Abstract
This article is a response to Barbara Forrest’ 2011 Synthese article, “On the Non-Epistemology of Intelligent Design.” Forrest offers an account of my philosophical work that consists almost entirely of personal attacks, excursions into my religious pilgrimage, and misunderstandings and misrepresentations of my work as well as of certain philosophical issues. Not surprisingly, the Synthese editors include a disclaimer in the front matter of the special issue in which Forrest’s article was published. In my response, I address three topics: (1) My interest in Intelligent Design (ID) and public education and why as a Thomist I have grown more skeptical and explicitly critical of ID over the years, (2) the sorts of philosophical mistakes with which Forrest’s article is teeming, and (3) my Christian faith, religious exclusivism, and interfaith dialogue.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aquinas, T. (1920). Summa theologica (Fathers of the English Dominican Province, trans., 2nd, revised, online edn.). Retrieved January 31, 2011, from http://www.newadvent.org/summa/index.html.
Aquinas, T. (1999). On human nature. In T. S. Hibbs (Ed.), Indianapolis: Hackett.
Aristotle. (1986). De anima (on the soul) (H. Lawson-Tancred, trans.). New York: Penguin Books.
Ashley B., Moraczewksi B. (1994) Is the biological subject of human rights present from conception?. In: Cataldo P. J., Moraczewski A. (eds) The fetal tissue issue: Medical and ethical aspects. Pope John Center, Braintree, MA, pp 33–60
Barr S. (2006) The miracle of evolution. First Things 160: 30–33
Beckwith F. J. (1985) Baha’i. Bethany House, Minneapolis
Beckwith, F. J. (1988–1989). Utilitarian arguments, abortion rights, and Justice Blackmun’s dissent in Webster: Some philosophical observations. In Simon Greenleaf Review of Law and Religion: A Scholarly Forum Interrelating Law, Theology and Human Rights, 8, 5–24.
Beckwith F. J. (1989) David Hume’s argument against miracles: A critical analysis. University Press of America, Lanham, MD
Beckwith F. J. (1992a) Personal bodily rights, abortion, and unplugging the violinist. International Philosophical Quarterly 32(1): 105–118
Beckwith F. J. (1992b) Abortion. In: Harrison R. K. (eds) Encyclopedia of Biblical and Christian ethics. Revised edition. Thomas Nelson, Nashville, pp 3–4
Beckwith F. J. (1992c) Civil rights. In: Harrison R. K. (eds) Encyclopedia of Biblical and Christian ethics. Revised edition. Thomas Nelson, Nashville, pp 73–75
Beckwith F. J. (1992d) Euthanasia. In: Harrison R. K. (eds) Encyclopedia of Biblical and Christian ethics. Revised edition. Thomas Nelson, Nashville, pp 138–139
Beckwith F. J. (1994) Separation of guru and state? The influence of New Age thinking on public education. In: Bauman M., Hall D. W. (eds) God and Caesar. Christian Publications, Camp Hill, PA, pp 285–317
Beckwith F. J. (1995a) From personhood to autonomy: The shifting legal focus in the abortion debate. In: Cameron N., Schiedermayer D., Kilner J. (eds) Bioethics and the future of medicine. Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, MI, pp 187–198
Beckwith F. J. (1995b) Pluralism, tolerance, and abortion rights. In: McKenna G., Feingold S. (eds) Taking sides: Clashing views on controversial political issues (9th ed.) McGraw-Hill, New York, pp 272–277
Beckwith F. J. (1996) The ethics of referral kickbacks and self-referral and the HMO physician as gatekeeper: An ethical analysis. Journal of Social Philosophy 28(3): 41–48
Beckwith F. J. (1999a) The “nobody deserves his or her talents argument for affirmative action”: A critical analysis. Social Theory and Practice 25(1): 53–60
Beckwith F. J. (1999b) Disagreement without debate: The Republican party platform and the human life amendment plank. Nexus: A Journal of Opinion 4: 113–133
Beckwith F. J. (2000) Is statecraft soulcraft? Faith, politics, and legal neutrality. In: Cameron N., Daniels S., White B. (eds) Bioengagement: Making a Christian difference through bioethics today. Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, MI, pp 113–131
Beckwith F. J. (2001a) Law, religion, and the metaphysics of abortion: A reply to Simmons. Journal of Church and State 43(1): 19–33
Beckwith F. J. (2001b) Mormon theism, the traditional Christian concept of God, and Greek philosophy: A critical analysis. Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 44(4): 671–695
Beckwith F. J. (2002) Cloning and reproductive liberty. Nevada Law Journal 3(1): 61–87
Beckwith F. J. (2003a) Law, Darwinism, and public education: The establishment clause and the challenge of intelligent design. Rowman and Littlefield, New York
Beckwith F. J. (2003b) Public education, religious establishment, and the challenge of intelligent design. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics, and Public Policy 17(2): 461–519
Beckwith F. J. (2003c) Science and religion twenty years after McLean v. Arkansas: Evolution, public education, and the new challenge of intelligent design. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 26(2): 455–499
Beckwith F. J. (2003d) When you come to a fork in the road, take it? Abortion, personhood, and the jurisprudence of neutrality. Journal of Church and State 44(3): 485–487
Beckwith F. J. (2004) Thomson’s “equal reasonableness” argument for abortion rights: A critique. American Journal of Jurisprudence 49: 118–134
Beckwith, F. J. (2004–2005). Rawls’s dangerous idea? Liberalism, evolution and the legal requirement of religious neutrality in public schools. Journal of Law and Religion, 20(2), 423–458.
