Research in Higher Education

, Volume 46, Issue 8, pp 883–928 | Cite as

Measuring Determinants of Student Return VS. Dropout/Stopout VS. Transfer: A First-to-Second Year Analysis of New Freshmen



To reflect academic challenges and enrollment patterns of today’s freshmen, this study measures the impact of high school preparation, first-year academic performance, multi-institution enrollment, and financial aid support on second-year persistence. Using multi-year cohorts at a public research university, results confirm the importance of including first-year math experience, math intensity of the declared major, simultaneous enrollment at another college/university, and second-year financial aid offers when measuring freshmen retention. The positive impact of a large-scale, state-funded scholarship program in widening access to college must be balanced against findings that show academic performance and readiness to take on and pass first-year math to be more important than aid in explaining freshmen dropout and transfer-out during both first and second semesters. Middle-income students with greater levels of unmet need face an elevated departure risk, while academically well-prepared freshmen with unmet need are more likely to transfer to other institutions.


student retention academic preparation financial aid state-funded scholarship concurrent enrollment multinomial logistic regression 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Adelman, C. 2004Principal Indicators of Student Academic Histories in Postsecondary Education, 1972–2000US Department of EducationWashington, DCGoogle Scholar
  2. Adelman, C. 1999Answers in the Tool BoxUS Department of EducationWashington, DCGoogle Scholar
  3. Astin, A. W. 1984Student involvement: A developmental theory for higher educationJournal of College Student Personnel25297308Google Scholar
  4. Bean, J. P. 1985Interaction effects based on class level in an explanatory model of college student dropout syndromeAmerican Educational Research Journal223565Google Scholar
  5. Bean, J. P. 1982Student attrition, intentions, and confidence: interaction effects in a path modelResearch in Higher Education17291319CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bean, J. P. 1980Dropouts and turnover: The synthesis and test of a causal model of student attritionResearch in Higher Education12155187CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Beeson, M., Wessel, R. 2002The impact of working on campus on the academic persistence of freshmenJournal of Student Financial Aid323745Google Scholar
  8. Beil, C., Reisen, C. A., Zea, M. C. 1999A longitudinal study of the effects of academic and social integration and commitment on retentionNASPA Journal37376385Google Scholar
  9. Belch, H., Gebel, M., Maas, G. M. 2001Relationship between student recreation complex use, academic performance, and persistence of first-time freshmenNASPA Journal38254268Google Scholar
  10. Belsley, D. A. 1991Conditioning DiagnosticsWileyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  11. Berger, J. B., Braxton, J. M. 1998Revising Tinto’s interactionalist theory of student departure through theory elaboration: Examining the role of organizational attributes in the persistence processResearch in Higher Education39103119CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bettinger, E. (2002, August). How financial aid affects persistence. Working paper, Case Western Reserve University.Google Scholar
  13. Billson, J. M., Brooks-Terry, M. 1987A student retention model for higher educationCollege and University62290305Google Scholar
  14. Borden, V. M. H. 2004Accommodating student swirl: When traditional students are no longer the traditionChange361017Google Scholar
  15. Braunstein, A., McGrath, M., Pescatrice, D. 2001Measuring the impact of financial factors on college persistenceJournal of College Student Retention2191203Google Scholar
  16. Braunstein, A., McGrath, M., Pescatrice, D. 1999Measuring the impact of income and financial aid offers on college persistenceResearch in Higher Education40247259CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Braxton, J. M eds. 2000Reworking the Student Departure PuzzleVanderbilt University PressNashville, TNGoogle Scholar
  18. Braxton, J. M., Milem, J. F., Sullivan, A. S. 2000The influence of active learning on the college student departure processJournal of Higher Education71569590Google Scholar
  19. Braxton, J. M., Sullivan, A. S., Johnson, R. M. 1997

    Appraising Tinto’s theory of college student departure

    Smart, J. C. eds. Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research (Vol. 10)Agathon PressNew York107164
    Google Scholar
  20. Bresciani, M. J., Carson, L. 2002A study of undergraduate persistence by unmet need and percentage of gift aidNASPA Journal40104123Google Scholar
  21. Cabrera, A. F., La Nasa, S. M. 2001On the path to college: Three critical tasks facing America’s disadvantagedResearch in Higher Education42119149CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Cabrera, A. F., Nora, A., Castaneda, M. 1993College persistence: Structural equations modeling test of an integrated model of student retentionJournal of Higher Education64123139Google Scholar
  23. Cabrera, A. F., Castaneda, M. B., Nora, A., Hengstler, D. 1992The convergence between two theories of college persistenceJournal of Higher Education6314364Google Scholar
  24. Cambiano, R. L., Denny, G. S., De Vore, J. B. 2000College student retention at a midwestern university: A six-year studyJournal of College Admission1662229Google Scholar
  25. Clabaugh, J. (2004, January 15). Sallie Mae doles out record student loans. Washington Business JournalRetrieved January 29, 2004, from
  26. Cohen, J., Cohen, P., West, S. G., Aiken, L. S. 2003Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences3L. Erlbaum Associates PublishersMahwah, NJGoogle Scholar
  27. Cofers, J., and Somers, P. (1998, April). I sold my soul to the company store: low debtload influences student decisions at public and private colleges. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association annual meeting, San Diego, CA.Google Scholar
  28. DesJardins, S. 2003

