Abstract
Multiple realization was once taken to be a challenge to reductionist visions, especially within cognitive science, and a foundation of the “antireductionist consensus.” More recently, multiple realization has come to be challenged on naturalistic grounds, as well as on more “metaphysical” grounds. Within cognitive science, one focal issue concerns the role of neural plasticity for addressing these issues. If reorganization maintains the same cognitive functions, that supports claims for multiple realization. I take up the reorganization involved in language dysfunctions to deal with questions concerned with multiple realization and neural plasticity. Beginning with Broca’s case for localization and the nineteenth century discussion of “reorganization,” and returning to more recent evidence for neural plasticity, I argue that, in the end, there is substantial support for multiple realization in cognitive systems; I further argue that this is wholly consistent with a recognition of methodological pluralism in cognitive science.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bechtel W. (1982) Two common errors in explaining biological and psychological phenomena. Philosophy of Science 49: 549–574
Bechtel W. (2001) Linking cognition and brain: The cognitive neuroscience of language. In: Bechtel W., Mandik P., Mundale J., Stufflebeam R.S. (eds) Philosophy and the neurosciences: A reader. Basil Blackwell, Oxford
Bechtel W., McCauley R.N. (1999) Heuristic identity theory (or back to the future): The mind–body problem against the background of research strategies in cognitive neuroscience. In: Hahn M., Stones S.C. (eds) Proceedings of the Twenty-First Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ, pp 67–72
Bechtel W., Mundale J. (1999) Multiple realizability revisited: Linking cognitive and neural states. Philosophy of Science 66: 175–207
Bechtel W., Richardson R.C. (1993) Discovering complexity: Decomposition and localization as strategies in scientific research. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Bickle J. (2003) Philosophy and neuroscience: A ruthlessly reductive account. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht
Broca P. (1861a) Perte de la parole. Ramollisement chronique et destruction partielle du lobe antérieur gauche du cerveau. Bulletins de la Société Anthropologie 2: 235–238
Broca P. (1861b) Remarques sur le siege de lat faculté du langage articulé, suivies d’une observatin d’aphémie (perte de la parole). Bulletins de la Société Anatomique 36: 330–357
Broca P. (1861c) Nouvelle observation d’aphenie produite par une lesion de la moitié postérieure des deuxiéme et troisiéme cironconvolutions frontales. Bulletins de la Société Anatomique 36: 398–407
Broca P. (1877) Rapport sur un mémoire de M. Armand de Fleury intitulé: De l’inégalité de deux hemispheres cérébraux. Bulletins de l’Académie de Médecine 6: 508–339
Caplan D. (2006) Aphasic deficits in syntactic processing. Cortex 42: 797–804
Caramazza A., Zurif E.B. (1976) Dissociation of algorithmic and heuristic processes in language comprehension: Evidence from aphasia. Brain and Language 3: 572–582
Churchland P.S. (1980) A perspective on mind–brain research. The Journal of Philosophy 77: 185–207
Churchland P.M. (1984) Matter and consciousness: A contemporary introduction to the philosophy of mind. MIT Press and Bradford Books, Cambridge
Churchland P.M. (1986a) Cognitive neurobiology: A computational hypothesis for laminar cortex. Biology and Philosophy 1: 25–51
Churchland P.S. (1986b) Neurophilosophy. MIT Press and Bradford Books, Cambridge
Couch M.B. (2005) Functional properties and convergence in biology. Philosophy of Science 72: 1043–1051
Cummins R. (1983) The nature of psychological explanation. MIT Press and Bradford Books, Cambridge
Démonet J., Thierry G., Cardebat D. (2005) Renewal of the neurophysiology of language: Functional neuroimaging. Physiological Reviews 85: 49–95
Fernald R.D. (2006) Casting a genetic light on the evolution of eyes. Science 313: 1914–1922
Finger S., Buckner R.L., Buckingham H. (2003) Does the right hemisphere take over after damage to Broca’s area? The Barlow case of 1877 and its history. Brain and Language 85: 385–395
Fodor J. (1975) The language of thought. Thomas Y. Crowell Co., New York
Hardcastle V.G. (1999) The myth of pain. MIT Press, Cambridge
Harrington A. (1987) Medicine, mind and the double brain. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Helmstädter C., Kurthen M., Linkke D.B., Elger C.E. (1997) Patterns of language dominance in focal left and right hemisphere epilepsies: Relation to MRI findings, EEG, sex, and age at onset of epilepsy. Brain and Cognition 33: 135–150
Hickock G., Poeppel D. (2007) The cortical organization of speech processing. Nature Reviews: Neuroscience 8: 393–402
Kandel E.R., Schwartz J.H. (1982) Molecular biology of learning: Modulation of transmitter release. Science 218: 433–443
Lenneberg E.H. (1967) Biological foundations of language. Wiley, New York
Loorende Jong H. (2007) Levels of explanation in biological phenomena. Philosophical Psychology 15: 441–462
Lycan W. (1981) Form, function, and feel. The Journal of Philosophy 78: 24–50
Lycan, W. (1986). Consciousness and the continuity of levels of nature. Draft.
