Abstract
This paper investigates causal relationships between planning and performance utilizing a longitudinal database with responses from the same 2,956 businesses over a four-year period. Results confirm the association between planning activity and performance that is evident in most extant literature. They also, however, cast doubt on the traditional perception of the causal sequence of that association. Although subject to a number of limitations, the results indicate that planning is more likely to be introduced into a small firm after a period of growth rather than before a period of growth. These results make an important contribution to understanding the planning performance relationship for two main reasons: they overcome the static data and relatively smaller sample size restrictions of many past studies; and, they provide evidence concerning the sequence of the relationship between planning and performance.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
T. J. Andersen (2000) ArticleTitle‘Strategic Planning, Autonomous Actions and Corporate Performance’ Long Range Planning 33 IssueID2 184–200 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0024-6301(00)00028-5
J. A. Berman D. D. Gordon G. Sussman (1997) ArticleTitle‘A Study to Determine the Benefits Small Business Firms Derive from Sophisticated Planning Versus Less Sophisticated Types of Planning’ The Journal of Business and Economic Studies 3 IssueID3 1–11
P. H. Dickson K. M. Weaver (1997) ArticleTitle‘Environmental Determinants and Individual-level Moderators of Alliance- Use’ Academy of Management Journal 40 404–425
D. S. Evans (1987) ArticleTitle’The Relationship Between Firm Growth, Size and Age: Estimates for 100 Manufacturing Industries’ Journal of Industrial Economics 35 IssueID4 567–581
B. Gibson (1997) ArticleTitle‘Reappraising the Link Between "Best Practice" and Performance in Small Firms: A Research Note’ Small Enterprise Research 5 IssueID2 61–67
B. Gibson G. Cassar (2002) ArticleTitle‘Planning Behaviour Variables in Small Firms’ Journal of Small Business Management 40 IssueID3 171–186 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1540-627X.00049
A. S. Goldberger (1991) A Course In Econometrics Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
S. Hart (1992) ArticleTitle‘An Integrative Framework for Strategy-Making Processes’ Academy of Management Review 17 327–351
ILO [International Labour Organization], 1998, ‘Recommendation Concerning General Conditions to Stimulate Job Creation in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises’, Recommendation 189 to the General Conference of the International Labour Organization, Geneva, June.
B. W. Keats J. S. Bracker (1988) ArticleTitle‘Toward a Theory of Small Firm Performance: A Conceptual Model’ American Journal of Small Business 12 IssueID4 41–58
Kotey B. and Meredith G.G. (1997). ‘Relationships Among Owner/Manager Personal Values, Business Strategies, and Enterprise Performance’. Journal of Small Business Management (April), 37–64.
G. T. Lumpkin G. G. Dess (1995) ArticleTitle‘Simplicity as a Strategy-making Process: The Effects of Stage of Organizational Development and Environment on Performance’ Academy of Management Journal 38 IssueID5 1386–1407
G. T. Lumpkin G. G. Dess (1996) ArticleTitle‘Clarifying the Entrepreneurial Orientation Construct and Linking it to Performance’ Academy of Management Review 21 IssueID1 135–172
Lumpkin, G. T, R. C. Shrader and G.E. Hills, 1998, ‘Does Formal Business Planning Enhance The Performance of New Ventures?", Paper presented at the 1998 Babson Entrepreneurship Research Conference, Gent, Belgium.
M. A. Lyles I. S. Baird J. B. Orris D. F. Kuratko (1993) ArticleTitle‘Formalized Planning in Small Business: Increasing Strategic Choices’ Journal of Small Business Management 31 IssueID2 38–50
C. H. Matthews S. G. Scott (1995) ArticleTitle‘Uncertainty and Planning in Small and Entrepreneurial Firms: An Empirical Assessment’ Journal of Small Business Management 33 IssueID4 34–52
P. McKiernan C. Morris (1994) ArticleTitle‘Strategic Planning and Financial Performance in U.K. SMEs: Does Formality Matter?’ British Journal of Management 5 S31–S41 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1467-8551.1994.tb00128.x
D. Miller (1987) ArticleTitle‘Strategy Making and Structure Analysis and Implications for Performance’ Academy of Management Journal 31 280–308
G. B. Murphy J. W. Trailer R. C. Hill (1996) ArticleTitle‘Measuring Performance in Entrepreneurship Research’ Journal of Business Research 36 15–23 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0148-2963(95)00159-X
Olson, P. D. and D. W. Bokor, 1995, ‘Strategy Process-Content Interaction: Effects on Growth Performance in Small, Start-Up Firms’, Journal of Small Business Management (January), 34–44.
H. M. O’Neill C. B. Saunders A. N. Hoffman (1987) ArticleTitle‘Beyond the Entrepreneur: Planning as the Organization Grows’ Business Forum 12 IssueID4 38–40
B. J. Orser S. Hogarth-Scott A. L. Riding (2000) ArticleTitle‘Performance, Firm Size, and Management Problem- Solving’ Journal of Small Business Management 38 IssueID4 42–58
J. A. Pearce E. B. Freeman R. B. Robinson (1987) ArticleTitle‘The Tenuous Link Between Formal Strategic Planning and Financial Performance’ Academy of Management Review 12 IssueID4 658–675
A. M. Pelham (1997) ArticleTitle‘Mediating Influences on the Relationship Between Market Orientation and Profitability in Small Industrial Firms’ Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice 5 IssueID3 55–76
Rauch, A. and M. Frese, 1998, ‘Planning; Environmental Hostility And Small Business Success: A Contingency Approach On The Relationship Between Planning Of Small Business Owners And Their Success’, Paper presented at the 1998 Babson Entrepreneurship Research Conference, Gent, Belgium.
G. C. Reid J. A. Smith (2000) ArticleTitle‘What Makes a New Business Start-Up Successful?’ Small Business Economics 14 165–182 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1008168226739
D. Rigby (2001) ArticleTitle‘Management Tools and Techniques: A Survey’ California Management Review 43 IssueID2 139–160
P. Risseeuw E. Masurel (1994) ArticleTitle’The Role of Planning in Small Firms: Empirical Evidence from a Service Industry’ Small Business Economics 6 313–322 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF01108398
L. W. Rue N. A. Ibrahim (1998) ArticleTitle‘The Relationship between Planning Sophistication and Performance in Small Businesses’ Journal of Small Business Management 36 IssueID4 24–32
Schwenk, C. R. and C. B. Shrader, 1993, ‘Effects of Formal Strategic Planning on Financial Performance in Small Firms: A Meta-Analysis’, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice (Spring), 53–64.
M. M. Stone C. G. Brush (1996) ArticleTitle‘Planning in Ambiguous Contexts: The Dilemma of Meeting Needs for Commitment and Demands for Legitimacy’ Strategic Management Journal 17 633–652 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1097-0266(199610)17:8<633::AID-SMJ837>3.0.CO;2-6
R. D. Teach R. G. Schwartz (2000) ArticleTitle‘Methodology to Study Firms’ Strategies and Performance Over Time’ Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice 8 IssueID3 32–40
M. Gelderen Particlevan M. Frese R. Thurik (2000) ArticleTitle’Strategies, Uncertainty and Performance of Small Business Startups’ Small Business Economics 15 IssueID3 165–181
N. Venkatraman V. Ramanujam (1986) ArticleTitle‘Measurement of Business Performance in Strategy Research: A Comparison of Approaches’ Academy of Management Review 1 IssueID4 801–814
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gibson, B., Cassar, G. Longitudinal Analysis of Relationships between Planning and Performance in Small Firms. Small Bus Econ 25, 207–222 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-003-6458-4
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-003-6458-4