    Event history methods: Conceptual issues and an application to student departure from college

    Smart, J. C. eds. Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and ResearchKluwer Academic PublishersNorwell, MA421471Vol. XVIII
    Google Scholar
  29. DesJardins, S. 2001A comment on interpreting odds-ratios when logistic regression coefficients are negativeAIR Professional File8117Google Scholar
  30. DesJardins, S., Ahlburg, D., McCall, B. 2002Simulating the longitudinal effects of changes in financial aid on student departure from collegeJournal of Human Resources3765379Google Scholar
  31. DuBrock, C., and Fenske, R. (2000, May). Financial aid and college persistence: a five-year longitudinal analysis. Paper presented at the 40th annual forum of the Association for Institutional Research, Cincinnati, OH.Google Scholar
  32. Farrell, E. F. 2005More students plan to work to help for college, record percentages of freshmen also expect to take on high debt.Chronicle of Higher Education51A1February 4Google Scholar
  33. Fenske, R., Porter, J., and DuBrock, C. (1999, May–June). Analyzing student aid packaging to improve low-income and minority student access, retention, and degree completion. Paper presented at the 39th annual forum of the Association for Institutional Research, Seattle, WA.Google Scholar
  34. Fiske, E. B. (2004, Spring). Student success. Focus (Lumina Foundation): 4–23.Google Scholar
  35. Gardner, J. N., McClenney, K., and Terenzini, P. T. (2004, April). Rethinking Retention. National Resource Center for the First-Year Experience and Students in Transition, Teleconference #3 of the 2004 Teleconference Series.Google Scholar
  36. Gillespie, M., and Noble, J. (1992) Factors Affecting Student Persistence: A Longitudinal Study. ACT Research Report, pp. 92–94.Google Scholar
  37. Grandy, J. 1998Persistence in science of high-ability minority studentsJournal of Higher Education69589620Google Scholar
  38. Greene, J. P., and Forster, G. (2003, September). Public High School Graduation and College Readiness Rates in the United States (Education Working Paper No. 3). New York: Manhattan Institute.Google Scholar
  39. Haycock, K. 2002Still at riskThinking K-166322(Education Trust)Google Scholar
  40. Hendel, D. D. (2001, April). The relative contribution of participating in a first-year seminar on student satisfaction and retention into the sophomore year. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Seattle, WA.Google Scholar
  41. Horn, L., Peter, K., Carroll, D. 2003What Colleges Contribute: Institutional Aid to Full-Time Undergraduates Attending 4-Year Colleges and Universities (NCES Report 2003–157)US Department of EducationWashington, DCGoogle Scholar
  42. Hosmer, D. W., Lemeshow, S. 2000Applied Logistic Regression2WileyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  43. Hu, S., St. John, E. P. 2001Student persistence in a public higher education system: Understanding racial and ethnic differencesJournal of Higher Education72265286Google Scholar
  44. IHEP [Institute for Higher Education Policy]. (2004, May). Investing in America’s Future: Why Student Aid Pays Off For Society and Individuals. Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  45. Ishitani, T. T. 2003A longitudinal approach to assessing attrition behaviour among first-generation studentsResearch in Higher Education44433449CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Ishitani, T. T., DesJardins, S. L. 2002A longitudinal investigation of dropout from college in the United StatesJournal of College Student Retention4173201CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Laden, R., Matranga, R., Peltier, G. 1999Persistence of special admissions students at a small universityEducation1207681Google Scholar
  48. Lau, L. K. 2003Institutional factors affecting student retentionEducation124126136Google Scholar
  49. Leppel, K. 2002Similarities and differences in the college persistence of men and womenReview of Higher Education25433450CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Laing, J., Sawyer, R., Noble, J. 1988Accuracy of self-reported activities and accomplishments of college-bound studentsJournal of College Student Development29362368Google Scholar
  51. Long, S. (1998) Influence of work study, loans, need-based gift aid, merit-base aid, and satisfaction with financial aid on freshmen-to-sophomore retention. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Missouri, Columbia.Google Scholar
  52. Mau, W. 2003Factors that influence persistence in science and engineering career aspirationsCareer Development Quarterly51234243Google Scholar
  53. McGrath, M., Braunstein, A. 1997The prediction of freshmen attrition: An examination of the importance of certain demographic, academic, financial, and social factorsCollege Student Journal31396408Google Scholar
  54. McPherson, M. S., and Schapiro, M. O. (1990, April). Does student aid affect college enrollment? New evidence on a persistent controversy. Williams Project on the Economics of Higher Education (Discussion Paper No. 1). Williamstown, MA: Williams College.Google Scholar