Manier, E. (1986). Problems in the development of cognitive neuroscience, effective communication between scientific domains. In PSA 1986 (Vol. I). Philosophy of Science Association.
McCauley R.N. (1996) Explanatory pluralism and the coevolution of theories in science. In: McCauley R.N. (eds) The Churchlands and their critics. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 17–47
McCauley, R. N. (2007). Reduction: Models of cross-scientific relations and their implications for the psychology-neuroscience interface. In P. Thagard (Ed.), Handbook of the philosophy of science: Philosophy of psychology and cognitive science (pp. 105–158). Elsevier.
McCauley R.N., Bechtel W. (2001) Explanatory pluralism and the identity theory. Theory and Psychology 11: 736–760
Polger T. (2004) Natural minds. MIT Press, Cambridge
Reilly J.S., Wulfeck B.B. (2004) Issues in plasticity and development: Language in atypical children. Brain and Language 88: 163–166
Richardson R.C. (1979) Functionalism and reductionism. Philosophy of Science 45: 533–558
Richardson R.C. (1982) How not to reduce a functional psychology. Philosophy of Science 49: 125–137
Richardson R.C. (2007) Reduction without the structures. In: Schouten M., LoorendeJong H. (eds) The matter of mind. Blackwell, London, pp 123–145
Richardson, R. C. Autonomy and multiple realization. Philosophy of Science (forthcoming).
Shapiro L. (2004) The mind incarnate. The MIT Press, Cambridge
Ungerleider L.G., Miskin M. (1982) Two cortical visual systems. In: Eagle D.J., Goodale M.A., Mansfield R.J. (eds) Analysis of visual behavior. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 549–586
van Empleton R., Jennekkens-Schinkel A., Busens E., Helders P.J.M., van Nieuwenhuizen O. (2004) Functional consequences of hemispherectomy. Brain 127: 2071–2079
Voets N.L. et al (2006) Distinct right frontal lobe activation in language processing following left hemisphere injury. Brain 129: 754–766
Wimsatt, W. (2007) Re-engineering philosophy for limited beings: Piecewise approximations to reality. Harvard University Press.
Young R.M. (1969) Mind, brain and adaptation in the nineteenth century. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Zurif E., Pinango M.M. (1999) The existence of comprehension patterns in Broca’s aphasia. Brain and Language 70: 133–138
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
I have had the opportunity to discuss these ideas with many people over many years. Most recently, Ken Aizawa, Bill Bechtel, John Bickle, Peggy DesAutels, Tom Polger, Larry Shapiro, Jackie Sullivan, and Larry Jost. The ideas were discussed at a workshop at the University of Cincinnati, Centenary College, the University of Georgia, and the Universität Osnabrück. In each case, they have led me to modify my views. The views also benefited from discussion at the Philosophy of Science Association in 2007, where Polger, Shapiro, Sullivan and I shared the stage, discussing related topics. Those papers are forthcoming in Philosophy of Science.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Richardson, R.C. Multiple realization and methodological pluralism. Synthese 167, 473–492 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-008-9387-6
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-008-9387-6