Abstract
This paper examines the changing ethical consciousness in Russia since the Bolshevik revolution of 1917 and discusses how this change was reflected in Russian religious philosophy. This process can be characterized by a series of sudden and violent replacements of contradictory ethical models, which, by disorientating the public consciousness, led to the atrophy of the ethical instinct. The last two models in the series correspond to the “anti-ethics” of the 1990s and the “non-ethics” of the third Millennium. The latter model (“non-ethics”) corresponds to the current absence of individual ethical positions and the willingness to adopt any position prescribed by the state. A review of philosophical reflection on this process shows that Russian religious thought did not foresee such an ethical catastrophe. Indeed, although Vladimir Solovyov presented an alarming eschatological foresight of the future, and despite the fact that the collection Landmarks, written in 1907, firmly identified the intelligentsia as a highly destructive agent promoting their own alternative ethics, the optimistic philosophical model nonetheless prevailed. According to this optimistic model, the period of disasters and catastrophes will be followed by a new spiritual reawakening.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
References
Aksakov, K. S. (1889a). Kratkij istoričeskij očerk Zemskikh Soborov. In K. S. Aksakov (Ed.), Polnoe Sobranie Sočinenij (2nd ed., Vol. 1). Moscow: Universitetskaja tipografija.
Aksakov, K. S. (1889b). Ob osnovnykh načalakh russkoj istorii. In K. S. Aksakov (Ed.), Polnoe Sobranie Sočinenij (2nd ed., Vol. 1). Moscow: Universitetskaja tipografija.
Arkhiepiskop Vasily (Krivošein). (2014). Pis’mo k uerodiakonu Davidu (Zuberu), 01/18 (31)/1979. In Afonskij period zhisni arkhiepiskopa Vasilija (Krivošeina) v dokumantakh. Russkij Monastyr‘Sv. Panteleimona na Afone.
Belonogova, J. I. (2003). Religiozno-nravstvennoe sostojanie russkogo krest’janstva po materialam tserkovnoj periodiki načala 20 v. In Ezhegodnaja Bogoslovskaja Konferentsija Pravoslavnogo Svjato-Tikhonovskogo Bogoslovskogo Instituta. Moscow: Izdatelstvo Pravoslavnogo Svjato-Tikhonovskogo Bogoslovskogo Instituta.
Berdyaev, N. A. (1990). Sud’ba Rossii. Moscow: Sovetskii Pisatel’.
Berdyaev, N. A. (1991). Dukhi russkoj revolutsii. In Vekhi. Iz Glubiny. Moscow: Izdatelstvo “Pravda”.
Fedotov, G. P. (2001). Russkaja religioznost’. Part I. Khristianstvo Kievskoj Rusi. 10-13 vv. In G. P. Fedotov (Ed.), Sobranie Sočinenij (Vol. 10). Moscow: SAM and SAM.
Fedotov, G. P. (2013). O natsional’nom pokajanii. In G. P. Fedotov (Ed.), Sobranie Sočinenij, in 12 vols (Vol. 6). Moscow: SAM and SAM.
Frank, S. L. (1991). Etika nigilizma. In Vekhi. Iz Glubiny. Moscow: Izdatelstvo “Pravda”.
Glukhovskij, D. (2017). Deti neizbezhno pobedjat, vopros o tom, uspeet li nyneshnjj vlast’ ikh isportit’. Novaja gazeta [New Newspaper], issue 64 (06/19/2017).
Granin, D. (2017). Ja takoj vrednyj, čto Bog menja boitsja pustit‘k sebe!. Novaja gazeta [New Newspaper], issue 72 (07/07/2017).
Horujy, S. S. (1999). “Ulysses” in a Russian looking-glass. In Joyce studies annual 1999. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Horujy, S. S. (2000). Metamorfozy slavjanofil’skoy idei v 20 veke. In S. S. Horujy (Ed.), O starom i novom (pp. 117–140). St. Petersburg: Aleteja.
Horujy, S. S. (2015). Practices of the self and spiritual practices. Michel Foucault and eastern christian discourse. Grand Rapids, Michigan/Cambridge: Eerdmans Publishing Company.
Iz glubiny: stat’i o russkoj revoljutsii [Out of the depths (De Profundis): A collection of articles on the Russian revolution] (1918). In Vekhi. Iz Glubiny. Moscow: Izdatelstvo “Pravda”.
Khomjakov, A. S. (1914). O juridičeskikh voprosakh. In A. S. Khomjakov (Ed.), Polnoe Sobranie Sočinenij (4th ed., Vol. 3). Moscow: Tipografija tovarishchestva Kushnereva i Ko.
Loznitsa, S. (2017). Istorija ne podčinjaetsja “sil’noj ruke”. Novaja gazeta [New Newspaper], issue 57 (05/31/2017).
Mikirtumov, I. (2016). Shkala tsennostej: Resursy otkrovennosti. Vedomosti [The Record], issue 4216 (12/02/2016).
Nemov, A. (1915). Ideja Slavjanskogo vozrozhdenija. Moscow: Tipo-litografija tovarishchestva N.N.Kushnereva i Ko.
Pokrovskij, I. A. (1991). Perunovo zakljat’e. In Vekhi. Iz Glubiny (pp. 443–458). Moscow: Izdatelstvo “Pravda”.
Trubetskoi, E. N. (1913). Mirovozzrenie Vladimira Solov’jova. Moscow: Put’.
Trubetskoi, E. N. (1918). Smysl zhizni. Moscow: Tipografija I.D.Sytina.
Author information
Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Horujy, S.S. The ethical catastrophe of contemporary Russia and its foresights in Russian thought. Stud East Eur Thought 70, 221–234 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11212-018-9311-7
Published:
Issue Date:
Keywords
- Ethics
- Russian philosophy
- Russia
- USSR
- Bolshevik turnover
- Soviet totalitarianism
- Post-Soviet ethics