Abstract
In many countries, loan guarantee programs are important elements of government policy with respect to small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). If loan guarantee schemes are to be effective, a majority of firms obtaining assistance through such a scheme ought not to be able to obtain financing from existing sources: a property known as incrementality or additionality. This paper describes a new approach to measuring incrementality. This work uses a two-stage process to estimate the incrementality of loans made under the terms of the Canada Small Business Financing (CSBF) program. First, a logistic regression-based model of loan outcomes (essentially a credit-scoring model) is estimated based on a large representative sample of SMEs. The resulting model was consistent with prior expectations and exhibited high levels of goodness-of-fit. The model was then employed to classify a sample of firms that had received loans under the terms of the loan guarantee scheme. Incremental loans ought to be classified as “turndowns” by the model; hence the proportion of loan guarantee recipients that the model classified as turndowns is a direct measure of incrementality. For the CSBF loan guarantee program incrementality was estimated (with 95% confidence) as 74.8±9.0%.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arrau P. (1997). Evaluation of CORFO’s CUBOS-SME program: 1991–1995. The Financier 4(1&2): 51–56
Besanko D. and Thakor A. (1987). Collateral and credit rationing: Sorting Equillibria in Monopolistic and Competitive Credit Markets. International Economic Review 28(6): 671–689
Bester H. (1985). Screening vs rationing in credit markets with imperfect information. Amercian Economic Review 75(5): 850–855
Bradshaw T. (2002). The contribution of small business loan guarantees to economic development. Economic Development Quarterly 16(4): 360–369
Castellanos J. (1997). The financial supervision of loan guarantors. The Financier 4(1&2): 34–43
Clark I., Lan P., Taylor A. and Leung F. (1998). A review of issues surrounding benefit–cost analyses of the small business loans program, Final Report, Ottawa. KPMG for Industry Canada, Canada
COMPAS Inc., 2002, Canada Small Business Financing Act employment impact study, Report to Industry Canada, Ottawa, Toronto and Winnipeg
Conference Board of Canada, 2003, Methodological review: Review of Loan Incrementality Studies for the Canada Small Business Financing Act, Conference Board of Canada, Ottawa
Cowling M. and Mitchell P. (2003). Is the small firms loan guarantee scheme hazardous for banks or helpful to small business?. Small Business Economics 21(1): 63–71
Cressy, R., 2002. Funding gaps: A Symposium, The Economic Journal, 11(2), February: F1–F16
Gudger M. (1997). Sustainability of credit guarantee systems. The Financier 4(1&2): 30–33
Hatakeyama M, Yamamori M. and Nakamura H. (1997). Credit guarantee systems for small and medium enterprises in some Asian countries. The Financier 4(1&2): 62–73
Holden P. (1997). Collateral without consequence: Some Causes and Effects of Financial Underdevelopment in Latin America. The Financier 4(1&2): 12–21
Industry Canada, 1998, Highlights of the Small Business Loans Act SBLA stakeholder consultations, Government of Canada, Ottawa
Industry Canada, 2002, Results-based management and accountability framework (RMAF) for the core program under the Canada Small Business Financing Act, Government of Canada, Ottawa
KPMG Management Consulting, 1999, An evaluation of the Small Firms Loan Guarantee Scheme, URN: 99/720, Crown Copyright, Ottawa
Levitsky J. (1997a). SME guarantee schemes: a summary. The Financier 4(1&2): 5–11
Levitsky J. (1997b). Best practice in credit guarantee schemes. The Financier 4(1&2): 86–94
Llisterri J. (1997). Credit guarantee systems: Preliminary Conclusions. The Financier 4(1&2): 95–99
Llorens J. (1997). Loan guarantee systems for SMEs in Europe. The Financier 4(1&2): 74–85
(1997). The National Guarantee Fund of Colombia. The Financier 4(1&2): 44–50
Meyer, R. and G. Nagarajan, 1996, Evaluating credit guarantee programs in developing countries, Paper Presented at the Meetings of the American Agricultural Economics Association, San Antonio, TX, July
Morrison Donald (1969). On the interpretation of discriminant analysis. Journal of Marketing Research VI(2): 156–163
Nitani Miwako and Riding Allan (2005). Promoting enterprise development or subsidizing tradition? The Japan credit supplementation system. International Small Business Journal 23(1): 48–71
Oehring E. (1997). The FUNDES experience with loan guarantee programs in Latin America: Model, Results and Prospects. The Financier 4(1&2): 57–61
Parker Simon (2002). Do banks ration credit to new enterprises? Should governments intervene?. Scottish Journal of Political Economy 49(2): 162–195
PriceWaterhouseCoopers, 1998, Cost benefit analysis of the small business loans program, Final Report to Industry Canada, Ottawa
Rhyne E. H. (1988). Small Business, Banks and SBA Loan Guarantees: Subsidizing the Weak or Bridging a Credit Gap. Quorum Books, Westport, CT
Riding A. and Thomas R. (1994). The␣Canadian small business – bank interface: a recursive model. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 18(4): 5–24
Riding A. and Haines G. (2001). Loan guarantees: Cost of Default and Benefits to Small Firms. Journal of Business Venturing 16(6): 565–612
Stiglitz J. and Weiss A. (1981). Credit rationing in markets with incomplete information. American Economic Review 71(2): 393–409
Stiglitz J. and Weiss A. (1983). Incentive Effects of Terminations: Applications to the Credit and Labor Markets. American Economic Review 73(5): 912–927
Thomas D. Roland (1993). Inference using complex data from surveys and experiments. Canadian Psychology 34(4): 415–431
Vogel R. and Adams D. (1997). Costs and benefits of loan guarantee programs. The Financier 4(1&2): 22–29
Wynant L. and Hatch J. (1991). Banks and Small Business Borrowers. University of Western Ontario, London, Canada
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Riding, A., Madill, J. & Haines , G. Incrementality of SME Loan Guarantees . Small Bus Econ 29, 47–61 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-005-4411-4
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-005-4411-4