Skip to main content

Musine Kokalari and the Power of Images: Law, Aesthetics and Memory Regimes in the Albanian Experience

Abstract

Tarot cards are one means to unlocking an image. In this article, the image is that of the Albanian writer and political dissident Musine Kokalari at her 1946 trial. Her photograph features in Albanian discourses about its communist past. I argue that the image provides clues as to the manner in which the country has faced up to its own history. For what is certain is that the Albanian account of the Enver Hoxha dictatorship (1944–1991) remains incomplete. Drawing on Walter Benjamin’s notion of ‘here-and-now in a flash’, and Roland Barthes’ and Italo Calvino’s reflections on photography and the power of the visual, we can identify at least two distinct memory regimes in the relevant historical, legal and political narratives.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3

Notes

  1. Freedberg [1, 440] observes, in referring to Roland Barthes, ‘So much for the magnificent fullness of the photograph. It transcends death and peculiarly replenishes the lost being. What is lost or absent seems present, but we cannot know why. As soon as we strive to grasp that presence in all its fullness, we either fail or set out to tame or destroy it’.

  2. Such as King [2].

  3. In this article image is used interchangeably with photograph. Of course, image can refer to ‘any likeness, figure, motif, or form that appears in some medium or other’, Mitchell [3].

  4. Barthes [4, 9] refers to the Spectrum of the Photograph, and its relation to the ‘spectacle’, which ‘adds to it that rather terrible thing which is there in every photograph: the return of the dead’.

  5. Yates [5, 6].

  6. Kirchheimer [7, 419].

  7. This is a point discussed in semiotics and semiology, beginning with the work of Ferdinand de Saussure, in his Course on General Linguistics [8], based on a summary of his lectures delivered at the University of Geneva between 1906 and 1911. His work serves as a foundation for modern investigations into what underpins perception and communication. Charles S. Peirce, who worked on similar problems at the same time, made an important contribution to the debate with his notion of ‘Firstness’ as the primary perceptive event that is endowed with semiological meaning. See Buchler [9, 80].

  8. This paper develops the work set out in Fijalkowski and Grosescu [10]. There is now a wealth of studies in the field of transitional justice. See for example, Teitel [11]. For considerations of domestic accountability in post-dictatorial societies, see Stan [12], Nalepa [13], David [14], Serrano and Popovski [15], Czarnota et al. [16]. Other works in this field analyse the politics of memory applied through historical commissions and museums, such as de Brito et al. [17]; and, finally, Mark [18].

  9. Rush [19, vii].

  10. Rush [19, vii].

  11. Girling [20, 109].

  12. During her exile Musine was extremely careful about making contact with anyone. Under constant surveillance by the Sigurimi, she never discussed her account, or perhaps only with select family members, but contact with them was severely restricted. Interview with Linda Kokalari [21]. Musine’s writings have not been revisited or reissued by the state in the post-dictatorial period. This was done only by private initiatives, with financial support from the Albanian Ministry of Tourism, Cultural Affairs, Youth and Sports.

  13. Benjamin [22, 395].

  14. Benjamin [22, 395].

  15. Benjamin [22, 395].

  16. Sontag [23], Butler [24].

  17. Heard [25, 130].

  18. For example, see Douzinas and Neal [26] or Mitchell [3, 27].

  19. Carrabine [28] and Carney [29].

  20. Douzinas and Neal [26, 13].

  21. Goodrich [30, vii].

  22. Goodrich [30, vii].

  23. Goodrich [31].

  24. As argued by Wittgenstein, in his lectures on aesthetics. Allen [32], quoted in Turvey [33, 478–479].

  25. Calvino [34].

  26. Images can also be found at the heart of a mnemonical community. In other words, a memory holds communities together, for example, in relation to specific events. Interpretations of these occurrences can vary, which makes the memory ‘fixed’, as a commemoration site, or ‘dynamic’, serving as a catalyst for a ‘memory event’. See, for example, the discussion concerning the Katyń massacre in Etkind et al. [35], Terdiman [36].

