Descriptive accounts of the nature of explanation in neuroscience and the global goals of such explanation have recently proliferated in the philosophy of neuroscience (e.g., Bechtel, Mental mechanisms: Philosophical perspectives on cognitive neuroscience. New York: Lawrence Erlbaum, 2007; Bickle, Philosophy and neuroscience: A ruthlessly reductive account. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishing, 2003; Bickle, Synthese, 151, 411–434, 2006; Craver, Explaining the brain: Mechanisms and the mosaic unity of neuroscience. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007) and with them new understandings of the experimental practices of neuroscientists have emerged. In this paper, I consider two models of such practices; one that takes them to be reductive; another that takes them to be integrative. I investigate those areas of the neuroscience of learning and memory from which the examples used to substantiate these models are culled, and argue that the multiplicity of experimental protocols used in these research areas presents specific challenges for both models. In my view, these challenges have been overlooked largely because philosophers have hitherto failed to pay sufficient attention to fundamental features of experimental practice. I demonstrate that when we do pay attention to such features, evidence for reduction and integrative unity in neuroscience is simply not borne out. I end by suggesting some new directions for the philosophy of neuroscience that pertain to taking a closer look at the nature of neuroscientific experiments.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Aizawa K. (2007) The biochemistry of memory consolidation: A model system for the philosophy of mind. Synthese 155: 65–98
Bechtel W. (2007) Mental mechanisms: Philosophical perspectives on cognitive neuroscience. Lawrence Erlbaum, New York
Bechtel W., Stufflebeam R.S. (2001). Epistemic issues in procuring evidence about the brain: The importance of research instruments and techniques. In: Bechtel W., Mandik P., Mundale J., Stufflebeam R.S. (Eds). Philosophy and the neurosciences: A reader. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 55–81
Bickle J. (1998) Psychoneural reduction: The new wave. MIT Press, Cambridge
Bickle J. (2003) Philosophy and neuroscience: A ruthlessly reductive account. Kluwer Academic Publishing, Dordrecht
Bickle J. (2006) Reducing mind to molecular pathways: Explicating the reductionism implicit in current cellular and molecular neuroscience. Synthese 151: 411–434
Bickle J. (2007) Ruthless reductionism and social cognition. Journal of Physiology-Paris 101: 230–235
Bielsky I., Hu S., Ren X., Terwilliger E., Young L. (2005) The V1a vasopressin receptor is necessary and sufficient for normal social recognition: A gene replacement study. Neuron 47: 503–513
Bliss T., Lømo T. (1973) Long-lasting potentiation of synaptic transmission in the dentate area of the anaesthetized rabbit following stimulation of the perforant path. Journal of Physiology 232(2): 331–356
Bogen J. (2002) Epistemological custard pies from functional brain imaging. Philosophy of Science 69: S59–S71
Bogen J., Woodward J. (1988) Saving the phenomena. The Philosophical Review 97: 303–352
Bronfenbrenner U. (1979) The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Brunswick E. (1943) Organismic achievement and environmental probability. The Psychological Review 50: 255–272
Campbell D.D., Stanley J. (1963) Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research. Rand-McNally, Chicago
Cartwright N. (1991) Replicability, reproducibility and robustness: Comments on collins. History of Political Economy 23(1): 143–155
Cartwright N. (1999) The dappled world: A study of the boundaries of science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Churchland P.S. (1982) Mind brain reduction—new light from the philosophy of science. Neuroscience 7(5): 1041–1047
Cook T.D., Campbell D.D. (1979) Quasi-experimentation: Design and analysis issues for field settings. Rand-McNally, Chicago
Craver C. (2001) Role functions, mechanisms and hierarchy. Philosophy of Science 68: 31–55
Craver C. (2002) Interlevel experiments and multilevel mechanisms in the neuroscience of memory. Philosophy of Science Supplement 69: S83–S97
Craver C. (2003) The making of a memory mechanism. Journal of the History of Biology 36: 153–195
Craver C. (2007) Explaining the brain: Mechanisms and the mosaic unity of neuroscience. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Craver C., Darden L. (2001) Discovering mechanisms in neurobiology: The case of spatial memory. In: Machamer P.K., Grush R., McLaughlin P.(eds) Theory and method in the neurosciences. University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh
Cronbach L., Meehl P. (1955) Construct validity in psychological tests. Psychological Bulletin 52: 281–302
Dudek, S., & Fields, R. D. (2001). Mitogen-activated protein kinase/Extracellular signal-regulated kinase activation in somatodendritic compartments: Roles of action potentials, frequency, and mode of calcium entry. The Journal of Neuroscience, 21, RC122.
English J.D., Sweatt J.D. (1996) Activation of p42 mitogen-activated protein kinase in hippocampal long-term potentiation. Journal of Biological Chemistry 271(40): 24329–24332
English J.D., Sweatt J.D. (1997) A requirement for the mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade in hippocampal long term potentiation. Journal of Biological Chemistry 272(31): 19103–19106
Feest, U. (2003). Operationism, experimentation, and concept formation. Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh.
