While racial inequalities in college entry and completion are well documented, much less is known about racial disparities in the development of general collegiate skills, such as critical thinking. Using data from the Wabash National Study of Liberal Arts Education, we find substantial inequality in the development of critical thinking skills over four years of college between African American and White students. The results indicate that these inequities are not related to students’ academic experiences in college but are substantially related to their experiences with diversity. These findings have important implications for understanding racial inequality in higher education and considering strategies for addressing observed disparities.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Critical thinking is a term that is often used but rarely clearly defined. In essence, it aims to reflect one’s ability to analyze, synthesize, and/or evaluate information. To date, two standardized assessments of critical thinking most commonly used in published research are the Critical Thinking Test from the Collegiate Assessment of Academic Proficiency (CAAP) developed by the ACT and the collegiate learning assessment (CLA) developed by the Council for Aid to Education. CAAP includes three components: analyzing, evaluating, and extending an argument. CLA similarly includes an analysis and critique of an argument as well as critical reading and evaluation. Although CAAP and CLA are designed very differently, they produce similar results in terms of the overall gains in student performance (Pascarella et al. 2011a). Moreover, a recent validity study of three different tests—CAAP, CLA and MAPP (Measure of Academic Proficiency and Progress, developed by the ETS)—supported the measures’ construct validity (Klein et al. 2009).
Three institutions participated in multiple waves of the study. A dummy variable for those institutions is included in analysis.
Although the number of students in different racial categories is low, it is important to note that the sample examined in this study includes students who entered higher education through four-year institutions and persisted through four years of college. Authors’ calculations indicate that the proportion of African American students in the WNS sample is similar to a comparable sample in the Education Longitudinal Study (ELS), which is a nationally representative sample. The proportion of Asian students is lower in the WNS sample and the comparison cannot be made for Hispanic students because ELS uses different racial/ethnic categories.
For a list of studies using the Wabash National Study data, see: http://www.liberalarts.wabash.edu/research-and-publications/.
We include 0.10 statistical significance level in the table given the small number of students in different racial groups.
Some studies of cognitive development estimate conditional effects by race. However, that is rarely the focus of their inquiry. The focus is typically on understanding how specific experiences facilitate student development, and conditional effects are reported as a complement to the overall analysis.
American College Testing (ACT) Program. (1991). CAAP Technical Handbook, Iowa City, IA, Author.
antonio, A. L. (2001). The role of interracial interaction in the development of leadership skills and cultural knowledge and understanding. Research in Higher Education, 42, 593–617.
Arum, R., & Roksa, J. (2011). Academically adrift: Limited learning on college campuses. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Arum, R., & Roksa, J. (2014). Aspiring adults adrift: Tentative transitions to adulthood. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U). (2008). How should colleges assess and improve student learning? Employers’ views on the accountability challenge. Washington, DC: AAC&U.
Astin, A. (1993). What matters in college. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Baron, R. M., & Kenny, D. A. (1986). The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51(6), 1173–1182.
Bok, D. (2006). Our underachieving colleges: A candid look at how much students learn and why they should be learning more. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Bowman, N. A. (2010). College diversity experiences and cognitive development: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 80(1), 4–33.
Bowman, N. A. (2012). Promoting sustained engagement with diversity: The reciprocal relationships between informal and formal college diversity experiences. Review of Higher Education, 36(1), 1–24.
Bowman, N. A. (2013). How much diversity is enough? The curvilinear relationship between college diversity interactions and first-year student outcomes. Research in Higher Education, 54(8), 874–894.
Bowman, N. A., Brandenberger, J. W., Hill, P. L., & Lapsley, D. K. (2011). The long-term effects of college diversity experiences: Well-being and social concerns 13 years after graduation. Journal of College Student Development, 52(6), 729–739.
Bowman, N. A., & Brandenberger, J. W. (2012). Toward a model of college diversity experiences and attitude change. The Review of Higher Education, 35(2), 179–205.
Bray, G., Pascarella, E. T., & Pierson, C. (2004). Postsecondary education and some dimensions of literacy development: An exploration of longitudinal evidence. Reading Research Quarterly, 39, 306–330.
Blaich C., & Wise, K. (2014). Clear and organized teaching. Center for Inquiry, Wabash College. Accessed http://www.liberalarts.wabash.edu/practitioners-corner/2014/4/15/clear-and-organized-teaching.html.