  27. Barthes [4, 25–28]. Calvino [37, 71–76].

  28. Stoehrel [38].

  29. Stoehrel [38, 558].

  30. Barthes [4, 25–28]. Calvino [37, 75].

  31. For Benjamin, what weakens during this period is the ‘aura’ of the work of art in question, something that occurred for the first time with photography. ‘Aura’ concerns the object’s authority, which derives from history and originality. Benjamin [39].

  32. Barthes [40, 31–37]. Also [41].

  33. Emphasis in the original. Barthes [40, 44].

  34. Elander [42].

  35. Smith [43, 72].

  36. Smith [43, 72].

  37. Smith [43, 72, 73].

  38. Bell [44, 1–15].

  39. Bell [44, 1–15].

  40. Bell [44, 1–15].

  41. Cover [45] discusses the meaning of jurisgenerative as referring to the ways in which law is given meaning through a community’s narratives and rules, ‘their somewhat distinct nomos’, at p. 40. Bell uses Cover’s notion in her work [44].

  42. Bell [44, 1–15].

  43. Packard [46, 68–69 and 62–63], respectively. The tarot card images are taken from Commons Wikimedia and in the public domain because the copyright has expired PD-US-not renewed.

  44. Effendi [47, iii].

  45. Biberaj [48, 407–408].

  46. The Sigurimi permeated the society to the extent that every third citizen had either served time in labour camps or been interrogated by the secret police. Austin and Ellison [49, 179]. See also Vickers [50].

  47. Pipa [51, 25].

  48. Packard [46, 72, 73].

  49. Packard [46, 54, 55].

  50. The tarot card images are taken from Commons Wikimedia and in the public domain because the copyright has expired PD-US-not renewed.

  51. Literary circles were hubs of intellectual and political activity, and Albania was no different to Europe during this pre-war period of 1918–1939. Mak [52].

  52. But she was very much engaged in politics. This increased as the war was drawing to a close and her political vision for Albania became tangible. Interview with Kokalari [53].

  53. Pepa [54, 117], translation modified. This scene recalls Sophie Scholl’s stance at the trial of the members of the White Rose. See Dumbach and Newborn [55] and ‘Sophie Scholl: the Final Days’ [56].

  54. Pepa [54, 118].

  55. For a personal account of this labour camp see Lubonja [57].

  56. Gjyqësor, file 1624, item 1051/2, microfilm [58].

  57. ‘During work hours she was what they wanted her to be. But, after work, she was what she wanted to be: well dressed, beautiful and with a book in her hands. One needs to keep in mind the time and place we are referring to, the Rrëshen of those years’, interview with Kokalari [21].

  58. Austin and Ellison [49, 182].

  59. But see Aliko [59].

  60. Martirët (The Martys) [60].

  61. Packard [46, 64, 65]. The tarot card images are taken from Commons Wikimedia and in the public domain because the copyright has expired PD-US-not renewed.

  62. Packard [46, 70–710].

  63. The first show trial, called the ‘Albanian Nuremberg Trial’, was held from March to April 1945 and presided over by Koci Xoxe, Minister of Defence and the Interior. Xoxe was instrumental in creating the infamous Sigurimi, the Albanian security or political police. The 60 defendants in the trial were government officials, who were charged and sentenced on multiple counts of treason and collaboration with the enemy (then Italy and Germany). The main fabricated accusation was that they were ‘traitors and enemies of the people’. Aliko [59, 17].

  64. ‘Groups of resistance', such as the ‘Groups of Legalists’ or the ‘Group of Social Democrats’. Pepa [54, 117].