Beckwith F. J. (2005a) Gimme that ol’ time separation: A review essay. Chapman Law Review 8(1): 309–327
Beckwith F. J. (2005b) Sects in the city: Mormonism and the philosophical perils of being a missionary faith. Southern Baptist Journal of Theology 9(2): 14–30
Beckwith F. J. (2005c) Arguments from bodily rights: A critical analysis. In: Boonin D., Oddie G. (eds) What’s wrong? Applied ethicists and their critics. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 108–114
Beckwith F. J. (2006a) It’s the epistemology, stupid! science, public schools, and what counts as knowledge. In: Dembski W. A. (eds) Darwin’s nemesis: Phillip Johnson and the intelligent design movement. IVP Academic, Downers Grove, IL, pp 105–116
Beckwith F. J. (2006b) Taking theology seriously: The status of the religious beliefs of judicial nominees for the federal bench. Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics, and Public Policy 20(1): 455–471
Beckwith F. J. (2006c) The court of disbelief: The constitution’s article VI religious test prohibition and the judiciary’s religious motive analysis. Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 33(2,3): 337–360
Beckwith F. J. (2006d) Defending abortion philosophically: A review of David Boonin’s a defense of abortion. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 31: 177–203
Beckwith F. J. (2007a) Defending life: A moral and legal case against abortion choice. Cambridge University Press, New York
Beckwith F. J. (2007b) Dawson, Joseph Martin. In: Finkelman Paul (eds) Encyclopedia of American civil liberties. Taylor and Francis, New York, pp 397–398
Beckwith F. J. (2007c) Edwards v. Aguillard 382 U.S. 578 (1987). In: Finkelman Paul (eds) Encyclopedia of American civil liberties. Taylor and Francis, New York, pp 480–482
Beckwith F. J. (2007d) Epperson v. Arkansas 393 U.S. 97 (1968). In: Finkelman Paul (eds) Encyclopedia of American civil liberties. Taylor and Francis, New York, pp 511–512
Beckwith F. J. (2007e) Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 112 S. Ct. 2791 (1992). In: Finkelman Paul (eds) Encyclopedia of American civil liberties. Taylor and Francis, New York, pp 1174–1175
Beckwith, F. J. (2007f). When the saint goes swearing in. In First things. Online, May 24, 2007. Retrieved February 1, 2011, from http://www.firstthings.com/onthesquare/2007/05/when-the-saints-goes-swearing-.
Beckwith F. J. (2007g) Bioethics, the Christian citizen, and the pluralist game. Christian bioethics 13: 159–170
Beckwith, F. J. (2008–2009). Must theology sit in the back of secular bus? The federal courts’ view of religion and its status as knowledge. Journal of Law and Religion, 24(2), 547–568.
Beckwith F. J. (2009a) Return to Rome: Confessions of an Evangelical Catholic. Brazos Press, Grand Rapids, MI
Beckwith F. J. (2009b) Faith, reason, and the Christian university: What John Paul II can teach Christian academics. Logos: A Journal of Catholic Thought and Culture 12(3): 53–67
Beckwith F. J. (2009c) The courts, natural rights, and religious claims as knowledge. Santa Clara Law Review 49(2): 429–458
Beckwith F. J. (2009d) Carey v. population services international (1977). In: Hudson D. L., Schultz D. A., Vile J. R. (eds) Encyclopedia of the first amendment. Congressional Quarterly Press, Washington, D.C.
Beckwith F. J. (2009e) Mount healthy city school Dist. Bd. Of Educ. v. Doyle (1977). In: Hudson D. L., Schultz D. A., Vile J. R. (eds) Encyclopedia of the first amendment. Congressional Quarterly Press, Washington, D.C.
Beckwith F. J. (2009f) McGowan v. Maryland (1961). In: Hudson D. L., Schultz D. A., Vile J. R. (eds) Encyclopedia of the first amendment. Congressional Quarterly Press, Washington, D.C.
