Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting

, Volume 34, Issue 2, pp 179–197 | Cite as

With or without you: market quality of floor trading when screen trading closes early

Original Research


Most stock markets are characterized by a number of parallel operating trading systems which interact intensively with each other. Usually, smaller trading platforms take the leading domestic main market as a benchmark in the price discovery process and for closing open trading positions. But what happens if the smaller trading systems suddenly have to act without this benchmark platform? We examine the effects of the reduction of the daily business hours of a screen based main trading system while a parallel floor based trading system keeps on operating. We provide evidence that liquidity improves while informed trading and informational efficiency of prices decrease at the floor based trading system as a result of the no longer operating main market. While prior research on parallel trading focuses on changes due to a growing number of trading venues, we present the first evidence on market effects when the main trading platform reduces trading hours.


Parallel trading Liquidity Information based trading Market efficiency 

JEL Classification



  1. Abhyankar A, Ghosh D, Levin E, Limmack RJ (1997) Bid-ask spreads, trading volume and volatility: intra-day evidence from the London stock exchange. J Bus Finance Account 24(3/4):343–362CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Amihud Y, Lauterbach B, Mendelson H (2003) The value of trading consolidation: evidence from the exercise of warrants. J Financ Quant Anal 38(4):829–846CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Anand A, Martell T (2001) “Informed” limit order trading. Presented at 2002 Financial Management Association Annual Meeting, San AntonioGoogle Scholar
  4. Arnold T, Hersch P, Mulherin JH, Netter J (1999) Merging markets. J Finance 54(3):1083–1107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Barclay MJ, Hendershott T (2003) Price discovery and trading after hours. Rev Financ Stud 16(4):1041–1073CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Barclay MJ, Hendershott T (2004) Liquidity externalities and adverse selection: evidence from trading after hours. J Finance 59(2):681–710CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Barclay MJ, Hendershott T, McCormick DT (2003) Competition among trading venues: information and trading on electronic communications networks. J Finance 58(6):2637–2666CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Barnea A (1974) Performance evaluation of New York stock exchange specialists. Q J Econ 107:797–817Google Scholar
  9. Baruch S (2005) Who benefits from an open limit-order book? J Bus 78(4):1267–1306CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Battalio RH (1997) Third market broker-dealers: cost competitors or cream skimmers? J Finance 52(1):341–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bernhardt D, Hughson E (1997) Splitting orders. Rev Financ Econ 10(1):69–101Google Scholar
  12. Beveridge S, Nelson C (1981) A new approach to the decomposition of economic time series into permanent and transitory components with particular attention to the measurement of the ‘Business Cycle’. J Monet Econ 7:151–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Biais B (1993) Price formation and equilibrium liquidity in fragmented and centralized markets. J Finance 48(1):157–185CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Bloomfield R, O’Hara M, Saar G (2005) The “Make” or “Take” decision in an electronic market: evidence on the evolution of liquidity. J Financ Econ 75(1):165–199CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Boehmer B, Boehmer E (2003) Trading your neighbor’s ETFs: competition or fragmentation. J Bank Finance 27(9):1667–1703CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Boehmer E, Kelley E, Pirinsky C (2009) Institutional investors and the informational efficiency of prices. Rev Financ Stud 22(9):3563–3594CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Boehmer E, Saar G, Yu L (2005) Lifting the veil: an analysis of pre-trade transparency at the NYSE. J Finance 60(2):783–815CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Chan K, Chung YP, Johnson H (1995) The intraday behavior of bid-ask spreads for NYSE stocks and CBOE options. J Financ Quant Anal 30:329–346CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Chan K, Chung YP, Fong W-M (2002) The informational role of stock and option volume. Rev Financ Stud 15(4):1049–1075CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Chordia T, Roll R, Subrahmanyam A (2005) Liquidity and market efficiency. Working Paper, UCLA Anderson School of ManagementGoogle Scholar
  21. Chowdhry B, Nanda V (1991) Multimarket trading and market liquidity. Rev Financ Stud 4(3):483–511CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Commerton-Forde C, Rydge J (2004) A review of stock market microstructure. Working Paper, SIRCAGoogle Scholar
  23. Conrad J, Johnson KM, Wahal S (2003) Institutional trading and alternative trading systems. J Financ Econ 70(1):99–134CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. DeFontnouvelle P, Fishe RPH, Harris JH (2000) The behavior of bid-ask spreads and volume in options markets during the competition for listings in 1999. Working Paper, University of MiamiGoogle Scholar
  25. Demarchi M, Foucault T (2000) Equity trading systems in Europe: a survey of recent changes. Annales D’Économie et de Statistique 60:73–115Google Scholar
  26. Deutsche Börse (2003) Factbook 2003,
  27. Easley D, Kiefer NM, O’Hara M, Paperman JB (1996) Liquidity, information, and infrequently traded stocks. J Finance 51(4):1405–1436CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Easley D, Kiefer NM, O’Hara M (1997a) The information content of the trading process. J Empir Finance 4:159–186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Easley D, Kiefer NM, O’Hara M (1997b) One day in the life of a very common stock. Rev Financ Stud 10(3):805–835CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Easley D, Engle RF, O’Hara M, Wu L (2008) Time-varying arrival rates of informed and uninformed trades. J Financ Econom 6(2):171–207Google Scholar