  65. Moran et al. [61, 121].

  66. Gjygjsore, file 1615, item 1081, microfilm [58].

  67. Shehu [62, 487].

  68. Aliko [59].

  69. Sarat [63].

  70. Sarat [63].

  71. Pepa [54, 119], translation modified.

  72. Packard [46, 90–91]. The tarot card images are taken from Commons Wikimedia and in the public domain because the copyright has expired PD-US-not renewed.

  73. Interview with Ndoja [64].

  74. Tufa [65]. See also Davies [66].

  75. As in Northern Ireland, see McNamee [67].

  76. Austin and Ellison [49, 182].

  77. Austin and Ellison [49, 182]. Genc Ruli was the Minister of Finance at the time.

  78. Austin and Ellison [49, 182].

  79. Albania's first multi-party elections were held in 1991. Austin and Ellison [49, 182].

  80. Austin and Ellison [49, 182].

  81. Austin and Ellison [49, 182]. Berisha was from the Democratic Party. He was President of Albania from 2005 to 2013. Prior to that he was Prime Minister from 1992 to 1997.

  82. Packard [46, 52, 53]. The tarot card images are taken from Commons Wikimedia and in the public domain because the copyright has expired PD-US-not renewed.

  83. Osiel [68, 114].

  84. Osiel [68, 114–115].

  85. Rush [19, vii].

  86. Přibáň [69, 145].

  87. Osiel [68, 276].

  88. I am grateful to Kadare for drawing my attention to this [70].

  89. Again I am grateful to Kadare for drawing my attention to this [70].

  90. Such as Professor Sabiha Kasimati. See Saraçi (Mulleti) [71, 231–232]. The basis for the charges was the same: suspicion of collaborating with the West. By 1948 the Stalinist show trial had been perfected and applied across communist Europe. See Hodos [72].

  91. Saraçi (Mulleti) [71].

  92. de Rapper and Durand [73, 221].

  93. I am grateful to Elez Biberaj for the information.

  94. See Lubonja [74].

  95. Attributed to Lubonja, book presentation of The False Apocalypse: From Stalinism to Capitalism, Anglo-Albanian Association Meeting, London School of Economics, 15 October 2014.

  96. The legend would later form the basis of Kadare’s story The Ghost Rider [75]. The spelling of Kostantin varies, from Konstantin, Constantine, or Constantin. I have used the spelling from The Ghost Rider.

  97. Rubinlir [76, 77, 78], translation modified. Sad Rubinlir is the name Sadri Ahmeti assumed as a writer.

  98. Lubonja [74]

References

  1. Freedberg, David. 1989. The power of images: Studies in the history and theory of response. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

    Google Scholar 

  2. King, David. 2010. Red star over Russia: A visual history of the Soviet Union from 1917 to the death of Stalin. London: Tate.

    Google Scholar 

  3. Mitchell, W.J.T. 2005. What do pictures want? The lives and loves of images. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

    Google Scholar 

  4. Barthes, Roland. 2000. Camera Lucida: Reflections on photography (trans: Howard, Richard). London: Vintage.

  5. Yates, Frances A. 1981. In the cards. In The New York Review of Books.

  6. Yates, Frances A. 1966. The art of memory. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

    Google Scholar 

  7. Kirchheimer, Otto. 1961. Political justice. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  8. de Saussure, Ferdinand. 1972. Course on general linguistics. Chicago: Open Court Press.

    Google Scholar 

  9. Buchler, Justus. 1955. Philosophical writings of Charles S. Peirce. New York: Dover.

    Google Scholar 

  10. Fijalkowski, Agata and Grosescu, Raluca. eds. 2015. Transitional criminal justice in post-dictatorial and post-conflict societies. Series on Transitional Justice. Cambridge: Intersentia.

  11. Teitel, Ruti. 2000. Transitional justice. New York: Oxford University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  12. Stan, Lavinia (ed.). 2008. Transitional justice in Eastern Europe and former Soviet Union. London: Routledge.