Ferguson J., Aldag M., Insel T., Young L. (2001) Oxytocin in the medial amygdala is essential for social recognition in the mouse. Journal of Neuroscience 21(20): 8278–8285
Ferguson J.N., Young L.J., Insel T.R. (2002) The neuroendocrine basis of social recognition. Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology 23: 200–224
Franklin A. (1986) The neglect of experiment. Cambridge University Press, New York
Franklin A. (1999) Can that be right?: Essays on experiment, evidence, and science. Kluwer, Boston
Giovannini M., Blitzer R., Wong T., Asoma K., Tsokas P., Morrison J., Iyengar R., Landau E. (2001) Mitogen-activated protein kinase regulates early phosphorylation and delayed expression of Ca2+ Calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II in long-term potentiation. Journal of Neuroscience 21(18): 7053–7062
Goldman A. (1988) Epistemology and cognition. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Guala F. (2003) Experimental localism and external validity. Philosophy of Science Supplement 70: 1195–1205
Guala F. (2005) The methodology of experimental economics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hacking I. (1983) Representing and intervening. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hacking I. (1992) The self-vindication of the laboratory sciences. In: Pickering A.(eds) Science as practice and culture. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Hummler, E., Cole, T., Blendy, J., Ganss, R., Aguzzi, A., Schmid, W., Beerman, F., & Schutz, G. (1994). Targeted mutation of the CREB gene: Compensation within the CREB/ATF family of transcription factors. In Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA (Vol. 91, pp. 5647–5651).
Impey S., Obrietan K., Storm D.R. (1999) Making new connections: Role of ERK/MAP kinase signaling in neuronal plasticity. Neuron 23: 11–14
Kogan J.H., Frankland P.W., Blendy J.A., Coblentz J., Marowitz Z., Shüz G., Silva A.J. (1997) Spaced training induces normal long-term memory in CREB mutant mice. Current Biology 7(1): 1–11
Kogan J.H., Frankland P.W., Silva A.J. (2000) Long-term memory underlying hippocampus- dependent social recognition in mice. Hippocampus 10(1): 47–56
Latour B. (1988) The pateurization of France. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Loorende Jong H. (2006) Explicating pluralism: Where the mind to molecular pathway gets off-track. Synthese 151(3): 435–443
Mayo D. (1991) Novel evidence and severe tests. Philosophy of Science 58: 523–552
Mayo D. (1996) Error and the growth of experimental knowledge. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Mayo D. (2000) Experimental practice and an error statistical account of evidence. Philosophy of Science 67(3): S193–S207
Messick S. (1989) Validity. In: Linn R.L.(eds) Educational measurement, 3rd ed. Macmillan, New York, pp 13–103
Mitchell S. (2003) Biological complexity and integrative pluralism. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Mitchell S., Dietrich M. (2006) Integration without unification: An argument for pluralism in the biological sciences. American Naturalist 168: S73–S79
Nagel E. (1961) The structure of science: Problems in the logic of scientific explanation. Harcourt, Brace and World, New York
Richter K., Wolf G., Engelmann M. (2005) Social recognition memory requires two stages of protein synthesis in mice. Learning and Memory 12: 407–413
Schouten M., Loorende Jong H. (2005) Ruthless reductionism. Philosophical Psychology 18(4): 473–486
Selcher J.C., Weeber E.J., Christian J., Nekrasova T., Landreth G., Sweatt J.D. (2003). A Role for ERK MAP Kinase in Physiological Temporal Integration in Hippocampal Area CA1. Learning and Memory 1: 26–39
Shadish W., Cook T., Campbell D. (2002) Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston
Sullivan, J., Memory consolidation, multiple realization and modest reductions. Philosophy of Science Supplement (in press).
Sullivan, J. (2003). Regulation of extracellular signal-regulated kinase during long-term potentiation in area CA1 of the rat hippocampus in vivo. Master’s Thesis, University of Pittsburgh.
Sullivan, J. (2007). Reliability and validity of experiment in the neurobiology of learning and memory. Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh.
Taylor C. (1964) Explanation of behavior. Prometheus, Amherst, NY
Thor D.H., Holloway W.R. (1982) Social memory of the male laboratory rat. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 96(6): 1000–1006
Watabe A.M., Zaki P.A., O’Dell T.J. (2000) Coactivation of β-adrenergic and cholinergic receptors enhances the induction of long-term potentiation and synergistically activates mitogen-activated protein kinase in the hippocampal CA1 region. The Journal of Neuroscience 20(16): 5924–5931
Wimsatt W. (1981). Robustness, reliability, and overdetermination. In: Brewer M.B., Collins B.E. (Eds). Scientific inquiry and the social sciences. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Inc.
Woodward J. (1989) Data and phenomena. Synthese 79: 393–472
Woodward J. (2000) Data, phenomena and reliability. Philosophy of Science 67(3): S163–S179
About this article
Cite this article
Sullivan, J.A. The multiplicity of experimental protocols: a challenge to reductionist and non-reductionist models of the unity of neuroscience. Synthese 167, 511 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-008-9389-4
- Long-term potentiation (LTP)