borer Physiol Entomol 20 330 336 Google Scholar López, C, Eizaguirre, M, Albajes, R 2003 Courtship and mating behaviour of the Mediterranean corn borer, Sesamia nonagrioides (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Span J Agric Res 1 43 51 Google Scholar López, C, Sans, A, Eizaguirre, M 1999 Influencia de la planta de maíz en el apareamiento de Sesamia nonagrioides Lefèbvre (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Invest Agr Prod Prot Veg 14 415 422 Google Scholar López, C, Sans, A, Asín, L, Eizaguirre, M 2001 Phenological model for Sesamia nonagrioides (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Environ Entomol 30 23 30 Google Scholar Lopez, MD, Prasifka, JR, Bruck, DJ, Lewis, LC 2005 Utility of ground beetle species in field tests of potential nontarget effects of Bt crops Environ Entomol 34 1317 1324 Google Scholar Lumbierres, B, Albajes, R, Pons, X 2004 Transgenic Bt maize and Rhopalosiphum padi (Hom., Aphididae) performance Ecol Entomol 29 309 317 CrossRef Google Scholar NRC (National Research Council) 2002Environmental effects of transgenic plants: the scope and adequacy of regulation National Academy Press Washington Google Scholar Musser, FR, Shelton, AM 2003 Bt sweet corn and selective insecticides: impacts on pests and predators J Econ Entomol 96 71 80 PubMed Google Scholar
Obrist L, Dutton A, Albajes R and Bigler F (2005) Exposure of arthropod predators to Cry1Ab toxin in Bt maize fields.
Google Scholar Onstad, DW, Gould, F 1998 Modelling the dynamics of adaptation to transgenic maize by European corn borer (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) J Econ Entomol 91 585 593 Google Scholar Orr, DB, Landis, DA 1997 Oviposition of European corn borer (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) and impact of natural enemy populations in transgenic versus isogenic corn J Econ Entomol 90 905 909 Google Scholar Pilcher, CD, Obrycki, JJ, Rice, ME, Lewis, LC 1997 Preimaginal development, survival and field abundance of insect predators on transgenic Bacillus thuringiensis corn Environ Entomol 26 446 454 Google Scholar Pilcher, CD, Rice, ME, Obrycki, JJ 2005 Impact of transgenic Bacillus thuringiensis corn and crop phenology on five non target arthropods Environ Entomol 34 1302 1316 Google Scholar Pons, X, Lumbierres, B, López, C, Albajes, R 2004 No effects of Bt maize on Orius majusculus (Heteroptera: Anthocoridae) IOBC/WPRS Bull 27 131 136 Google Scholar Pons, X, Lumbierres, B, López, C, Albajes, R 2005 Abundance of non-target pests in transgenic Bt-maize: a farm scale study Eur J Entomol 102 73 79 Google Scholar Poza, M, Pons, X, Farinós, GP, López, C, Ortego, F, Eizaguirre, M, Castañera, P, Albajes, R 2005 Impact of farm-scale Bt maize on abundance of predatory arthropods in Spain Crop Prot 24 677 684 Google Scholar Prasifka, JR, Hellmich, RL, Dively, GP, Lewis, LC 2005 Assessing the effects of pest management on nontarget arthropods: the influence of plot size and isolation Environ Entomol 34 1181 1192 Google Scholar Raps, A, Kehr, J, Gugerli, P, Moar, WJ, Bigler, F, Hilbeck, A 2001 Immunological analysis of phloem sap of Bacillus thuringiensis corn and of the non target herbivore Rhopalosiphum padi (Homoptera: Aphididae) for the presence of Cry1Ab Mol Ecol 10 525 533 CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar Rauschen, S, Ecker, J, Gathmann, A, Schphan, I 2004 Impact of growing Bt-maize on cicadas: diversity, abundance and methods IOBC/WPRS Bull 27 137 142 Google Scholar
Royal Society of Canada (2001) Elements of precaution: recommendations for the regulation of food biotechnology in Canada. The Royal Society of Canada, Ottawa.
Consulted on June 22, 2005, page 160 and others
Saxena, D, Flores, S, Stotzky, G 2002 Bt toxin is released in root exudates from 12 transgenic corn hybrids representing three transformation events Soil Biol Biochem 34 133 137 Google Scholar Tabashnik, BE 1994 Evolution of resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis Annu Rev Entomol 39 47 79 CrossRef Google Scholar Tabashnik, BE, Cushing, NL, Finson, N, Johnson, MW 1990 Field development of resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis in diamondback moth (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae) J Econ Entomol 83 1671 1676 Google Scholar Vacher, C, Bourguet, D, Rousset, F, Chevillon, C, Hochberg, ME 2003 Modelling the spatial configuration of refuges for a sustainable control of pests: a case study of Bt cotton J Evolution Biol 16 378 387 CrossRef Google Scholar