    Google Scholar 

  13. Nalepa, Monika. 2010. Skeletons in the closet: Transitional justice in post-communist Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

    Book  Google Scholar 

  14. David, Roman. 2011. Lustration and transitional justice: Personnel systems in the Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

    Book  Google Scholar 

  15. Serrano, Mónika, and Veselin Popovski (eds.). 2012. After oppression: Transitional justice in Latin America and Eastern Europe. New York: United Nations University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  16. Czarnota, Adam, Martin Krygier, and Wojciech Sadurski (eds.). 2005. Rethinking the rule of law after communism. Budapest: CEU Press.

    Google Scholar 

  17. de Brito, Barahona, Carmen Gonzales-Enriquez, and Paloma Aguilar (eds.). 2001. The politics of memory: Transitional justice in democratizing societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  18. Mark, James. 2010. The unfinished revolution: Making sense of the communist past in central-Eastern Europe. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  19. Rush, Peter. 2012. Introduction. In The arts of transitional justice, ed. Olivera Simić, and Peter D. Rush, 5–11. Berlin: Springer.

    Google Scholar 

  20. Girling, Evi. 2011. The witnessing of judgment: Between error, mercy and vindictiveness. In Is the death penalty dying? European and American perspectives, ed. Austin Sarat, and Jürgen Martschukat, 109–125. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

    Chapter  Google Scholar 

  21. Kokalari, Linda. 2013. Musine Kokakari’s great-niece, correspondence 21 July 2013.

  22. Benjamin, Walter. 1999. ‘On the concept of history’. In Selected writings, Volume 4, 19381940 (trans: Eiland, Howard and McLaughlin, Kevin). Harvard: Harvard University Press.

  23. Sontag, Susan. 2003. Regarding the pain of others. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

    Google Scholar 

  24. Butler, Judith. 2009. Frames of war: When is life grievable?. New York: Verso.

    Google Scholar 

  25. Heard, Kathryn A. 2011. ‘Unframing the death penalty’. In Is the death penalty dying? European and American perspectives, ed. Austin Sarat, and Jürgen Martschukat, 126–149. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  26. Douzinas, Costas, and Lynda Neal (eds.). 1999. Law and the image: The authority of art and the aesthetics of law. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

    Google Scholar 

  27. Mitchell, W.J.T. 1994. Picture theory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

    Google Scholar 

  28. Carrabine, Eamonn. 2012. Just images: Aesthetics, ethics and visual criminology. British Journal of Criminology 52(3): 463–489.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  29. Carney, Phil. 2010. Crime, punishment and the force of photographic spectacle. In Framing criminology: Cultural criminology and the image, ed. Keith J. Hayward, and Mike Presdee, 17–35. London: Routledge.

    Google Scholar 

  30. Goodrich, Peter. 1990. Languages of law: From logics of memory to nomadic masks. London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson.

    Google Scholar 

  31. Goodrich, Peter. 2009. Judging pictures: A case study of portraits of the Chief Justices, Supreme Court of New South Wales. International Journal of Law in Context 5(3): 295–314.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  32. Allen, R. 2007. Looking at motion pictures. In Film theory and philosophy, ed. R. Allen, and M. Smith, 77. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

    Google Scholar 

  33. Turvey, Malcolm. 2009. Wittgenstein. In The Routledge companion to philosophy and film, ed. Paisely Livingston, and Carl Plantinga, 470–480. London: Routledge.

    Google Scholar 

  34. Calvino, Italo. 1998. The castle of crossed destinies and the tavern of crossed destinies. London: Vintage.

    Google Scholar 

  35. Etkind, Alexander, Finnin, Rory, Blacker, Uilleam, Fedor, Julie, Lewis, Simon, Mälksoo, Maria, and Mroz, Matilda Eds. 2012. Remembering Katyn. London: Polity.

  36. Terdiman, Richard. 1993. Present modernity and the past memory crisis. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  37. Calvino, Italo. 2013. Collection of sand. New York: Mariner.