  55. Menard, S. 2001Applied Logistic Regression Analysis2CA: SageNewbury ParkGoogle Scholar
  56. Mortenson, T. (2003, November). Emerging higher education policy trends and roles for institutional research. Paper presented at the Midwest Institutional Research Association, Bloomington, MN.Google Scholar
  57. Murtaugh, P. A., Burns, L. D., Schuster, J. 1999Predicting the retention of university studentsResearch in Higher Education40355371CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Okun, M. A., Benin, M., Brandt-Williams, A. 1996Staying in college: Moderators of the relation between intention and institutional departureJournal of Higher Education67577596Google Scholar
  59. Pascarella, E. T., Terenzini, P. T., Wolfle, L. M. 1986Orientation to college and freshman year persistence/withdrawal decisionsJournal of Higher Education57155175Google Scholar
  60. Pascarella, E. T., Terenzini, P. T. 1980Predicting freshman persistence and voluntary dropout decisions from a theoretical modelJournal of Higher Education516075Google Scholar
  61. Paulsen, M., St. John, E. P. 2002Social class and college costs: Examining the financial nexus between college choice and persistenceJournal of Higher Education73189236Google Scholar
  62. Pedhazur, E. J. 1997Multiple Regression in Behavioral ResearchHarcourt BraceNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  63. Peng, C. J., So, T. H., Stage, F. K., St. John, E. P. 2002The use and interpretation of logistic regression in higher education journals: 1988–99Research in Higher Education43259293CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Perna, L. W. (1997). The contribution of financial aid to undergraduate persistence. Paper presented at the 22th annual forum of the Association for Study of Higher Education, Albuquerque, NM.Google Scholar
  65. Porter, S. R. 2002Including transfer-out behavior in retention models: Using the NSC EnrollmentSearch dataAir Professional File82116Google Scholar
  66. Potter , W. 2003Students overestimate cost of attending college, report saysChronicle of Higher Education50A27October 2Google Scholar
  67. Rosenbaum, J. E. 2001Beyond College For AllRussell SageNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  68. Sanoff, A. P. (2004, April 30). Americans see money for college somewhere over the rainbow. Chronicle of Higher Education 50(34): B6.Google Scholar
  69. Sidle, M. W., McReynolds, J. 1999The freshman year experience: Student retention and student successNASPA Journal36288300Google Scholar
  70. Somers, P. 1995A comprehensive model for examining the impact of financial aid on enrollment and persistenceJournal of Student Financial Aid251327Google Scholar
  71. Spady, W. G. 1971Dropouts from higher education: An interdisciplinary review and synthesisInterchange16485Google Scholar
  72. St. John, E. P. 2000The impact of student aid on recruitment and retention: what the research indicatesNew Directions for Student Services896175Google Scholar
  73. St. John, E. P. 1992Workable models for institutional research on the impact of student financial aidJournal of Student Financial Aid221326Google Scholar
  74. St. John, E. P., Hu, S., Simmons, A., Carter, D. F., Weber, J. 2004What difference does a major make? the influence of college major field on persistence by African American and White studentsResearch in Higher Education45209232CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. St. John, E. P., Hu, S., Weber, J. 2001State policy and the affordability of public higher educationResearch in Higher Education4240128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. St. John, E. P., Hu, S., Tuttle, T. 2000Persistence by undergraduates in an urban public university: Understanding the effects of financial aidJournal of Student Financial Aid302337Google Scholar
  77. Tinto, V. 1997Classroom as communities: Exploring the educational character of student persistenceJournal of Higher Education68599623Google Scholar
  78. Tinto, V. 1987Leaving College: Rethinking the Causes and Cures of Student AttritionUniversity of Chicago PressChicagoGoogle Scholar
  79. Tinto, V. 1975Dropout from higher education: A theoretical synthesis of recent researchReview of Educational Research4589125Google Scholar
  80. UCCSN [University and Community College System of Nevada]. (2004, March). Performance Indicator Report 2003–2004. Reno, NV: UCCSN, Office of Academic & Student Affairs.Google Scholar
  81. Weiler, W. C. 1996Factors influencing the matriculation choices of high ability studentsEconomics of Education Review152336CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Weiler, W. C. 1987An application of the nested multinomial logit model to enrollment choice behaviorResearch in Higher Education27273282CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institutional AnalysisUniversity of NevadaRenoUSA

Personalised recommendations