Research in Higher Education

, Volume 47, Issue 4, pp 451–476 | Cite as

Does adviser mentoring add value? A longitudinal study of mentoring and doctoral student outcomes

  • Laura L. PaglisEmail author
  • Stephen G. Green
  • Talya N. Bauer


This study of the impact of doctoral adviser mentoring on student outcomes was undertaken in response to earlier research that found (a) students with greater incoming potential received more adviser mentoring, and (b) adviser mentoring did not significantly contribute to important student outcomes, including research productivity [Green, S. G., and Bauer, T. N. (1995). Personnel Psychology 48(3): 537–561]. In this longitudinal study spanning 5 1/2 years, the effect of mentorship on the research productivity, career commitment, and self-efficacy of Ph.D. students in the ‘hard’ sciences was assessed, while controlling for indicators of ability and attitudes at program entry. Positive benefits of mentoring were found for subsequent productivity and self-efficacy. Mentoring was not significantly associated with commitment to a research career.


mentors doctoral students research productivity 


  1. Anderson L. E., Carta-Falsa J. (2002). Factors that make faculty and student relationships effective. College Teaching 50(4):134–139CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Anderson E. M., Shannon A. L. (1988). Toward a conceptualization of mentoring. Journal of Teacher Education 39(1):38–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Austin A. E. (2002). Preparing the next generation of faculty. The Journal of Higher Education 73(1):94–122CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bandura A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review 84(2):191–215CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Bandura A. (1986). Social Foundations of Thought and Action: A Social Cognitive Theory. Englewood Cliffs NJ, Prentice-HallGoogle Scholar
  6. Bargar R. R., Mayo-Chamberlain J. (1983). Advisor and advisee issues in doctoral education. The Journal of Higher Education 54(4):407–432CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bauer T. N., Green S. G. (1994). Effect of newcomer involvement in work-related activities: A longitudinal study of socialization. Journal of Applied Psychology 79(2):211–223CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Biglan A. (1973). The characteristics of subject matter in different academic areas. Journal of Applied Psychology 57(3):195–203CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Blackburn R. T., Lawrence J. H. (1995). Faculty at Work: Motivation, Expectation, Satisfaction. Baltimore MD, Johns Hopkins University PressGoogle Scholar
  10. Bullard L. G., Felder R. M. (2003). Mentoring: A personal perspective. College Teaching 51(2):66–70Google Scholar
  11. Busch J. W. (1985). Mentoring in graduate schools of education: Mentors’ perceptions. American Educational Research Journal 22(2):257–265CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cameron S. W., Blackburn R. T. (1981). Sponsorship and academic career success. Journal of Higher Education 52(4):369–377CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Campbell T. A., Campbell D. E. (1997). Faculty/student mentor program: Effects on academic performance and retention. Research in Higher Education 38(6):727–742CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Cesa I. L., Fraser S. C. (1989). A method for encouraging the development of good mentor- protégé relationships. Teaching of Psychology 16(3):125–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Chao G. T., Walz P. M., Gardner P. D. (1992). Formal and informal mentorships: A comparison on mentoring functions and contrast with nonmentored counterparts. Personnel Psychology 45(3):619–636CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Cook T. D., Campbell D. T. (1979). Quasi-experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings. Boston, Houghton MifflinGoogle Scholar
  17. Cronan-Hillix T., Gensheimer L. K., Cronan-Hillix W. A., Davidson W. S. (1986). Students’ views of mentors in psychology graduate training. Teaching of Psychology 13(3):123–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dollinger S. J. (1989). Predictive validity of the Graduate Record Examination in a clinical psychology program. Professional Psychology: Research & Practice 20(1):56–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Douglas, C. A., and Schoorman, F. D. (1988). The impact of career and psychosocial mentoring by supervisors and peers. Paper presented at the meeting of the Academy of Management, Anaheim, CAGoogle Scholar
  20. Dreher G. F., Ash R. A. (1990). A comparative study of mentoring among men and women in managerial, professional, and technical positions. Journal of Applied Psychology 75(5):539–546CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Dreher G. F., Cox T. H. (1996). Race, gender, and opportunity: A study of compensation attainment and the establishment of mentoring relationships. Journal of Applied Psychology 81(3):297–308CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. Ericsson K. A., Simon H. A. (1980). Verbal reports as data. Psychological Review 87(3):215–251CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Fagenson E. A. (1989). The mentor advantage: Perceived career/job experiences of protégés versus nonprotégés. Journal of Organizational Behavior 10(4):309–320CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Ford J. K., MacCallum R. C., Tait M. (1986). The application of exploratory factor analysis in applied psychology: A critical review and analysis. Personnel Psychology 39(2):291–314CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Freund R. J., Littell R. C. (1991). SAS System for Regression, 2nd edition. Cary NC, SAS Institute Inc.Google Scholar
  26. Gist M. E., Mitchell T. R. (1992). Self-efficacy: A theoretical analysis of its determinants and malleability. Academy of Management Review 17(2):183–211CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Green S. G. (1991). Professional entry and the adviser relationship: Socialization, commitment, and productivity. Group & Organization Studies 16(4):387–407CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Green S. G., Bauer T. N. (1995). Supervisory mentoring by advisers: Relationships with doctoral student potential, productivity, and commitment. Personnel Psychology 48(3):537–561CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hackman J. R., Wiggins N., Bass R. (1970). Prediction of long-term success in doctoral work in psychology. Educational and Psychological Measurement 30(2):365–374CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hissong D. (1993). Excel in your engineering. Chemical Engineering 100:157–160Google Scholar