    Google Scholar 

  38. Rodrigo Ferrada Stoehrel. 2013. The legal image’s forgotten aesthetic. International Journal of the Semiotics of Law 26(3): 555–577.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  39. Benjamin, Walter. 1973. The work of art in the age of mechanical reproduction. In Illuminations, ed. Benjamin, Walter (trans: Zohn, Harry) 219–253. London: Fontana.

  40. Barthes, Roland. 1977. Image, music, text (trans: Heath, Stephen). London: Fontana Press.

  41. Barthes, Roland. 2009. Mythologies (trans: Lavers, Annette). London: Vintage.

  42. Elander, M. 2012. Education and photography at Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum. In The arts of transitional justice, ed. O. Simić, and P.D. Rush, 43–62. Berlin: Springer.

    Google Scholar 

  43. Smith, Lindsay. 2010. The wont of photography, or the pleasure of mimesis. In Illustrations, optics, and objects in nineteenth-century literary and visual cultures, ed. Luisa Calè, and Patrizia Di Bello, 65–86. Palgrave: Basingstoke.

    Google Scholar 

  44. Bell, Vikki. 2014. Art and post-dictatorship: Ethics and aesthetics in transitional Argentina. London: Routledge.

    Google Scholar 

  45. Cover, Robert M. 1983. The Supreme Court, 1982 Term—Foreword: Nomos and Narrative. Harvard Law Review 97(1): 4–68.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  46. Packard, Mary. 2013. The Golden Tarot: The Visconti-Sforza deck. New York: The Book Shop.

    Google Scholar 

  47. Effendi, Wassa. 1999. The truth on Albania and the Albanians: Historical and critical issues, introduction Robert Elsie (trans: Fairman, Edward Saint John), first published in 1879 by National Press Agency, London. London: Centre for Albanian Studies.

  48. Biberaj, Elez. 2015. Albania: The challenges of transition. In Central and East European politics: From communism to democracy, 2nd ed, ed. Sharon L. Wolchik, and Jane L. Curry, 407–431. London: Rowman & Littlefield.

    Google Scholar 

  49. Austin, Robert C., and Jonathan Ellison. 2008. Albania. In Transitional justice in Eastern Europe and former Soviet Union, ed. Lavinia Stan, 176–199. London: Routledge.

    Google Scholar 

  50. Vickers, Miranda. 2008. The Albanians, 5th ed. London: I.B. Tauris.

    Google Scholar 

  51. Pipa, Arshi, and Albanian Stalinism. 1990. East European Monographs, No. CCLXXXVII. New York: Columbia University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  52. Mak, Geert. 2008. In Europe. London: Random House.

    Google Scholar 

  53. Kokalari, Rozeta. 2015. Musine Kokalari’s second cousin, 12 May 2015, Tirana.

  54. Pepa, Pjeter. 2003. The criminal file of Albania’s communist dictator (trans: Morcka, Vangjel). Tirana: Shtepia Botuese Uegen.

  55. Dumbach, Annette, and Jud Newborn. 2006. Sophie Scholl and the White Rose. Oxford: Oneworld.

    Google Scholar 

  56. Scholl, Sophie. 2005. The final days (dir. Marc Rothemund).

  57. Lubonja, Fatos. 2009. Second sentence: Inside the Albanian Gulag (trans: Hodgson, John). London: I.B. Tauris.

  58. Albanian Ministry of the Interior archives in Tirana and are denoted by Dosje Gjyqësor (Judicial File), file [number], item [number], microfilm.

  59. Aliko, Tomor. 2007. Genocide on the intellectual elite of the Albanian nation under the communist terror. Tirana: Shtypur ne Shtypshkronjen “Maluka”.

    Google Scholar 

  60. The Martyrs. 2012. dir. Saimir Kumbaro.

  61. Moran, Les, Gary Watt, Linda Mulcahy, and David Isaac. 2013. Four reflections on the art of justice: The judge’s perspective. Law and Humanities 7(1): 113–128.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  62. Novruz Xh Shehu. 2009. Musine Kokalari: An extraordinary woman. Greer: Tirana.

    Google Scholar 

  63. Sarat, Austin. 1999. Rhetoric and remembrance: Trials, transcription, and the politics of critical reading. Legal Studies 23: 355–378.

    Google Scholar 

  64. Ndoja, Davjola. 2013. Former researcher at the ISCC, 1 May 2013, Tirana.

  65. Tufa, Agron. 2011. Në mungesë një tribunali (In the Absence of a Tribunal), Panorama Online, 26 August 2011.

  66. Davies, Norman. 2013. The Deep Stains of Dictatorship. New York Review of Books. May 9, 2013. http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2013/may/09/deep-stains-dictatorship/?pagination=false. Last accessed July 21, 2015.

  67. McNamee, Eugene. 2009. Eye witness—memorialising humanity in Steve McQueen’s Hunger. International Journal of Law in Context 5(3): 281–294.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  68. Osiel, Mark. 1997. Mass atrocity, collective memory, and the law. London: Transaction Books.

    Google Scholar 

  69. Přibáň, Jiří. 2002. Dissidents of law: On the 1989 velvet revolutions, legitimations, fictions of legality and contemporary version of the social contract. Aldershot: Ashgate.

    Google Scholar 

  70. Kadare, Ismail. 6 October 2014, Paris.

  71. Saraçi, Fatbardha. 2013. Kalvari i grave në burgjet e komunizmit (The women’s calvary in communist prisons). Tirana: Instituti i Studimit të Krimeve dhe Pasojave të Komunizmit.

  72. Hodos, George, and Show Trials. 1987. Stalinist purges in Eastern Europe, 1948–1954. London: Praeger.

    Google Scholar 

  73. de Rapper, Gilles, and Anouk Durand. 2011. Family photographs in socialist Albania: State photography and the private sphere. In Audiovisual media and identity issues in Southeastern Europe, ed. Eckehard Pistrick, Nicola Scaldaferri, and Gretel Schwörer, 210–229. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

    Google Scholar 

  74. Lubonja, Fatos. 2014. The false apocalypse: From Stalinism to capitalism (trans: Hodgson, John). London: Istros Books.

  75. Kadare, Ismail. 2014. The ghost rider (trans: Bellos, David). London: Canongate.

  76. Sad Rubinlir. 1999. 33 years on the cross (trans: Allagiu, Florian). Tirana, Marin Barleti.

  77. Albanian National Archives.

  78. Albanian Telegraphic Agency.

  79. Kadare, Ismail. 2014. Twilight of the Eastern Gods (trans: Bellos, David). London: Canongate.

  80. The tarot card images are taken from Commons Wikimedia and in the public domain because the copyright has expired PD-US-not renewed.

Download references

Acknowledgments

Lancaster University’s Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences (FASS) Research Fund enabled me to carry out vital archival work in 2012/2013. I am extremely grateful to Florian Allagiu and Davjola Ndoja for their research assistance, and to Cosmin Cercel, Bela Chatterjee and Martin Thom for invaluable suggestions and support. Any errors are my own. The archival materials referred to in this article come from the Albanian Ministry of the Interior Archives, the Albanian National Archives and the Albanian Telegraphic Agency. The Ministry of the Interior Archives are denoted by Dosje Gjyqësor (Judicial File), file [number], item [number], microfilm.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Agata Fijalkowski.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Fijalkowski, A. Musine Kokalari and the Power of Images: Law, Aesthetics and Memory Regimes in the Albanian Experience. Int J Semiot Law 28, 577–602 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11196-015-9437-6

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11196-015-9437-6

Keywords

  • Law and aesthetics
  • Tarot cards
  • Photograph
  • Musine Kokalari
  • Albania
  • Memory regimes
  • Transitional justice