Cabrera, A. F., & Nora, A. (1994). College students’ perceptions of prejudice and discrimination and their feelings of alienation: A construct validation approach. Review of Education Pedagogy and Cultural Studies, 16(3–4), 387–409.
Cabrera, A. F., Nora, A., Terenzini, P. T., Pascarella, E. T., & Hagedorn, L. S. (1999). Campus racial climate and the adjustment of students to college: A comparison between White students and African-American students. The Journal of Higher Education, 70(2), 134–160.
Cacioppo, J., Petty, R., & Kao, C. F. (1984). The efficient assessment of need for cognition. Journal of Personality Assessment, 48(3), 306–307.
Carini, R. M., Kuh, G. D., & Klein, S. P. (2006). Student engagement and student learning: Testing the linkages. Research in Higher Education, 47(1), 1–32.
Chang, M. J., Astin, A. W., & Kim, D. (2004). Cross-racial interaction among undergraduates: Some consequences, causes, and patterns. Research in Higher Education, 45(5), 529–553.
Chickering, A., & Gamson, Z. (1987). Seven principles for good practice in undergraduate education. AAHE Bulletin, 39, 3–7.
Chickering, A., & Gamson, Z. (1991). Applying the seven principles for good practice in undergraduate education. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Cruce, T. M., Wolniak, G. C., Seifert, T. A., & Pascarella, E. T. (2006). Impacts of good practices on cognitive development, learning orientations, and graduate degree plans during the first year of college. Journal of College Student Development, 47, 365–383.
Dee, J. R., & Daly, C. J. (2012). Engaging faculty in the process of cultural change in support of diverse student populations. In S. D. Museus & U. M. Jayakumar (Eds.), Creating campus cultures: Fostering success among racially diverse student populations (pp. 168–188). New York, NY: Routledge.
Deil-Amen, R., & Lopez-Turley, R. (2007). A review of the transition to college literature in sociology. Teachers College Record, 109(10), 2324–2366.
Dorans, N. J. (2004). Freedle’s Table 2: Fact or fiction? Harvard Educational Review, 74, 62–72.
Fischer, M. J. (2007). Settling into campus life: Differences by race/ethnicity in college involvement and outcomes. The Journal of Higher Education, 78(2), 125–156. doi:10.1353/jhe.2007.0009.
Fischer, C. S., Hout, M., Jankowski, M. S., Luca, S. R., Swidler, A., & Voss, K. (1996). Inequality by Design. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Flowers, L. A., & Pascarella, E. T. (2003). Cognitive effects of college: Differences between African American and Caucasian students. Research in Higher Education, 44(1), 21–49.
Freedle, R. O. (2003). Correcting the SAT’s ethnic and social class bias: a method for reestimating SAT scores. Harvard Educational Review, 73, 1–43.
Goldrick-Rab, S., & Roksa, J. (2008). A federal agenda for promoting student success and degree completion. Washington, DC: Center for American Progress.
Greene, T. G., Marti, C. N., & McClenney, K. (2008). The effort-outcome gap: Differences for African American and Hispanic community college students in student engagement and academic achievement. The Journal of Higher Education, 79(5), 513–539. doi:10.1353/jhe.0.0018.
Grodsky, E., & Felts, E. (2009). Social stratification in higher education. Teachers College Record, 111(10), 2347–2384.
Grodsky, E., Warrant, J. R., & Felts, E. (2008). Testing and social stratification in American education. Annual Review of Sociology, 34, 385–404.
Gurin, P., Dey, E., Hurtado, S., & Gurin, G. (2002). Diversity and higher education: Theory and impact on educational outcomes. Harvard Educational Review, 72(3), 330–366.
Harper, S. R. (2012). Foreword. In S.D. Museus & U.M. Jayakumar (Eds.), Creating campus cultures: Fostering success among racially diverse student populations (pp. ix-xi). New York, NY: Routledge.
Harper, S. R., & Hurtado, S. (2007). Nine themes in campus racial climates and implications for institutional transformation. New Directions for Student Services, 120, 7–24.
Heck, R. H., & Thomas, S. L. (2008). An introduction to multilevel modeling techniques (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.
Hout, M. (1996). The politics of mobility. In A. C. Kerckhoff (Ed.), Generating social stratification: Toward a new research agenda (pp. 293–316). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Hu, S., & Kuh, G. D. (2003). Diversity experiences and college student learning and personal development. Journal of College Student Development, 44(3), 320–334.
Hurtado, S. (2001). Linking diversity and educational purpose: How diversity affects the classroom environment and student development. In G. Orfield (Ed.), Diversity challenged: Evidence on the impact of affirmative action (pp. 187–203). Cambridge, MA: Harvard Educational Publishing Group.
Hurtado, S. (2005a). The next generation of diversity and intergroup relations research. Journal of Social Issues, 61, 595–610.
Hurtado, S. (2005b). Diversity and learning for a pluralistic democracy. In W. R. Allen, M. Bonous-Hammarth, R. T. Teranishi, & O. C. Dano (Eds.), Higher education in a global society: Achieving diversity, equity and excellence (pp. 249–267). Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
Hurtado, S., & Carter, D. (1997). Effects of college transition and perceptions of the campus racial climate on Latina/o college students’ sense of belonging. Sociology of Education, 70, 324–345.
Hurtado, S., Milem, J., Clayton-Pedersen, A., & Allen, W. (1998). Enhancing campus climates for racial/ethnic diversity: Educational policy and practice. The Review of Higher Education, 21, 279–302.
Kim, M. M. (2002). Cultivating intellectual development: Comparing women-only colleges and coeducational colleges for educational effectiveness. Research in Higher Education, 43(4), 447–481.
Klein, S., Liu, O. L, & Sconing, J. (2009). Test validity study report. Washington DC: Fund for the Improvement of postsecondary education. Accessed http://www.voluntarysystem.org/docs/reports/TVSReport_Final.pdf.
Kugelmass, H., & Ready, D. D. (2011). Racial disparities in collegiate cognitive gains: A multilevel analysis of institutional influences on learning and its equitable distribution. Research in Higher Education, 52(4), 323–348.
Kuh, G. D., Cruce, T. M., Shoup, R., Kinzie, J., & Gonyea, R. M. (2008). Unmasking the effects of student engagement on first-year college grades and persistence. The Journal of Higher Education, 79(5), 540–563. doi:10.1353/jhe.0.0019.
Kuh, G. D., & Pascarella, E. T. (2004). What does institutional selectivity tell us about educational quality? Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 36(5), 52–59.
Lahmers, A. G., & Zulauf, C. R. (2000). Factors associated with academic time use and academic performance of college students: A recursive approach. Journal of College Student Development, 41(5), 544–556.
Loes, C., Pascarella, E. T., & Umbach, P. (2012). Effects of diversity experiences on critical thinking skills: Who benefits? The Journal of Higher Education, 83(1), 1–25.
Lundberg, C. A. (2012). Predictors of learning for students from five different racial groups. Journal of College Student Development, 53(5), 636–655. doi:10.1353/csd.2012.0071.
Museus, S. D. (2014). The Culturally Engaging Campus Environments (CECE) Model: A new theory of college success among racially diverse student populations. In M. B. Paulsen (Ed.), Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research (pp. 189–227). New York: Springer.
Museus, S. D., & Jayakumar, U. M. (Eds.). (2012). Creating campus cultures: Fostering success among racially diverse student populations. New York, NY: Routledge.
National Research Council (NRC). (2012). Education for life and work: Developing transferable knowledge and skills in the 21 st century. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
Nelson Laird, T. F. (2005). College students’ experiences with diversity and their effects on academic self-confidence. Research in Higher Education, 46(4), 365–387.
Nora, A., & Cabrera, A. F. (1996). The role of perceptions of prejudice and discrimination on the adjustment of minority students to college. The Journal of Higher Education, 67(2), 119–148.
Pascarella, E. T. (1985). College environmental influences on learning and cognitive development: A critical review and synthesis. In J. Smart (Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (Vol. 1). New York: Agathon.
Pascarella, E. T., Blaich, C., Martin, G. L., & Hanson, J. M. (2011a). How robust are the findings of academically adrift? Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 43(3), 20–24.
Pascarella, E., Bohr, L., Nora, A., & Terenzini, P. (1995). Cognitive effects of 2-year and 4-year colleges: New evidence. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 17(1), 83–96.