Beckwith F. J. (2009g) Meek v. Pittenger (1975). In: Hudson D. L., Schultz D. A., Vile J. R. (eds) Encyclopedia of the first amendment. Congressional Quarterly Press, Washington D.C.
Beckwith, F. J. (2009–2010). How to be an anti-intelligent design advocate. University of St. Thomas Journal of Law and Public Policy 4(1), 35–65.
Beckwith F. J. (2010a) Guidance for doting and peeping Thomists: A review essay of Aquinas: A Beginner’s guide. Philosophia Christi 12(2): 429–439
Beckwith F. J. (2010b) Politics for Christians: Statecraft as soulcraft. InterVarsity, Downers Grove, IL
Beckwith, F. J. (2010c). Intelligent design, Thomas Aquinas, and the ubiquity of final causes. BioLogos Foundation, 22 May 2010. Retrieved January 30, 2011, from http://biologos.org/uploads/projects/beckwith_scholarly_essay.pdf.
Beckwith F. J. (2010d) Dignity never been photographed: Scientific materialism, enlightenment liberalism, and Steven Pinker. Ethics and medicine: An international journal of bioethics 26(2): 93–110
Beckwith, F. J. (2010e). Arguments from bodily rights: A critical analysis. In L. Vaughn (Ed.), Contemporary moral arguments: Readings in ethical issues (pp. 200–207). New York: Oxford University Press.
Beckwith F. J. (2010f) Politics, Evangelicals, and the unavoidability of metaphysics. In: Ryden David K. (eds) Is the good book good enough? Evangelical perspectives public policy. Lexington books, Lanham, MD, pp 225–235
Beckwith, F. J. (2011a). The human being, a person of substance: A response to Dean Stretton, In S. Napier (Ed.), Persons, moral worth, and embryos: A critical analysis of pro-choice arguments from philosophy, law, and science. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Beckwith, F. J. (2011b). Mormonism, natural law, and constitutional democracy: Reflections on the Romney candidacy. In J. Baker (Ed.), Sowing the fields of peacemakers: Essays on Mormon philosophy and theology in honor of David L. Paulsen. Draper, UT: Kofford Books.
Beckwith, F. J. (2012a) Bork, Robert. In D. L. Hudson & J. R. Vile (Eds.), Encyclopedia of the fourth amendment. Washington, DC.: Congressional Quarterly Press.
Beckwith, F. J. (2012b). Comstock act. In D. L. Hudson & J. R. Vile (Eds.), Encyclopedia of the Fourth Amendment. Washington, DC.: Congressional Quarterly Press.
Beckwith, F. J. (2012c). Greenawalt, Ken. In D. L. Hudson & J. R. Vile (Eds.), Encyclopedia of the fourth amendment. Washington, DC.: Congressional Quarterly Press.
Beckwith, F. J. (2012d). Posner, Richard. In D. L. Hudson & J. R. Vile (Eds.), Encyclopedia of the fourth amendment. Washington, DC.: Congressional Quarterly Press.
Beckwith, F. J., Jones, T. (eds) (1997) Affirmative action: Social justice or reverse discrimination?. Prometheus books, Amherst, NY
Beckwith, F. J., & Laycock, D. (2005, September 26). Is teaching intelligent design legal? In Legal affairs. Retrieved January 30, 2011, from http://www.legalaffairs.org/webexclusive/debateclub_id0905.msp.
Beckwith, F. J., Mosser, C., Owen, P. (eds) (2002) The new Mormon challenge: Responding to the latest defenses of a fast-growing movement. Zondervan, Grand Rapids, MI
Beckwith F.J., Parrish S.E. (1991) The Mormon concept of God: A philosophical analysis. Studies in American religion. (Vol. 55). Edwin Mellen Press, Lewiston, NY
Beckwith F. J., Peppin J. (2000) Physician-value neutrality: A critique. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics 28(1): 67–77
Beckwith, F. J., Pojman, L. P. (eds) (1998) The abortion controversy 25 years after Roe v. Wade: A Reader (2nd ed.). Wadsworth, Belmont, CA
Behe M. (1996) Darwin’s black box. The Free Press, New York
Boonin D. (2002) A defense of abortion. Cambridge University Press, New York
Branch, G., & Fetzer, J. H. (Eds.). (2011). Evolution and its rivals [Special issue]. Synthese, 179(1).
