Intelligent design advocate William Dembski has introduced a measure of information called “complex specified information”, or CSI. He claims that CSI is a reliable marker of design by intelligent agents. He puts forth a “Law of Conservation of Information” which states that chance and natural laws are incapable of generating CSI. In particular, CSI cannot be generated by evolutionary computation. Dembski asserts that CSI is present in intelligent causes and in the flagellum of Escherichia coli, and concludes that neither have natural explanations. In this paper, we examine Dembski’s claims, point out significant errors in his reasoning, and conclude that there is no reason to accept his assertions.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT for USA
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.
Adami C., Ofria C., Collier T.C. (2000) Evolution of biological complexity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 97: 4463–4468
Apostolico, A., & Lonardi, S. (2000). Compression of biological sequences by greedy off-line textual substitution. In Proceedings of the IEEE data compression conference (DCC), pp. 143–152.
Berlekamp E.R., Conway J.H., Guy R.K. (1982) Winning ways, for your mathematical plays. Academic Press, London
Boyer P. (2001) Religion explained. Basic Books, New York
Byl J. (1989) Self-reproduction in small cellular automata. Physica D 34: 295–299
Catania A.C., Cutts D. (1963) Experimental control of superstitious responding in humans. Journal of Experimental Analysis of Behavior 6: 203–208
Chaitin G. (1974) Information-theoretic limitations of formal systems. Journal of the Association for Computing Machinery 21: 403–424
Channon, A. (2001). Passing the ALife test: Activity statistics classify evolution in Geb as unbounded. In J. Kelemen & P. Sosík (Eds.), Proceedings of the 6th European conference on advances in artificial life (ECAL 2001), Vol. 2159 of Lecture notes in artificial intelligence (pp. 417–426). Berlin: Springer.
Chen, X., Kwong, S., & Li, M. (1999). A compression algorithm for DNA sequences and its applications in genome comparison. In Proceedings of the 10th workshop on genome informatics, pp. 52–61.
Dembski W.A. (1998) The design inference: Eliminating chance through small probabilities. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Dembski W.A. (1999) Intelligent design: The bridge between science & theology. InterVarsity Press, Illinois
Dembski W.A. (2002) No free lunch: Why specified complexity cannot be purchased without intelligence. Rowman & Littlefield, Ianham, MD
Dembski W.A. (2004) The design revolution: Answering the toughest questions about intelligent design. InterVarsity Press, Illinois
Dinsmore A.D., Wong D.T., Nelson P., Yodh A.G. (1998) Hard spheres in vesicles: Curvature-induced forces and particle-induced curvature. Physical Review Letters 80: 409–412
Edis T. (2001) Darwin in mind: ‘Intelligent design’ meets artificial intelligence. Skeptical Inquirer 25(2): 35–39
Elsberry W., Shallit J. (2003) Eight challenges for intelligent design advocates. Reports of the NCSE 23(5–6): 23–25
Elsberry W., Shallit J. (2004) Playing games with probability: Dembski’s complex specified information. In: Young M., Edis T. (eds) Why intelligent design fails. Rutgers University Press, Piscataway, NJ, pp 121–138
Fitelson B., Stephens C., Sober E. (1999) How not to detect design—critical notice: William A. Dembski, the design inference. Philosophy of Science 66: 472–488
Forrest B., Gross P.R. (2004) Creationism’s Trojan horse: The wedge of intelligent design. Oxford University Press, New York
Gajardo A., Moreira A., Goles E. (2002) Complexity of Langton’s ant. Discrete Applied Mathematics 117: 41–50
Glicksman E. (1984) Free dendritic growth. Materials Science and Engineering 65: 45
Göbel, F. (1979). On the number of Hamiltonian cycles in product graphs. Technical report # 289. Technische Hogeschool Twente, Netherlands.
Godfrey-Smith P. (2001) Information and the argument from design. In: Pennock R.T. (eds) Intelligent design creationism and its critics. The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 577–596
Goles E., Margenstern M. (1996) Sand pile as a universal computer. International Journal of Modern Physics C 7(2): 113–122
Goles E., Schulz O., Markus M. (2001) Prime number selection of cycles in a predator-prey model. Complexity 6(4): 33–38. http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/fulltext?ID=84502365&PLACEBO=IE.pdf.
Grumbach S., Tahi F. (1994) A new challenge for compression algorithms: Genetic sequences. Information Processing and Management 30: 875–886
Heeren F. (2000) The deed is done. American Spectator 33(10): 28–29
Heltzer R.A., Vyse S.A. (1994) Intermittent consequences and problem solving: The experimental control of “superstitious” beliefs. Psychological Record 44: 155–169
Hewish A., Bell S.J., Pilkington J.D.H., Scott P.F., Collins R.A. (1968) Observation of a rapidly pulsating radio source. Nature 217: 709–713
Hirvensalo M. (2001) Quantum computing. Springer, Berlin
Kahneman D., Slovic P., Tversky A. (1982) Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kaplan P.D., Rouke J.L., Yodh A.G., Pine D.J. (1994) Entropically driven surface phase separation in binary colloidal mixtures. Physical Review Letters 72: 582–585
Kari L. (1997) DNA computing: Arrival of biological mathematics. Mathematical Intelligencer 19(2): 9–22
Kessler M.A., Werner B.T. (2003) Self-organization of sorted patterned ground. Science 299: 380–383
Kestenbaum D. (1998) Gentle force of entropy bridges disciplines. Science 279: 1849
Keynes J.M. (1957) A treatise on probability. Macmillan, London
Kirchherr W., Li M., Vitányi P. (1997) The miraculous universal distribution. Mathematical Intelligencer 19(4): 7–15. http://www.cwi.nl/paulv/papers/mathint97.ps.
