Preventive Pre-trial Detention without Punishment
- 602 Downloads
The pre-trial detention of individuals charged with crimes is viewed by many legal scholars as problematic. Standard arguments against it are that it constitutes legal punishment of individuals not yet convicted of crimes, violates the presumption of innocence, and rests on dubious predictions of future crime. I defend modified and restrained forms of pre-trial detention. I argue that pre-trial detention could be made very different than imprisonment, should be governed by strict criteria, and is warranted, when the evidence of danger is convincing. I contend that the presumption of innocence does not preclude us from doing many other things to criminal suspects and defendants that imply their guilt. Finally, I dispute arguments designed to show that pre-trial detention can be justified to prevent absconding or interferences with the course of justice, but not to prevent other, and sometimes much more serious, offenses.
KeywordsPre-trial detention Legal punishment Dangerousness
- Ashworth, Andrew, and Mike Redmayne. 2010. The criminal process, 4th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Baradaran, Shima. 2011. Restoring the presumption of innocence. Ohio State Law Journal 72: 723–776.Google Scholar
- Baradaran, Shima, and Frank L. McIntyre. 2011. Predicting violence. Texas Law Review 90: 497–570.Google Scholar
- Bowers, Josh. 2008. Punishing the innocent. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 156: 1117.Google Scholar
- Justice Policy Institute. 2011. Factsheet: Pretrial detention and remand to custody. http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/pretrial_detention_and_remand_to_custody.pdf.
- Kleinig, John. 1998. The hardness of hard treatment. In Fundamentals in sentencing theory, ed. A. Ashworth, and M. Wasik, 273–298. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
- Laufer, William S. 1995. The rhetoric of innocence. Washington Law Review 70: 329–421.Google Scholar
- Marlow, Kristina. 1997. Prisoners’ rights. Georgetown Law Journal 86: 1953–2010.Google Scholar
- Miller, Marc, and Martin Guggenheim. 1990. Pretrial detention and punishment. Minnesota Law Review 75: 335–426.Google Scholar
- Morse, Stephen J. 1996. Blame and danger: An essay on preventive detention. Boston University Law Review 76: 113–154.Google Scholar
- Struve, Catherine T. 2013. The conditions of pretrial detention. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 161: 1009–1079.Google Scholar
- von Hirsch, Andrew. 1993. Censure and sanctions. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar