Social Indicators Research

, Volume 75, Issue 2, pp 169–216 | Cite as

How Social Relations and Structures can Produce Happiness and Unhappiness: An International Comparative Analysis

Article

Abstract

In this paper, subjective well being, as measured by survey questions on happiness and life satisfaction, is investigated from a sociological-comparative point of view. The central thesis is that happiness and satisfaction must be understood as the outcome of an interaction process between individual characteristics and aspirations on the one side, and social relations and macrosocial structures on the other side. A distinction is made between life satisfaction and happiness; the former is more seen as the outcome of an evaluation process including material and social aspirations and achievements, the latter as an outcome of positive experiences, particularly close personal relationships. The focus of this paper is on micro- and macrosocial conditions favouring or inhibiting the emergence of happiness and satisfaction. It is hypothesized that dense and good basic social relations, occupational involvement and success, sociocultural (religious and altruistic) orientations and participation are conducive to happiness and life satisfaction; the same should be true at the macrolevel for economic prosperity, relatively equal social structures, a well-established welfare state and political democracy. The latter conditions, however, should be more important for life satisfaction than for happiness. A comparative, multilevel regression analysis of happiness in 41 nations around the world is carried out (using the World Value Survey 1995–1997). Both our general assumption and most of the specific hypotheses could be confirmed. It turned very clearly that “happiness” and “life satisfaction” are two different concepts. It could be shown that microsocial embedding and sociocultural integration of a person are highly relevant for happiness. However, contrary to earlier studies, we find that macrosocial factors like the economic wealth of nation, the distribution of income, the extent of the welfare state and political freedom are also relevant, particularly for satisfaction. What counts most is the ability to cope with life, including subjective health and financial satisfaction, close social relations, and the economic perspectives for improvement in the future, both at the level of the individual and at that of the society. These abilities are certainly improved by favourable macrosocial conditions and institutions, such as a more equal income distribution, political democracy and a welfare state.

Keywords

happiness international comparison life satisfication social institutions social structure social structure and happiness 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Arendt, , Hannah,  1958The Human ConditionUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  2. Argyle, , Michael,  1987The Psychology of HappinessRoutledgeLondon/New YorkGoogle Scholar
  3. Beck, Ulrich, Elisabeth Beck-Gernsheim,  eds. 1994Riskante Freiheiten. Individualisierung in modernen GesellschaftenSuhrkampFrankfurt and MainGoogle Scholar
  4. Bellebaum, Alfred, () eds. 1992Glück und ZufriedenheitWestdeutscher VerlagOpladenEin SymposiumGoogle Scholar
  5. Bellebaum, Alfred, Klaus Barheier,  eds. 1997GlücksvorstellungenWestdeutscher VerlagOpladenEin Rückgriff in die Geschichte der SoziologieGoogle Scholar
  6. Biswas-Diener, , Robert, , Ed Diener,  2001‘Making the best of a bad situation: Satisfaction in the slums of Calcutta’Social Indicators Research.55329353CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Boudon, , Raymond,  2002Dèclin de la morale? Dèclin des valeurs?Éditions Nota Bene/CefanQuebecGoogle Scholar
  8. Bradburn, , Norman, M., David, Caplovitz 1965Reports on HappinessAldineChicagoGoogle Scholar
  9. Bradburn, , Norman, M. 1969The Structure of Psychological Well-BeingAldineChicagoGoogle Scholar
  10. Campbell, A., Converse, P. E., Rogers, W. L. 1976The Quality of American LifeRussel SageNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  11. Christoph, , Bernhard, , Heinz-Herbert Noll,  2003‘Subjective well-being in the European Community’Social Indicators Research.64521546CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Crooker, , Karen, J., Near, Janet P. 1998‘Happiness and satisfaction: Measures of affect and cognition?’Social Indicators Research.44195224CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Csikszentmihalyi, , Mihaly,  1990Flow: The Psychology of Optimal ExperienceHarper & RowNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  14. Damasio, , Antonio,  1999The Feeling of What Happens. Body and Emotion in the Making of ConsciousnessHarcourt, Brace & CoNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  15. Davies, , James, C. 1962‘Toward a theory of revolution’American Sociological Review.27519Google Scholar
  16. De, Botton, Alain,  2004Status AnxietyHamish Hamilton (Penguin)LondonGoogle Scholar
  17. Diener Ed, , Eunkook Suh,  1997‘Measuring quality of life: Economic, social, and subjective indicators’Social Indicators Research.40189216Google Scholar
  18. Diener, Ed 2000‘Subjective well-being. The science of happiness and a proposal for a national index’American Psychologist.553443CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Di Tella, R., MacCulooch, R., Oswald, A. 2001‘Preferences over inflation and unemployment: Evidence from surveys on happiness’American Economic Review91335341Google Scholar
  20. Doyle, , Kenneth, O., Sounmi, Youn 2000‘Exploring the traits of happy people’Social Indicators Research52195209CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Durkheim, Emile: 1960, Le Suicide, Paris: Presses Universitaire de France (here quoted after the German edition : Der Selbstmord, Neuwied/Berlin: Luchterhand Verlag 1973).Google Scholar
  22. Durkheim, , Emile,  1964The Division of Labor in SocietyThe Free Press/Collier MacmillanNew York/LondonGoogle Scholar
  23. Easterlin, , Richard, A. 1974