Pascarella, E. T., Cruce, T., Umbach, P. D., Wolniak, G. C., Kuh, G. D., Carini, R. M., et al. (2006). Institutional selectivity and good practices in undergraduate education: How strong is the link? The Journal of Higher Education, 77(2), 251–285.
Pascarella, E. T., Edison, M., Nora, A., Hagedorn, L., & Braxton, J. (1996). Effects of teacher organization/preparation and teacher skill/clarity on general cognitive skills in college. Journal of College Student Development, 37, 7–19.
Pascarella, E. T., Martin, G. L., Hanson, J. M., Trolian, T. L., Gillig, B., & Blaich, C. (2014). Effects of diversity experiences on critical thinking skills over four years of college. Journal of College Student Development, 55(1), 86–92. doi:10.1353/csd.2014.0009.
Pascarella, E. T., Palmer, B., Moye, M., & Pierson, C. T. (2001). Do diversity experiences influence the development of critical thinking? Journal of College Student Development, 42(3), 257–271.
Pascarella, E., Salisbury, M., & Blaich, C. (2011b). Exposure to effective instruction and college student persistence: A multi-institutional replication and extension. Journal of College Student Development, 52, 4–19.
Pascarella, E. T., & Terenzini, P. (1991). How college affects students. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Pascarella, E. T., & Terenzini, P. (2005). How college affects student(Vol. 2): A third decade of research. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Pascarella, E. T., Wang, J., Trolian, T. L., & Blaich, C. (2013). How the instructional and learning environments of liberal arts colleges enhance cognitive development. Higher Education, 66(5), 569–583.
Pascarella, E. T., Wolniak, G. C., Pierson, C. T., & Flowers, L. A. (2004). The role of race in the development of plans for a graduate degree. The Review of Higher Education, 27(3), 299–320.
Plant, E. A., Ericsson, K. A., Hill, L., & Asberg, K. (2005). Why study time does not predict grade point average across college students: Implications of deliberate practice for academic performance. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 30(1), 96–116.
Raudenbush, S. W., & Bryk, A. S. (2002). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Roksa, J., & Arum, R. (2015). Inequality in skill development on college campuses. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility, 39, 18–31.
Roksa, J., Kilgo, C. A., Trolian, T. L., Pascarella, E. T., Blaich, C., Wise, K. S. (In press). Engaging with diversity: How positive and negative diversity interactions shape students’ cognitive outcomes. Journal of Higher Education.
Saenz, V. B., Ngai, H. N., & Hurtado, S. (2007). Factors influencing positive interactions across race for African-American, Asian-American, Latino, and White college students. Research in Higher Education, 48(1), 1–38.
Strayhorn, T. L. (2010). When race and gender collide: Social and cultural capital’s influence on the academic achievement of African-American and Latino males. The Review of Higher Education, 33(3), 307–332.
Terenzini, P. T., Springer, L., Pascarella, E. T., & Nora, A. (1995). Influences affecting the development of students’ critical thinking skills. Research in Higher Education, 36(1), 23–39.
Tierney, W. G. (1992). An anthropological analysis of student participation in college. Journal of Higher Education, 63(6), 603–618.
Tinto, V. (1993). Leaving college: Rethinking the causes and cures of student attrition (2nd ed.). Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Trolian, T. L., Kilgo, C. A., Pascarella, E. T., Roksa, J., Blaich, C., Wise, K. (2014, November). Race and exposure to good teaching during college. Paper presented at the meeting of the Association for the Study of Higher Education, Washington, D.C.
Umbach, P. D., & Kuh, G. D. (2006). Student experiences with diversity at liberal arts colleges: Another claim for distinctiveness. Journal of Higher Education, 77(1), 169–192.
United States Department of Education. (2006). A test of leadership: Charting the future of U.S. higher education. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
Research on this project is supported by a grant from the Spencer Foundation. Moreover, data collection and preparation is supported by a grant from the Center of Inquiry in the Liberal Arts at Wabash College to the Center for Research on Undergraduate Education at The University of Iowa.
About this article
Cite this article
Roksa, J., Trolian, T.L., Pascarella, E.T. et al. Racial Inequality in Critical Thinking Skills: The Role of Academic and Diversity Experiences. Res High Educ 58, 119–140 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-016-9423-1
- Critical thinking
- Academic experiences
- College student development