  31. Holmes C. B., Beishline M. J. (1996). Correct classification, false positives, and false negatives in predicting completion of the Ph.D. from GRE scores. Psychological Reports 79(3):939–945Google Scholar
  32. Hunt D. M., Michael C. (1983). Mentorship: A career training and development tool. Academy of Management Review 8(3):475–485CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jablin F. M. (1988). Organizational entry, assimilation, and exit. In: Jablin F. M., Putnam L. L., Roberts K. H., Porter L. W. (eds), Handbook of Organizational Communication. Beverly Hills CA, Sage, pp. 679–740Google Scholar
  34. Kerres D. J. (1994). Precepts of project management. Civil Engineering 64(9):70–72Google Scholar
  35. Kram K. E. (1983). Phases of the mentor relationship. Academy of Management Journal 26(4):608–625CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Kram K. E. (1985). Mentoring at Work: Developmental Relationships in Organizational Life. Glenview IL, Scott ForesmanGoogle Scholar
  37. Kram K. E., Isabella L. A. (1985). Mentoring alternatives: The role of peer relationships in career development. Academy of Management Journal 28(1):110–132CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Louis M. R., Posner B. Z., Powell G. N. (1983). The availability and helpfulness of socialization practices. Personnel Psychology 36(4):857–866CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Luna G., Cullen D. (1998). Do graduate students need mentoring?. College Student Journal 32(3):322–330Google Scholar
  40. Lyness K. S., Thompson D. E. (2000). Climbing the corporate ladder: Do female and male executives follow the same route?. Journal of Applied Psychology 85(1):86–101CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  41. Lyons W., Scroggins D. (1990). The mentor in graduate education. Studies in Higher Education 15(3):277–285CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Maher M. A., Ford M. E., Thompson C. M. (2004). Degree progress of women doctoral students: Factors that constrain, facilitate, and differentiate. The Review of Higher Education 27(3):385–408CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Marien B. A. (1992). Quality in R&D: Putting TQM into the performance review process. Research Technology Management 35(1):39–43Google Scholar
  44. Noe R. A. (1988). An investigation of the determinants of successful assigned mentoring relationships. Personnel Psychology 41(3):457–479CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Parson R. J. (1991). Enlightened management must lay a strong foundation in training new engineers. Industrial Engineering 23(4):34–38Google Scholar
  46. Podsakoff P. M., Organ D. W. (1986). Self-reports in organizational research: Problems and prospects. Journal of Management 12(4):531–544CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Quinlan K. M. (1999). Enhancing mentoring and networking of junior academic women: What, why and how?. Journal of Higher Education Policy & Management 21(1):31–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Ragins B. R., Cotton J. L. (1999). Mentor functions and outcomes: A comparison of men and women in formal and informal mentoring relationships. Journal of Applied Psychology 84(4):529–550CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  49. Reskin B. F. (1979). Academic sponsorship and scientists’ careers. Sociology of Education 52(3):129–146CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Riley S., Wrench D. (1985). Mentoring among women lawyers. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 15(4):374–386CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Robertson M., Nielsen, W. (1961). The Graduate Record Examination and the selection of graduate students. American Psychologist 16:648–650CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Rose G. L. (2003). Enhancement of mentor selection using the ideal mentor scale. Research in Higher Education 44(4):473–494CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Scandura T. A., Schriesheim C. A. (1994). Leader–member exchange and supervisor career mentoring as complementary constructs in leadership research. Academy of Management Journal 37(6):1588–1602CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Schein E. H. (1968). Organizational socialization and the profession of management. Industrial Management Review 9(Winter):1–15Google Scholar
  55. Sigma Xi, and Scientific Research Society (1987). A New Agenda for Science, New Haven, CTGoogle Scholar
  56. Smith E. R., Miller F. D. (1978). Limits on perspectives on cognitive processes: A reply to Nisbett and Wilson. Psychological Review 85(4):355–362CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Thacker A. J., Williams R. E. (1974). The relationship of the Graduate Record Examination to grade point average and success in graduate school. Educational and Psychological Measurement 34(4):939–944CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Weidman J. C., Stein E. L. (2003). Socialization of doctoral students to academic norms. Research in Higher Education 44(6):641–656CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. White P. (1980). Limitations on verbal reports of internal events: A refutation of Nisbett and Wilson and of Bem. Psychological Review 87(1):105–112CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Whitely W., Dougherty T. W., Dreher G. F. (1991). Relationship of career mentoring and socioeconomic origin to managers’ and professionals’ early career progress. Academy of Management Journal 34(2):331–351CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Whiting V. R., de Janasz S. C. (2004). Mentoring in the 21st century: Using the Internet to build skills and networks. Journal of Management Education 28(3):275–293CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  • Laura L. Paglis
    • 1
    • 4
    Email author
  • Stephen G. Green
    • 2
  • Talya N. Bauer
    • 3
  1. 1.School of Business AdministrationUniversity of EvansvilleEvansvilleUSA
  2. 2.Krannert School of ManagementPurdue UniversityWest LafayetteUSA
  3. 3.School of Business AdministrationPortland State UniversityPortlandUSA
  4. 4.School of Business AdministrationUniversity of EvansvilleEvansvilleUSA

Personalised recommendations