    ‘Does economic growth improve the human lot? Some empirical evidence’

    David, P. A.Melvin, W. R. eds. Nations and Households in Economic GrowthStanford University PressPalo Alto California
    Google Scholar
  24. Eckersley, , Richard,  2000‘The state and fate of nations: Implications of subjective measures of personal and social quality of life’Social Indicators Research.52327CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions in Europe: 2004. Quality of life in Europe. Life satisfaction in an enlarged Europe, Dublin.Google Scholar
  26. Frank, , Robert,  1999Luxury Fever. Why Money Fails to Satisfy in an Era of ExcessFree PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  27. Frey, , Bruno, S., Alois Stutzer,  2002Happiness and Economics. How the Economy and Institutions Affect Well-BeingPrinceton University PressPrinceton/OxfordGoogle Scholar
  28. Fromm, , Erich,  1956The Art of LovingHarperNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  29. Fuentes, , Nicole, , Mariano Rojas,  2001‘Economic theory and subjective well-being: Mexico’Social Indicators Research53289314CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Galbraith, , John, K. 1958The Affluent SocietyPenguinHarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
  31. Glatzer, , Wolfgang, , Wolfgang Zapf,  1984Lebensqualität in der Bundesrepublik Objektive Lebensbedingungen und subjektives WohlbefindenCampusFrankfurt/New YorkGoogle Scholar
  32. Goldstein, , Harvey,  1995Multilevel Statistical ModelsEdward ArnoldLondonGoogle Scholar
  33. Greenspoon, , Peter, J., Saklofske, Donald H. 2001‘Toward an integration of subjective well-being and psychopathology’Social Indicators Research5481108CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Gundelach, , Peter, , Svend Kreiner,  2004‘Happiness and life satisfaction in advanced European countries’Cross-Cultural Research.38359386CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Haller, , Max,  1981Gesundheitsstörungen als persönliche und soziale Erfahrung. Eine soziologische Studie über verheiratete Frauen im BerufOldenbourg/ Verlag für Geschichte und PolitikMünchen/WienGoogle Scholar
  36. Haller, , Max,  1990‘The challenge for comparative sociology in the transformation of Europe’International Sociology.5183204Google Scholar
  37. Haller, , Max,  2002‘Theory and method in the comparative study of values’European Sociological Review.18139158CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Haller, , Max,  2003‘Europe and the Arab-Islamic worldA sociological perspective on the sociocultural differences and mutual (mis-) perceptions between two neighbouring cultural areas’, Innovation.16227252Google Scholar
  39. Haller, , Max, , Markus Hadler,  2002Wer hat von den politischen Reformen der 90er Jahre profitiert? Modernisierungsgewinner und –verlierer in Ost- und Westeuropa und den USA’Europäische Rundschau30115127Google Scholar
  40. Haller, , Max, , Markus Hadler,  2004

    ‘Happiness as an expression of freedom and self-determination A comparative, multilevel analysis’

    Wolfgang Glatzer, Susanne Below, Matthias Stoffregen,  eds. Challenges for the Quality of Life in Contemporary Societies.Kluwer Academic PublishersDordrecht
    Google Scholar
  41. Haybron, , Daniel, M. 2003‘What do we want from a theory of happiness?’Metaphilosophy.34305329CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Hayek, , Friedrich, A. 1960The Constitution of LibertyRoutledge & Kegan Paul/University of Chicago PressLondon/ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  43. Hayo, , Bernd, , Wolfgang Seifert,  2003Subjective economic well-being in Eastern Europe’Journal of Economic Psychology24329348CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Headey, , Bruce, , Elsie Holmström, , Alexander Wearing,  1984Well-being and ill-being: Different dimensions’Social Indicators Research.14115139CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Hofstede, , Geert,  1984Culture’s Consequences International Differences in Work-Related ValuesSageBeverly Hills/London/New DelhiGoogle Scholar
  46. Höllinger, , Franz, , Max, Haller 1990‘Kinship and social networks in modern societies: A cross-cultural comparison among seven nations’European Sociological Review.6103124Google Scholar
  47. Hradil, Stefan, (1998), ‘Die Seismographen der Modernisierung. Singles in Deutschland’, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte, Beilage zur Wochenzeitung Das Parlament, B53/98, 25.12.1998, pp. 9–16Google Scholar
  48. Hughes, , Everett, C. 1994On Work, Race, and the Sociological ImaginationUniversity of Chicago PressChicago/LondonGoogle Scholar
  49. Huizinga, , Johan,  1956Homo ludens Vom. Ursprung der Kultur im SpielRowohltHamburgGoogle Scholar
  50. Inglehart, Ronald et al.: 2000, World Values Surveys and European Value Surveys, 1981-1984, 1990-1993, and 1995-1997, ICPSR - Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research, University of Michigan (mimeo)Google Scholar
  51. Inglehart, Ronald and Jacques-Rene Rabier.: 1986, ‘Aspirations adapt to situations - but why are the Belgians so much happier than the French? A cross-cultural analysis of the subjective quality of life’, in Frank M. Andrews (ed.), Research on the Quality of Life, Michigan: The Survey Research Center/Institute for Social Research, pp. 1-56Google Scholar
  52. Inkeles, Alex, (1989), ‘National character revisited’, in M. Haller and H.J. Hoffmann-Nowonty, W. Zapf (eds.), Kultur und Gesellschaft, Frankfurt/New York: Campus, pp. 98-112Google Scholar
  53. Jahoda, , Marie,  1982Employment and unemployment. A social-psychological analysisCambridge University PressCambridge etcGoogle Scholar
  54. Jahoda, , Marie, , Paul Lazarsfeld, , Hans Zeisel,  1997Die Arbeitslosen von MarienthalSuhrkampFrankfurt am MainGoogle Scholar
  55. Klages, Helmut, (1992), ‘Glückserzeugung durch Politik- ein immer vergeblicheres Unterfangen? Thesen auf der Grundlage empirischer Politikforschung’, in Bellebaum, Alfred (eds.), Glück und Zufriedenheit. Ein Symposium, Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag, pp. 102-119Google Scholar
  56. Kuzmics, , Helmut,  1989Der Preis der Zivilisation Die Zwänge der Moderne im theoretischen VergleichCampusFrankfurt/New YorkGoogle Scholar
