Financial Aid and College Persistence: Do Student Loans Help or Hurt?
Using data from two freshmen cohorts at a public research university (N = 3730), this study examines the relationship between loan aid and second-year enrollment persistence. Applying a counterfactual analytical framework that relies on propensity score (PS) weighting and matching to address selection bias associated with treatment status, the study estimates that loan aid exerts a significant negative effect on persistence for students from low-income background (i.e., Pell eligible), and those taking up high amounts of loans in order to meet total cost of attendance, including students who exhausted the available amount of subsidized loan aid. However, no significant incremental effect associated with unsubsidized loan aid, net of subsidized loan aid, could be detected. The estimated effect of loan aid on persistence controls for first-year academic experience and takes into account 26 factors related to loan selection and persistence in order to match students with loan aid to a counterfactual case in covariate adjusted regression. Comparison with results from non-matched-sample analysis suggests selection bias may mask the negative effect of loans detected with matched-sample estimation. Validity of covariates determining the loan selection process and criteria for acceptable balance in the matched data are discussed, and implications for future research are addressed.
KeywordsStudent persistence Financial aid Loans Low income Causal inference estimation Propensity score
- AASCU. (2006, August). Student debt burden. Policy Matters, 3(8). Retrieved January 15, 2017, from http://www.aascu.org/uploadedFiles/AASCU/Content/Root/PolicyAndAdvocacy/PolicyPublications/StudentDebtBurden.pdf.
- Adelman, C. (2004). Principal indicators of student academic histories in postsecondary education, 1972-2000. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.Google Scholar
- Adelman, C. (2006). The toolbox revisited: Paths to degree completion from high school through college. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.Google Scholar
- Allison, P. (2012). When can you safely ignore multicollinearity? Statistical Horizons. Retrieved February 12, 2017 from https://statisticalhorizons.com/multicollinearity.
- Angrist, J. D. (2003). Randomized trials and quasi-experiments in education research. NBER reporter no. 4. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
- Angrist, J., Autor, D., Hudson, S., & Pallais, A. (2014, December). Leveling up: Early results from a randomized evaluation of post-secondary aid. NBER Working Paper 20800. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
- Astin, A. W. (1993). What matters in college? Four critical years revisited. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Bettinger, E. P., Long, B. T., Oreopoulos, P., & Sanbonmatsu, L. (2009, September). The role of simplification and information in college decisions: Results from the H&R Block FAFSA experiment. NBER working paper 15361. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
- Bowman, N. A., & Herzog, S. (eds.) (2014). Methodological Advances and Issues in Studying College Impact. New Directions for Institutional Research no. 161, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Bresciani, M. J., & Carson, L. (2002). A study of undergraduate persistence by unmet need and percentage of gift aid. NASAP Journal, 40, 104–123.Google Scholar
- Brown, M., Haughwout, A., Lee, D., Scally, J., & van der Klaaw, W. (2014, April). Measuring student debt and its performance. Staff Report No. 668. New York: Federal Reserve Bank of New York.Google Scholar
- Chen, J., & Zerquera, D. (2011). “A methodological review of studies on effects of financial aid on college student success. Paper prepared for the 36th annual conference of the Association for Education Finance and Policy.Google Scholar
- Dowd, A. C. (2004, May 12). Income and financial aid effects on persistence and degree attainment in public college. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 12(21). Retrieved March 18, 2005 from http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v12n21/.
- Elliot, W., & Nam, I. (2013). Reducing student loan debt through parents’ college savings (Vol. 49, pp. 265–286). St Louis, MO: Center for Social Development at Washington University.Google Scholar
- Haynes, R. M. (2008). The impact of financial aid on postsecondary persistence: A review of the literature. NASFAA Journal of Student Financial Aid, 37, 30–35.Google Scholar
- Herzog, S. (2008, January). Estimating the influence of financial aid on student retention. Education working paper archive. Fayetteville, AR: University of Arkansas, Department of Education Reform.Google Scholar
- Herzog, S. (2014). The propensity score analytical framework: An overview and institutional research example. In. N.A. Bowman & S. Herzog (Eds.), Methodological advances and issues in studying college impact. New Directions for Institutional Research no. 161. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Institute for College Access & Success. (2015, October). Student debt and the class of 2014: The project on student debt. 10th annual report. Washington, DC: Institute for College Access & Success.Google Scholar
- Ipsos & Sallie Mae. (2012). How America pays for college 2012. Retrieved Feb 12, 2017 from http://news.salliemae.com/sites/salliemae.newshq.businesswire.com/files/publication/file/HowAmericaPays2012.pdf.
- Kane, L. (2016, January 12). Student loan debt in the US has topped $1.3 trillion. Business Insider. Retrieved May 19, 2016 from http://www.businessinsider.com/student-loan-debt-state-of-the-union-2016-1.
- Lechner, M. (1999, December). Identification and estimation of causal effects of multiple treatments under the conditional independence assumption. Discussion paper no. 91. Bonn, Germany: Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA).Google Scholar
- Looney, A., & Yannelis, C. (2015, September). A crisis in student loans? How changes in the characteristics of borrowers and in the institutions they attend contributed to rising loan defaults. Brookings papers on economic activity. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.Google Scholar
- Marx, B. M., & Turner, L. J. (2015, January). Borrowing trouble? Student loans, the cost of borrowing, and implications for the effectiveness of need-based grant aid. NBER working paper 20850. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
- Mendoza, P. (2012). Should I work or should I borrow? A counterfactual analysis on the effect of working while in enrolled and debt on baccalaureate completion. Journal of Student Financial Aid, 42, 25–59.Google Scholar
- Mortenson, T. (1999, October). Unmet and overmet financial need of undergraduate students. Postsecondary Education Opportunity, 88, 1–10.Google Scholar
- Murnane, R. J., & Willett, J. B. (2010). Methods matter: Improving causal inference in educational and social science research. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Pascarella, E. T., & Terenzini, P. T. (2005). How college affects students: A third decade of research. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Robb, C. A., Moody, B., & Adbel-Ghany, M. (2011–2012). College student persistence to degree: The burden of debt. Journal of College Student Retention, 13, 431–456.Google Scholar
- Soria, K. M., Weiner, B., & Lu, E. C. (2014). Financial decisions among undergraduate students from low-income and working-class social backgrounds. Journal of Student Financial Aid, 44, 2–23.Google Scholar
- The Institute for College Access & Success. (2016). Private loans: Facts and trends. Retrieved February 12, 2017 from http://bit.lv/28WOv4Q.
- Tinto, V. (1993). Leaving college: Rethinking the causes and cures of student attrition. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- Welbeck, R., Diamond, J., Mayer, A., & Richburg-Hayes, L. (2014). Piecing together the college affordability puzzle. MDRC report. New York: MDRC.Google Scholar