  31. Easley D, Hvidkjaer S, O’Hara M (2002) Is information risk a determinant of asset returns? J Finance 57(5):2185–2221CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Fong K, Madhavan A, Swan PL (2001) Why do markets fragment? A panel-data analysis of off-exchange trading. Working Paper, University of SidneyGoogle Scholar
  33. Glosten L (1994) Is the electronic open limit order book inevitable? J Finance 49(4):1127–1161CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Glosten L (1999) Introductory Comments: Bloomfield and O’Hara, and Flood, Huismann, Koedijk, and Mahieu. Rev Financ Stud 12:1–3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Goldstein MA, van Ness BF, van Ness RA (2002) The intraday probability of informed trading. Presented at Annual Meeting of Financial Management Association 2003, DenverGoogle Scholar
  36. Goodfellow C, Bohl MT (2006) The quality of floor and electronic trading systems directly compared: evidence from a natural experiment on the German stock market. Working Paper, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität MünsterGoogle Scholar
  37. Goodfellow C, Bohl MT, Schiereck D (2008) Vorteilhaftigkeit des börslichen Abendhandels aus Anlegersicht. Kredit und Kapital 41(4):541–556Google Scholar
  38. Gouriéoux C, Jasiak J, Le Fog G (1999) Intra-day market activity. J Financ Markets 2:193–226CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Grammig J, Schiereck D, Theissen E (2000) Informationsbasierter Handel über IBIS. zfbf—Schmalenbachs Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung 52(November):619–642Google Scholar
  40. Grammig J, Schiereck D, Theissen E (2001) Knowing me, knowing you: trader anonymity and informed trading in parallel markets. J Financ Markets 4:385–412CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hasbrouck J (1993) Assessing the quality of a security market: a new approach to transaction-cost measurement. Rev Financ Stud 6(1):191–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Hasbrouck J (1995) One security, many markets: determining the contributions to price discovery. J Finance 50(4):1175–1199CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Hasbrouck J, Schwartz RA (1988) An assessment of stock exchange and over-the-counter markets. J Portf Manag 14:10–16CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Hautsch N (2004) Modelling irregularly spaced financial data: theory and practice of dynamic duration models, vol 539, 1st edn. Springer, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  45. Hendershott T, Jones CP (2005) Island goes dark: transparency, fragmentation and regulation. Rev Financ Stud 18(3):743–793CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Jain PK (2002) Institutional design and liquidity at stock exchanges around the world. Working Paper, University of MemphisGoogle Scholar
  47. Jain PK, Joh G-H (1988) The dependence between hourly prices and trading volume. J Financ Quant Anal 33:269–283CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Jain PK, Siang CX, McInish TH, Taechapiroontong N (2003) Informed trading in parallel auction and dealer markets: an analysis on the London stock exchange. Presented at 14th annual conference on financial economics and accountingGoogle Scholar
  49. Kyle AS (1985) Continuous auctions and insider trading. Econometrica 53(6):1315–1336CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Madhavan A (1995) Consolidation, fragmentation, and the disclosure of trading information. Rev Financ Econ 8(3):579–603Google Scholar
  51. Madhavan A (2000) Market microstructure: a survey. Working Paper: University of Southern CaliforniaGoogle Scholar
  52. Mayhew S (2002) Competition, market structure, and bid-ask spreads in stock option markets. J Finance 57(2):931–958CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. McInish TH, Wood RA (1992) An analysis of intraday patterns in bid/ask spread for NYSE stocks. J Finance 47(2):753–764CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. McInish TH, van Ness BF, van Ness RA (2002) After-hours trading of NYSE Stocks on the regional stock exchanges. Rev Financ Econ 11(4):287–297CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Pagano M (1989a) Endogenous market thinness and stock price volatility. Rev Econ Stud 56(186):269–287Google Scholar
  56. Pagano M (1989b) Trading volume and asset liquidity. Q J Econ 104(2):255–274CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Reck M (2001) Call market mechanism on Deutsche Börse. In: Schwartz RA, Beiner N, Humbach MJ (eds) The electronic call auction: market mechanism and trading. Norwell, Dordrecht, pp 133–144Google Scholar
  58. Schreiber PS, Schwartz RA (1986) Price discovery in securities markets. J Portf Manag 12:43–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Sims C (1980) Macroecomics and reality. Econometrica 48(1):1–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Theissen E (2001) Price discovery and screen trading systems. Working Paper, Bonn Econ Discussion Papers 35/2001Google Scholar
  61. Theissen E (2002) Floor versus screen trading: evidence from the German stock market. J Inst Theor Econ 158(1):32–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Theissen E (2003a) Organized equity markets. In: Krahnen JP, Schmidt RH (eds) The German financial system, pp 139–162Google Scholar
  63. Theissen E (2003b) Trades anonymity, price formation and liquidity. Eur Finance Rev 7(1):1–26CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Wahal S (1997) Entry, exit, market makers, and the bid-ask spread. Rev Financ Stud 10(3):871–901CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Wood RA, McInish TH, Ord JK (1985) An investigation of transaction data for NYSE stocks. J Finance 40(3):723–739CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Endowed Chair for Banking and Finance, European Business School (EBS)International UniversityOestrich-WinkelGermany
  2. 2.Xetra Market DevelopmentDeutsche Börse AGLondonUnited Kingdom

Personalised recommendations