  57. Land, , Kenneth, C.,  et al. 2001‘Child and youth well-being in the United States, 1975-1998: Some findings from a new index’Social Indicators Research.56241320CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Lane, , David, , Cameron Ross,  1997‘Russian political elites, 1991-1995: Recruitment and renewal’International Politics34169192Google Scholar
  59. Lane, , Robert, A. 2000The Loss of Happiness in Market DemocraciesYale University PressNew Haven/LondonGoogle Scholar
  60. Letwin, William, () eds. 1983Against Equality Readings on. Social and Economic PolicyMacmillanLondon/BasingstokeGoogle Scholar
  61. Lewada, Juri, (1992), Die Sowjetmenschen 1989-1991. Soziogramm eines Zerfalls, Berlin: Argon (Russ. ed. 1991)Google Scholar
  62. Magen, , Zipora,  1996‘Commitment beyond self and adolescence: The issue of happiness’Social Indicators Research.37235267CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Makinen, , Judy, A., Pychyl, Timothy A. 2001‘The differential effects of project stress on life-satisfaction’Social Indicators Research.53116CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Mechanic, , David,  1974Politics, Medicine, and Social ScienceWileyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  65. Merleau-Ponty, , Maurice,  1960‘Le philosophe et son ombre’In Merleau-Ponty M.(eds.)Signes. Librairie Gallimard ParisGoogle Scholar
  66. Merton, , Robert, K. 1967On Theoretical SociologyFree Press/MacmillanNew York/LondonGoogle Scholar
  67. Methfessel, , Klaus, , Jörg Winterberg,  1998Der Preis der Gleichheit. Wie Deutschland die Chancen der Globalisierung verspieltEconDüsseldorf/MünchenGoogle Scholar
  68. Michalos, , Alex, C. 1980‘Satisfaction and Happiness’Social Indicators Research.8385422Google Scholar
  69. Michalos, , Alex, C., Anita M., Hubley, Bruno D., Zumbo, Dawn, Hemingway 2001‘Health and other aspects of the quality of life of older people’Social Indicators Research.54239274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Miles, , Marc, A.,  et al. 2004Index of Economic FreedomHeritage FoundationWashingtonGoogle Scholar
  71. Myers, , David, G. 1993The Pursuit of Happiness: Who is Happy and Why?AvonNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  72. Myers, , David, G. 2000‘The funds, friends, and faith of happy people’American Psychologist.555667CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Nippa, , Annegret,  1991Haus und Familie in arabischen Ländern Vom Mittelalter bis zur GegenwartC.H. BeckMünchenGoogle Scholar
  74. Noll, Heinz-Herbert and Roland Habich, (1990), ‘Individuelle Wohlfahrt: vertikale Ungleichheit oder horizontale Disparitäten?’, in Sonderband 7: Lebenslagen, Lebensläufe, Lebensstile, Peter A. (eds.), Soziale Welt, Berger/Stefan Hradil, pp. 153-188Google Scholar
  75. Nozick, Robert, (1989), The Examined Life. Philosophical Meditations, New York: Simon & Schuster (here quoted after the German edition: Vom richtigen, guten und glücklichen Leben, München: Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag)Google Scholar
  76. Peabody, Dean, (1985), National Characteristics, Cambridge etc.: Cambridge University Press/Paris: Editions de la Maison des Sciences de l’HommeGoogle Scholar
  77. Plè, , Bernhard,  1997

    ‘Aus der Krise zu neuem Glück Gegemwartsanalysen und Zukunftserwartungen im Positivismus’

    Bellebaum, Alfred, Klaus Barheier,  eds. Glücksvorstellungen.Ein Rückgriff in die Geschichte der Soziologie. Westdeutscher VerlagOpladen3653
    Google Scholar
  78. Przeworski, , Adam, , Henri Teune,  1970The Logic of Comparative InquiryWileyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  79. Pyysiäinen, , Ilkka,  2001How Religion Works Towards a New Cognitive Science of ReligionBrillLeiden/Boston/KölnGoogle Scholar
  80. Rabash, Jon et al., (2000), A User’s Guide do MlWin, Version d.1d, Centre for Multilevel Modelling, Institute of Education, University of LondonGoogle Scholar
  81. Rampichini, , Carla, , SilvanaSchifini d, ´Andrea 1997‘A hierarchical ordinal probit model for the analysis of life satisfaction in Italy’Social Indicators Research.444169Google Scholar
  82. Rawls, , John,  1972A Theory of JusticeOxford University PressLondon/Oxford/New YorkGoogle Scholar
  83. Rehberg, Karl-Siegbert, (1997), ‘Die Angst vor dem Glück. Anthropologische Motive’, in Alfred Bellebaum (eds.), Glücksvorstellungen. Ein Rückgriff in die Geschichte der Soziologie, Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag, S.153-176Google Scholar
  84. Ryan, , Richard, M., Edward L., Deci 2000‘Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-beingAmerican Psychologist.556878CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Ryan, , Lisa, , Suzanne, Dziurawiec 2001‘Materialism and its relationship to life satisfaction’Social Indicators Research.55185197CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Scheff, , Thomas, J. 1990Microsociology Discourse, Emotion and Social StructureUniversity of Chicago PressChicago/LondonGoogle Scholar
  87. Scheff, , Thomas, J. 1997Emotions, the social bond and human relationships Part/whole analysisCambridge University PressCambridge/New York/MelbourneGoogle Scholar
  88. Schoeck, Helmut 1960Envy. A theory of social behaviourHarcourtBrace & World New yorkGoogle Scholar
  89. Schulz, , Wolfgang, ,  et al. 1988‘Subjektive Lebensqualität in Österreich’SWS-Rundschau.28162173Google Scholar
  90. Schulz, , Wolfgang,  1995‘Multiple-discrepancies theory versus resource theory’Social Indicators Research.34153169CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Schyns, , Peggy,  1998‘Crossnational differences in happiness: Economic and cultural factors explored’Social Indicators Research.43326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Scitovsky, , Tibor,  1976The Joyless Economy An Inquiry into Human Satisfaction and Consumer DissatisfactionOxford University PressNew York etc.Google Scholar
  93. Seligman, , Martin, E. P., Mihaly, Csikszentmihalyi 2000‘Positive psychology’American Psychologist.55514CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Sen, , Amartya,  1999Development as FreedomAlfred KnopfNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  95. Sennett, , Richard, , Jonathan, Cobb 1972The Hidden Injuries of ClassVintage BooksNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  96. Shimada, Atsushi, (1976), ‘Wandel des traditionellen Familiensystems’, in Ikutaro Shimuzu and Yoshiro Tamanoi (eds.), Gesellschaft Japans. Soziale Gruppen, Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag, 1976Google Scholar
  97. Smith, Adam, (1986), The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Classworks (1st ed. London, 1759)Google Scholar
  98. Sprenger, , Reinhard, K. 2002Mythos Motivation. Wege aus einer SackgasseCampusFrankfurt/New YorkGoogle Scholar
  99. Suttie, I. R. 1963The Origins of Love and Hate, HarmondsworthPenguinMiddlesexGoogle Scholar
  100. Tocqueville, , Alexis,  1947Democracy in AmericaOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  101. Veenhoven, , Ruut,  1983‘The growing impact of marriage’Social Indicators Research.124963CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  102. Veenhoven, Ruut,  eds. 1989How Harmful Is Happiness? Consequences of Enjoying Life or NotUniversitaire Pres RotterdamRotterdam/The HagueGoogle Scholar
  103. Veenhoven, , Ruut,  1994‘Is happiness a trait? Tests of the theory that a better society does not make people any happier’Social Indicators Research32101160CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  104. Veenhoven, , Ruut,  1999‘Quality-of-life in individualistic society. A comparison of 43 nations in the early 1990s’Social Indicators Research.48157186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Vittersø, Joar, Espen Roysamb and Ed Diener, (2002), “The concept of life satisfaction across cultures: Exploring its diverse meaning and relation to economic wealth’, in Eleonora Gallone (eds.), The Universality of Subjective Wellbeing Indicators, Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 81-103Google Scholar
  106. Vittersø, , Joar, , Fredrik Nielsen,  2002‘The conceptual and relational structure of subjective well-being, neuroticism, and extraversion: Once again, neuroticism is the important predictor of happiness’Social Indicators Research.5789118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Voslensky, , Michael, S. 1982Nomenklatura. Die herrschende Klasse der SowjetunionPabel/MoewigRastattGoogle Scholar
  108. Weber, , Max,  2003The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of CapitalismDover PublicationsMinneola, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  109. Weerasinghe, , Jana, , Lorne Tepperman,  1994‘Suicide and happiness: Seven tests of the connection’Social Indicators Research.32199233CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  110. Willi, , Victor,  1966Grundlagen einer empirischen Soziologie der Werte und WertsystemeOrell FüssliZürichGoogle Scholar
  111. Zahn, , Ernest,  1960Soziologie der Prosperität. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft im Zeichen des WohlstandsDeutscher Taschenbuch VerlagMünchenGoogle Scholar
  112. Zwicky, , Heinrich,  1982Politische Aktivität, Illegitimität und Stabilisierung. Eine Untersuchung kontextueller Determinanten von Bürgeraktivitäten und Unzufriedenheit in der SchweizRüeggerDiessenhofenGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of SociologyKarl Franzens-University Graz, Austria and Facoltà di Sociologia, Università degli StudiTrentoItaly
  2. 2.Department of SociologyKarl Franzens-University GrazAustria

Personalised recommendations