In the game theory literature, Garrett Hardin’s famous allegory of the “tragedy of the commons” has been modeled as a variant of the Prisoner’s Dilemma, labeled the Herder Problem (or, sometimes, the Commons Dilemma). This brief paper argues that important differences in the institutional structures of the standard Prisoner’s Dilemma and Herder Problem render the two games different in kind. Specifically, institutional impediments to communication and cooperation that ensure a dominant strategy of defection in the classic Prisoner’s Dilemma are absent in the Herder Problem. Their absence does not ensure that players will achieve a welfare-enhancing, cooperative solution to the Herders Problem, but does create far more opportunity for players to alter the expected payoffs through cooperative arrangements. In a properly modeled Herder Problem—along the lines of an assurance game—defection would not always be the dominant strategy. Consequently, the Herder Problem is not in the nature of a Prisoner’s Dilemma.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Alcock J.E. and Mansell D. (1977). Predisposition and behavior in a collective dilemma. Journal of Conflict Resolution 21: 443–457
Axelrod R. (1985). The evolution of cooperation. Basic Books, New York
Baird D.G., Gertner R.H. and Picker R.C. (1994). Game theory and the law. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA
Berkes F. (1992). Success and failure in marine coastal fisheries of Turkey. In: Bromley D.W. (eds). Making the Commons work: Theory, practice, and policy. San Francisco, ICS Press, pp. 161–182
(1992). Making the Commons work: Theory, practice and policy. ICS Press, SanFrancisco
Coase R.H. (1960). The problem of social cost. Journal of Law and Economics 3: 1–44
Cole D.H. (2002). Pollution and property: Comparing ownership institutions for environmental protection. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dahlman C. (1980). The open-field system and beyond: Property rights analysis of an economic institution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dawes R.M. (1973). The Commons dilemma game: An N-Person mixed-motive game with a dominating strategy for defection. ORI Research Bulletin 13: 1–12
Dawes, R. M. (1975). Formal models of dilemmas in social decision making. In M. F. Kaplan & S. Schwartz (Eds.), Human judgment and decision processes: Formal and mathematical approaches (pp. 87–108). New York: Academic Press.
Dixit A. and Nalebuff B. (1991). Thinking strategically: The competitive edge in business, politics and everyday life. Norton, New York
Edney J. (1979). The nuts game: A concise Commons dilemma analog. Environmental Psychology and Nonverbal Behavior 3: 252–254
Farrell J. and Rabin M. (1996). Cheap Talk. Journal of Economic Perspectives 10: 103–118
Feld B.C. (2006). Police interrogation of juveniles: An empirical study of policy and practice. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 97: 219–316
Gardner R. (1995). Games for business and economics. Wiley, New York
Goetze D. (1994). Comparing prisoner’s dilemma, Commons dilemma and public goods provision designs in laboratory experiments. Journal of Conflict Resolution 38: 56–86
Hardin G. (1968). The tragedy of the Commons. Science 162: 1243–1248
Hope C.A. and Stover R.G. (1982). Teaching Sociology 9: 383–399
Inbau F.E. and Reid J.E. (1967). Criminal interrogation and confessions. Williams & Wilkins Co, Baltimore
Laming D. (2003). Understanding human motivation: What makes people tick?. Wiley-Blackwell, Boston
Mailath G.J. and Samuelson L. (2006). Repeated games and reputations: Long-run relationships. Oxford University Press, Oxford
(1987). The question of the Commons: The culture and ecology of communal resources. University of Arizona Press, Tucson
North D.C. (1990). Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ostrom E. (1990). Governing the Commons. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ostrom E. and Gardner R. (1993). Coping with asymmetries in the Commons: Self-governing irrigation systems can work. Journal of Economic Perspectives 7: 93–112
Ostrom E., Gardner R. and Walker J. (1994). Rules, games, and common-pool resources. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor
Ostrom E. and Nagendra H. (2006). Insights on linking forests, trees and people from the air, on the ground, and in the laboratory. PNAS 103: 19224–19231
Ostrom E., Walker J. and Gardner R. (1992). Covenants with and without a sword: Self-governance is possible. American Political Science Review 86: 404–417
Pearce D.W. and Warford J.J. (1993). World without end: Economics, environment and sustainable development. Oxford University Press, New York
Poundstone W. (1992). Prisoner’s dilemma. Doubleday, New York
Rapoport A. and Chammah A.M. (1965). Prisoner’s dilemma. University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor
Richards D. (2001). Reciprocity and shared knowledge structures in a prisoner’s dilemma game. Journal of Conflict Resolution 45: 621–635
Sen A.K. (1967). Isolation, assurance and the social rate of discount. Quarterly Journal of Economics 81: 112–124
Schelling T.C. (1960). The strategy of conflict. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Skryms B. (2003). The stag hunt and the evolution of social structure. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
The Staff of the Law-Medicine Center. (1962). Psychology of interrogation. In S. R. Gerber & O. Schroder, Jr. (Eds.), Criminal investigation and interrogation (pp. 247–285). Cincinnati: W.H. Anderson Co.
About this article
Cite this article
Cole, D.H., Grossman, P.Z. Institutions matter! Why the Herder Problem is not a Prisoner’s Dilemma. Theory Decis 69, 219–231 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11238-008-9121-3
- Game theory
- Prisoner’s Dilemma
- Herder Problem
- Stag hunt
- Assurance game
- Tragedy of the commons