Koons R.C. (2001) Remarks while introducing Dembski’s talk at the conference Design, self-organization and the integrity of creation. Calvin College, Grand Rapids, Michigan
Koza J.R. (1994) Artificial life: Spontaneous emergence of self-replicating and evolutionary self-improving computer programs. In: Langton C.G. (eds) Artificial life III.. Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, CA, pp 225–262
Kuhnert L., Agladze K.I., Krinsky V.I. (1989) Image processing using light-sensitive chemical waves. Nature 337: 244–247
Lanctot, J. K., Li, M., & Yang, E. (2000). Estimating DNA sequence entropy. In Proceedings of the 11th ACM-SIAM symposium on discrete algorithms (SODA), pp. 409–418.
Laplace P.S. (1952) A philosophical essay on probabilities. Dover, New York
Lenski R.E., Ofria C., Pennock R.T., Adami C. (2003) The evolutionary origin of complex features. Nature 423: 139–145
Li M. (2002) Compressing DNA sequences. In: Jiang T., Xu Y., Zhang M.Q. (eds) Current topics in computational molecular biology. The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 157–171
Lipson H., Pollack J.B. (2000) Automatic design and manufacture of robotic lifeforms. Nature 406: 974–978
Medawar P.B. (1984) The limits of science. Harper & Row, New York
Meyer S.C. (2000) DNA and other designs. First Things 102: 30–38
Olofsson P. (2007) Intelligent design and mathematical statistics: a troubled alliance. Biology and Philosophy 23(4): 545–553
Pallen M.J., Matzke N.J. (2006) From the origin of species to the origin of bacterial flagella. Nature Reviews Microbiology 4(10): 784–790
Perakh M. (2004) Unintelligent design. Prometheus, New York
Pigliucci M. (2000) Chance, necessity, and the new holy war against science. A review of W. A. Dembski’s the design inference. BioScience 50: 79–81
Pigliucci M. (2001) Design yes, intelligent no: A critique of intelligent design theory and neocreationism. Skeptical Inquirer 25(5): 34–39
Rambidi N.G., Yakovenchuk D. (2001) Chemical reaction-diffusion implementation of finding the shortest paths in a labyrinth. Physical Review E 63: 026607
Ray T. (1994) Evolution, complexity, entropy, and artificial reality. Physica D 75: 239–263
Ray, T. (2001). Evolution of complexity: Tissue differentiation in network Tierra. http://www.isd.atr.co.jp/ray/pubs/atrjournal/index.html.
Rizzotti M. (2000) Early evolution: From the appearance of the first cell to the first modern organisms. Birkhäuser, Boston
Roche D. (2001) A bit confused: Creationism and information theory. Skeptical Inquirer 25(2): 40–42
Rothemund, P. W. K., & Winfree, E. (2000). The program-size complexity of self-assembled squares. In Proceedings of the thirty-second annual ACM symposium on theory of computing, pp. 459–468. ACM.
Rudski J.M., Lischner M.I., Albert L.M. (1999) Superstitious rule generation is affected by probability and type of outcome. Psychological Record 49: 245–260
Sainsbury R.M. (1995) Paradoxes (2nd ed). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Schmitt A.O., Herzel H. (1997) Estimating the entropy of DNA sequences. Journal of Theoretical Biology 188: 369–377
Schneider, T. D. (2001). Rebuttal to William A. Dembski’s posting. http://www.lecb.ncifcrf.gov/toms/paper/ev/dembski/rebuttal.html.
Shallit J. (2002) Review of William Dembski, no free lunch. BioSystems 66: 93–99
Shallit, J. (2004). Dembski’s mathematical achievements. Retrieved May 12 2004, from http://www.pandasthumb.org/pt-archives/000207.html.
Shannon C. (1950) Prediction and entropy of printed English. Bell System Technical Journal 3: 50–64
Sims K. (1994) Evolving 3D morphology and behavior by competition. In: Brooks R.A., Maes P. (eds) Artificial life IV: Proceedings of the fourth international workshop on the synthesis and simulation of living systems. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp 28–39
Steinbock O., Tóth A., Showalter K. (1995) Navigating complex labyrinths: Optimal paths from chemical waves. Science 267: 868–871
Wein, R. (2000). What’s wrong with the design inference. http://www.metanexus.net/metanexus_online/show_article2.asp?id=2654.
Wilkins J., Elsberry W. (2001) The advantages of theft over toil: The design inference and arguing from ignorance. Biology and Philosophy 16: 711–724. ftp://ftp.wehi.edu.au/pub/wilkinsftp/dembski.pdf.
Yelen D.R. (1971) The acquisition and extinction of superstitious behavior. Journal of Experimental Research in Personality 5: 1–6
Young M., Edis T. (eds) (2004) Why intelligent design fails. Rutgers University Press, Piscataway, NJ
About this article
Cite this article
Elsberry, W., Shallit, J. Information theory, evolutionary computation, and Dembski’s “complex specified information”. Synthese 178, 237–270 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-009-9542-8
- Information theory
- Evolutionary computation
- Artificial life
- Complex specified information