Budziszewski J. (2009) The line through the heart: Natural law as fact, theory, and sign of contradiction. ISI Books, Wilmington, DE
Carroll W. E. (2000) Creation, evolution, and Thomas Aquinas. Revue des Questions Scientifiques 171: 319–347
Carroll W. E. (2006) At the mercy of chance? Evolution and the Catholic tradition. Revue des Questions Scientifiques 177: 179–204
Colb, S. F. (2001). A creeping theocracy: How the U.S. Government uses its power to enforce religious principles. FindLaw’s Writ. Retrieved January 31, 2011, from http://writ.news.findlaw.com/colb/20011121.html.
Craig W. L. (1979) The kalam cosmological argument. Macmillan, London
Dembski W. A. (1998) The design inference. Cambridge University Press, New York
Dembski W. A. (2001) No free lunch. Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD
Feser E. (2008) The last superstition. St. Augustine’s Press, South Bend, IN
Fisher A. (1991) When did I begin? revisited. Linacre Quarterly 58: 59–68
Forrest B. (2000) The possibility of meaning in human evolution. Zygon 35(4): 861–880
Forrest B. (2011) The non-epistemology of intelligent design: The implications for public policy. Synthese 178(2): 331–379
Gage L. P. (2010) Darwin, design and Thomas Aquinas: The mythical conflict between Thomism and intelligent design. Touchstone 23(6): 37–44
George M. I. (2002) On attempts to salvage Paley’s argument from design. In: O’Callaghan John (eds) Science, philosophy, and theology. St. Augustine’s Press, South Bend, IN
George R. P., Tollefsen C. (2008) Embryo: A defense of human life. Doubleday, New York
Gilson E. (2009) From Aristotle to Darwin and back again: A journey in final causality, species, and evolution. Originally published in English, 1984. Ignatius Press, San Francisco
Haldane J., Lee P. (2003) Aquinas on human ensoulment, abortion and the value of life. Philosophy 78: 255–278
John Paul II. (1995). Evangelium vitae: The gospel of life: On the value and inviolability of human life. Washington, DC: U. S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Kaczor C. (2010) The ethics of abortion: Women’s rights, human life, and the question of justice. Routledge, New York
Lee P. (2004) The pro-life argument from substantial identity: A defense. Bioethics 18: 249–263
Lee P. (2010) Abortion and unborn human life (2nd ed.). The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, DC
McLaren A. (1982) The embryo. In: Austin C. R., Shorts R. V. (eds) Reproduction in mammals, book 2: Embryonic and fetal development. (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 1–25
Machuga R. (2002) In defense of the soul. Brazos Press, Grand Rapids, MI
Mere Creation. (1996). Mere creation: Reclaiming the book of nature conference on design and origins, 14–17 November 1996. Retrieved January 28, 2011, from http://www.origins.org/mc/menus/sched.html.
Moreland J. P. (2009) Consciousness and the existence of God. Routledge, New York
Mormonism and American Politics. (2007). Conference at Princeton University. Sponsored by Princeton’s Center for the Study or Religion, November 9–10, 2007. Retrieved February 1, 2011, from http://www.princeton.edu/~csrelig/mormonism&politics.
National Bioethics Advisory Commission: (1999) Ethical issues in human stem cell research: Report and recommendations of the national bioethics advisory commission. National Bioethics Advisory Commission, Rockville, MD
National Institutes of Health. (2011). Stem cell basics. Retrieved January 31, 2011, from http://stemcells.nih.gov/info/basics/basics1.
Oderberg D. S. (2007) Real essentialism. Routledge, New York
PhilPapers Surveys. (2009). Retrieved January 25, 2011, from http://philpapers.org/surveys/results.pl.
Pinker S. (2008) The stupidity of dignity. The New Republic 238(9): 28–31
Plantinga A. (1993) Warrant and proper function. Oxford University Press, New York
Rawls J. (1993) Political liberalism. Columbia University Press, Columbia
Ryland M. (2009) Intelligent design theory. In: Fastiggi Robert L. (eds) New Catholic encyclopedia supplement 2009. Gale, Detroit, pp 470–478
Sayre-McCord, G. (2009). Moral realism. Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Retrieved January 27, 2011, from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-realism/.
State Board of Education: (2004) Science framework for California public schools kindergarten through grade twelve. California Department of Education, Sacramento
Stoljar, D. (2009). Physicalism. Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Retrieved February 5, 2011 from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/physicalism/.
Tkacz M. W. (2007) Thomas Aquinas vs the intelligent designers: What is God’s finger doing in my pre-biotic soup?. In: Baird R. M., Rosenbaum S. E. (eds) Intelligent design: Science or religion?. Prometheus Books, Amherst, NY
Tooley M. (1983) Abortion and infanticide. New York, Oxford
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Beckwith, F.J. Or we can be philosophers: a response to Barbara Forrest. Synthese 192 (Suppl 1), 3–25 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-011-9891-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-011-9891-y